Pretty sure this is what [uSER=14703]@Bald Eagle[/uSER] wanted to do

 

C - CJ

1B - Derek Lee

2B - Castillo

3B - Lowell

SS - Hanley

OF - Sheffield

OF - Cabrera

OF - Conine

SP - JJ

SP - Brown 

SP - Livan

SP - Beckett

SP - Leiter

BP - Benitez

MNG - Edwin

 

 

C - Pudge

1B - Derek Lee

2B - Castillo

3B - Lowell

SS - Alex Gonzalez

OF - Pierre

OF - Cabrera

OF - Conine

SP - Beckett

SP - Pavano

SP - Burnett

SP - Penny

SP - Willis

BP - Urbina

MNG - McKeon

 

 

This isn't what [uSER=14703]@Bald Eagle[/uSER] was trying to do. He was asking for great Marlins in general. He wasn't asking for a "best Marlin at each position" list. 

 

Not sure why that Marlins Hall of Fame thread is so confusing to several. 

 

 

 

 

I hate when people lump all 3 outfield positions together as if positions mean absolutely nothing.

 

 

Here are the ones voted for the Florida Marlins all-time team

 

[ATTACH]1615._xfImport[/ATTACH]

 

[ATTACH]1614._xfImport[/ATTACH]

 

C - Pudge

1B - Derek Lee

2B - Castillo

3B - Lowell

SS - Alex Gonzalez

OF - Pierre

OF - Cabrera

OF - Conine

SP - Beckett

SP - Pavano

SP - Burnett

SP - Penny

SP - Willis

BP - Urbina

MNG - McKeon

 

You forgot Looper was still the closer... Not Urbina.

 

 

Here are the ones voted for the Florida Marlins all-time team

 

[ATTACH]1615[/ATTACH]

 

[ATTACH]1614[/ATTACH]

 

Nice pic. Loved it when Lowell came to bat at Pro Player. It would always play DMX "WHOOO! Yall gon make me lose my mind, Up in here! Up in here!!

 

 

John Boles for all time manager.

 

 

You forgot Looper was still the closer... Not Urbina.

 

You forgot Looper fell apart and Urbina took over.

 

Though technically Willis wouldn't be there and instead Redmond would. And probably Encarnacion in the OF, though to the best of my memory Conine was swapping with LF and 1B and thereby did play almost every game.

 

 

 

The irony...

 

One puts a barrel to a barrel of fish, and when he gets so eager and fires... he makes... a squall. 

 

 

You forgot Looper fell apart and Urbina took over.

 

Though technically Willis wouldn't be there and instead Redmond would. And probably Encarnacion in the OF, though to the best of my memory Conine was swapping with LF and 1B and thereby did play almost every game.

 

I did. Don't remember exactly how they managed Conine. I think Conine and Cabrera swapped more in LF than Encarnacion. If my memory holds.

 

 

If I recall Lowell got hurt toward the end of 2003?  

 

That may have been what really was the motivation behind picking up Conine....

 

But memory is a hair fuzzy.

 

 

If I recall Lowell got hurt toward the end of 2003?  

 

That may have been what really was the motivation behind picking up Conine....

 

But memory is a hair fuzzy.

 

I believe so. 

 

 

If I recall Lowell got hurt toward the end of 2003?  

 

That may have been what really was the motivation behind picking up Conine....

 

But memory is a hair fuzzy.

 

Yes. Lowell broke his hand so they traded for Niner.

 

 

Yes. Lowell broke his hand so they traded for Niner.

 

I impress myself sometimes.

 

 

The irony...

 

One puts a barrel to a barrel of fish, and when he gets so eager and fires... he makes... a squall. 

 

You can't help but think of me and firing loads. Happy!

 

 

You tried, that's what counts. 

 

 

C CJ

 

1B Jeff Conine

 

2B Luis Castillo

 

3B Miguel Cabrera 

 

SS Hanley Ramirez 

 

OF Gary Sheffield

 

OF Giancarlo Stanton 

 

OF Juan Pierre

 

SP Jose Fernandez

 

SP Dontrelle Willis

 

SP Josh Johnson

 

SP Livan Hernandez

 

SP Ricky Nolasco

 

CP Antonio Alfonseca 

 

This team ?

 

 

Nolasco though? You wouldn't put Kevin Brown or Josh Beckett before Nolasco? 

 

 

[uSER=2328]@SilverBullet1929[/uSER] I mean Nolasco is the all time leader in wins..... and losses. I feel like it is fitting. 

 

 

[uSER=2328]@SilverBullet1929[/uSER] I mean Nolasco is the all time leader in wins..... and losses. I feel like it is fitting. 

 

Fair point but much of that is just because he was here longer than others. I wouldn't choose Nolasco to start a game over Kevin Brown. And if I was asked who was a better pitch in his time as a Marlin I wouldn't say "Nolasco because he has the most wins."