Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2009 NFL Thread

Featured Replies

I think the NFC champ is going to come out of the woodwork this year.. it's not going to be a team that we would predict in our top 3 or 4 right now.

 

 

I'd take that bet, my top 4 being: Giants, Cardinals, Falcons and the Vikes

 

 

All those teams over the Eagles?

 

I could maybe understand the other 3, but why the Vikes? They're not even sure who their QB is, right now. Kinda tough to win without a QB.

I think the NFC champ is going to come out of the woodwork this year.. it's not going to be a team that we would predict in our top 3 or 4 right now.

 

 

I'd take that bet, my top 4 being: Giants, Cardinals, Falcons and the Vikes

 

 

All those teams over the Eagles?

 

I could maybe understand the other 3, but why the Vikes? They're not even sure who their QB is, right now. Kinda tough to win without a QB.

 

 

No it isn't. Bears got to the super bowl without one (lol Grossman), the Ravens won in 2000 without one. Steelers were working with a rookie Ben in 2006 (he was below average his rookie season and the super bowl), same goes for Brady (although Brady was better than Ben in his first season and super bowl). Brad Johnson was the QB for the super bowl Bucs in 2003. It isn't the QB that is needed to win super bowls, it is the defense that is needed.

 

The saying holds true that defenses win championships.

I totally forgot about the Vikings. LOL, they have the best defense in the NFL (easily the #1 rush defense). If they finally got a passing game going, they would be damn near unstoppable.

 

 

 

That team that James Harrison is on has something to say about that.

I totally forgot about the Vikings. LOL, they have the best defense in the NFL (easily the #1 rush defense). If they finally got a passing game going, they would be damn near unstoppable.

 

 

 

That team that James Harrison is on has something to say about that.

 

 

I was trying to say "one of the best defenses in the NFL", as you can tell by the way it was said, and the fact I put #1 rush defense there.

I find it surprising (but I am pleased) that nobody has mentioned the DallASS Cowgirls.

I think the NFC champ is going to come out of the woodwork this year.. it's not going to be a team that we would predict in our top 3 or 4 right now.

 

 

I'd take that bet, my top 4 being: Giants, Cardinals, Falcons and the Vikes

 

 

All those teams over the Eagles?

 

I could maybe understand the other 3, but why the Vikes? They're not even sure who their QB is, right now. Kinda tough to win without a QB.

 

 

No it isn't. Bears got to the super bowl without one (lol Grossman), the Ravens won in 2000 without one. Steelers were working with a rookie Ben in 2006 (he was below average his rookie season and the super bowl), same goes for Brady (although Brady was better than Ben in his first season and super bowl). Brad Johnson was the QB for the super bowl Bucs in 2003. It isn't the QB that is needed to win super bowls, it is the defense that is needed.

 

The saying holds true that defenses win championships.

 

Those were DOMINANT defensive teams. The Vikings defense is amongst the top, but I wouldn't call them dominant.

I think the NFC champ is going to come out of the woodwork this year.. it's not going to be a team that we would predict in our top 3 or 4 right now.

 

 

I'd take that bet, my top 4 being: Giants, Cardinals, Falcons and the Vikes

 

 

All those teams over the Eagles?

 

I could maybe understand the other 3, but why the Vikes? They're not even sure who their QB is, right now. Kinda tough to win without a QB.

 

 

No it isn't. Bears got to the super bowl without one (lol Grossman), the Ravens won in 2000 without one. Steelers were working with a rookie Ben in 2006 (he was below average his rookie season and the super bowl), same goes for Brady (although Brady was better than Ben in his first season and super bowl). Brad Johnson was the QB for the super bowl Bucs in 2003. It isn't the QB that is needed to win super bowls, it is the defense that is needed.

 

The saying holds true that defenses win championships.

 

Those were DOMINANT defensive teams. The Vikings defense is amongst the top, but I wouldn't call them dominant.

 

The Vikings had the best rush defense last season, and their team hasn't changed from last season. When you have the kind of rush defense the Vikings have, it is ok to be 18th in passing defense. I believe their defense and their running game will be good enough to compensate for the average passing game. Like I said, I'm not calling them a super bowl team, but they are a team that has a chance at the NFC Championship game.

  • Author

All those teams over the Eagles?

 

I could maybe understand the other 3, but why the Vikes? They're not even sure who their QB is, right now. Kinda tough to win without a QB.

 

 

A) They are a west coast offensive passing team, Tarvaris Jackson had like... a QB rating over 90 the past however many games he played... the trick to a west coast system is giving the QB time to learn it.

 

B) They have one of, if not the best O-line in football, built for running and quick passes/screen passes.

 

C) 3/4 of their Dline are animals... they have a decent LB corps and Sharper and Winfield in the secondary makes them flat out dangerous.

