July 4, 201016 yr Gaby is just a good hitter. You can go on and on about him not having ideal power, but he has plenty enough power to make himself useful. Also, I really don't buy into the idea that he is outplaying himself. Except for a down year in High A ball, Gaby was always a solid or better hitter in the minors, and his numbers right now are very close to his minor league production as a whole. It's not unthinkable at all that an advanced age rookie like Gaby could be hitting the same way in the majors, in fact its entirely common that guys like him can equal or better their minor league numbers. He wouldn't have been in the position to earn a starting job both this year and last year if he hadn't have always been highly rated for his approach and presence at the plate. That's why scouts look at a guy like him and feel more confident projecting him as a major league player than other guys who may put up similar numbers in the minors but have a less solid approach, so they will be more easily exploitable at the major league level. A guy with his numbers at first base, he wouldn't ever have been noted if their wasn't a realistic possibility of his doing just as well in the majors with that approach. And the idea of trading him now would go against what this article and what my guy feeling is, in that the team wants to have less streaky and more consistent hitters. Gaby's approach doesn't lend itself to incredible streakiness like Uggla and Ross, and while he is no doubt riding a hot streak (as is Hanley, FTR) he is not likely to experience drastic cold streaks with the way he approaches the plate. I'm confident that Gaby is not going to be a liability. Honestly, I might have doubted that before I saw him put up so good production in the majors, but now that he is I see absolutely nothing in his track record to suggest that he can't sustain pretty good, if not quite as good as now, production in the majors.
July 4, 201016 yr @CanesCop: Right now, Gaby is producing near what Logan's ceiling may be. It's pretty unlikely that Logan can OPS 900+ even as he matures. Unless a team is willing to give up a top-25 spec (which they aren't going to be willing to) then there is absolutely no reason to trade the best hitter on your team not named Hanley, especially when he's making $400k. No more crazy talk. I'm going to assume that was actually directed at me, since I'm the only one who made such a notion. My thing with Gaby is this, he's preforming well above even the highest ceilings given to him and for a rookie with three months under his belt (Minus short stints here or there) that's a scary thought when evaluating him as a player. It's not exactly uncommon for players to have these stellar numbers as rookies and regress to various degrees throughout their careers. Is this the real Gaby here or is this Gaby briefly and greatly out preforming his expectations. Personally I think this is simply a great run that is well above the standards he'll have throughout his career, it happens. And with another first basemen in the minors who is much younger and on paper is likely to have more success over his career it does in my eyes make Gaby a tad more expendable. I'm not saying actively shop him, but if some team calls up with interest in him and offers a good haul I think you take it. He's a 27 year old rookie three months into the season vastly out preforming any and all expectations, if someone is willing to offer us a couple of pieces we desperately need personally I'd take it. I'll leave it to one of you stats hounds to check this out, but it seems that Coghlan could fall in the same category, but everyone wants to keep him. And didn't a lot of folks actually think Gaby would in fact be a big success? I remember lots of people in the two past off-seasons crying for Gaby to be brought up, moreso than for Coghlan. Just food for thought.
July 4, 201016 yr @CanesCop: Right now, Gaby is producing near what Logan's ceiling may be. It's pretty unlikely that Logan can OPS 900+ even as he matures. Unless a team is willing to give up a top-25 spec (which they aren't going to be willing to) then there is absolutely no reason to trade the best hitter on your team not named Hanley, especially when he's making $400k. No more crazy talk. I'm going to assume that was actually directed at me, since I'm the only one who made such a notion. My thing with Gaby is this, he's preforming well above even the highest ceilings given to him and for a rookie with three months under his belt (Minus short stints here or there) that's a scary thought when evaluating him as a player. It's not exactly uncommon for players to have these stellar numbers as rookies and regress to various degrees throughout their careers. Is this the real Gaby here or is this Gaby briefly and greatly out preforming his expectations. Personally I think this is simply a great run that is well above the standards he'll have throughout his career, it happens. And with another first basemen in the minors who is much younger and on paper is likely to have more success over his career it does in my eyes make Gaby a tad more expendable. I'm not saying actively shop him, but if some team calls up with interest in him and offers a good haul I think you take it. He's a 27 year old rookie three months into the season vastly out preforming any and all expectations, if someone is willing to offer us a couple of pieces we desperately need personally I'd take it. Double post see below
July 4, 201016 yr @CanesCop: Right now, Gaby is producing near what Logan's ceiling may be. It's pretty unlikely that Logan can OPS 900+ even as he matures. Unless a team is willing to give up a top-25 spec (which they aren't going to be willing to) then there is absolutely no reason to trade the best hitter on your team not named Hanley, especially when he's making $400k. No more crazy talk. I'm going to assume that was actually directed at me, since I'm the only one who made such a notion. My thing with Gaby is this, he's preforming well above even the highest ceilings given to him and for a rookie with three months under his belt (Minus short stints here or there) that's a scary thought when evaluating him as a player. It's not exactly uncommon for players to have these stellar numbers as rookies and regress to various degrees throughout their careers. Is this the real Gaby here or is this Gaby briefly and greatly out preforming his expectations. Personally I think this is simply a great run that is well above the standards he'll have throughout his career, it happens. And with another first basemen in the minors who is much younger and on paper is likely to have more success over his career it does in my eyes make Gaby a tad more expendable. I'm not saying actively shop him, but if some team calls up with interest in him and offers a good haul I think you take it. He's a 27 year old rookie three months into the season vastly out preforming any and all expectations, if someone is willing to offer us a couple of pieces we desperately need personally I'd take it. The only thing Gaby is outperforming are minor league equivalent's. They don't really make an allowance for guys who are likely to replicate their production compared to guys who are prone to be exploited (like Stanton, Maybin). The second category weighs down the first.
