Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2009 NFL Thread

Featured Replies

  • Author

PPGis not a great stat b/c the offense sucking (with turnovers, etc.) hasan impact on those #'s, and that has nothing to do with the defense.

 

As for "best 4-3 defense"...I could be wrong, but aren't the Ravens playing the 4-3?

 

 

 

Turnovers have just as much of a deceptive effect on YPG too. Oakland Raiders a couple years ago had the best YPG pass-defense in the NFL. Part of that was due to actually having a great secondary, but a lot of it had to do with their offense turning it over in the other team's Red Zone all the time, so the opposing team didn't have to go very far.

 

It's certainly plausible to say both are deceptive stats but, when you look at the defenses that have been consistently the best over the last 10 years, those defenses are mostly near the top in PPG allowed. There's always those ones who sneak in there with YPG.

 

 

 

 

 

 

A big reason why Oakland was the leader in that category was b/c there was no need to pass the ball against them. The offense never scored, so once you had a 2 possession lead, there was no need to pass. Their run defense sucked, so all that had to be done was run out the clock, and play some defense (against an offense that was absolutely pitiful).

 

That's just further proving the YPG weakness...

PPGis not a great stat b/c the offense sucking (with turnovers, etc.) hasan impact on those #'s, and that has nothing to do with the defense.

 

As for "best 4-3 defense"...I could be wrong, but aren't the Ravens playing the 4-3?

 

 

 

Turnovers have just as much of a deceptive effect on YPG too. Oakland Raiders a couple years ago had the best YPG pass-defense in the NFL. Part of that was due to actually having a great secondary, but a lot of it had to do with their offense turning it over in the other team's Red Zone all the time, so the opposing team didn't have to go very far.

 

It's certainly plausible to say both are deceptive stats but, when you look at the defenses that have been consistently the best over the last 10 years, those defenses are mostly near the top in PPG allowed. There's always those ones who sneak in there with YPG.

 

 

 

 

 

 

A big reason why Oakland was the leader in that category was b/c there was no need to pass the ball against them. The offense never scored, so once you had a 2 possession lead, there was no need to pass. Their run defense sucked, so all that had to be done was run out the clock, and play some defense (against an offense that was absolutely pitiful).

 

That's just further proving the YPG weakness...

 

 

Yes, but that also sucks for PPG b/c Oakland's offense had a bunch of giveaways that year, resulting to points for the opponent, that had little to do with the defense. That's actually the worst offensive team I've ever seen, I think.

For some reason, my hunch tells me that Tampa will challenge for the Superbowl this year. I hope that I am wrong and that the Redskins do that. :mischief

Jay Cutler is NOT overrated. He's easily one of the best QBs in the league.

And until Mcnabb can win the big game, the Giants are the best team in thr NFC. The Eagles can't touch the Giants, IMO. Giants are to loaded.

 

 

The Giants are the best team in the NFC? How'd they do in the superbowl last season?

 

The Giants are one of several very good NFC teams, they are not easily better or worse than any of that top tier of teams in a general manner.

 

I do think Jay Cutler is overrated because people act as if he's some sort of irreplaceable commodity... but Denver losing Cutler would not have the same impact as: Colts losing Manning, Saints losing Brees, Pats losing Brady... etc etc. People love the deep ball, big armed QB, Chicks dig the long ball, whether it's off the bat or as a perfect spiral...

 

And Iowa, yes, you have every reason to be excited about having a "star" QB for the first time in decades. The Bears are a solid, competitive team.... but they were before Cutler, too

 

What does last year have to do with this season?

 

During the offseason, the Giants added Chris Canty, arguably the best DE in FA, and had the best draft, IMO.

 

Some may say they lost Burress, but who they added will make fans forget about Burres. They drafted Hakeem Nicks(who some say is a clone of Anquan Boldin),added Ramses Barden(Red Zone threat), and they added Clint Sintim( Fits their Defense).

So, they have solid receivers, a solid TE, A QB who showed he can win the Big Game, a dominant offensive Line, and a Dominant running attack.

 

On the defensive side, they added to their pass rush by drafting Sintim and getting back Osi. The pass rush will make their secondary better, when it's already good to begin with. It should be elite with that pass rush.

 

IDK, I just don't see any team that can challenge the Giants. They're just to loaded.

 

As for Jay Cutler, I thought you meant he isn't good. He isn't up there with Brady and Manning, for sure. And honestley, I think the Broncos got the better end of the trade. Two first round picks, and a solid QB.

How do you guys see the Lions finishing? I think they can win some games this year. Maybe Matt Stafford can be there Matt Ryan.

How do you guys see the Lions finishing? I think they can win some games this year. Maybe Matt Stafford can be there Matt Ryan.

 

 

 

 

 

Pretty badly.

  • Author

What does last year have to do with this season?

