Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

MLB the Show 16

Featured Replies

I'm sticking with the sliders from OS lol. I've gotten to the end of June with no major injuries. Just bad luck. Or Marlins luck lol. No Stanton, Jose, we all know the feeling.

Yeah I took the same sliders u suggested and I love them. Suddenly I can hit! Lol not sure if the sliders helped or now that I've gotten more games in I'm just getting the hang of zone hitting but so far so good. But even then I lowered the injury frequency a couple notches.

 

 

I need my roster to match the real Marlins one 24/7/365

To an extent I'm like this. In 2012 Hanley was basically putting up MVP numbers, at the trade deadline I shipped him to the Dodgers for eovaldi and fucked up my season just because I wanted it close to reality.

 

Now what I do is I have my Marlins franchise that will be close to but not exact to reality as I'll take the happenings in the game into consideration.... but at the same time I'll have a backup roster file with the exact real life Marlins moves for when I feel like playing a one off game based on whatever the team is doing.

 

 

 

 

 

To an extent I'm like this. In 2012 Hanley was basically putting up MVP numbers, at the trade deadline I shipped him to the Dodgers for eovaldi and fucked up my season just because I wanted it close to reality.

 

Now what I do is I have my Marlins franchise that will be close to but not exact to reality as I'll take the happenings in the game into consideration.... but at the same time I'll have a backup roster file with the exact real life Marlins moves for when I feel like playing a one off game based on whatever the team is doing.

 

It would be interesting if they had a feature in franchise mode that could start off from the point the real team is at, and see if you can either continue their fortunes or right the ship.

 

Say it was August 1st, your team is 6 games out of a playoff spot, and now you take it over at that point and try to get them to the playoffs. Fun idea!

 

 

Great idea. Sounds fun for picking up other teams too like the Royals last year.

 

Lol it'd be "Jumping on the bandwagon" mode

  • Author

I actually don't like it to be exact to the real thing, I make moves based on what's going on. Like Edwin Jackson has a mid 2 ERA in 25 relief appearances, why cut him? Realmuto was slumping real bad, hitting .160 midway thru June, he's on a AAA assignment to find his swing back (called up Telis and he's starting over Mathis). 

 

 

I actually don't like it to be exact to the real thing, I make moves based on what's going on. Like Edwin Jackson has a mid 2 ERA in 25 relief appearances, why cut him? Realmuto was slumping real bad, hitting .160 midway thru June, he's on a AAA assignment to find his swing back (called up Telis and he's starting over Mathis). 

I love this but it's not always as easy with the Marlins which is why I'm doing a Rockies franchise as well. To run it without emotional attachments as if I was really handed the Rockies gm position and told to make them a winner.

 

 

I love this but it's not always as easy with the Marlins which is why I'm doing a Rockies franchise as well. To run it without emotional attachments as if I was really handed the Rockies gm position and told to make them a winner.

 

I'd quit

 

 

With the Rockies franchise, you at least have a good offensive core with some strong defense. Just get dat pitching.

Yep I'm working on it.

 

 

I really haven't played this since Dee Gordon got suspended.  :HerpDerp-min:

 

Yeah, same for me with franchise mode.

 

However, I'm going to start a Rockies franchise, similar to Mr. SilverBullet.

 

Speaking of ...

 

Hey [uSER=2328]@SilverBullet1929[/uSER] - in your Rockies franchise, have you made any trades? I'm looking at "suggested trades" for guys like CarGo and Story, and my goodness, you're probably better off trading them. I'm going to keep Arenado.

 

Edit: I did "suggested trade" with CarGo, and the Yankees came up with a few different offers. One was Chapman and Bird, another was Pineda plus a couple others, one was Miller and a couple others.

 

I edited it to be Chapman and Pineda for CarGo and a 19 year old "B" potential prospect. Yankees are interested. Just to give you an idea.

 

One with Trevor Story:

 

Yankees offered a trade of Chapman, Pineda, and Gregorius. You go way down in salary, but goddamn.