 

Summary: Teams that can run the ball at will and play great defense = Sweet man

 

 

 

I totally forgot about the Vikings. LOL, they have the best defense in the NFL (easily the #1 rush defense). If they finally got a passing game going, they would be damn near unstoppable.

 

 

 

That team that James Harrison is on has something to say about that.

 

Vikings have the best 4-3 defense in the league... their only competition is the Giants, but the Giants secondary doesn't touch the Vikings.

 

One thing to note, that most people don't, about passing defense. If you're a good team with a good defense and win a lot of games, you're going to give up a lot of garbage "ait it out" yards late in the game that adversely impact that stat. Ultimately, points per game is the best simple metric to use.

All those teams over the Eagles?

 

I could maybe understand the other 3, but why the Vikes? They're not even sure who their QB is, right now. Kinda tough to win without a QB.

 

 

A) They are a west coast offensive passing team, Tarvaris Jackson had like... a QB rating over 90 the past however many games he played... the trick to a west coast system is giving the QB time to learn it.

 

B) They have one of, if not the best O-line in football, built for running and quick passes/screen passes.

 

C) 3/4 of their Dline are animals... they have a decent LB corps and Sharper and Winfield in the secondary makes them flat out dangerous.

 

Summary: Teams that can run the ball at will and play great defense = Sweet man

 

 

 

I totally forgot about the Vikings. LOL, they have the best defense in the NFL (easily the #1 rush defense). If they finally got a passing game going, they would be damn near unstoppable.

 

 

 

That team that James Harrison is on has something to say about that.

 

Vikings have the best 4-3 defense in the league... their only competition is the Giants, but the Giants secondary doesn't touch the Vikings.

 

One thing to note, that most people don't, about passing defense. If you're a good team with a good defense and win a lot of games, you're going to give up a lot of garbage "ait it out" yards late in the game that adversely impact that stat. Ultimately, points per game is the best simple metric to use.

 

 

PPG is a pretty bad way to measure a defense. A team can be stopped at the 35 yard line or stopped at the 3 and have the same scoring result. Sometimes it's skewed, but YPG is probably the best team defensive stat out there.

  • Author

PPG is a pretty bad way to measure a defense. A team can be stopped at the 35 yard line or stopped at the 3 and have the same scoring result. Sometimes it's skewed, but YPG is probably the best team defensive stat out there.

 

 

YPG is weak because if you're a team that relies on shutting down the run and ball control, you're going to give up "garbage" passing yards. Who cares if you gave up a field goal that was a 50 yarder or a 30 yarder, you didn't give up a touchdown. Gotta remember, there are a lot of cases of offensive turnovers on the bad side of the field where the defense has to hold up and holding the offense to a field goal is still a victory.

 

But when you're playing prevent defense up by 11 with 1 minute left and the opposing team drops 50 or so yards (while simultaneously eating clock off the board) your YPG suffers from meaningless yardage.

 

Look at the Dolphins YPG splits during their crappy year, they got run on like a pee wee league team, which ultimately skewed their passing defense, making it look better than it actually was, because why would a team that's beating you bother passing anyways? Thereby lowering the PYPG...

PPG is a pretty bad way to measure a defense. A team can be stopped at the 35 yard line or stopped at the 3 and have the same scoring result. Sometimes it's skewed, but YPG is probably the best team defensive stat out there.

 

 

YPG is weak because if you're a team that relies on shutting down the run and ball control, you're going to give up "garbage" passing yards. Who cares if you gave up a field goal that was a 50 yarder or a 30 yarder, you didn't give up a touchdown. Gotta remember, there are a lot of cases of offensive turnovers on the bad side of the field where the defense has to hold up and holding the offense to a field goal is still a victory.

 

But when you're playing prevent defense up by 11 with 1 minute left and the opposing team drops 50 or so yards (while simultaneously eating clock off the board) your YPG suffers from meaningless yardage.

 

Look at the Dolphins YPG splits during their crappy year, they got run on like a pee wee league team, which ultimately skewed their passing defense, making it look better than it actually was, because why would a team that's beating you bother passing anyways? Thereby lowering the PYPG...

 

 

There's a big difference between a 50 or a 30 yard FG. If a drive starts at mid-field for a team, and they drive for 15 yards to set up around a 50 yard FG, that's much different than if they drive for 45 yards and get multiple first downs, only to settle for around a 20 yard FG.

 

Neither one is great, but I'd go with YPG. Then again, the best way to judge is usually just by watching the games.

I would love to make a bet with you PWG with something cutler related

 

 

And I wasnt saying that (the giants/eagles comment) because I'm a bears fan... well not totally... but just because I think there there are a good amount of teams that could come out of the NFC... not just the eagles or giants

  • Author

There's a big difference between a 50 or a 30 yard FG. If a drive starts at mid-field for a team, and they drive for 15 yards to set up around a 50 yard FG, that's much different than if they drive for 45 yards and get multiple first downs, only to settle for around a 20 yard FG.