 

During the offseason, the Giants added Chris Canty, arguably the best DE in FA, and had the best draft, IMO.

 

Some may say they lost Burress, but who they added will make fans forget about Burres. They drafted Hakeem Nicks(who some say is a clone of Anquan Boldin),added Ramses Barden(Red Zone threat), and they added Clint Sintim( Fits their Defense).

So, they have solid receivers, a solid TE, A QB who showed he can win the Big Game, a dominant offensive Line, and a Dominant running attack.

 

On the defensive side, they added to their pass rush by drafting Sintim and getting back Osi. The pass rush will make their secondary better, when it's already good to begin with. It should be elite with that pass rush.

 

IDK, I just don't see any team that can challenge the Giants. They're just to loaded.

 

As for Jay Cutler, I thought you meant he isn't good. He isn't up there with Brady and Manning, for sure. And honestley, I think the Broncos got the better end of the trade. Two first round picks, and a solid QB.

 

 

The thing about drafting WRs is that it's genuinely one of the harder positions to transition between college and pro with. So yeah, Nicks may be a really cool prospect, but just like the vast majority of receivers that come out of college, should not be relied upon immediately. And the thing about Eli, he's not the most accurate QB out there and needs WRs that can adjust their routes and such to his throws, ultimately not an easy development process.

 

Their secondary on the whole is pretty average, and yes, it's their pass rush that makes the rest of the defense look good... but with Osi returning, they had a good D-line anyways, Canty just provides quality depth, so his acquisition isn't as big as you make it out to be.

 

But, the teams I named would provide legitimate challenges to the Giants, those teams being the Cardinals, Vikes... etc

 

They'll compete, but in no way are they head and shoulders over the rest of the league, their weaknesses are just as easy to expose as anyone else's.

For some reason, my hunch tells me that Tampa will challenge for the Superbowl this year. I hope that I am wrong and that the Redskins do that.

 

 

As awesome as that would be, I don't see it happening. We have too much uncertainty at QB this year, I mean Byron Leftwich is projected to be our starter

 

I love the acquisition of Kellen Winslow, him and Bryant gives our QB some pretty good targets, so if we can just get some decent play from a QB, we should do alright, maybe sneak into the playoffs but a 8-8 record in our first season with a new coach seems more likely.

PWG... sounds like all you think Cutler can do is throw the deep ball. He knows his receivers. He knows where they want the ball... high or low, etc. He throws the deep ball as good as anyone but is also a play maker. He doesn't under/over throw receivers consistently like Orton. Orton and Cutler aren't in the same leagues. I'd love for you to watch orton last year and still have hair left. Can't beleive I'm not bald

  • Author

PWG... sounds like all you think Cutler can do is throw the deep ball. He knows his receivers. He knows where they want the ball... high or low, etc. He throws the deep ball as good as anyone but is also a play maker. He doesn't under/over throw receivers consistently like Orton. Orton and Cutler aren't in the same leagues. I'd love for you to watch orton last year and still have hair left. Can't beleive I'm not bald

 

 

That's all well and good, but there are really roughly only 3200 yards of passing offense on that team... ~ 1300 to TEs, 800 to Hester and a remaining 1000-1100 to the RBs/other WRs. Last year, Kyle Orton managed to pass for 2900... so you're talking a net gain of less than 20 passing yards a game that weren't there before, that's maaaaaaaybe 2 first downs over the course of one game.

 

And I mean, for all your hair pulling, Ben Roethlisberger had 15 INTs and 14 fumbles and a crapton of over/underthrown deep balls... I can't tell you how many times I'd see Nate Washington get open for nothing..., Orton was only 12 INTs and 6 fumbles. You're really over-hyping what Cutler is going to bring to that team, Cutler or not, it's a run-first, defensive oriented team.

Yes,but that also sucks for PPG b/c Oakland's offense had a bunch of giveaways that year, resulting to points for the opponent, that had little to do with the defense. That's actually the worst offensive team I've ever seen, I think.

 

 

 

That's my entire point though, is that turnovers put just as much of a skew on YPG as they do PPG. They're both important stats to look at for a defense but PPG is more important.

 

 

For some reason, my hunch tells me that Tampa will challenge for the Superbowl this year. I hope that I am wrong and that the Redskins do that. :mischief

 

 

 

That's quite the hunch, since most people would think they'll be competing for number 1 pick.

 

Seriously, what in the WORLD is that hunch based off of?

 

IDK, I just don't see any team that can challenge the Giants. They're just to loaded.

 

They were supposed to be loaded last year too and it didn't work out so well. There's too much parity in the NFL to be so certain that one team has got a clearly better team than everyone else. They play in a very tough NFC East, there would be NO shock if they came in third place in their own division.

