Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Overrated Movies

Featured Replies

  • Author

Ok this is inspired from the AFI list. You can rank them if you want but list the movies you consider some of the most overrated of all time, or just in our time.

 

My short list of the classics I consider overrated

 

2001: A Space Oddysey - Boring, Boring, Amazing Visual, Boring, Boring Boring. The storyboard for 2001

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly - A great movie but IMO not the best Western that would go to the Wild bunch

The Wizard of Oz - Granted, this is solely a matter of taste and not me judging the film for it's artistic merits but I just hated this movie.

The Grapes of Wrath - Just never got into it

Dances with Wolves - Just didn't enjoy it

North by Northwest - Granted I've never been a Cary Grant fan and am a huge Jimmy Stewart fan but I just did not think this movie was as good as some of Hitchcock's other stuff.

 

Ok some more contemporary choices

 

Major League - It's good but I don't think its one of the great sports comedies

Cinderella Man - At least in my area, everyone raves about how inspiring this movie was. Well in real life Jimmy Braddock was an alcoholic a**hole, and this movie is just way over the top in sappiness. Seabiscuit is where it's at for Howard and sports movies.

Edward Scissorhands - Maybe it's just because I'm part of the generation that has such a hard on for Jhonny Depp but people of my age get very angry when you rip on this emo fest of a movie.

A nightmare before Christmas - Tim Burton is not my god.

Cars and Finding Nemo - Go watch Toy Story or the Incredibles

 

Ok, now I could just go on in terms of contemporary.

 

You suck.

 

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly was the greatest Western EVER.

Dances With Wolves was one of the last great epic films made. Movie is amazing.

Wizard of Oz? Groundbreaking.

2001: A Space Oddyssey, even more groundbreaking. I know people cant stand it because it only has like 4 lines of dialogue and moves slowly, but watch it and think about whats going on in it.

Have you ever seen the Wild Bunch? 10 times better, and does it in the same style thus negating Good, Bad, and Ugly. The only reason the WB is not the western that we go to is because it has to be chopped up for TV, and it's biggest star is Ernert Borgnine.

 

And as for Dances, terribly terribly inaccurate on a movie that was supposed to pride itself on it's authenticity and Kevin Costner bores me.

 

The last two are entirely opinion based, I'm not going to like a movie because history tells me I'm supposed to. The Wizard of Oz is gay, and 2001 is coma inducing.

Ai (Artificial Intellegence) They could have used some for this film.

Total waste of Haley Jo Osmet.

 

Crash- I totally agree.

 

 

Cars, Ice Age- the entire ilk, I totally agree.

 

I'm sure I'll think of a few more right after I post this.

Goodfellas?! I'm not the greatest at dissecting films.. but come on!

Actually, while I'm in a blaspheming mood I'll throw this one out there as well:

Citizen Kane

 

I understand why it is considered so great FOR ITS TIME, but this isn't pre WWII America anymore. Before you flame me on this one, netflix it and get back to me.

Citizen Kane is good if only because it inspired my favorite White Stripes song.

What does 7 Nation Army have to do with Citizen Kane?

:lol

Citizen Kane is good if only because it inspired my favorite White Stripes song.

What does 7 Nation Army have to do with Citizen Kane?

:lol

 

Oh no he didn't.

Gladitor

Titanic

Completely agree on Gladiator. How Crowe could lose for a Beautiful Mind and win for Gladiator is everything that is wrong with movie awards.

Gladitor

 

 

Ohh good call on Gladiator. I forgot about that one, but it is another bad-mediocre movie that somehow won best picture.

Ok this is inspired from the AFI list. You can rank them if you want but list the movies you consider some of the most overrated of all time, or just in our time.

 

My short list of the classics I consider overrated

 

2001: A Space Oddysey - Boring, Boring, Amazing Visual, Boring, Boring Boring. The storyboard for 2001

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly - A great movie but IMO not the best Western that would go to the Wild bunch

The Wizard of Oz - Granted, this is solely a matter of taste and not me judging the film for it's artistic merits but I just hated this movie.

