October 23, 201610 yr Author Oh shit. @Michael and I had like an hour-long chat last night That sounds absolutely awful.
October 23, 201610 yr I love 1 game Wild Card games in all sports (I think basketball should introduce the idea). There's nothing more exciting than seeing teams have everything at stake in a single night.
October 23, 201610 yr Author Oh and Theo Epstein is already a Hall of Famer (and he was after his Red Sox run anyway). I'm pretty sure there's textbooks being written in front offices modeled off of his practices running a baseball team. I hope he sees the Marlins front office as equally cursed and takes over. Hopefully this inspires Loria to can that piece of shit Mike Hill.
October 23, 201610 yr I know we're all in Cubs talk right now but I love Michael's "Now watch Miller dominate in Boston. Just our luck". Somebody was close to being called a time traveler. Oh shit. @Michael and I had like an hour-long chat last night about time travel. This is scary. Are you a spy @dim? Well then. lol
October 23, 201610 yr Author I love 1 game Wild Card games in all sports (I think basketball should introduce the idea). There's nothing more exciting than seeing teams have everything at stake in a single night. It's exciting, yeah, but it's incompatible with how baseball is designed.
October 23, 201610 yr I love 1 game Wild Card games in all sports (I think basketball should introduce the idea). There's nothing more exciting than seeing teams have everything at stake in a single night. Basketball already has 8 teams from each conference making it, they don't need a wild card spot. They already have five. Lol
October 23, 201610 yr It's exciting, yeah, but it's incompatible with how baseball is designed. And that's fair to think 162 games shouldn't be decided by 1. In terms of structure it could be considered unfair. But I also see it as a team getting a shot they otherwise wouldn't have had in the previous format, and a top wild card team should be able to have a top pitcher available to win a single game. When I look at in from a team building standpoint, the better team should have a roster constructed to win that game, and thus it isn't unfair if a team goes in prepared.
October 23, 201610 yr Is this the first time 2 managers who managed different teams that reached the WS in the same decade meet in the WS with new teams? Meanwhile Girardi crying at home why he pissed off Loria while he polish is NL Manager of Year Award with all those rookies...
October 23, 201610 yr Author And that's fair to think 162 games shouldn't be decided by 1. In terms of structure it could be considered unfair. But I also see it as a team getting a shot they otherwise wouldn't have had in the previous format, and a top wild card team should be able to have a top pitcher available to win a single game. When I look at in from a team building standpoint, the better team should have a roster constructed to win that game, and thus it isn't unfair if a team goes in prepared. Eh, I don't think that these clearly sub 90-win teams need to be given a shot even if it generates more money for MLB. Also, the second wild card has fucked over the Marlins this season. It forces mediocre teams to sell the farm and "go for it" when they wouldn't otherwise be legitimate contenders.
October 23, 201610 yr While it is true the 2nd Wild Card creates more in the mix, the effect is neglible on the border teams. It wouldn't matter. Buyers are buyers and sellers are sellers. There is no net profit in spects and no net gain in teams or farms. Belief in playoffs is not bad. If they just had the top 2 teams battle it would be evident. Now who is the buyers and sellers? See? Everyone would be a seller anyway in this regard but there would be no spects to get in return. See my point?
October 23, 201610 yr It's awful and anti-baseball. Big decisions aren't supposed to be decided in a one-game series. This isn't football or soccer. Win your division.
October 23, 201610 yr Author While it is true the 2nd Wild Card creates more in the mix, the effect is neglible on the border teams. It wouldn't matter. Buyers are buyers and sellers are sellers. There is no net profit in spects and no net gain in teams or farms. Belief in playoffs is not bad. If they just had the top 2 teams battle it would be evident. Now who is the buyers and sellers? See? Everyone would be a seller anyway in this regard but there would be no spects to get in return. See my point? No.
October 23, 201610 yr Author Win your division. Then why have a wild card at all? Might as well get rid of divisions altogether too if you want to make that argument.
October 23, 201610 yr No. Well, that makes 2 of us. But the point is being a seller wouldn't work because you still have to be even better to make the playoffs now. Making the playoffs for this Fish should be the goal and it is a lofty goal as well. I am sleep deprived, apologies.
October 23, 201610 yr I had a whole post written but it was deleted. I'll write the cliffnotes now When looking at how the Cubs got from their 2016 roster to now, it's incredible. Only a single player in the majors was not acquired by Epstein, and that was the catcher Willson Contreras who was a 2009 signing. They've done it by turning bad assets and getting undervalued players from other teams (Arrieta, Hammel, Fowler, Hendricks). Even the big money signings they've made (Heyward, Lester, Zobrist) are guys who could be replaced at this moment by other players and there wouldn't be a noticeable drop off. The Cubs have hit incredibly in the first round under Epstein (Bryant, Schwarber, Almora, Baez). Even in a trade where they gave up a good asset in Samardzija, they were able to somehow get back one of the other great assets they gave up in Hammel . I'm not even talking about the 'pen that has been boosted by acquiring an elite guy in Chapman and another great guy in Montgomery. All this and the Cubs still have the #21, 23, and 97 prospects in baseball. I marvel at the job Epstein has done and he's truly the model of modern moneyball. He's built around the draft while also taking both incredible chances and finding undervalued players that are considered trash by other teams. There hasn't been a better mind in baseball that I've ever seen. When people talk rebuild, this is what they have in mind. Almost nobody is going to be able to build as perfect as this (which includes shrewd minds in the front office and an ownership team that gives them the room to spend and take chances), but even on a smaller scale the platform has been set forth for how to succeed in baseball in today's era.
October 23, 201610 yr Author I had a whole post written but it was deleted Odd for two reasons and disappointing to read. 1) I wonder why it was deleted 2) The editor is supposed to auto-save replies so that posts can't be lost. I need to check and see what happened here, that's a critical one for a message board.
October 23, 201610 yr Author Odd for two reasons and disappointing to read. 1) I wonder why it was deleted 2) The editor is supposed to auto-save replies so that posts can't be lost. I need to check and see what happened here, that's a critical one for a message board. Probably for the best. It would have been 10 times longer otherwise.
October 23, 201610 yr Why was Marlins man putting up 4 fingers during every pitch? You gotta be more specific, where was he putting those 4 fingers up?
October 23, 201610 yr You gotta be more specific, where was he putting those 4 fingers up? He was behind home plate the whole night
October 23, 201610 yr You gotta be more specific, where was he putting those 4 fingers up? Oh so he's a catcher? *sigh* Well, you had a good run.
October 23, 201610 yr I hate the fact that everyone talks about Bartman, it totally overshadows a Marlins WS team. But that said, I'm pulling for the Cubs. I have nothing against either team winning, but if I had to pick one it would be the Cubs (longer wait).
October 23, 201610 yr Author http://nypost.com/2016/10/23/f-king-classy-cubs-fans-threw-beer-at-dodgers-families-pitcher/ If it was an isolated incident, that'd be one thing but I have had personal experiences with Cubs fans. They have some of the biggest assholes as fans. Fuck the Cubs.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.