Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Suspensions from the Brawl

Featured Replies

Sanabia got five games because MLB wants to be certain that he misses a start. A five game suspension is pretty much the minimum suspension a starting pitcher can get, although it isn't a written rule.

 

 

I would think thought that Volstad would have got more games then. NOT THAT I WANT IT GUYS, believe me. But since in a way Volstad was an "instigator" by throwing the balls at Morgan, I would think Volstad would get more than 1 more than Sanabia. Hope everyone understands what I just said, lol.

If you assume that, Morgan should have gotten much more too (on top of the original 7).

 

I agree that Morgan should have got more for charging the mound, fighting, gestures and words to the crowd as he was walked out, etc. Especially the "WWE" approach and it sounded as if he was displaying "the chip" on his shoulder to postgame interviews. What he got, on top of what just happened with the Cards AND fan, just isn't enough. I also heard he was arguing with the Marlins crowd before all this ? ? ? Wonder if any of that tape got sent to MLB.

 

But I'm not sure why Volstad just got 1 more game than Sanabia. And I don't want Volstad to get more, just it seems uneven. BUT either way, it is just 1 start :)

Morgan deserves to spend the rest of this season suspended. I've mentioned this before, but at the current moment he's a hazard to the safety of the players, fans, and anyone around him. If Morgan isn't forced to take mandatory anger management classes, MLB and the Washington Nationals aren't doing their jobs properly.

 

Also, Sanabia without a doubt deserved one game for this. He was throwing some serious hay makers, and as some people mentioned before, he was the first one there and was one of the biggest aggressors on the field.

 

All the suspensions seem right. Listach didn't belong where he was, I don't care if he was protecting his player, he shouldn't be at the bottom of that pile.

 

Gaby's 3 games were obviously gonna happen. Nobody lands as perfect of a haymaker as Gaby did doesn't get anything less or more than 3.

 

I think all these suspensions were to be expected. I even expected the relatively small number for Morgan. I don't think MLB is being tough enough with him honestly. Right now he's a poor image of the sport and a poor image of what the Washington Nationals truly are. Morgan should excuse himself from the team for the season and come back a better person next year (although "The Kid" isn't going to do that because his ego is in the way).

  • Author

Morgan should excuse himself from the team for the season and come back a better person next year (although "The Kid" isn't going to do that because his ego is in the way).

 

 

Yep, he appealed the new suspension and is playing today.

I've been over to the MLB Nationals site and read the Nats' comments. It appeared to me that the Marlins have forgotten, but not certain that there won't be some issues from the Nats side next week.

Morgan should excuse himself from the team for the season and come back a better person next year (although "The Kid" isn't going to do that because his ego is in the way).

 

 

Yep, he appealed the new suspension and is playing today.

 

Sorry, I think that's wrong. I wouldn't think the MLB would allow a second suspension to be appealed while another has been postponed. I'm certainly disappointed with MLB on this.

Veras was ejected, for no reason (unless he said something very, very vulgar, in which case fists were flying so I dont think you could say anything to get you ejected).

 

And also... lol at Sanabia getting a longer suspension than Listach or Stalen.

 

Or the fact that he had a longer suspension than Gaby.

 

Or the fact that none of them were ejected (save Volstad) and they all got suspended, but the ejected Marlin, Veras, didnt get suspended.

 

Or the fact that Sanabia got suspended at all. Or the fact that Nyjer Morgan didnt get... perhaps... 3 times the amount of games suspended as any single person out there.

 

- Charging the mound, ultimately the only agressor in the whole dilema

- throwing the first punch

- Cursing at the fans

- tearing his jersey off

- injuring Brett Hayes

- having an amazing track record of doing all of this - not the first time he's charged a mound, or made a fool of this sport throwing his glove at a ball he misses, or throwing a ball at a fan

 

The MLB should've put Nyjer Morgan in his place, 8/15 games does not do it. Should've been for the season.

 

The difference between Sanabia and Stalen is that Sanabia's a starting pitcher and Stalen's a relief pitcher though. They naturally assume Stalen would have played in all 3 games he's suspended, whereas Sanabia theoretically miss just one start. Anyway, I'm just saying.

 

Again, I don't think Sanabia should have been suspended at all.

The difference between Sanabia and Stalen is that Sanabia's a starting pitcher and Stalen's a relief pitcher though. They naturally assume Stalen would have played in all 3 games he's suspended, whereas Sanabia theoretically miss just one start. Anyway, I'm just saying.

 

Again, I don't think Sanabia should have been suspended at all.

 

 

Lol I know, I said that at the bottom about Sanabia shouldnt have been suspended at all.

 

Point though about the starter versus relief pitcher, but what most concerns me is the weakness of the MLB on this matter - Morgan shouldnt be playing today and should not have gotten off with almost the same amount of games as Chris Volstad.

Sanabia got suspended because he started throwing down, a 5 game suspension for a SP is really a 1 game suspension. That's fair.

 

I think Gaby shouldn't have been suspended for more than 1 game but whatever.

 

I think it's ridiculous that the CBA allows Morgan to play today. MLB should have moved his appeal date up and sent him off. I also believe he should have been sent off for the season and maybe some mandatory counseling because there's something wrong with him obviously.