Yes,but that also sucks for PPG b/c Oakland's offense had a bunch of giveaways that year, resulting to points for the opponent, that had little to do with the defense. That's actually the worst offensive team I've ever seen, I think.

 

 

 

That's my entire point though, is that turnovers put just as much of a skew on YPG as they do PPG. They're both important stats to look at for a defense but PPG is more important.

 

 

For some reason, my hunch tells me that Tampa will challenge for the Superbowl this year. I hope that I am wrong and that the Redskins do that.

 

 

 

That's quite the hunch, since most people would think they'll be competing for number 1 pick.

 

Seriously, what in the WORLD is that hunch based off of?

 

IDK, I just don't see any team that can challenge the Giants. They're just to loaded.

 

They were supposed to be loaded last year too and it didn't work out so well. There's too much parity in the NFL to be so certain that one team has got a clearly better team than everyone else. They play in a very tough NFC East, there would be NO shock if they came in third place in their own division.

 

 

I agree...no one else like the Redskins to sneak into a playoff spot?

IDK, I just don't see any team that can challenge the Giants. They're just to loaded.

 

They were supposed to be loaded last year too and it didn't work out so well. There's too much parity in the NFL to be so certain that one team has got a clearly better team than everyone else. They play in a very tough NFC East, there would be NO shock if they came in third place in their own division.

 

 

They won the division. How did that not go so well?

And you have to remember, they were without Plaxico Burress, their top WR. This season, they loaded up at the WR position.

Granted, they are rookies, I will give you guys that.

  • Author

They won the division. How did that not go so well?

And you have to remember, they were without Plaxico Burress, their top WR. This season, they loaded up at the WR position.

Granted, they are rookies, I will give you guys that.

 

 

The point is, you said "how could anyone challenge the Giants" they were challenged because they didn't make it to the super bowl, nobody's contesting that they're not a solid team, but they are certainly not a juggernaut by any means.

IDK, I just don't see any team that can challenge the Giants. They're just to loaded.

 

They were supposed to be loaded last year too and it didn't work out so well. There's too much parity in the NFL to be so certain that one team has got a clearly better team than everyone else. They play in a very tough NFC East, there would be NO shock if they came in third place in their own division.

 

 

They won the division. How did that not go so well?

And you have to remember, they were without Plaxico Burress, their top WR. This season, they loaded up at the WR position.

Granted, they are rookies, I will give you guys that.

 

Well they lost in their first playoff game. At home. To their division opponent.

They won the division. How did that not go so well?

And you have to remember, they were without Plaxico Burress, their top WR. This season, they loaded up at the WR position.

Granted, they are rookies, I will give you guys that.

 

 

The point is, you said "how could anyone challenge the Giants" they were challenged because they didn't make it to the super bowl, nobody's contesting that they're not a solid team, but they are certainly not a juggernaut by any means.

 

 

They were without Plaxico Burress for the playoffs, and without Osi for the entire season.

This year, they get Osi back. And like I said, had a great draft. Hakeem Nicks and Ramses Barden don't have to set the world on fire. The Giants already have two solid Wideouts in Steve Smith and Domenik Hixon. Nicks and Barden can come in and do their thing. Which is score in the Red Zone. Plus, their Running attack is crazy good, and their defense got so much better with the additions of Canty, Osi, and Sintim.

 

Maybe you don't see them as a juggernaut, but I do. Too vicious on every level of the game.

IDK, I just don't see any team that can challenge the Giants. They're just to loaded.

 

They were supposed to be loaded last year too and it didn't work out so well. There's too much parity in the NFL to be so certain that one team has got a clearly better team than everyone else. They play in a very tough NFC East, there would be NO shock if they came in third place in their own division.

 

 

They won the division. How did that not go so well?

And you have to remember, they were without Plaxico Burress, their top WR. This season, they loaded up at the WR position.

Granted, they are rookies, I will give you guys that.

 

Well they lost in their first playoff game. At home. To their division opponent.

 

They still made the playoffs, though. They lost in the second round, but still made the playoffs.

am i the only one who think that cutler is a total bitch?? first he forces his way out of denver. makes douchebag comments about denver's fan base which by the way is a really good fan base. and now he's built tension with urlacher and hester by calling them out. this guy has too much ego for a QB that is 3 games under .500 in his career.

There's a guy in New England. The name is Tom Brady. He is now healthy, again. Good luck to the rest of the NFL.

 

 

Just because he is playing doesn't mean the NFL is totally screwed. I'd like to see how he plays when the regular season starts. Let's see how he trusts that knee.

And, btw, Brady is one player. He doesn't block for himself, or play defense. The Patriots can lose.

 

 

With a very good team around him, as well...

 

I think the Giants proved, no team in unbeatable.

 

And I think they will win the division, possibly the Conference but I don't think the offense has the firepower to compete with the top tier of the AFC. And mark my words, this team will miss Derrick Ward ten times more than Plaxico.

