July 18, 201412 yr Very rare for a first overall pick to not sign. Any idea what the rules are in terms of him playing overseas and becoming a FA that way?
July 18, 201412 yr I would've declined, too. The Astros were already signing him at a big discount. That's so Marlins Astros!
July 18, 201412 yr So in this regard the Marlins did end up with the first overall pick this past draft...SUCCESS Really sucks the Astros couldn't sign Aiken, but they tried to lowball him after the injury was found. $5 million's a good offer for anybody especially one with injury concerns, but if Aiken feels he was slighted by the 'Stros originally and thinks he can regain his top draft status and make that money plus some next year, well all power to him. I'm not 100% what the rules are for a top pick who doesn't sign, but I'm pretty sure Aiken's gonna go play at JUCO for a season. I would've thought he'd go to UCLA but it seems he wants to go the JUCO route.
July 18, 201412 yr Author I'm not 100% what the rules are for a top pick who doesn't sign, but I'm pretty sure Aiken's gonna go play at JUCO for a season. I would've thought he'd go to UCLA but it seems he wants to go the JUCO route. Probably doesn't want to wait the required 2 years if he goes to UCLA.
July 18, 201412 yr Probably doesn't want to wait the required 2 years if he goes to UCLA. Thought it was 3 years?
July 18, 201412 yr Could be, I'm unsure of the rules with the draft Yea, pretty darn sure it's 3 unless something changed. Only JUCO players are eligible year to year. I believe the NFL is 2 years, maybe?
July 18, 201412 yr DisAstros. Aiken will probably go the Bryce Harper route and play at JuCo. His agent is apparently trying to file a grievance that will allow him to become a FA outright though, so this could get interesting.
July 18, 201412 yr Author It's unlikely he'd win that grievance but worth a try. Nix SHOULD win his grievance though
July 18, 201412 yr Astros offered 40% of slot for months. In a panic they offered 5 mil with minutes to go and never got a yes or no. They just told them to pound sand. The fact the players have no leverage on this is what is disturbing. The Astros said he was injured and offered a lot less. The player got numerous second opinions saying he's fine and still couldn't leverage up until the very end.
July 18, 201412 yr Astros offered 40% of slot for months. In a panic they offered 5 mil with minutes to go and never got a yes or no. They just told them to pound sand. The fact the players have no leverage on this is what is disturbing. The Astros said he was injured and offered a lot less. The player got numerous second opinions saying he's fine and still couldn't leverage up until the very end. The players have leverage; they can say no. And this situation will only fuel the players leverage in the future.
July 19, 201412 yr Not as cut and dry as they didn't come to a deal, they did come to deal earlier in the process ... and then they discovered he had an abnormally small UCL and then cut their offer significantly. Essentially, he got RA Dickey'd
July 19, 201412 yr And this is precisely why nobody will ever take the MLB draft seriously like the NFL draft or even the NBA draft... at least until they cut the crap with allowing players to not sign and just go back into the draft pool the next year.
July 19, 201412 yr Its been over 30 years since the #1 overall pick failed to sign, so its not unprecedented. Aiken's options are he can honor his commitment to UCLA, but not be eligible for the draft again until 2017, he could sign with a JUCO and get drafted again next year, he can sign with an independent team and get drafted again or the most unlikely might be to seek becoming a free agent through a lawsuit against the Astros. Hard to believe they'll get the #2 pick in the draft next year for failure to sign him.
July 19, 201412 yr He probably wants to finish his degree, and Astros said no? Only logical pseudo-noble thing I could think of that makes sense but not really.
July 19, 201412 yr He probably wants to finish his degree, and Astros said no? Only logical pseudo-noble thing I could think of that makes sense but not really. They had a deal guaranteed for $6.5m. They found his arm had an injury, so they withdrew the offer and then offered $5m. Aiken's side got all pissy and wanted to keep the $6.5m and, well, they never signed him. Oops.
July 19, 201412 yr Maybe my knowledge of the draft is shaky but I'm with squall on this. Your getting 5 mil as a signing bonus and don't even have to throw a pitch in a game. Take the money and anything more in free agency down the line is just cake.
July 19, 201412 yr Astros offered 5 Mill 5 minutes before the deadline. After an agreed to deal, he had the physical and the astors threw the hissy fit and offerd exactly 40% of slot- or the bare minimum to prevent him from being a free agent automatically and the barfe minimum to get a 2nd overall pick if he didnt sign. The issue with the DisAstros is they didnt negotiate in good faith- the issues the Astros saw are only seen by the Astros. He threw 97+ in his last game and worked out twice for them after with the same velo. The Astros tired to sign him below slot to use the money on Nix and Marshall. When that didn't happen, they also pulled the offer to the other players. One of them had an agreed upon deal and took a physical as well. He was cleared and about to sign when the DisAstros pulled back the offer. Aikens situation was they agreed at 6.5M, 4 doctors saw him and only one Astros doctor saw an issue. Thats three second opinions. The Astros offered 3.1M or the minumum to get a pick next year and didnt come up from that until the deadline, when they went to 4, then 5M with 5 Minutes to go. They tried to save face by "Making" a legitimate offer when they knew he was upset at them pulling the offer off the table and slaping him with a 60% cut. The only reason they offered 5M is because they are afraid of the courts deciding in Aikens favor. I hope he becomes a free agent, along with Marshall and Nix- just so the tanking 'stros get nothing for a tanked 2013. The Astros deserve nothing. While the kid is acting like a brat, hes right. Astros tried to get him on the cheap to sign two other players. When It didnt work all 3 kids got screwed in the process. Especially the other perfectly healthy kid that had his offer pulled just because Aiken wasn't signing.
July 19, 201412 yr 17 year old kid turning down five million dollars. smart. I doubt the Astros would have filed the paperwork in time.
July 19, 201412 yr I doubt the Astros would have filed the paperwork in time. If I remember right, when Harper signed, it was about 30 seconds before the deadline.
July 20, 201412 yr There's an interesting article on the Baseball America free section about unsigned first round picks and their history afterwards. http://www.baseballamerica.com/draft/modern-history-unsigned-first-rounders/ It doesn't look like this will work out too well for him financially if he returns in future drafts.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.