July 24, 200917 yr The Athletics and Cardinals have completed a trade that sends outfielder Matt Holliday to St. Louis in exchange for third baseman Brett Wallace, outfielder Shane Peterson and right-handed pitcher Clayton Mortensen, sources confirmed to ESPN The Magazine's Buster Olney. In addition, sources said the Athletics will throw in $1.5 million to the Cardinals. Holliday, 29, is eligible for free agency after this season, and has had a lackluster season overall with the Athletics, hitting .287 with 11 homers and 54 RBIs. But he has hit well this month, batting .344 with a .421 on-base percentage, and one scout who has seen him play said Tuesday that Holliday is swinging the bat as well now as he has all year. The Cardinals have been searching for a way to upgrade their offense to build some lineup protection for first baseman Albert Pujols. Earlier this season, St. Louis had indicated to other teams that it did not have a lot of money to spend, but it's possible that the Cardinals' front office could navigate that issue by getting approval from ownership, or by having Oakland kick in some money to offset the money still owed to Holliday, which is about $6 million. Oakland acquired Holliday in a trade with Colorado last fall, in the hope that he would be the anchor to the Athletics' offense. But Holliday -- and the whole Oakland offense -- has struggled for much of this year, and rival general managers have wondered if the shift in baseball's economics might compel the Athletics to move Holliday. Holliday is earning $13.5 million in salary this season, and in order for Oakland to recoup draft picks, it would have to offer him arbitration. Holliday could be in line for an award of $16 million, something that might be more difficult for the small-market Athletics to absorb. The Yankees, after all, declined to offer Bobby Abreu arbitration last fall because they feared that he might accept it. http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=4353256
July 24, 200917 yr At first, I thought that it said the Cards got Halliday and I was glad that the Phillies didn't get him But good for St. Louis you are obviously making a run to hold the division lead. I wonder how the Cubs/Astros will respond?
July 24, 200917 yr At first, I thought that it said the Cards got Halliday and I was glad that the Phillies didn't get him But good for St. Louis you are obviously making a run to hold the division lead. I wonder how the Cubs/Astros will respond? lol, ditto. Does that mean that the Cards don't want Halladay now that they traded away the prospects that Toronto wanted?
July 24, 200917 yr The Yankees, after all, declined to offer Bobby Abreu arbitration last fall because they feared that he might accept it. :lol
July 24, 200917 yr This trade is proof that Billy Beane always finds a way to get the best prospects in any deal. Wallace will be in the majors as early as next year to become the permanent replacement to injury prone Chavez.
July 24, 200917 yr I wonder if the cards will still go after Roy halladay. They seem to be throwing every thing they have into this season.
July 25, 200917 yr i heard a rumor that phills and halladay are close to a deal. Yeah the Jays want J.A. Happ and 3 other players.
July 25, 200917 yr i heard a rumor that phills and halladay are close to a deal. Yeah the Jays want J.A. Happ and 3 other players. i heard it was happ, drabek and dominic brown. i highly doubt that the phillies give in to giving up their #1 prospect (brown), and their 2nd and 3rd ranked pitchers
July 25, 200917 yr This trade is proof that Billy Beane always finds a way to get the best prospects in any deal. Wallace will be in the majors as early as next year to become the permanent replacement to injury prone Chavez. Billy Beane if f***ing overrated. What did he do, exactly? Holliday for Wallace? He probably gave up more to get Holliday (trading Street and Gonzalez), in the first place.
