July 20, 201412 yr Author Yea, pretty darn sure it's 3 unless something changed. Only JUCO players are eligible year to year. I believe the NFL is 2 years, maybe? JUCOs can be drafted at any time, players without a redshirt at 4 year schools can be drafted after their sophomore year.
July 20, 201412 yr JUCOs can be drafted at any time, players without a redshirt at 4 year schools can be drafted after their sophomore year. Is that new? I thought 4 years schools was a minimum 3 years.
July 20, 201412 yr If I remember right, when Harper signed, it was about 30 seconds before the deadline. But the nationals wanted to make he deal and keep him. I'd argue the Astros didn't want Aiken unless it was for bottom dollar.
July 20, 201412 yr But the nationals wanted to make he deal and keep him. I'd argue the Astros didn't want Aiken unless it was for bottom dollar. You may be right, but at the same time ... it's a business, and each player can be considered a product. They saw a defect in this product they're attempting to "buy" if you will, so would you want to pay top dollar for that defective product? (Assuming the physical results on him were true)
July 20, 201412 yr JUCOs can be drafted at any time, players without a redshirt at 4 year schools can be drafted after their sophomore year. If they go to a 4yr school, the only way to get drafted after their sophomore year is if they have to turn 21 before the draft
July 21, 201412 yr You may be right, but at the same time ... it's a business, and each player can be considered a product. They saw a defect in this product they're attempting to "buy" if you will, so would you want to pay top dollar for that defective product? (Assuming the physical results on him were true) From what's been reported- the defect isn't true and was a ploy to bring the signing bonus down to sign both Nix And Marshall with the saved cap room. Even the 5m offer was to sign nix as well. Nix agreed with the Astros at 1.5m and was in town to sign the deal when try pulled back. The 1.5 plus the 5m to Aiken was exactly the slot for the 1 overall pick and what they agreed on.
July 21, 201412 yr From what's been reported- the defect isn't true and was a ploy to bring the signing bonus down to sign both Nix And Marshall with the saved cap room. Even the 5m offer was to sign nix as well. Nix agreed with the Astros at 1.5m and was in town to sign the deal when try pulled back. The 1.5 plus the 5m to Aiken was exactly the slot for the 1 overall pick and what they agreed on. If that is the case, then that's terrible on the Astros part. Be very interesting to see what happens - what would you do in Aiken's position? Attempt to become a free agent, play in a JuCo, go to University, play in Japan? The possibilities are endless!
July 21, 201412 yr I would have taken 5 million dollars, jerked off, and gone to sleep. You wouldn't have taken a dump? Damn, dude, that money has satisfied you.
July 21, 201412 yr If they go to a 4yr school, the only way to get drafted after their sophomore year is if they have to turn 21 before the draft So only if they were held back, basically. So almost all of the time most players at 4-year schools are not eligible until their Junior year. If that is the case, then that's terrible on the Astros part. Be very interesting to see what happens - what would you do in Aiken's position? Attempt to become a free agent, play in a JuCo, go to University, play in Japan? The possibilities are endless! I would probably bet on Juco.
July 22, 201412 yr I would have taken 5 million dollars, jerked off, and gone to sleep. In fairness that also occurs after Taco Bell, so.
July 22, 201412 yr If that is the case, then that's terrible on the Astros part. Be very interesting to see what happens - what would you do in Aiken's position? Attempt to become a free agent, play in a JuCo, go to University, play in Japan? The possibilities are endless! I probably would have checked in on going to Japan on a one year deal. They probably would over pay by a boat load to get an American player with his potential for the one year. Realistically, he stood up for himself. I can't fault him for that. He may have endangered his financial future but he'll always get another chance. Some team will draft him next year.
July 24, 201412 yr Haven't read it yet but I want to save the link- from the writers and Astros perspective apparently http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=24223
July 25, 201412 yr Good recap of how the Astros didn't negotiate I good faith. http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2014/07/mlbpa-files-grievance-against-astros-relating-to-unsigned-draft-picks.html
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.