July 4, 201016 yr I'm all for this team trying to build for next year. I just really hope they don't turn this into another stupid building-for-a-tomorrow-that-never-comes thing. This team wasn't supposed to fall this hard this year and they did. Hopefully it's only this year they're conceding.. They really aren't tanking. The run differential is where it should be and the team is drastically unlucky in 1 run games with an 8-16 record. They are underperforming because their cast of ancillary parts - 4-7th relievers in the pen and 10, 11, and 12th position players, are beyond pathetic and doing absolutely nothing. This is not a tomorrow never comes thing, unless you see nearly all of Stanton, Maybin, Morrison, Volstad, West, Marinez, Gaby, Coghlan, Jennings, Ceda, etc, to all turn into average or worse performers. Really unlikely that happens even if a few don't hit projections. Team's in good shape even without Uggla, Ross, and Cantu. Just need to beef up young pitching, and for the love of good sign a veteran bench and 1-2 relievers next year.
July 4, 201016 yr 27 year old first basemen with no power having a hot stretch that he likely wont be able to sustain makes him an attractive sell high candidate too. This isn't your fantasy baseball league. No on expects Gaby to be this .850-.875 OPSing monster, but there is nothing wrong with a guy hitting .280/.350/.450, and playing respectable defense. That isn't a world beater at 1B by any means, but it's a productive player and one we are lucky to have. Sign that guy to play 1B in free agency for more than a year? Hell no. Keep him through arbitration? Hell yes. We also don't know if Morrison is going to hit at the big league level (or lefties), so it would be stupid to put all your marbles in one sack. We need both of these guys. And if both want to hit, Morrison isn't going to be the first plodding LF out there. And realistically, if Maybin and Stanton take over their positions, Maybin would be able to shade to LF a little to help. This is not a problem by any means. We are lucky to have both of them, and we have the ability to play both of them.
July 4, 201016 yr I'm all for Cody and Cantu going at this point, but if Uggla can net us our biggest return then you gotta do what you gotta do and deal him. I'm sure at the deadline there will be a number of teams wanting a power 2B to help get them into the playoffs.
July 4, 201016 yr This team NEEDS to get rid of players like Uggla who in my opinion does not help this team when it really matters most (a la a runner on second with two outs). OPS RISP: .805 OPS RIPS 2 Outs: .808 People walk him with RISP because he would "help the team"
July 4, 201016 yr Yeah, I'm not claiming that Gaby will OPS 900+, so Spike has most certainly twisted my words. He also may not OPS 850 like he's doing now, although his peripherals look decent (BABIP only a little over expected, HR/FB is avg, etc.). The point is still that there is no reason to trade him unless the return is spectacular.