July 25, 200917 yr This trade is proof that Billy Beane always finds a way to get the best prospects in any deal. Wallace will be in the majors as early as next year to become the permanent replacement to injury prone Chavez. Billy Beane if f***ing overrated. What did he do, exactly? Holliday for Wallace? He probably gave up more to get Holliday (trading Street and Gonzalez), in the first place. Ok, here's the thing... Billy Beane, at this point, just traded a good outfielder for 2 of a team's top 10 prospects and another player pegged to be a solid contributor. Yes, was the "getting Matt Holliday" thing not successful? Absolutely, and he'd be the first to admit it, but considering he got the Cardinals to give up more than they should have, he still does better than the typical GM. Also, let's wait and see what happens before we go saying whether or not a trade has been a good one or a bad one. Just like we're waiting on Smolinksi. You yourself know that Closers are generally overrated, and Carlos Gonzalez haven't proven anything yet. It's not every pitcher that succeeds in Colorado, so Greg Smith may only be valuable as a trade piece. Remember, he's now playing in the PCL. So basically, he traded Carlos Gonzalez, Greg Smith and Huston Street for a temporary use of Matt Holliday and Wallace, Peterson and Mortenson. Look at his team's needs. It's not a bad job, at all... all things considered.
July 25, 200917 yr i heard a rumor that phills and halladay are close to a deal. Yeah the Jays want J.A. Happ and 3 other players. i heard it was happ, drabek and dominic brown. i highly doubt that the phillies give in to giving up their #1 prospect (brown), and their 2nd and 3rd ranked pitchers phils rejected it
July 25, 200917 yr This trade is proof that Billy Beane always finds a way to get the best prospects in any deal. Wallace will be in the majors as early as next year to become the permanent replacement to injury prone Chavez. Billy Beane if f***ing overrated. What did he do, exactly? Holliday for Wallace? He probably gave up more to get Holliday (trading Street and Gonzalez), in the first place. Ok, here's the thing... Billy Beane, at this point, just traded a good outfielder for 2 of a team's top 10 prospects and another player pegged to be a solid contributor. Yes, was the "getting Matt Holliday" thing not successful? Absolutely, and he'd be the first to admit it, but considering he got the Cardinals to give up more than they should have, he still does better than the typical GM. Also, let's wait and see what happens before we go saying whether or not a trade has been a good one or a bad one. Just like we're waiting on Smolinksi. You yourself know that Closers are generally overrated, and Carlos Gonzalez haven't proven anything yet. It's not every pitcher that succeeds in Colorado, so Greg Smith may only be valuable as a trade piece. Remember, he's now playing in the PCL. So basically, he traded Carlos Gonzalez, Greg Smith and Huston Street for a temporary use of Matt Holliday and Wallace, Peterson and Mortenson. Look at his team's needs. It's not a bad job, at all... all things considered. It's just everything he does now people make him seem like a genius b/c of his Moneyball book, and the fact he got rid of the Mulder's and Zito's before they started being bad, and he got good value for them. But fact is, he's never won a championship (yes, I know...it takes luck to get this done, at times, and he was consistently making the playoffs, at one point when he had those guys like Hudson/Mulder/Zito). The A's also haven't been competitive for 3 consecutive years now. If you ask me, he's gone away from his Moneyball book a bit. It also pisses me off b/c he gets so much credit, yet a guy like Admin Beinfest (who works with a smaller payroll) doesn't get half the credit he (Beane) gets...most likely b/c he's never come out with such a theory in a book.
