Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Now that Hanley is (theoretically) signed

Featured Replies

Why anyone would give Willingham anything more than a one year deal with the worst of all position players chronic injuries (labrums and elbows aside), a bad back is beyond me. This is not an "I don't like Willingham" post, I like the guy, a lot. but Unlike Jacobs where he's had a series of freak problems, Willingham's is recurring and like McPherson (I don't know enough about either particular problem) could require surgery at some point, even conceivably this season if it flares up again.

 

Good, productive player. Not the guy you want to give any long term commitment to and in his case three years is too long.

 

Willingham always has a series of short term problems... but he will still play. You cant make the defense for Jacobs, they arent "freak" injuries. As long as the guy plays 130+ or so games, I dont see injury as a big problem.

 

I realize by your sig you're in love with Willingham but try to be rational.

 

Jacobs - broken foot, left hand, right thumb, now an everyday quad.

 

Willingham - Recurring *back* problems going back to 2006. Said so himself. Same problem every time. His problem is skeletal not muscular and it doesn't get better without either regular cortisone treatments or eventually surgery.

Jake has had big injuries every year since 2004. Maybe he just has bad bones, I don't know. But he has ended up losing more time every season than Hammer has.

 

That said, as someone with similar back problems, I think Hammer should really get some type of real treatment for it, like you said. It's not the kind of thing that gets better with time, it just gets worse.

Why anyone would give Willingham anything more than a one year deal with the worst of all position players chronic injuries (labrums and elbows aside), a bad back is beyond me. This is not an "I don't like Willingham" post, I like the guy, a lot. but Unlike Jacobs where he's had a series of freak problems, Willingham's is recurring and like McPherson (I don't know enough about either particular problem) could require surgery at some point, even conceivably this season if it flares up again.

 

Good, productive player. Not the guy you want to give any long term commitment to and in his case three years is too long.

 

Willingham always has a series of short term problems... but he will still play. You cant make the defense for Jacobs, they arent "freak" injuries. As long as the guy plays 130+ or so games, I dont see injury as a big problem.

 

I realize by your sig you're in love with Willingham but try to be rational.

 

Jacobs - broken foot, left hand, right thumb, now an everyday quad.

 

Willingham - Recurring *back* problems going back to 2006. Said so himself. Same problem every time. His problem is skeletal not muscular and it doesn't get better without either regular cortisone treatments or eventually surgery.

 

I am being rational, I never defended Willingham... I just said you cant excuse Jacobs. You cant say his problem is skeletal and not say Jacobs isnt? His bones are soft... he always manages something wrong with his hands. And yes, some peoples bones break easier than others...

 

But anyways, I would keep them both, and not worry about injuries unless they are like... Really cutting playing time. Willingham only sits like enough for bench players to play, which they would have played anyways eventually.

Why anyone would give Willingham anything more than a one year deal with the worst of all position players chronic injuries (labrums and elbows aside), a bad back is beyond me. This is not an "I don't like Willingham" post, I like the guy, a lot. but Unlike Jacobs where he's had a series of freak problems, Willingham's is recurring and like McPherson (I don't know enough about either particular problem) could require surgery at some point, even conceivably this season if it flares up again.

 

Good, productive player. Not the guy you want to give any long term commitment to and in his case three years is too long.

 

Willingham always has a series of short term problems... but he will still play. You cant make the defense for Jacobs, they arent "freak" injuries. As long as the guy plays 130+ or so games, I dont see injury as a big problem.

 

I realize by your sig you're in love with Willingham but try to be rational.

 

Jacobs - broken foot, left hand, right thumb, now an everyday quad.

 

Willingham - Recurring *back* problems going back to 2006. Said so himself. Same problem every time. His problem is skeletal not muscular and it doesn't get better without either regular cortisone treatments or eventually surgery.

 

I am being rational, I never defended Willingham... I just said you cant excuse Jacobs. You cant say his problem is skeletal and not say Jacobs isnt? His bones are soft... he always manages something wrong with his hands. And yes, some peoples bones break easier than others...

 

But anyways, I would keep them both, and not worry about injuries unless they are like... Really cutting playing time. Willingham only sits like enough for bench players to play, which they would have played anyways eventually.

Yeah, I would like to add that Hammer start 137 games last season, while Jake started 108. In 2006, it was 131 to 120. I would use the minors to keep the trend, but I can't find them , plus Jake would have the advantage as he was a 1b in 2005 while Hammer was still a catcher. Jake didn't play most of 2004 an injury that ended his catching days.