 

 

Fuckin biter, I'm doing the Rockies. You can be my assistant to the GM though. But no moves yet, still in spring training. My general plan is to shop cargo and potentially blackmon and see what they can get me. I have a pipe dream of keeping an eye on the Marlins to see if I can acquire Jose at the trade deadline. I actually did some reading on theories on how to make a winner in Colorado, not in the game but in reality, just to get an idea of a loose game plan to stick too and one that stood out to me said the Rockies have never been able to develop or sign good pitching so that maybe they should actually focus on developing good hitting to use that as the currency to trade for pitching. So hope cargo has a good year, package him with something for Jose Fernandez or another ace and then in free agency sign new hitters to replace cargo and whatever other offensive pieces got traded away. Rinse and repeat. The Rockies have tried making pitchers when they actually are sitting on a hitter making factory so that's what they should be selling. That's gonna be my main strategy with this thing. I have a bunch of other tidbits, theories, ideas, etc that I can share as well. Crossing my fingers that I can stick with this thing long enough to see the full development of this project. I can never do this with the Marlins. If I do stuff with the fish and then in 2017 say they sign a couple free agents I just wanna delete my season and start fresh with the new players. With the Rockies I'll be able to ride this long term without any influence from the real team.

 

 

Fuckin biter, I'm doing the Rockies. You can be my assistant to the GM though. But no moves yet, still in spring training. My general plan is to shop cargo and potentially blackmon and see what they can get me. I have a pipe dream of keeping an eye on the Marlins to see if I can acquire Jose at the trade deadline. I actually did some reading on theories on how to make a winner in Colorado, not in the game but in reality, just to get an idea of a loose game plan to stick too and one that stood out to me said the Rockies have never been able to develop or sign good pitching so that maybe they should actually focus on developing good hitting to use that as the currency to trade for pitching. So hope cargo has a good year, package him with something for Jose Fernandez or another ace and then in free agency sign new hitters to replace cargo and whatever other offensive pieces got traded away. Rinse and repeat. The Rockies have tried making pitchers when they actually are sitting on a hitter making factory so that's what they should be selling. That's gonna be my main strategy with this thing. I have a bunch of other tidbits, theories, ideas, etc that I can share as well. Crossing my fingers that I can stick with this thing long enough to see the full development of this project. I can never do this with the Marlins. If I do stuff with the fish and then in 2017 say they sign a couple free agents I just wanna delete my season and start fresh with the new players. With the Rockies I'll be able to ride this long term without any influence from the real team.

 

Bro, you can make the Rockies good in year one. Look at my post, CarGo and Story can get you AWESOME returns. Story alone could have gotten me Chapman, Pineda, and Gregorius. Yes, salary takes a bite, but then if you trade CarGo for guys that are cheaper, it kinda balances out.

 

 

  • Author

Finally reached the midpoint of my Marlins franchise. Marlins are sitting atop of the NL East at 51-37 with the Mets 3 GB and Nats/Phils 7 GB.

 

Made my first trade, acquired RP Kevin Quackenbush (42 IP, 2.83 ERA, 46 K) for SP Eric Jokisch (was bouncing back from MLB to AAA as a long relief/spot starter). I hope Quackenbush can solidify the pen.

 

Looking to make a few more moves as the trade deadline approaches. I'd love to add a 3 starter (looking at Odorizzi, Smyly, Cashner) and some bench help. My bench is currently Mathis, Johnson, Don Kelly, Gillespie, Rojas.

 

Platooning Johnson/Dietrich at 1st has been great. 

 

Also might bring back Realmuto to the bigs, he was awful to start, in 50 games he was batting .153, but in AAA found his groove hitting a cool .268

 

Bour is done for the season and Yelich is out another month or so. 

 

 

Finally reached the midpoint of my Marlins franchise. Marlins are sitting atop of the NL East at 51-37 with the Mets 3 GB and Nats/Phils 7 GB.

 

Made my first trade, acquired RP Kevin Quackenbush (42 IP, 2.83 ERA, 46 K) for SP Eric Jokisch (was bouncing back from MLB to AAA as a long relief/spot starter). I hope Quackenbush can solidify the pen.

 

Looking to make a few more moves as the trade deadline approaches. I'd love to add a 3 starter (looking at Odorizzi, Smyly, Cashner) and some bench help. My bench is currently Mathis, Johnson, Don Kelly, Gillespie, Rojas.

 

Platooning Johnson/Dietrich at 1st has been great. 

 

Bour is done for the season and Yelich is out another month or so. 

 

What happened to Bour? :(

 

 

  • Author
What happened to Bour? :(

 

Dove to his right for a line drive and dislocated his ankle, out 6+ months. Total buzzkill he was tearing it up.

 

And a week later Yelich slid into 2nd and fractured his hand. 

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.