The Grapes of Wrath - Just never got into it

Dances with Wolves - Just didn't enjoy it

North by Northwest - Granted I've never been a Cary Grant fan and am a huge Jimmy Stewart fan but I just did not think this movie was as good as some of Hitchcock's other stuff.

 

Ok some more contemporary choices

 

Major League - It's good but I don't think its one of the great sports comedies

Cinderella Man - At least in my area, everyone raves about how inspiring this movie was. Well in real life Jimmy Braddock was an alcoholic a**hole, and this movie is just way over the top in sappiness. Seabiscuit is where it's at for Howard and sports movies.

Edward Scissorhands - Maybe it's just because I'm part of the generation that has such a hard on for Jhonny Depp but people of my age get very angry when you rip on this emo fest of a movie.

A nightmare before Christmas - Tim Burton is not my god.

Cars and Finding Nemo - Go watch Toy Story or the Incredibles

 

Ok, now I could just go on in terms of contemporary.

 

You suck.

 

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly was the greatest Western EVER.

Dances With Wolves was one of the last great epic films made. Movie is amazing.

Wizard of Oz? Groundbreaking.

2001: A Space Oddyssey, even more groundbreaking. I know people cant stand it because it only has like 4 lines of dialogue and moves slowly, but watch it and think about whats going on in it.

Have you ever seen the Wild Bunch? 10 times better, and does it in the same style thus negating Good, Bad, and Ugly. The only reason the WB is not the western that we go to is because it has to be chopped up for TV, and it's biggest star is Ernert Borgnine.

 

And as for Dances, terribly terribly inaccurate on a movie that was supposed to pride itself on it's authenticity and Kevin Costner bores me.

 

The last two are entirely opinion based, I'm not going to like a movie because history tells me I'm supposed to. The Wizard of Oz is gay, and 2001 is coma inducing.

 

Says the guy who thinks "Seabiscuits where its at".

Crash - already been covered

Love Actually - It's basically Crash in romantic comedy form, pure dreck, Shaun of the Dead was a better romantic comedy

Jurassic Park - Awesome movie, but Spielberg gave up on it to go work on Schindler's List, could've been much better had he not let George Lucas take over

Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope - The original Star Wars flick is quite cheesy, but it holds a very special place in my heart, but Empire Strikes Back is considerably better

Batman 1989 - It sucks hard and the only good performance is by Jack Nicholson playing himself

Spider-Man 1 & 2 - Crappy dialogue, low on action, no chemistry between a bunch of awful actors, "oh boy yeah", cheeseball monologues

  • Author

Ok this is inspired from the AFI list. You can rank them if you want but list the movies you consider some of the most overrated of all time, or just in our time.

 

My short list of the classics I consider overrated

 

2001: A Space Oddysey - Boring, Boring, Amazing Visual, Boring, Boring Boring. The storyboard for 2001

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly - A great movie but IMO not the best Western that would go to the Wild bunch

The Wizard of Oz - Granted, this is solely a matter of taste and not me judging the film for it's artistic merits but I just hated this movie.

The Grapes of Wrath - Just never got into it

Dances with Wolves - Just didn't enjoy it

North by Northwest - Granted I've never been a Cary Grant fan and am a huge Jimmy Stewart fan but I just did not think this movie was as good as some of Hitchcock's other stuff.

 

Ok some more contemporary choices

 

Major League - It's good but I don't think its one of the great sports comedies

Cinderella Man - At least in my area, everyone raves about how inspiring this movie was. Well in real life Jimmy Braddock was an alcoholic a**hole, and this movie is just way over the top in sappiness. Seabiscuit is where it's at for Howard and sports movies.

Edward Scissorhands - Maybe it's just because I'm part of the generation that has such a hard on for Jhonny Depp but people of my age get very angry when you rip on this emo fest of a movie.