 

To paint Hammer as the injury prone one as opposed to Jake is just wrong.

I think Josh Willingham can be our Garrett Anderson (playing better defense). He's been a Marlin from Day 1, and from Day 1 in the big leagues, he's been Mr.Consistency.

 

I think Hermida should be signed, as I said...he has the potential, and he's only 23 years old (people seem to forget this).

 

And...I don't see why no one mentions Reynel Pinto at this point. I know I did.

 

After that, I don't see anyone that I say, "We HAVE TO SIGN HIM." At least not on the ML roster. Fact is, we're still a small market team, and we have to pick the correct players.

 

As good as Uggla and Jacobs are, they're not THAT young, and we have replacements for them, in the minors.

 

I'd say keep Olsen too...depending on who's better after JJ comes back (JJ or Olsen?)...and then I think Andrew Miller will be a keeper. People fail to realize...it is Andrew Miller who is the best prospect on this staff. Ask any scout...they'll tell you, the most upside on this staff, comes from Andrew Miller.

 

So...

 

Hanley

Hermida

Hammer

Olsen / JJ (need some time to see how JJ comes back from the surgery)

Pinto

Maybin

Miller

 

Those are my keepers.

To paint Hammer as the injury prone one as opposed to Jake is just wrong.

 

Yes it would be.

 

That's not what I said though. "Chronic" is a medical term not one I picked out of the sky. It refers to the repeated occurrence of a particular injury or problem. In this case since early 2006. If every time Willingham had a back problem each one was different, then he could be called injury prone.

 

But that's not the case.

 

This is the same problem repeatedly manifesting itself. There is a significant difference. And that's why it's chronic. I apologize for repeating myself. None of which means he's a bad person or ballplayer or unworthy of hero-worship or an important member or contributor to the team. It just means as long as the problem continues to reoccur he shouldn't be a candidate for a long term contract.

 

As for Jacobs, one player has nothing to do with the other. Jacobs may be in fact injury prone, but in the sense it appears he's walking around with a black cloud over his head, things just seem to keep happening to him, but they are all unrelated.

 

That is the difference. it doesn't make one player better than the other. I never said Jacobs should be signed long term either for more or less the seem reason but different circumstances. There is too much risk involved it would seem in signing either player to an extended contract if you're the Marlins.

 

I don't know why that is hard to understand. It isn't either or. It isn't isn't my guy is better than your guy or any of that schoolyard stuff. One guy has a medical problem and one just seems to find new ways to get injured every season.

Truth is neither Willingham or Jake should be long term solutions for this team. No matter how much we love them.

To paint Hammer as the injury prone one as opposed to Jake is just wrong.

 

Yes it would be.

 

That's not what I said though. "Chronic" is a medical term not one I picked out of the sky. It refers to the repeated occurrence of a particular injury or problem. In this case since early 2006. If every time Willingham had a back problem each one was different, then he could be called injury prone.

 

But that's not the case.

 

This is the same problem repeatedly manifesting itself. There is a significant difference. And that's why it's chronic. I apologize for repeating myself. None of which means he's a bad person or ballplayer or unworthy of hero-worship or an important member or contributor to the team. It just means as long as the problem continues to reoccur he shouldn't be a candidate for a long term contract.

 

As for Jacobs, one player has nothing to do with the other. Jacobs may be in fact injury prone, but in the sense it appears he's walking around with a black cloud over his head, things just seem to keep happening to him, but they are all unrelated.

 

That is the difference. it doesn't make one player better than the other. I never said Jacobs should be signed long term either for more or less the seem reason but different circumstances. There is too much risk involved it would seem in signing either player to an extended contract if you're the Marlins.

 

I don't know why that is hard to understand. It isn't either or. It isn't isn't my guy is better than your guy or any of that schoolyard stuff. One guy has a medical problem and one just seems to find new ways to get injured every season.

The part that you are missing is that I agreed with you about Hammer. Me and him have the same back problems, so I understand it.

 

Now, the part that we disagree on is Jake. Some of us don't think that his injuries are random an unrelated. I think he just has weak bones, which makes his injuries related.

To paint Hammer as the injury prone one as opposed to Jake is just wrong.

 

Yes it would be.

 

That's not what I said though. "Chronic" is a medical term not one I picked out of the sky. It refers to the repeated occurrence of a particular injury or problem. In this case since early 2006. If every time Willingham had a back problem each one was different, then he could be called injury prone.

 

But that's not the case.

