Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Philly Series

Featured Replies

So while you all are still bickering about Julio, I thought it'd be time to be look ahead, you know, talk about the stuff that can be changed. Today starts a 3 day series against the 0-3 Phillies, who will hopefully continue their losing ways.

 

So we have a another classic Marlin/Philly. Here's you're pitching matchups:

 

Game 1: Jamie Moyer vs. Sergio Mitre

Game 2: Bretty Myers (0-0) vs. Dontrelle Willis (1-0)

Game 3: Zack Segovia vs. Scott Olsen (1-0)

 

I almost had to laugh when I learned the Sillies were seriously using Jamie Moyer as as starting pitcher. He's probably older than some of our hitters' fathers.

Anyways, I see this series 2-1 in favor of the Marlins.

One of two things happen:

 

1) We sweep the Phillies; or

2) Win only one or two games because our bullpen blows it.

 

I think we have the pitching advantage in every game, except maybe Saturday's game. I think we have an advantage then, too, but when Bretty Myers is on he's really good.

It would be great to end the weekend 4-2, especially if we can secure victory tonight and Saturday.

 

I say that as much as a fan as from a marketing standpoint. Friday setting up Saturday as a weekly event for the season by some early season victories can have a big impact on weekend attendance and ultimately trickling down to improved attendance throughout the week.

One of two things happen:

 

1) We sweep the Phillies; or

2) Win only one or two games because our bullpen blows it.

 

I think we have the pitching advantage in every game, except maybe Saturday's game. I think we have an advantage then, too, but when Bretty Myers is on he's really good.

 

Brett Myers is gonna get rocked on saturday, book it. :cool

One of two things happen:

 

1) We sweep the Phillies; or

2) Win only one or two games because our bullpen blows it.

 

I think we have the pitching advantage in every game, except maybe Saturday's game. I think we have an advantage then, too, but when Bretty Myers is on he's really good.

 

You don't think we have the pitching advantage on saturday with Willis? :blink:

 

I think we do, but he's pretty good when he's on. He's had an ERA under 4 in each of his last two seasons, and he's got good stuff. All I am saying is that I wouldn't be surprised if he outdueled Dontrelle.

One of two things happen:

 

1) We sweep the Phillies; or

2) Win only one or two games because our bullpen blows it.

 

I think we have the pitching advantage in every game, except maybe Saturday's game. I think we have an advantage then, too, but when Bretty Myers is on he's really good.

Mitre > Moyer? That's ridiculous. Can you explain why you think Mitre is better than Moyer?

The way he's been pitching and given that Moyer is 50 years old I think we have the advantage.

 

We can agree to disagree. I'm not going to get into an argument.

The way he's been pitching and given that Moyer is 50 years old I think we have the advantage.

 

We can agree to disagree. I'm not going to get into an argument.

Moyer's age is irrelevant as long as he continues to perform well.

 

Are you one of those people that puts a lot of weight on ST stats? It seems to me that you are given that you're so high on Mitre based his ST.

  • Author

I dunno but if you ask Jimmy Rollins, they are the team to beat this weekend :lol

The Braves showed the Phillies certainly are a team to beat, a rather easy one to beat too.

The way he's been pitching and given that Moyer is 50 years old I think we have the advantage.

 

We can agree to disagree. I'm not going to get into an argument.

Moyer's age is irrelevant as long as he continues to perform well.

 

Are you one of those people that puts a lot of weight on ST stats? It seems to me that you are given that you're so high on Mitre based his ST.

 

He started well last season, too. I just think he's got great stuff when he's on, but the main weakness in his career has been an inability to be consistent. This is probably because he's never really had a solid 3rd pitch, which by all accounts he has apparently gotten this season. So now he has a sinking fastball, a changeup, and a curve. That's pretty good.

 

Plus, if I am not mistaken, we shelled Moyer at least once last season.

The way he's been pitching and given that Moyer is 50 years old I think we have the advantage.

 

We can agree to disagree. I'm not going to get into an argument.

Moyer's age is irrelevant as long as he continues to perform well.

 

Are you one of those people that puts a lot of weight on ST stats? It seems to me that you are given that you're so high on Mitre based his ST.

 

He started well last season, too. I just think he's got great stuff when he's on, but the main weakness in his career has been an inability to be consistent. This is probably because he's never really had a solid 3rd pitch, which by all accounts he has apparently gotten this season. So now he has a sinking fastball, a changeup, and a curve. That's pretty good.

