Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Edgar Renteria

Featured Replies

Would have no problem. They definitely need to get someone as 3B insurance

Not that I would mind as this move provides some more flexibility, but after acquiring Infante, I'm pretty meh about this if it happens.

Ozzie Martinez wouldn't be a huge downgrade (if at all) to Renteria, at this point of their respective careers, imo. Renteria is not an everyday player so if he's "Plan B," I'd still be hoping that Dominguez wins a job in Spring Training.

 

Bench would be:

Helms

Renteria

Bonifacio

lefty bat

backup catcher

Is Renteria willing to take a back-up role or does he still want a chance to start?

 

 

 

I'm sure he wants a chance to start; if the Marlins give him a fair deal, I'm sure he'd sign and retire here.

If he stays with the Giants, he's at best a utility infielder because the Giants already have their starting SS, 2B, and 3B.

From a nostalgic point of view, I love it. From a talent point of view, meh.

I'm told by 2 sources that Edgar Renteria's name has not come up in discussions by #Marlins front office. Neither has Mike Cameron's name

 

- Joe Capozzi

"I have received at least another offer since I was a free agent, but it wasn't what I'm looking for to continue playing," Renteria said. "If I got a good offer, I'm playing, and if not, it's better to stay at home."

 

I have a feeling that offer was from the Marlins

I guess he's staying home then.

He's not a necessity, anyway.

"I have received at least another offer since I was a free agent, but it wasn't what I'm looking for to continue playing," Renteria said. "If I got a good offer, I'm playing, and if not, it's better to stay at home."

 

I have a feeling that offer was from the Marlins

 

Then you would be wrong. According to Beinfest the Marlins have not even entertained an idea of looking at him.

According to MLB rumors, Renteria has narrowed his options down to Giants, Cards, and Marlins.

 

 

With all of the fans talking about Joe Crede, etc. why not let Edgar Renteria finish his career with the Fish? I understand we need a lefty bat but as far as leadership goes (yes, it's really important to a team Erick- read the article on flamarlins.com with real manager quotes), Renteria is awesome and could really mentor Hanley. Realistically, Edgar has even mentioned a move to 2nd base, which would be a perfect fallback option (better option than Bonifacio) for Infante, who is due for a down year.

 

Injury prone, yes- but leadership wise, Edgar can be a valuable asset to a contending team with a productive 200 ABs.

 

Look at this bench:

 

Wes Helms

Edgar Renteria

Emilio Bonifacio

John Baker

Lefty Bat

 

 

 

Not sure why you're bringing up my name on this thread when I was the first to say earlier this offseason that I wouldn't have minded Renteria on the team. Then again, I don't see the point now considering that we got Infante in the Uggla trade. Seems whatever-ish to me.

 

The Marlins don't have the money to spend on leadership, and they certainly don't have the leftover money to spend on it on a guy who might bring two more fans out to the stadium this year. So those are two stupid reasons to sign the guy.

 

"Stupid" is too hard a word to use. The leadership role is a good point because Hanley does need to learn that. But Renteria isn't the answer. $1 mil to Wes is one thing, but to spend the type of $$$ that Edgar would want is something totally different. It's not that we don't have the $$$, it's just that that $$$ could be better spent. He's just not a good fit here. It wasn't a good idea earlier this off season, and it's not now.

I think you're completely overestimating the amount of money Edgar's going to get. He's a guy who lost his starting job last year, is old (will be "34", will play like he's 44), had a couple injuries that cut his season in half, and hasn't been good since 2007. I can't imagine that he'll command much of a salary at all.

 

C'mon Rab. Just admit it when you are wrong. It will make you feel so much better.

Renteria is worth 6 million according to sabernomics, so hes right..

 

 

 

LOL

 

Can I nominate this as the funniest post ever?

If we are continuing to look for lefty relief pitchers then it would be worth it for the Marlins to bring in Dontrelle Willis on a minor league contract.

 

People say he's done, but he is still young and could develop into a decent RP- we know the heart is at least into it.

 

 

They have been very actively scouting DTrain. And have decided his head is wrong.

 

That is a little paraphrasing, but almost precise wording from the FO.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.