July 4, 201016 yr @CanesCop: Right now, Gaby is producing near what Logan's ceiling may be. It's pretty unlikely that Logan can OPS 900+ even as he matures. Unless a team is willing to give up a top-25 spec (which they aren't going to be willing to) then there is absolutely no reason to trade the best hitter on your team not named Hanley, especially when he's making $400k. No more crazy talk. I'm going to assume that was actually directed at me, since I'm the only one who made such a notion. My thing with Gaby is this, he's preforming well above even the highest ceilings given to him and for a rookie with three months under his belt (Minus short stints here or there) that's a scary thought when evaluating him as a player. It's not exactly uncommon for players to have these stellar numbers as rookies and regress to various degrees throughout their careers. Is this the real Gaby here or is this Gaby briefly and greatly out preforming his expectations. Personally I think this is simply a great run that is well above the standards he'll have throughout his career, it happens. And with another first basemen in the minors who is much younger and on paper is likely to have more success over his career it does in my eyes make Gaby a tad more expendable. I'm not saying actively shop him, but if some team calls up with interest in him and offers a good haul I think you take it. He's a 27 year old rookie three months into the season vastly out preforming any and all expectations, if someone is willing to offer us a couple of pieces we desperately need personally I'd take it. I'll leave it to one of you stats hounds to check this out, but it seems that Coghlan could fall in the same category, but everyone wants to keep him. And didn't a lot of folks actually think Gaby would in fact be a big success? I remember lots of people in the two past off-seasons crying for Gaby to be brought up, moreso than for Coghlan. Just food for thought. Well one of the reasons there was such a call for Gaby was because for the past few years we've had a craptastic players at either first or third, with the lovely Jacobs and Bonifacio man their respective spots and we would have had what we have now; Cantu at third and Gaby at first. There wasn't much of a cry for Cogs because we've had Uggla manning second. As far as Cogs falling into the same category, he could indeed fall there (Gaby averaged an .849 OPS in his minor league career, Cogs a .839). I'm not saying Gaby will regress into the abyss, hell I expect him to have around a .800OPS on average for his career. I'm simply saying this team needs a lot of pieces and with Morrison ready to come up at anytime who is expected to out preform Gaby if some GM is willing to buy into the studly performance he's had so far and is willing to give us a couple of those pieces you take it.
July 4, 201016 yr Author 27 year old first basemen with no power having a hot stretch that he likely wont be able to sustain makes him an attractive sell high candidate too. ummm dont forget dan uggla and ryan howard were the same age when they came up.
July 4, 201016 yr Author though we are playing like sh*t....were still only 7.5 out of the wild card.
July 4, 201016 yr I'm looking at some numbers right now, and Gaby Sanchez is comparable to Kevin Youkilis minus a little OBP and plus some slugging. In the case of Youkilis, he showed signs of power in the minors without ever being a monster there, but he exploded after a couple years in the majors to average around .560 the last three years, age 29-31. There's no reason that Gaby can't fit into this mold, especially when you look at the sheer amount of doubles he had in certain seasons. There's a saying in scouting, "doubles in the minors translates to homers in the majors". There are a lot of reasons for this, but one of the obvious is that players will generally get stronger and more polished as he gets older. Also, keep in mind that the sheer number of extra base hits shows how many times these guys are squaring up the ball. Gaby's production right now doesn't have to be an aberration, though they are at a peak right now due to a hot streak and they will regress just a bit when he settles . But that level just a big below where he is right now is one he is entirely capable of sustaining or slightly exceeding throughout his career. And when you look at a guy like Youkilis, and take into account Gaby's hitting skills, frame, and polish, it is not impossible that he could have a pretty good power surge at some point.
July 4, 201016 yr I'm looking at some numbers right now, and Gaby Sanchez is comparable to Kevin Youkilis minus a little OBP and plus some slugging. In the case of Youkilis, he showed signs of power in the minors without ever being a monster there, but he exploded after a couple years in the majors to average around .560 the last three years, age 29-31. There's no reason that Gaby can't fit into this mold, especially when you look at the sheer amount of doubles he had in certain seasons. There's a saying in scouting, "doubles in the minors translates to homers in the majors". There are a lot of reasons for this, but one of the obvious is that players will generally get stronger and more polished as he gets older. Also, keep in mind that the sheer number of extra base hits shows how many times these guys are squaring up the ball. Gaby's production right now doesn't have to be an aberration, though they are at a peak right now due to a hot streak and they will regress just a bit when he settles . But that level just a big below where he is right now is one he is entirely capable of sustaining or slightly exceeding throughout his career. And when you look at a guy like Youkilis, and take into account Gaby's hitting skills, frame, and polish, it is not impossible that he could have a pretty good power surge at some point. That's really optimistic. Doubles in the minors turn into home runs for Logan Morrison hitting them at 20-21, and not Gaby Sanchez hitting them at 25. I appreciate the Youk comp, but it's really incredible the power output Youk has grown into. That's not normal, so I don't think that's a very strong argument for Gaby to turn into a 30 HR monster. Youkilis 2006-2007 is likely what Gaby will be. Solid, above average player. Great player for the Marlins to have. We shouldn't be looking to move him. We should be looking to build with him.
July 4, 201016 yr 27 year old first basemen with no power having a hot stretch that he likely wont be able to sustain makes him an attractive sell high candidate too. This isn't your fantasy baseball league. :lol I was going to say the same thing. That sounds like a fantasy baseball comment, not a real one.
