November 10, 200323 yr You guys make it seem that getting a 2nd baseman as Castillo is easy. Why cant you see that if Luis is gone our defense will suffer alot. Dont you understand that in order the game you need to have these 3 things in order : 1. pitching 2. Defense 3. Offense. The only reason Lowell had so many RBIs this season was the fact that you had Pierre, Castillo, and Pudge in the Lineup. And most of the time Lowell would leave a crapload of men on base. Castillo has been a valuable asset to our defense and offense, and there is no other second baseman with the range and speed that he has. His speed has suffered due to the fact that THERE WAS NO NEED FOR IT. If he had the role of leadoff hitter and pierre wasnt on the team he wouldve had 50+ steals, regardless of the hip injury. Without the 3 men in front of Lowell, he wouldve had at least 20 less RBIs. Im happy that he has become a better hitter and that he has connected for so many Homeruns and in my opinion he is the best 3rd baseman right now, But we already have Cabrera, and the most valuable part of OUR team (notice that not all teams rely on speed and defense) is the speed, dependable bat, and defense that Castillo offers. There's no easy replacements for Castillo, and thats what pisses me off about many of you who see Castillo as a luxury and think that he is not "important". Half the Marlins fans dont even know he had a 35 game hitting streak last season which made him the 2nd baseman and Latin player with such a long streak There is so much wrong with your post, I dont know where to begin. But I shall... First off, no one is saying it is easy to replace Castillo. In fact, I dont think anyone could honestly say that we would replace Castillo with a guy who could produce like him. Not initially anyway. But the fact is the Marlins dont have a lot of money. Other teams do. They will try and lure Castillo away with bigger deals. We cant compete with that, and we have to have priorities. Sorry, but Lowell is more important, from marketing (he's a local boy) to hitting/defense. Lowell is gold-glove caliber. He also is the most consistent run producer on this team the last 4 years (over 90 RBIs each season). With his bat and Cabs, you have a better chance of winning vs. Cabs and Castillo's. Castillo may cost you less money than Lowell, but not much. If it comes down to signing Castillo or Lowell, and it may, any person with more than two cells of grey matter will go with Lowell. The reason why Castillo was not the leadoff guy could have more to do with his hip injury than anything. You see, Luis did not hold up on his steals, he couldnt steal with the same success that he did previously because of his hip. He is not the runner he used to be. So to say that his speed suffered because there was no need for it is BS. And Luis did have the leadoff job for awhile, but Pierre performed better there than he did batting #2. So you had to do something to maximize the team's effectiveness. Now, I would agree that Luis' SB attempts went down with Pierre in front of him and on base. But his percentage was terrible, 21SB vs. 19CS? If that was any other hitter in the lineup, they would be scolded and never gotten the chance to be thrown out 19 times. Derek Lee had 21SB but only 8CS. Something is wrong with Luis...and I am not going to spend big money to experiment with him and let Lowell - a proven and more important hitter walk.
November 10, 200323 yr As an aside.... is anyone at the Sun-Sentinel actually able to read? Piazza to third? Hello? Either Berardino filed this story on a cocktail napkin or the editors at the Scum-Sentinel were all huffing paint thinner that day. How bush league.
November 10, 200323 yr The reason why Castillo was not the leadoff guy could have more to do with his hip injury than anything. You see, Luis did not hold up on his steals, he couldnt steal with the same success that he did previously because of his hip. He is not the runner he used to be. So to say that his speed suffered because there was no need for it is BS. And Luis did have the leadoff job for awhile, but Pierre performed better there than he did batting #2. So you had to do something to maximize the team's effectiveness. Now, I would agree that Luis' SB attempts went down with Pierre in front of him and on base. But his percentage was terrible, 21SB vs. 19CS? If that was any other hitter in the lineup, they would be scolded and never gotten the chance to be thrown out 19 times. Derek Lee had 21SB but only 8CS. Something is wrong with Luis...and I am not going to spend big money to experiment with him and let Lowell - a proven and more important hitter walk. I agree 100%... His hip problem bothers me...It might not be a hinderence now but a year or 2 down the road, what happens if it really flares up and cuts down on his playing time and we have him locked up for mucho dinero...It'll turn into the ALbert Belle Syndrome...ride the bench on medical disability, collect millions, and tie up the payroll like Sosa's cork-buddy Belle used to do If Castillo can prove he will be 100% healthy, then hell yeah I want him on this team, no contest...