 

Plus, if I am not mistaken, we shelled Moyer at least once last season.

Mitre has a career ERA over 6.00 and Moyer went 3-0 vs us last year so frankly I have no idea where you're coming from other than you're exhibiting homerism to its worst degree.

You need to chill out. Relax. I am working right now and I don't have time to sit here and research everything to death.

 

I still think we have the advantage today. It's not homerism, I just think this is the year Mitre steps it up and becomes a good middle of the rotation starter.

Moyer is a cagey veteran and depends more on location than velocity. That's what makes him dangerous. When I think of Moyer, I think of that old Charlie Hough joke: When a reporter asked about what was Hough's last fastball, Charlie replied, "78." The reporter looked and said, "78 mph?" To which Hough replied, "No, 1978, that was when I threw my last fastball!"

I've been following Mitre since he was at Chicago... I'm not at all sold on him. Every year I fall into the trap thinking that its his breakout year. I hope he proves me wrong!

Instead of looking at career stats which for any number of reasons may not be indicative of how well he pitches when healthy and starting, last April he finished the month with 3.82 ERA. He's starting and he's healthy (knock on wood) in 2007 and for myself that's the comparison I think is most relevant.

 

I would feel differently if he had four or five hundred innings under his belt about using career numbers but with 161 total inning and in 2005 for example he had three times as many relief appearances as starts, and 2006 double. So for me the career number is less an indicator than it might be with a more experienced pitcher.

Instead of looking at career stats which for any number of reasons may not be indicative of how well he pitches when healthy and starting, last April he finished the month with 3.82 ERA. He's starting and he's healthy (knock on wood) in 2007 and for myself that's the comparison I think is most relevant.

 

I would feel differently if he had four or five hundred innings under his belt about using career numbers but with 161 total inning and in 2005 for example he had three times as many relief appearances as starts, and 2006 double. So for me the career number is less an indicator than it might be with a more experienced pitcher.

I don't disagree with much of what you wrote however why look only at the 5 starts he made in April?

 

He made two starts in May before going on the DL. On May 12th he only made 3 pitches so I think that's where he got injured and that one should be ignored. He made a start on May 5th in which he got pounded. In his 6th starts, including the May 5th start, he averaged 5.8 innings with a 4.89 ERA and a 1.49 WHIP.

 

Was he injured on May 5th and that's the reason he got pounded? I don't remember. Either way I think it's obvious to anyone other than a Malins homer that Moyer is better than Mitre.

Instead of looking at career stats which for any number of reasons may not be indicative of how well he pitches when healthy and starting, last April he finished the month with 3.82 ERA. He's starting and he's healthy (knock on wood) in 2007 and for myself that's the comparison I think is most relevant.

 

I would feel differently if he had four or five hundred innings under his belt about using career numbers but with 161 total inning and in 2005 for example he had three times as many relief appearances as starts, and 2006 double. So for me the career number is less an indicator than it might be with a more experienced pitcher.

I don't disagree with much of what you wrote however why look only at the 5 starts he made in April?

 

He made two starts in May before going on the DL. On May 12th he only made 3 pitches so I think that's where he got injured and that one should be ignored. He made a start on May 5th in which he got pounded. In his 6th starts, including the May 5th start, he averaged 5.8 innings with a 4.89 ERA and a 1.49 WHIP.

 

Was he injured on May 5th and that's the reason he got pounded? I don't remember. Either way I think it's obvious to anyone other than a Malins homer that Moyer is better than Mitre.

 

One of the signs of an impending injury is having several bad outings. Usually something isn't right, the pitcher ignores it and keeps pitching, and then finally all hell breaks loose and he's so injured he has no choice but to come out.

One of the signs of an impending injury is having several bad outings. Usually something isn't right, the pitcher ignores it and keeps pitching, and then finally all hell breaks loose and he's so injured he has no choice but to come out.

Is your point that Mitre got pounded on May 5th because he was injured? If yes, how are you so sure?

I am not so sure, but I wouldn't be surprised if that's when his injury problems began.

 

I usually discount the previous 2 or 3 starts before a major injury, unless of course the injury was getting hit by a line drive or something like that.

 

Just think about what happened to Nolasco during spring training. He had back spasms and they sat him out for a few days. Fredi said he wouldn't have sat him out if it were the regular season. If he had pitched his back might have gotten so bad that one or two starts later he would have taken out and put on the DL. But, of course, he was pitching slightly injured, which would have aggravated the injury, etc. We wouldn't have known he was pitching injured when he in fact was.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.