A nightmare before Christmas - Tim Burton is not my god.

Cars and Finding Nemo - Go watch Toy Story or the Incredibles

 

Ok, now I could just go on in terms of contemporary.

 

You suck.

 

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly was the greatest Western EVER.

Dances With Wolves was one of the last great epic films made. Movie is amazing.

Wizard of Oz? Groundbreaking.

2001: A Space Oddyssey, even more groundbreaking. I know people cant stand it because it only has like 4 lines of dialogue and moves slowly, but watch it and think about whats going on in it.

Have you ever seen the Wild Bunch? 10 times better, and does it in the same style thus negating Good, Bad, and Ugly. The only reason the WB is not the western that we go to is because it has to be chopped up for TV, and it's biggest star is Ernert Borgnine.

 

And as for Dances, terribly terribly inaccurate on a movie that was supposed to pride itself on it's authenticity and Kevin Costner bores me.

 

The last two are entirely opinion based, I'm not going to like a movie because history tells me I'm supposed to. The Wizard of Oz is gay, and 2001 is coma inducing.

 

Says the guy who thinks "Seabiscuits where its at".

Tis the wonderful things about opinions. Although I'm sorry it's not an opinion in the terms of Dances. Don't portray yourself as historically acurate when nothing is further then the truth.

To some degree, every movie can be broken down so much to make it overrated. Not everyone from every generation is going to like or see what makes every movie great or not great. Except el penguino.

 

This family guy clip reminds me of this thread, big time:

To some degree, every movie can be broken down so much to make it overrated. Not everyone from every generation is going to like or see what makes every movie great or not great. Except el penguino.

 

This family guy clip reminds me of this thread, big time:

 

 

 

 

hahah! That was awesome. That is my attitude when someone tells me they don't like The Godfather. :lol

I remember the first time I watched The Godfather (I was 14 or 15) and just becoming so immersed in it that when it was over I was almost stunned by how damn good it was. No criticisms. Almost flawless. I've only thought that about a handful of films right after seeing them (Along the Waterfront, Amadeus, Schindler's List, Memento)

funny thing u mention Godfather.. which is the 1st movie that came to mind when i read the title of this thread.

 

Sorry for those fans.

 

oh by the way, i thought gladiator was good and wasn't even "overrated"

The ones that come to mind for me are Titanic, Raging Bull, most Charlie Chaplin films, 2001, Casablanca (my dad is obsessed with this film), Citizen Kane (certainly not the best movie ever by any means), and a few others.

 

Goodfellas is underrated, if anything.

LOL @ The Godfather being overrated. Just people who are starved for attention or under the age of 20.

 

My vote for overrated is American Pie.

Goodfellas is underrated, if anything.

How do you come to that conclusion?

 

It was nominated for Best Picture, Director, Screenplay and both supporting actor awards.

 

Its in the AFI top 100.

 

Its in the IMDB top 20.

 

It has a really high Rotten Tomatoes approval rating.

 

Many of the top critics have hailed it.

 

No idea how it could be considered 'underrated'.

LOL @ The Godfather being overrated. Just people who are starved for attention or under the age of 20.

Is that always your answer when people disagree with you?

 

 

 

 

I am not going to get into a debate about The Godfather being overrated. The mere assertion that it is overrated is worthy of a laugh but not a discussion,

 

 

Go pick a fight with someone else.

LOL @ The Godfather being overrated. Just people who are starved for attention or under the age of 20.

Is that always your answer when people disagree with you?

 

 

 

 

I am not going to get into a debate about The Godfather being overrated. The mere assetion that it is overrated is worthy of a laugh but not a discussion,

 

 

Go pick a fight with someone else.

 

Quoted for truth.

I never said it was overrated...only that your patented answers are tiresome.

 

 

 

Add me to your Ignore list then.

 

Problem solved.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.