November 10, 200323 yr I'd rather keep Lowell....You guys noticed how Eager and how Fast Lowell was to get back in the lineup after Breaking his thumb.....Now He knows how to play through pain.....Oh and did i mention he can Hit. I dunno...I dont care for louie all that much....he's just not a hitter. Good defense is great but I see him fail in the clutch...even with his 300 plus average.
November 10, 200323 yr I just hope that we can keep Pudge. If not, it's okay. I won't stop being his biggest fan in Miami. I can deal with having Javy Lopez or Benny Santiago though. We'll see what happens.
November 10, 200323 yr I can deal with having Javy Lopez or Benny Santiago though. Santiago I could see, but Javy Lopez?
November 10, 200323 yr I can deal with having Javy Lopez or Benny Santiago though. Santiago I could see, but Javy Lopez? I heard something that Javy may be a possibility. ::shrug:: If it was between Javy and Benny, I'd choose Benny in a heartbeat.
November 10, 200323 yr I think it is either Pudge or Castro. And if Castro is found guilty, and we lose Pudge, it will be some low cost move - maybe just keep Redmond. The other thing about Luis that scares me is his approach. It is the total opposite of Pierre's and if he starts to struggle will not work his way out of it. His hip, in my mind, is just too much of a risk to throw all this money at him. It surprises me that this hasnt come up in other discussions.
November 10, 200323 yr I can deal with having Javy Lopez or Benny Santiago though. Santiago I could see, but Javy Lopez? I heard something that Javy may be a possibility. ::shrug:: If it was between Javy and Benny, I'd choose Benny in a heartbeat. Benny is getting up there in age isnt he? Javy over Santiago in my book... anyday
November 10, 200323 yr It better be! :angry im just hoping we dont give either Luis or Pudge a no trade clause to EVERY team... that could come back to bite us BIG TIME
November 10, 200323 yr im just hoping we dont give either Luis or Pudge a no trade clause to EVERY team... that could come back to bite us BIG TIME I don't think that Beinfest(maybe Samson) is that stupid. After everything that has happend in the past year, I trust him to make the best decisions for this team and that isn't one of them....
November 10, 200323 yr Benny is getting up there in age isnt he? Javy over Santiago in my book... anyday That's true. But Javy isn't a youngun' either. :mischief2
November 10, 200323 yr Benny is getting up there in age isnt he? Javy over Santiago in my book... anyday That's true. But Javy isn't a youngun' either. :mischief2 Javy is 33... either way, he had one of the best contract years I have ever seen... I doubt we see those numbers next year
November 10, 200323 yr That's true. But Javy isn't a youngun' either He's just a few years old than Pudge, Miri :mischief
November 10, 200323 yr As long as they can play the game right, it's all good....and Pudge tops in my book. :thumbup
November 10, 200323 yr As long as they can play the game right, it's all good....and Pudge tops in my book. :thumbup Thats all that matters :thumbup
November 10, 200323 yr I don't have a list per se.... But here's some things I don't want to see: 1. Pudge given a monster long-term deal. 2. The FO trying to outbid the Yankees for a slap-hitting 2B. 3. No more than 1 starter dealt, if any. (including AJ) 4. Mike Lowell dealt.
November 11, 200323 yr The reason Castillo is higher on the resign list than Lowell is because we have a VERY competent player to replace him by the name of Cabrera. At 2B we have a gaping hole if Castillo leaves and seems like we could only get a stop-gap like a Vina. All of these media words and articles could just be posturing anyway...who really knows?
November 11, 200323 yr The reason Castillo is higher on the resign list than Lowell is because we have a VERY competent player to replace him by the name of Cabrera. At 2B we have a gaping hole if Castillo leaves and seems like we could only get a stop-gap like a Vina. All of these media words and articles could just be posturing anyway...who really knows? Everything Sham said. Plus Luis is a free agent NOW. Lowell is a free agent NEXT YEAR. Hmmm... NOW?....NEXT YEAR? Which one do you get's the first attention? And Sham is also right to say alot of what you're spoon-fed in the media is just so much posturing.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.