  • Author

They were without Plaxico Burress for the playoffs, and without Osi for the entire season.This year, they get Osi back. And like I said, had a great draft. Hakeem Nicks and Ramses Barden don't have to set the world on fire. The Giants already have two solid Wideouts in Steve Smith and Domenik Hixon. Nicks and Barden can come in and do their thing. Which is score in the Red Zone. Plus, their Running attack is crazy good, and their defense got so much better with the additions of Canty, Osi, and Sintim.Maybe you don't see them as a juggernaut, but I do. Too vicious on every level of the game.

 

Their running attack is harshly weakened with the loss of Ward, they have an unproven passing game with a QB that needs receivers to adjust to his ball, offensively, they have a good offensive line, that's the only staple there. Defensively, their D-line is the best pass-rushing 4-3 line in football, their secondary and LB corps are mediocre and are only made to look good as a result of that d-line. And their special teams are no greater or worse than any other team really. "Vicious on every level?" Nah, not really.

 

But here, let me re-hash your exercise for the Steelers:

 

They were without a cohesive offensive line all year, and without a consistent running back for most of the season. Like I said, they had a great draft. They added quality depth to their already good defensive line in Hood and added a burned at the WR/STs in Mike Wallace to offset the losses of Gary Russell and Nate Washington. We already have two solid WRs in Ward and Holmes so Wallace and Sweed can come in and do their thing, specifically score in the endzone. Our running attack is health and should be good again.

 

The above team is not a juggernaut, just a good team with exploitable weaknesses. But when you describe them like that, it ignores the weaknesses. Against a West Coast team (like, omg the eagles who beat them in the playoffs) the pass-rushing defensive line is negated, which exposes their secondary and LBs for what it is. They, too, lost their DCoordinator, and will be dinged by that and more teams will start to exploit it with 3step drops and PA attacks.

 

 

Well they lost in their first playoff game. At home. To their division opponent.

They still made the playoffs, though. They lost in the second round, but still made the playoffs.

 

"Juggernauts" do not go "One-and-done" in the playoffs... this just goes to reaffirm what we're saying, they're a good playoff caliber team, but beyond that... ehhhhh...

 

am i the only one who think that cutler is a total bitch?? first he forces his way out of denver. makes douchebag comments about denver's fan base which by the way is a really good fan base. and now he's built tension with urlacher and hester by calling them out. this guy has too much ego for a QB that is 3 games under .500 in his career.

 

No, I hate Cutler for that nonsense. Dude's a primadonna idiot that's going to regret playing better teams in the NFC north 4-6 games a season.

I disagree with your evaluation of the Giants secondary and linebackers to a lesser extent. But of course you're going to put on your red and black glasses - just as everyone does with their team. I could refute your points and discuss the talent added through free agency and the draft to both group but the games are played on the field, trying to act like Kreskin is for weenies.

  • Author

I disagree with your evaluation of the Giants secondary and linebackers to a lesser extent. But of course you're going to put on your red and black glasses - just as everyone does with their team. I could refute your points and discuss the talent added through free agency and the draft to both group but the games are played on the field, trying to act like Kreskin is for weenies.

 

 

It's not that I'm trying to disparage the Giants or anything, I can't say it enough, they are a good team. But, there really is no such thing as a juggernaut in today's NFL, not with the specialization and niches in the game. And, I'm not saying that the other facets are bad, but rather exploitable weaknesses. Every team has a weakness, and it's just that while the Giants have quality players in their secondary/LB corps, there is no refuting that they are made to look better than they are by the d-line... which would give the impression that they're studs.

 

I was scouting a local team, and I wondered why all their LBs had over 100 tackles, because their LBs weren't overly good, they just had a D-line that cut down the o-line every play, so it'd be the 3-4 LBs vs whoever was left standing. It's sort of the same principle in effect for the Giants. Once the O-line picks up all the rushers, it's the LBs vs whoever is left and usually, in the Giants case, it's beneficial to them. (You know all this, I'm sure, but I'm going into detail for the sake of discussion) But this takes time, and the Giants play in a division with not one, but two West Coast passing teams who thrive on quick-hitting passes, which negate that advantage. And other teams can adapt to try to use those concepts against them, too.

 

Also, Red and Black sunglasses? Black and Gold, perhaps?

 

As for being a weeny... fine, I'm a weeny, I like breaking down things if just for the discussion and tangents it leads to... better than just saying "lol go stillers!"

Also, Red and Black sunglasses? Black and Gold, perhaps?

 

 

Typing too quickly. My bad.

  • Author

Also, Red and Black sunglasses? Black and Gold, perhaps?

 

 

Typing too quickly. My bad.

 

Well I mean, just an FYI... I am super critical about how crappy the Steelers offensive line is and how that could really hurt the team's chances of doing anything.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.