July 4, 201016 yr I'm looking at some numbers right now, and Gaby Sanchez is comparable to Kevin Youkilis minus a little OBP and plus some slugging. In the case of Youkilis, he showed signs of power in the minors without ever being a monster there, but he exploded after a couple years in the majors to average around .560 the last three years, age 29-31. There's no reason that Gaby can't fit into this mold, especially when you look at the sheer amount of doubles he had in certain seasons. There's a saying in scouting, "doubles in the minors translates to homers in the majors". There are a lot of reasons for this, but one of the obvious is that players will generally get stronger and more polished as he gets older. Also, keep in mind that the sheer number of extra base hits shows how many times these guys are squaring up the ball. Gaby's production right now doesn't have to be an aberration, though they are at a peak right now due to a hot streak and they will regress just a bit when he settles . But that level just a big below where he is right now is one he is entirely capable of sustaining or slightly exceeding throughout his career. And when you look at a guy like Youkilis, and take into account Gaby's hitting skills, frame, and polish, it is not impossible that he could have a pretty good power surge at some point. That's really optimistic. Doubles in the minors turn into home runs for Logan Morrison hitting them at 20-21, and not Gaby Sanchez hitting them at 25. I appreciate the Youk comp, but it's really incredible the power output Youk has grown into. That's not normal, so I don't think that's a very strong argument for Gaby to turn into a 30 HR monster. Youkilis 2006-2007 is likely what Gaby will be. Solid, above average player. Great player for the Marlins to have. We shouldn't be looking to move him. We should be looking to build with him. I didn't mean to imply that Gaby was going to slug .560 like Youk. Just showing that it's possible for guys to exceed their minor league production even after they break into the majors later. I think Gaby could easily exceed Youk's 2006-2007, given that his power production was generally better in the upper minors.
July 4, 201016 yr though we are playing like sh*t....were still only 7.5 out of the wild card. Keep the faith!
July 4, 201016 yr Yeah there's really no reason to lose faith so early. We could easily pull a White Soxs in 05 or Rockies in 07 and have the greatest August and September ever after struggling the majority of the season and making the playoffs.
July 4, 201016 yr Yeah there's really no reason to lose faith so early. We could easily pull a White Soxs in 05 or Rockies in 07 and have the greatest August and September ever after struggling the majority of the season and making the playoffs. Well maybe not easily......
July 4, 201016 yr Yeah there's really no reason to lose faith so early. We could easily pull a White Soxs in 05 or Rockies in 07 and have the greatest August and September ever after struggling the majority of the season and making the playoffs. Well maybe not easily...... Well you it won't be easy but I meant big turnarounds do happen often.
July 4, 201016 yr Yeah there's really no reason to lose faith so early. We could easily pull a White Soxs in 05 or Rockies in 07 and have the greatest August and September ever after struggling the majority of the season and making the playoffs. Well maybe not easily...... Well you it won't be easy but I meant big turnarounds do happen often. Yeah, but big turnarounds are a lot less likely when you're competing against so much talent in your own division.
July 4, 201016 yr Its safe to say that besides their rotation the Braves are overachieving. I mean they are doing well with there best two hitters, McCann and Jones having proabaly one of the worst seasons of there careers. The Nats are starting to play more like the Nats, The Mets pitching is coming back down to earth and the Phillies are getting bit by the injury bug. If the Marlins ever pick it up and go on a nice 8 or 9 game win streak and win multiple series in a row they should be able to get right back in the front running of the Divison and Wildcard races.
July 4, 201016 yr Yeah there's really no reason to lose faith so early. We could easily pull a White Soxs in 05 or Rockies in 07 and have the greatest August and September ever after struggling the majority of the season and making the playoffs. Well maybe not easily...... Well you it won't be easy but I meant big turnarounds do happen often. Yeah, but big turnarounds are a lot less likely when you're competing against so much talent in your own division. And they're less likely if you've sold off some of your best players in July. But even then it has been done and I'm ready to keep the faith as long as they don't keep sliding downhill.
July 5, 201016 yr Question from me. Let's say Marlins get back into the race for Wild Card or Division but finish the year at only like 82-89 wins. Over .500. Do you still trade one or a combo of Uggla, Cantu, and Ross for what you can? Esp if either of them heats up and has a pretty good season? I'm pretty sure if the Marlins somehow made the playoffs or won the World Series...Loria would keep at least 1 if not 2 of them.
July 5, 201016 yr Question from me. Let's say Marlins get back into the race for Wild Card or Division but finish the year at only like 82-89 wins. Over .500. Do you still trade one or a combo of Uggla, Cantu, and Ross for what you can? Esp if either of them heats up and has a pretty good season? I'm pretty sure if the Marlins somehow made the playoffs or won the World Series...Loria would keep at least 1 if not 2 of them. Cantu is gone at the end of the year as a free agent.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.