July 25, 200917 yr It's just everything he does now people make him seem like a genius b/c of his Moneyball book, and the fact he got rid of the Mulder's and Zito's before they started being bad, and he got good value for them. But fact is, he's never won a championship (yes, I know...it takes luck to get this done, at times, and he was consistently making the playoffs, at one point when he had those guys like Hudson/Mulder/Zito). The A's also haven't been competitive for 3 consecutive years now. If you ask me, he's gone away from his Moneyball book a bit. It also pisses me off b/c he gets so much credit, yet a guy like Admin Beinfest (who works with a smaller payroll) doesn't get half the credit he (Beane) gets...most likely b/c he's never come out with such a theory in a book. Somewhere Michael Lewis weeps in anonymity And the reason Beane got the credit was because he and his organization INNOVATED this style. Remember, Beane was established before Beinfest really took over for us. What the Marlins do reflects more favorably on our scouting and our ability to trade a Josh Beckett for a Hanley Ramirez... a top pitcher (in some circles) for a top prospect. There's no super theory behind that... it's just good scouting and having good talent to trade. Most people misinterpret what "Moneyball" is... it's not HRs, it's not OBP... it's none of that. It's getting the most possible bang for your buck... and in the case of Holliday, everyone "knew" Beane could only get 60 cents on the dollar for him, and yet he still came out with at least 90 cents on the dollar, getting three prospects back (including 2 top ten prospects of the Cardinals, guys the Jays wanted for Halladay). It reminds me of someone interviewing Joe Maddon, and they asked what his take on "Moneyball" was, and he said something along the lines of "Oh, I like a lot of what they go for, I just like using stolen bases while they don't" But if Beane had Carl Crawford, BJ Upton and players of that ilk, he'd run them like wild... (simultaneously driving up their trade value). Beinfest is a good GM, but like I said, he's not innovated the game in any way. In terms of Small Payroll management, the A's did that, too... it's only very recently did they start getting payroll flexibility... heck, Billy Beane had to almost personally finance a trade for Ricardo Rincon at one point.
July 25, 200917 yr It's just everything he does now people make him seem like a genius b/c of his Moneyball book, and the fact he got rid of the Mulder's and Zito's before they started being bad, and he got good value for them. But fact is, he's never won a championship (yes, I know...it takes luck to get this done, at times, and he was consistently making the playoffs, at one point when he had those guys like Hudson/Mulder/Zito). The A's also haven't been competitive for 3 consecutive years now. If you ask me, he's gone away from his Moneyball book a bit. It also pisses me off b/c he gets so much credit, yet a guy like Admin Beinfest (who works with a smaller payroll) doesn't get half the credit he (Beane) gets...most likely b/c he's never come out with such a theory in a book. Somewhere Michael Lewis weeps in anonymity And the reason Beane got the credit was because he and his organization INNOVATED this style. Remember, Beane was established before Beinfest really took over for us. What the Marlins do reflects more favorably on our scouting and our ability to trade a Josh Beckett for a Hanley Ramirez... a top pitcher (in some circles) for a top prospect. There's no super theory behind that... it's just good scouting and having good talent to trade. Most people misinterpret what "Moneyball" is... it's not HRs, it's not OBP... it's none of that. It's getting the most possible bang for your buck... and in the case of Holliday, everyone "knew" Beane could only get 60 cents on the dollar for him, and yet he still came out with at least 90 cents on the dollar, getting three prospects back (including 2 top ten prospects of the Cardinals, guys the Jays wanted for Halladay). It reminds me of someone interviewing Joe Maddon, and they asked what his take on "Moneyball" was, and he said something along the lines of "Oh, I like a lot of what they go for, I just like using stolen bases while they don't" But if Beane had Carl Crawford, BJ Upton and players of that ilk, he'd run them like wild... (simultaneously driving up their trade value). Beinfest is a good GM, but like I said, he's not innovated the game in any way. In terms of Small Payroll management, the A's did that, too... it's only very recently did they start getting payroll flexibility... heck, Billy Beane had to almost personally finance a trade for Ricardo Rincon at one point. My bad, I knew he didn't write it. I have never read the book (and again, in no way, am I calling him a bad GM by saying he's overrated). Just wondering though, are you sure it has nothing to do with .OBP? Just asking b/c everytime you hear Moneyball, it seems like it's a theory where Beane puts more emphasis on getting guys with the ability to get on base more often (high .OBP type of guys). At least that's what certain announcers, etc. would lead you to believe...that's why I ask. I've always been interested in buying and reading the book, but for some reason, I never have.
