July 1, 200917 yr This is amazing. Hermida has to go to the minors now? Please. If the Marlins send Hermida down, I'd be pretty pissed. He's doing just fine against RHP...Carroll is handling the LHP. There's nothing wrong with a platoon. Lots of teams (even good teams) have them. This is silly. (especially considering our 3B never went down...)
July 2, 200917 yr This is amazing. Hermida has to go to the minors now? Please. If the Marlins send Hermida down, I'd be pretty pissed. He's doing just fine against RHP...Carroll is handling the LHP. There's nothing wrong with a platoon. Lots of teams (even good teams) have them. This is silly. (especially considering our 3B never went down...) Yes, Yes and Yes. Especially the last part in parenthesis.
July 2, 200917 yr When you have 3 hits since June 14, something is wrong. yes but earlier in the season bonerface was doing just as bad if not worse at some points and he was never sent down.
July 2, 200917 yr When you have 3 hits since June 14, something is wrong. So he should be sent down for two bad weeks?
July 2, 200917 yr When you have 3 hits since June 14, something is wrong. yes but earlier in the season bonerface was doing just as bad if not worse at some points and he was never sent down. He should have been sent down, too.
July 2, 200917 yr When you have 3 hits since June 14, something is wrong. What other OF'er in our organization do you really see putting up a near .800 .OPS against RHP (and I'm using this stat, considering this is now Hermida's role on this team)? He's slumping. Before this recent slump, he was .OPS'ing over .800 overall. Hermida will more than likely never be a stud, but he's also not as bad as some on here say, and he sure as hell doesn't deserve a demotion to the minor leagues right now. (btw, Nolasco was sent down b/c he was really hurting the team, at the time, sucking badly. His ERA was over 9. Hermida has been nowhere near that bad...not even the worst hitter, but since Bonifacio is on a little 9 game run, people seem to be liking the "winner" a little more now. Lets see how he does, on a consistent basis, against teams not named the Nationals...or Natinals).
July 2, 200917 yr When you have 3 hits since June 14, something is wrong. What other OF'er in our organization do you really see putting up a near .800 .OPS against RHP (and I'm using this stat, considering this is now Hermida's role on this team)? Ross Gload
July 2, 200917 yr 3 hits since June 14. We could have easily called up Maybin to take his place and move Ross to RF. I've always been a Hermida defender, and I still am. I'm just saying, a trip to the minors couldn't hurt him.
July 2, 200917 yr When you have 3 hits since June 14, something is wrong. What other OF'er in our organization do you really see putting up a near .800 .OPS against RHP (and I'm using this stat, considering this is now Hermida's role on this team)? Ross Gload Realistically, the Marlins have no intentions of doing that. Just like they, unfortunately, have no intentions of putting Coghlan at 3B b/c, apparently, we have a "winner" there. It is what it is. I wouldn't mind Gload getting some more AB's, though. Still don't see how he's any better than Hermida.
July 2, 200917 yr Hanley had a streak from June 5-21 in 06 where he went 5/56. Should he have been sent down? Not comparing the two, just saying everyone has streaks where they can't pull their head out of their ass. It doesn't mean they need to be sent down, especially when they really aren't reasonably replacable by anyone we could legitimately get.
July 2, 200917 yr 3 hits since June 14. We could have easily called up Maybin to take his place and move Ross to RF. I've always been a Hermida defender, and I still am. I'm just saying, a trip to the minors couldn't hurt him. So you're basing this demotion on a 3-36 slump?
July 2, 200917 yr When you have 3 hits since June 14, something is wrong. What other OF'er in our organization do you really see putting up a near .800 .OPS against RHP (and I'm using this stat, considering this is now Hermida's role on this team)? Ross Gload Well, Gload has been nice against RHP this year, he's been meh against them in his career. If he gets more ABs he's probably a pretty good bet to go back to his career norms.
July 2, 200917 yr Yes, Hermida in his time as a Marlin, never produced numbers like Hanley. He only had one great season, and that was in 2007. He's in a huge slump right now, and we don't know If he'll bounce back. Sending him to the minors could help. Look, I'm a huge Hermida defender. I always defend him. But he's struggling big time. Some minor league time couldn't hurt.
July 2, 200917 yr yes hes struggling but just because hes in a slump doesnt mean you send him down. Now if he is still hitting at this pace in a couple weeks then maybe I could see an argument. dont forget right before this slump he was one of if not the hottest hitter on the team
July 2, 200917 yr Yes, Hermida in his time as a Marlin, never produced numbers like Hanley. He only had one great season, and that was in 2007. He's in a huge slump right now, and we don't know If he'll bounce back. Sending him to the minors could help. Look, I'm a huge Hermida defender. I always defend him. But he's struggling big time. Some minor league time couldn't hurt. Just saying, Hanley hadn't shown THAT much that season and went through an even worse slump. Should he have been sent down?
July 2, 200917 yr ATL is beating philly 6-1 BTW and hamels thier "ACE" is gone without recording an out in the 5th.
July 2, 200917 yr Sorry, I thought that was this year. In 06, he was a rookie. So, of course, we all didn't expect him to play that well. Hermida, however, has had chances and stil hasn't produced, except for in 2007. All I'm suggesting is a little Minor League time. It did wonders for Nolasco, maybe it could help Hermida.
July 2, 200917 yr Holy crap, the phillies are getting no hitted my jurrjens in the top of the 7th. 1-9 atlanta. Just wanted to put that out there :whistle
July 2, 200917 yr Holy crap, the phillies are getting no hitted my jurrjens in the top of the 7th. 1-9 atlanta. Just wanted to put that out there :whistle okay nevermind...
July 2, 200917 yr Sending him down is retarded. But I do think that, especially if we have long term plans for Coghlan in LF, that Hermida should be shopped.
July 2, 200917 yr Sorry, I thought that was this year. In 06, he was a rookie. So, of course, we all didn't expect him to play that well. Hermida, however, has had chances and stil hasn't produced, except for in 2007. All I'm suggesting is a little Minor League time. It did wonders for Nolasco, maybe it could help Hermida. I don't like this argument. "Minor league time" isn't a cure-all for slumps and just because it helped Nolasco doesn't necessarily mean that it will help Hermida. Maybe Hermida just needs to play through this slump? I do understand the team is in a great position right now to lead the NL East and having Hermida struggle is not an ideal situation but just because he has struggled for two weeks (like someone mentioned earlier) I don't think he should be sent to the minors. How quickly we forget how well he was performing before June 14th. A trip down to the minors is quite a drastic move when Hermida hasn't been as terrible as some of our other players, in my opinion.
July 2, 200917 yr But It can help him. That's the whole point. It's not because he's in a slump. He has 3 hits since June 14. 3 hits. All I did was agree with Marlins2003 that sending him down to the Minors wouldn't hurt.
July 2, 200917 yr It could help or it might not. It's not like he's flailing blindly at the ball, his bb and k rates are about the same as for the season, aren't they (on my phone can't be bothered to check again...)
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.