Help a GM out, which of this trade do you think the Marlins should accept? Should I accept more then 1 offer if it is possible?

 

Mets Offer:

RF Milledge and Bannister for SP Dontrelle Willis

 

Blue Jays Offer:

Wells for SP Willis and CF Abercrombie

 

Chicago Cubs Offer:

Cubs get: Reggie Abercrombie and Ricky Nolasco

Marlins get: Juan Pierre, Ryan Harvey, and one of Sean Marshall/Carlos Marmol

What an odd thread.

 

Mets trade: Wouldn't do under any circumstances.

 

Blue Jays trade: Hm. How long is Wells under contract for? I do think, offensively and defensively, he is one of the best CF's out there and he would look great roaming the field of DS. But I'm still not sold on trading Willis just because of what he brings this franchise. Reluctantly, I decline.

 

Cubs trade: I'd do it. I think Nolasco's future lies in the pen. That being said, Juan Pierre is probably not the answer in CF, but for what we give up, I'd still do the deal.

The Cubs GM should be fired if that trade was offered We would have to be insane not to accept it. The Mets proposal is just pitiful. The Jays scenario needs tweaking they need to throw something else in the pot but it is a start

Just so you're aware, Pierre's a free-agent.

What an odd thread.

 

Mets trade: Wouldn't do under any circumstances.

 

Blue Jays trade: Hm. How long is Wells under contract for? I do think, offensively and defensively, he is one of the best CF's out there and he would look great roaming the field of DS. But I'm still not sold on trading Willis just because of what he brings this franchise. Reluctantly, I decline.

 

Cubs trade: I'd do it. I think Nolasco's future lies in the pen. That being said, Juan Pierre is probably not the answer in CF, but for what we give up, I'd still do the deal.

 

Wells has a year left on his deal.

Are these rumors or did you just think up of 3 random trades?

I got it from this thread: http://marlinsclubhouse.com/forums/showthread.php?tid=2050

hahahaha

I offer them Girardi for Pierre, you thik that a smart trade?

I offer then Girardi for Pierre, you thik that a smart trade?

 

well apparantly hes going to be gone...so why not get JP?

I offer then Girardi for Pierre, you thik that a smart trade?

 

 

You do understand the concept of free agency right?

I offer then Girardi for Pierre, you thik that a smart trade?

 

 

You do understand the concept of free agency right?

 

:lol

 

Apparently not.

FA? What that? :confused

wow....

Can someone please explain to me what a FA? I would be appreciated if you do and please take your time and make sure it is readable and simple.

I offer then Girardi for Pierre, you thik that a smart trade?

 

 

You do understand the concept of free agency right?

 

:lol

 

Apparently not.

Haha...how about we let the Cubs have Girardi...if they also take Abercrombie as part of the deal...final offer.

 

(Wow...Abercrombie was just given away by the Marlins!?!?)

Can someone please explain to me what a FA? I would be appreciated if you do and please take your time and make sure it is readable and simple.

Can someone please explain to me what a FA? I would be appreciated if you do and please take your time and make sure it is readable and simple.

 

 

Oh... you're serious.

 

Free agency is when a player's contract with a team has expired, and thus that team no longer has control over that player, thus they can't trade said player. The player can then make up his mind whether he wants to re-sign with that team, or move to another team, pending on what offers he receives from rival teams.

 

For example, Joe Borowski signed a one year contract with us, that means that we can't trade him this off-season, as he is not under our control anymore. He can either decide to re-sign with us (if the Marlins want him too), or leave for another team.

No way that the Mets are going to trade Milledge

ARE YOU MAD?! Take Wells, and trade some vets for a upcoming rookie pitcher.

I'm confused.. does Abercrombie have trade value or something?

I'm confused.. does Abercrombie have trade value or something?

 

youre dealing with Marlins Troll here...

I would really like to see Vernon Wells on the Marlins, but I wouldn't like to give up Willis and also the chances of keeping Wells after his contract is up are very slim, so I say no. The player we should try to go after this offseason is Torii Hunter.

If you wouldn't trade Willis for Wells, you're certifiable.

first thread of the post season?