July 25, 200917 yr My bad, I knew he didn't write it. I have never read the book (and again, in no way, am I calling him a bad GM by saying he's overrated). Just wondering though, are you sure it has nothing to do with .OBP? Just asking b/c everytime you hear Moneyball, it seems like it's a theory where Beane puts more emphasis on getting guys with the ability to get on base more often (high .OBP type of guys). At least that's what certain announcers, etc. would lead you to believe...that's why I ask. I've always been interested in buying and reading the book, but for some reason, I never have. It's a common misconception. Moneyball is finding undervalued players and using them to field a competitive team. In the period of time Beane is illustrated in the book, OBP was undervalued... but subtly. Obviously guys like (at the time) Jason Giambi were getting huge contracts for being awesome, but guys like Scott Hatteberg before he went to the As, was a backup catcher with a career .357 OBP. At the time though, he was injured and sporting a .267 BA, so he didn't seem that valuable. So... for the minimum, you could get yourself a ~.750 OPS for the league minimum because he wasn't flashy. Obviously, since like, 2002-2003, a lot of GMs saw this model and had more resources, driving up the value of OBP guys. Obviously, since around that time, the A's have gotten progressively less competitive and have started a model that resembles more of what we do. It's a necessary adaptation... and, around that time, statistics weren't as in vogue as they are now, but with the "Stat for everything" age of the internet we're in, there are fewer and fewer trade secrets as had previously been exploited. And, aside from the stats aspect, another thing that made Beane (in)famous, was inserting himself (or trying to, in a lot of cases) into a trade he basically had no business being involved in. Like when Minaya was trading Cliff Floyd from Montreal to the Sox, Beane had found this out and almost convinced Minaya to trade him to Beane on the agreement that Beane would get all the prospects Minaya wanted to begin with, plus a prospect from him. (Anyone that's played OOTP with me knows I'm also infamous for that crap). But, he'd basically take the players and get something for nothing, or at the very least, something he didn't want.
July 25, 200917 yr My bad, I knew he didn't write it. I have never read the book (and again, in no way, am I calling him a bad GM by saying he's overrated). Just wondering though, are you sure it has nothing to do with .OBP? Just asking b/c everytime you hear Moneyball, it seems like it's a theory where Beane puts more emphasis on getting guys with the ability to get on base more often (high .OBP type of guys). At least that's what certain announcers, etc. would lead you to believe...that's why I ask. I've always been interested in buying and reading the book, but for some reason, I never have. It's a common misconception. Moneyball is finding undervalued players and using them to field a competitive team. In the period of time Beane is illustrated in the book, OBP was undervalued... but subtly. Obviously guys like (at the time) Jason Giambi were getting huge contracts for being awesome, but guys like Scott Hatteberg before he went to the As, was a backup catcher with a career .357 OBP. At the time though, he was injured and sporting a .267 BA, so he didn't seem that valuable. So... for the minimum, you could get yourself a ~.750 OPS for the league minimum because he wasn't flashy. Obviously, since like, 2002-2003, a lot of GMs saw this model and had more resources, driving up the value of OBP guys. Obviously, since around that time, the A's have gotten progressively less competitive and have started a model that resembles more of what we do. It's a necessary adaptation... and, around that time, statistics weren't as in vogue as they are now, but with the "Stat for everything" age of the internet we're in, there are fewer and fewer trade secrets as had previously been exploited. And, aside from the stats aspect, another thing that made Beane (in)famous, was inserting himself (or trying to, in a lot of cases) into a trade he basically had no business being involved in. Like when Minaya was trading Cliff Floyd from Montreal to the Sox, Beane had found this out and almost convinced Minaya to trade him to Beane on the agreement that Beane would get all the prospects Minaya wanted to begin with, plus a prospect from him. (Anyone that's played OOTP with me knows I'm also infamous for that crap). But, he'd basically take the players and get something for nothing, or at the very least, something he didn't want. Would you say his recent deal to acquire Scott Hairston fits the explanation (although I'm not sure since Gallagher was one of the guys in the Harden deal that came his way)? Or Beinfest picking up relievers like Kiko Calero for basically nothing. Stuff like that.