 

This is the same problem repeatedly manifesting itself. There is a significant difference. And that's why it's chronic. I apologize for repeating myself. None of which means he's a bad person or ballplayer or unworthy of hero-worship or an important member or contributor to the team. It just means as long as the problem continues to reoccur he shouldn't be a candidate for a long term contract.

 

As for Jacobs, one player has nothing to do with the other. Jacobs may be in fact injury prone, but in the sense it appears he's walking around with a black cloud over his head, things just seem to keep happening to him, but they are all unrelated.

 

That is the difference. it doesn't make one player better than the other. I never said Jacobs should be signed long term either for more or less the seem reason but different circumstances. There is too much risk involved it would seem in signing either player to an extended contract if you're the Marlins.

 

I don't know why that is hard to understand. It isn't either or. It isn't isn't my guy is better than your guy or any of that schoolyard stuff. One guy has a medical problem and one just seems to find new ways to get injured every season.

The part that you are missing is that I agreed with you about Hammer. Me and him have the same back problems, so I understand it.

 

Now, the part that we disagree on is Jake. Some of us don't think that his injuries are random an unrelated. I think he just has weak bones, which makes his injuries related.

 

I think he's related to Alejandro De Aza :blink:

I wish we could keep them all, but.....

 

I say drop or trade:

 

Jorge Cantu - He's been our quick fix for the season. I don't see him as a long-term Marlins player.

Josh Willingham - The dude is almost 30 and Brett Carroll is a nice up-&-comer thats prime for a chance at an outfield spot. People love to tell us we have bad defense, well Brett Carroll is our answer. It would suck if we lost him but thats how we roll down here in South Florida.

Mike Jacobs - Man, this is a tough one. He's finally playing up to his potential, but should the Marlins really go after this one year bait he's set up? You know what... It's a toss up between Dan and Jacobs. I'd be happy with either one if we had to pick a single player. Dan is older than Jacobs, but by only a year...

Kevin Gregg - ...I never liked Superman. :rolleyes:

 

Now the people we need to chain up for at least another year:

 

Scott Olsen - You know I was kinda torn on this one, but only because someone posted about him intending to leave on the first available chance on this forum. Now that right there just makes me wanna trade his butt straight to Japan, if possible, or wherever and reap in some prospects, but I say for now keep him. Along the way he'll be rising his trade value so thats a plus on our side if anything negative were to come up.

Jeremy Hermida - Yeah, I wanna keep him, but I really don't have much of a reason. He's a great, young player, but I have yet to see him excel in any particular department. What's he supposed to be? A power hitter? A BA-hitter?

Andrew Miller - I think he's shown promise quite quickly. He got put straight into the rotation from day 1, floundered a bit in his first few starts, but has now awaken in his last few starts. When the new Marlins Stadium finally opens, it better include "MILLER-TIME!"

Renyel Pinto & his posey... most of them at least :mischief - It's the most demoralizing thing to witness a win in reach just escape because of a poor bullpen.

Cameron Maybin - Keep him on a short leash, don't lock him up. He's proven nothing so far in the minor leagues so he deserves no free pass.

My priority list:

 

R. Pinto(one of, if not the best lefty set up men in the bigs)

J. Hermida(sign him now while its cheap)

S. Olsen(he is as good as we thought)

 

 

Trade:

Uggla (crappy d, strikesout alot, low avg)

Willingham(I hate to say it but he is prone to injury, not that young)

Cantu(RIGHT NOW, HE HAS VALUE)

Gregg(no more than a year or two here)

 

of course, so long as the Marlins are in first, all should stay the same.

I think we should keep all, but use Gregg as trade bait, and give the closer role to Lindstrom/Tank.

 

But right now, things are going so well that i don't want to screw anything up. i feel like I've said that a million times now.

I wouldn't buy any of the others out. Go year with year with the ones you want to keep.

i believe this is the right answer...we have alot of good question marks coming up in with our developing pitching...while my answer to this question would be olsen first...i believe we should do a little more evaluating before we start handing out big deals to guys who may not be worth it by next year or 2010

i find it funny that I have barely seen any posts looking to keep Uggla. who frankly has been the most consistent in terms of production, other than Hanley, on the team.

i find it funny that I have barely seen any posts looking to keep Uggla. who frankly has been the most consistent in terms of production, other than Hanley, on the team.

 

 

I'm one for signing Uggla to a multi-year deal. Worst comes to worst he'll fetch something in a trade should he not be the right fit. I personally think he's more worth investing in than Willingham or Jacobs (although I'm not saying we should rule out long term deals for them, either.)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.