Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2017 Payroll

Featured Replies

picking bour from the mlb rule 5 is prob their best move in a while. and it definitely was a doosey.

 

Phelps/Prado was a massive win too.

 

Overall, it's been absolutely terrible

 

 

picking bour from the mlb rule 5 is prob their best move in a while. and it definitely was a doosey

 

the prado trade with the yankees is probably at worst even, i'd give the marlins the edge (at least based on major league production to this point)

 

 

the prado trade with the yankees is probably at worst even, i'd give the marlins the edge (at least based on major league production to this point)

 

i edited the post. that trade was a massive win and is only reason team isnt 10 games under

 

 

There's several good Marlins moves if we really think about it but yes it's been mostly crap and in the overall picture it's worse because even the good moves haven't put us back into long term contention.

 

 

the prado trade with the yankees is probably at worst even, i'd give the marlins the edge (at least based on major league production to this point)

 

Eovaldi's numbers put him as a #4/5 starter at best and a worse producer than David Phelps alone. Garrett Jones is playing in Korea now and Domingo German missed all of last season and a lot of this season after getting elbow surgery (that said I still like German and disliked getting rid of him.)

 

Nothing really needs to be added about Martin Prado's performance this year other than a potential top 5 MLB third baseman. 

 

I promise you that the Yankees would LOVE to undo that trade. It's the best trade return-wise the Marlins have made the last four years.

 

EDIT: Didn't read the post fully, although I don't even think it can be argued "at worst" to be even. It's a win no matter how you look at it. The only way it becomes an even trade is if Domingo German makes the majors by age 26 and becomes a star, which is incredibly unlikely. 

 

 

There's several good Marlins moves if we really think about it but yes it's been mostly crap and in the overall picture it's worse because even the good moves haven't put us back into long term contention.

 

I remember going over the last three or four years and I don't think there were "several". I remember looking and the Yankees trade stood out as well as Bour in the AAA portion of the Rule V draft was a steal. 

 

However, I think one people the Marlins fanbase here tends to believe is the Marlins horribly lost a bunch of trades, when many of them are less extreme than people believe. Players we've traded including Nathan Eovaldi, Austin Barnes, Andrew Heaney, Kike Hernandez, Chad Wallach, Domingo German, Chris Paddack, Colin Moran, Jake Marisnick, and a few other players haven't exactly left the team and set the world on fire elsewhere. Many of them are performing at below average rates in the majors and the minors. 

 

The biggest lost values that the Marlins have given up in the last few trades are Francis Martes and Anthony Desclafani. When it comes to Disco, he was a low end top 10 prospect in our system who started out as a reliever and put up solid, low 3 ERA type numbers in places like A and AA ball. Think a slightly better version of what we have now in Luis Castillo in the system. Disco's ceiling was expected to be a #4 starter, and that was a consensus among fans and the front office. His 2016 performance has come as a complete surprise that not many people at all can say they were expecting. 

 

Martes, who is now a top MLB prospect, was 18 years old and had only pitched in the Gulf Coast League when we traded him. At that point players like him are traded or released all the time and nobody thinks twice about it. He was honestly a bit of a throwaway in the Astros trade that even Houston didn't know what they were getting. Again a situation where nobody predicted. 

 

When I think about why the team is in the situation it is in, I don't think about the prospects we've traded as the end all be all of problems. The team of guys we traded are mostly low end starters or future bench players. The problem has always been the lack of return from the short term players acquired. Guys like Latos, Cashner, Haren, Rodney, etc... put up mediocre to absolutely bad numbers and are off the team the next season. Using the big free agent money available the last few years to sign guys like Buck, Bell, Reyes, Salty, Morse, and Chen. While Chen is to be determined, the previous five players were bad players who lasted only a season or two. The failure in recent drafts to restock the farm system has made all of these moves more glaringly apparent than they otherwise would be. The lack of spending in the international free agent market also leaves the team limited.

 

It's a long line of bad bets the front office has made. Making a couple of these moves would go by the wayside and few would notice, but making multiple of them back to back has put all of them in the forefront. There's a ton of moves the front office has made that I agreed with at the time (Latos trade, Morse signing, Chen signing, acquisition of Prado). There's a ton of moves they've made that I disagreed with at the time (Dodgers trade, Cashner trade, trading away Trevor Williams for a pitching coach, etc...). It honestly doesn't matter. The point is there's enough bad moves made that we are in the situation we are in. Somebody should be held responsible. But instead I guarantee you that injuries will be blamed for this season rather than years of decision making that has failed to build proper depth.