July 25, 200917 yr My bad, I knew he didn't write it. I have never read the book (and again, in no way, am I calling him a bad GM by saying he's overrated). Just wondering though, are you sure it has nothing to do with .OBP? Just asking b/c everytime you hear Moneyball, it seems like it's a theory where Beane puts more emphasis on getting guys with the ability to get on base more often (high .OBP type of guys). At least that's what certain announcers, etc. would lead you to believe...that's why I ask. I've always been interested in buying and reading the book, but for some reason, I never have. It's a common misconception. Moneyball is finding undervalued players and using them to field a competitive team. In the period of time Beane is illustrated in the book, OBP was undervalued... but subtly. Obviously guys like (at the time) Jason Giambi were getting huge contracts for being awesome, but guys like Scott Hatteberg before he went to the As, was a backup catcher with a career .357 OBP. At the time though, he was injured and sporting a .267 BA, so he didn't seem that valuable. So... for the minimum, you could get yourself a ~.750 OPS for the league minimum because he wasn't flashy. Obviously, since like, 2002-2003, a lot of GMs saw this model and had more resources, driving up the value of OBP guys. Obviously, since around that time, the A's have gotten progressively less competitive and have started a model that resembles more of what we do. It's a necessary adaptation... and, around that time, statistics weren't as in vogue as they are now, but with the "Stat for everything" age of the internet we're in, there are fewer and fewer trade secrets as had previously been exploited. And, aside from the stats aspect, another thing that made Beane (in)famous, was inserting himself (or trying to, in a lot of cases) into a trade he basically had no business being involved in. Like when Minaya was trading Cliff Floyd from Montreal to the Sox, Beane had found this out and almost convinced Minaya to trade him to Beane on the agreement that Beane would get all the prospects Minaya wanted to begin with, plus a prospect from him. (Anyone that's played OOTP with me knows I'm also infamous for that crap). But, he'd basically take the players and get something for nothing, or at the very least, something he didn't want. Would you say his recent deal to acquire Scott Hairston fits the explanation (although I'm not sure since Gallagher was one of the guys in the Harden deal that came his way)? Or Beinfest picking up relievers like Kiko Calero for basically nothing. Stuff like that. Billy Beane actually thought extremely high of Calero. Remember he was one of the three returns in the trade that sent Beane's favorite player (Tim Hudson) to the Braves. Calero had great 2005 and 2006 seasons after being traded to the A's, but he had a terrible 2007 and spent all of 2008 in AAA, so based on those concerns they had to let him go. I think Beinfest taking on Calero was more of seeing that he only had one real fall off season and Beane had given up on him at that point, so like the Weachter move it was another low risk high reward move, so in a way it could be seen as a Billy Beane kind of move.
July 25, 200917 yr Would you say his recent deal to acquire Scott Hairston fits the explanation (although I'm not sure since Gallagher was one of the guys in the Harden deal that came his way)? Or Beinfest picking up relievers like Kiko Calero for basically nothing. Stuff like that. What explanation?
July 26, 200917 yr Would you say his recent deal to acquire Scott Hairston fits the explanation (although I'm not sure since Gallagher was one of the guys in the Harden deal that came his way)? Or Beinfest picking up relievers like Kiko Calero for basically nothing. Stuff like that. What explanation? Picking up a .750+ .OPS type player without having to give up much in return. EDIT: As I said though...probably not, since Sean Gallagher isn't a bad prospect.
July 26, 200917 yr Picking up a .750+ .OPS type player without having to give up much in return. EDIT: As I said though...probably not, since Sean Gallagher isn't a bad prospect. What you give up, though, is always relative. And, in the case of trading with the Padres, it's easy to be deceived trading pitching to them. Gallagher, in time in Chicago and Oakland, showed nothing consistent, whereas Scott Hairston has reasonably proven himself to be major league contributor. So, it's a low risk move in Oakland's case... which is another staple in Moneyball, lowering the risks. So, now instead of having what could be equated to the Jeremy Hermida of pitchers, he has an average player.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.