 

Neither one is great, but I'd go with YPG. Then again, the best way to judge is usually just by watching the games.

 

 

Ultimately, we'll agree to disagree on the base of it, but it's funny you mention that.

 

From what I've learned defensively of football, from schemes and such... generally speaking, a team will only get one or two long, sustained drives a game... unless they're a juggernaut offense like the Colts or Pats were... so, that being said, if you're an average team, and your opponent drives the length of the field only to get a field goal, assuming your DC isn't a moron, you've set yourself up well for the game.

 

Most scoring is the result of a big play and then a drive the remaining distance, moreso than anything more methodical anyways... sans the notable exceptions.

 

Heck, Dick LeBeau agrees with what I said because he always game plans around giving up 14 points a game, because he knows that there will be two drives that will just happen and will usually result in scoring... it's cool how it normalizes over a full season and they averaged 13.9 last season... man that's cool.

PPG is not a great stat b/c the offense sucking (with turnovers, etc.) has an impact on those #'s, and that has nothing to do with the defense.

 

As for "best 4-3 defense"...I could be wrong, but aren't the Ravens playing the 4-3?

  • Author

I would love to make a bet with you PWG with something cutler related

 

 

And I wasnt saying that (the giants/eagles comment) because I'm a bears fan... well not totally... but just because I think there there are a good amount of teams that could come out of the NFC... not just the eagles or giants

 

 

Really, the only thing I would bet Cutler related is that he's overrated, vs your saying he's not... apparently. There's nothing we could bet on... I think we'd both agree with the Bears run heavy offense, he's not going to get 4000 yards passing... the TDs thing is also obviously affected by this... plus he'll be facing consistently better defenses in that division than he did in the AFC West (lol raiders/chiefs 4 games a year)...

 

I may not like Cutler (very much at all) but I'm also not a dummy. :)

 

I will say this though, while nothing special... Kyle Orton was more than fine for how that team is currently constructed, whereas bringing in Cutler with nobody to throw to lessens any potential gains acquiring him may have netted you. If you guys somehow bring Brandon Marshall in, too... there'll be a different story.

  • Author

PPG is not a great stat b/c the offense sucking (with turnovers, etc.) has an impact on those #'s, and that has nothing to do with the defense.

 

As for "best 4-3 defense"...I could be wrong, but aren't the Ravens playing the 4-3?

 

 

Ravens play everything from 4-3 to 46 to 3-4... I don't know for sure, post-Rex Ryan, but I typically count them towards the 3-4 because of how they utilize their LBs

See I disagree completely about Orton being better for this team. I actually think I just threw up in my mouth ;)

 

I think this is going to open things up tremendously for Mr. Forte who consistently got bombarded in the box yet still made plays. I think with the evolution of Hester running down field and Olsen turning into a Top 5 stud TE... to go along with Dez Clark and lesser known comodoties like Bennett, this team will do some damage on offense. Not to forget the much improved line (Williams, Pace, Omalye)

 

Forte is going to go off

  • Author

PPG is not a great stat b/c the offense sucking (with turnovers, etc.) has an impact on those #'s, and that has nothing to do with the defense.

 

As for "best 4-3 defense"...I could be wrong, but aren't the Ravens playing the 4-3?

 

 

Haha, this was actually the argument I was waiting for someone to use against PPG, because it's really the only good one, but it's rather atypical that a team would have a lights-out defense and an offense that is that bad... it's usually buffered by something like a decent-good running game to lessen the impact of turnovers... plus a good kicking game to play field-position. But, normalized over a full season, I think the "static" in PPG is less noteworthy than the static in YPG.

 

Typically though, the leader boards in both stats are nearly identical.

  • Author

See I disagree completely about Orton being better for this team. I actually think I just threw up in my mouth ;)

 

I think this is going to open things up tremendously for Mr. Forte who consistently got bombarded in the box yet still made plays. I think with the evolution of Hester running down field and Olsen turning into a Top 5 stud TE... to go along with Dez Clark and lesser known comodoties like Bennett, this team will do some damage on offense.

 

Forte is going to go off

 

 

The thing about TEs, which are really the only non-RB threat the Bears have, offensively, is that you don't need any sort of huge QB to exploit the natural mismatches they create. This is why Orton, your Brad Johnson 2.0, if you will, isn't a huge loss over Cutler. The single thing you gain is a better deep ball, which is designed pretty specifically for one player on that offense.