 

 

  • Author
to sign a FA of any worth (i.e. someone who will actually contribute) you generally have to overpay anyway.  the ones available this will compound that because none of them are true standouts at their position so it will likely make overpayment even more likely.  I personally don't give a shit if they overpay because Loria certainly has more than enough to sign just about anyone he wants with his low payroll.  I'm just saying the typical overpayments will be even worse than usual. 

 

Overest overpay !?

 

 

  • Author
exactly.

 

They need to sign an actual proven platoon partner for Bour not this half ass sign a guy who is clearly declining shit (see chris johnson). Steve Peace would be perfect.

 

I still think they can do ozuna for bauer or paxton. both the mariners and indians could use a cheap club controlled 2-3 WAR ofer.

 

Then they need to pay for a real CFer and basically pray that the middle IF magically reverts to 2015 form.

 

The bullpen will be fine when they switch Capps to closer.

 

CAPPS FOREVER.

 

 

  • Author
Arizona is a perfect example of why MLB would never force any owner to sell or spend money because the Diamondbacks and others including the 2012 Marlins have shown that spending just to spend doesn't work. There's enough argument to maintain payroll restrictions than to force a team to spend. I know Loria's payroll is an unbelievable low but I'm just saying MLB will never force spending or selling for reasons like that.

 

MLB may won't ,but MLBPA would to close watch how teams using the BIG money they got from the new TV deals,because the players association just want players to earn the most money from teams.

 

 

MLBPA can't force a team to spend big even thought they will have a huge TV deal

 

 

  • Author
MLBPA can't force a team to spend big even thought they will have a huge TV deal

 

So I used "watch close" and not "force".

 

 

Waiting for the money of new TV deal and ballpark naming right.

What is up with this desparstion for giving up the naming rights? It's not that much money and it's not gonna happen anytime soon. Besides I like the "Marlins" in the name of the stadium.

 

 

 

 

there's plenty of good value OF FAs out there

Because we're so lacking in outfielders.

 

 

 

 

the prado trade with the yankees is probably at worst even, i'd give the marlins the edge (at least based on major league production to this point)

We got rid of garret jones. Definitely a win.

 

 

 

 

Because we want Loria to spend money on the team.

That money is too small. It's going to his pocket. Not worth the loss in name.

 

 

 

 

What do you mean based on? What value you do perceive the marlins have in the name? You slap on a lighted sign from some corporation and you immediately earn money. Marlins park the name brings nothing. 

Exactly. Whoring itself like practically every other team. Marlins park does bring something, identity. The team is not a corporate shrill. It actually wants to make something for itself by actually standing out. One of the few teams that can say that. And considering loria is not going to do it and the amount of money is small, I see no point in barking up this issue. Focus on the upcoming TV deal.

 

 

 

 

There has been so much negative publicity associated with the building of the stadium and its financing which still permeates in the media, couple that with terrible team management, and the repulsion associated with Loria/Samson and you have a stadium naming right asset that is virtually worthless.

 

Team needs a fresh start in Jacksonville. Family friendly attractive stadium, we can fill the 12,000 seats and assure Loria/Samson of the sellouts they crave. 

 

 

The team is not a corporate shill? What? The team is a corporation. Their job is to make money. The marlins do a good enough job through their incompetency to create a reputation. Having the ballpark named after the team doesn't do anything. This isn't fenway, wrigley, or yankee. It's the fucking marlins. Loria apparently needs every last penny in order to afford a team. Why not bring in 5 mil a year for doing zero work? 

Exactly my point. It's the one thing he hasn't screwed up. And, Loria is only going to line his pockets with it. It's not going to help the team. So what? You want to give him another vehicle to make money while frustrating you more? Are you a masochist?

 

 

 

 

We are all masochists as marlins fans.

 

Not collecting money for basically doing nothing is a mistake; even if Loria adds it directly to his pockets. 

Not your problem. That's his. But you are certainly free to make fun of him for it!

 

 

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.