 

I also think Listach should have gotten a week. A coach can't get in on that, I don't care what his intention are.

Sanabia got suspended because he started throwing down, a 5 game suspension for a SP is really a 1 game suspension. That's fair.

 

I think Gaby shouldn't have been suspended for more than 1 game but whatever.

 

I think it's ridiculous that the CBA allows Morgan to play today. MLB should have moved his appeal date up and sent him off. I also believe he should have been sent off for the season and maybe some mandatory counseling because there's something wrong with him obviously.

 

I also think Listach should have gotten a week. A coach can't get in on that, I don't care what his intention are.

 

 

With a PSYCHIATRIST and ANGER MANAGEMENT :D

With a PSYCHIATRIST and ANGER MANAGEMENT :D

 

 

You mean Psychologist, Psychiatrists just give medicine to the mentally ill, psychologists study weather someone is crazy or not...

 

Sucks that Sanabia and Volstad both have to miss starts, my guesses are Badenhop and one of Villanueva or Kohler get the second start or if anything they might go to Sosa or Hensley which is highly unlikely.

 

The lineup is going to look weird but their are a couple of things they can do.

 

What I would like to see is

Maybin CF

Logan 1B

Hanley SS

Uggla 2B

Stanton RF

Tracy/Helms 3B

Bonifacio LF

Catcher

 

Hopefully they can appeal long enough to be able to play in the crucial Atlanta series this weekend.

With a PSYCHIATRIST and ANGER MANAGEMENT :D

 

 

You mean Psychologist, Psychiatrists just give medicine to the mentally ill, psychologists study weather someone is crazy or not...

No, Psychiatrist give medicine to those who need, not just the "mentally ill". They also figure out what is mentally wrong with someone, whether it be depression, dementia, ADHD, or any number of things. Psychologists are like psychiatrists but don't give out medicine.

 

Also, it's worth noting that they don't need to take their suspension at the same time. We don't need two extra starters, just 1 to first spell Volstand and then spell Sanabia or visa versa.

First off, I agree with you guys..Morgan shouldn't have gotten off so easily and shouldn't be allowed to appeal a second suspension! As for seeing Sanabia, I watched the video over and over and wow you guys have good eyes. It happens so fast, I wish I could play the video is slow motion. But I did notice Andrew Miller's mustache lol

 

As for who's playing first when Gaby is suspended, I wouldn't honestly be surprised seeing Helms there at first and Tracy at third. Not saying I like that but I won't be suprised seeing that

I'd like to see Logan at first but I wouldn't be surprised if we see Helms/Tracy at 1B/3B.

 

 

Wow, you read my mind or I read yours...either way, freaky :blink:

With a PSYCHIATRIST and ANGER MANAGEMENT :D

 

 

You mean Psychologist, Psychiatrists just give medicine to the mentally ill, psychologists study weather someone is crazy or not...

 

 

It's a psychiatrist. Psychologists can play the same role as a counsilor but cant perscrible medicine; they're not MDs.

 

 

 

 

I think.

With a PSYCHIATRIST and ANGER MANAGEMENT :D

 

 

You mean Psychologist, Psychiatrists just give medicine to the mentally ill, psychologists study weather someone is crazy or not...

 

 

It's a psychiatrist. Psychologists can play the same role as a counsilor but cant perscrible medicine; they're not MDs.

 

 

 

 

I think.

Bingo bango.

  • Author

A psychiatrist is the equivalent of any other medical doctor, except that they specialize in mental disorders. They have gone to medical school and received either a MD or DO and can prescribe medications to patients.

 

A psychologist has not gone to medical school and but rather graduate psychology programs. They typically do research, counseling, or clinical work. They have "patients" but can't prescribe medication. Many of them have PhDs and thus aren't licensed physicians.

A psychiatrist is the equivalent of any other medical doctor, except that they specialize in mental disorders. They have gone to medical school and received either a MD or DO and can prescribe medications to patients.

 

A psychologist has not gone to medical school and but rather graduate psychology programs. They typically do research, counseling, or clinical work. They have "patients" but can't prescribe medication. Many of them have PhDs and thus aren't licensed physicians.

 

Right.

 

And I agree with Dr Willinghamr, you shut the door.

So I'm thinking this idea would be rejected, but during really bad Marlins games where we're going to lose by a lot or during rain delays, what if we could get a guy to dress up as Nyjar Morgan and have Billy the Marlin beat him to a pulp..ya know just to entertain the crowd at the stadium?...probably not going to happen right?

I'd like to see Logan at first but I wouldn't be surprised if we see Helms/Tracy at 1B/3B.

 

 

Yeah, with how much this organization hates to move players around and break their "comfort level" (whether that's position, line up spot, ect), I severely doubt we see Logan at first. I'd love to see Scotty Cuz in lf with logan at 1b though

So ... since Morgan's appealing, what do you think the chances are he does something against the Marlins next week if he's still playing then?

So ... since Morgan's appealing, what do you think the chances are he does something against the Marlins next week if he's still playing then?

 

 

0% chance...yet again it's Nyjer Morgan so who knows

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.