 

To start the season, yeah, DCs will "play it safe" and get run on by Forte, but once they start figuring out the TE match ups, a good press CB like Antoine Winfield or Al Harris can really work well, especially with Winfield having Sharper over the top to cover Hester's speed.

 

There will still be 8-man-fronts.

  • Author

Oh, and I should mention I meant "better" versus the value of what you gave up. The draft picks could have provided any number of other pieces that would have made more of a difference than adding a deep ball to the playbook...

PPGis not a great stat b/c the offense sucking (with turnovers, etc.) hasan impact on those #'s, and that has nothing to do with the defense.

 

As for "best 4-3 defense"...I could be wrong, but aren't the Ravens playing the 4-3?

 

 

 

Turnovers have just as much of a deceptive effect on YPG too. Oakland Raiders a couple years ago had the best YPG pass-defense in the NFL. Part of that was due to actually having a great secondary, but a lot of it had to do with their offense turning it over in the other team's Red Zone all the time, so the opposing team didn't have to go very far.

 

It's certainly plausible to say both are deceptive stats but, when you look at the defenses that have been consistently the best over the last 10 years, those defenses are mostly near the top in PPG allowed. There's always those ones who sneak in there with YPG.

 

 

 

See I disagree completely about Orton being better for this team. I actually think I just threw up in my mouth ;)

 

I think this is going to open things up tremendously for Mr. Forte who consistently got bombarded in the box yet still made plays. I think with the evolution of Hester running down field and Olsen turning into a Top 5 stud TE... to go along with Dez Clark and lesser known comodoties like Bennett, this team will do some damage on offense. Not to forget the much improved line (Williams, Pace, Omalye)

 

Forte is going to go off

 

 

I'm sorry but, a good passing game has a great affect on a running game, but a QB by himself does no such thing. Having Jay Cutler does not automatically just make those non-existent receiving weapons feared. As much as Jay Cutler is much better than Kyle Orton, the Bears Offense is not going to make defenders all of a sudden fear guys because the ball is getting there slightly more sharply or something.

The bears had absolutely no deep ball whatsoever last year. The number of times it was over thrown or underthrown... makes me wanna go insane. And the Marshall love, i think the QB made the WR on that one so give Earl Bennett, Iglesias, Knox, Rideau... bennett in particular some time before we rush to judgement.

 

I guess we'll see. I think Hester, Bennett, Olsen and Dez.. to go with Forte and a healthy Kevin Jones and a very very good OLine will be fun. I am very excited. And all his teammates, former and present, gushing over him make me even more excited.

 

FWIW... I'm 26 years old and Cutler is the 29th starting Chicago QB in my lifetime so I think I have a reason to be excited ;)

Jay Cutler is NOT overrated. He's easily one of the best QBs in the league.

And until Mcnabb can win the big game, the Giants are the best team in thr NFC. The Eagles can't touch the Giants, IMO. Giants are to loaded.

PPGis not a great stat b/c the offense sucking (with turnovers, etc.) hasan impact on those #'s, and that has nothing to do with the defense.

 

As for "best 4-3 defense"...I could be wrong, but aren't the Ravens playing the 4-3?

 

 

 

Turnovers have just as much of a deceptive effect on YPG too. Oakland Raiders a couple years ago had the best YPG pass-defense in the NFL. Part of that was due to actually having a great secondary, but a lot of it had to do with their offense turning it over in the other team's Red Zone all the time, so the opposing team didn't have to go very far.

 

It's certainly plausible to say both are deceptive stats but, when you look at the defenses that have been consistently the best over the last 10 years, those defenses are mostly near the top in PPG allowed. There's always those ones who sneak in there with YPG.

 

 

 

 

 

 

A big reason why Oakland was the leader in that category was b/c there was no need to pass the ball against them. The offense never scored, so once you had a 2 possession lead, there was no need to pass. Their run defense sucked, so all that had to be done was run out the clock, and play some defense (against an offense that was absolutely pitiful).

  • Author

Jay Cutler is NOT overrated. He's easily one of the best QBs in the league.

And until Mcnabb can win the big game, the Giants are the best team in thr NFC. The Eagles can't touch the Giants, IMO. Giants are to loaded.

 

 

The Giants are the best team in the NFC? How'd they do in the superbowl last season?

 

The Giants are one of several very good NFC teams, they are not easily better or worse than any of that top tier of teams in a general manner.

 

I do think Jay Cutler is overrated because people act as if he's some sort of irreplaceable commodity... but Denver losing Cutler would not have the same impact as: Colts losing Manning, Saints losing Brees, Pats losing Brady... etc etc. People love the deep ball, big armed QB, Chicks dig the long ball, whether it's off the bat or as a perfect spiral...

 

And Iowa, yes, you have every reason to be excited about having a "star" QB for the first time in decades. The Bears are a solid, competitive team.... but they were before Cutler, too

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.