Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Michael Hill maybe removed from his position !!!

Featured Replies

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2019/09/nl-east-notes-freeman-braves-phillies-marlins.html

 

"Perhaps of even more consequence, there are rumblings that Michael Hill will be removed from his position as President of Baseball Ops, a title he’s held since a being promoted from GM in 2013. Hill has been with the organization since 2002. Scuttlebutt has long-time Giants front office frontman Brian Sabean as a potential replacement, while current Marlins VP of Player Development and Scouting Gary Denbo has be increasingly relied upon of late. Notably, both Sabean and Denbo have ties to Derek Jeter’s early days with the Yankees."

 

 

Tbh that report doesn't sound very concrete to me and if anything Hill has made his case to stay at least in some capacity so I wouldn't count on this unless something more definitive is reported. 

 

 

Tbh that report doesn't sound very concrete to me...

 

I'm curious. What does concrete sound like?

 

 

I had a music teacher who, when berating the poor performance of the woodwinds, once asked how much sewage does it take to turn a glass of Pepsi into sewage? I contend that anything greater than a molecule or two of doody-water changes the drink from soda to sewage. Even a 10th of a teaspoon.

 

His purpose was to get the clarinets to tune their dang instruments, but the analogy is relevant here. We know, without much doubt, that Loria was a very bad owner, an unqualified meddler and a penny pincher -- the worst combo. And yet, after a sip of the sewage Pepsi, we are now confident we don't like Pepsi. In reality, though, Pepsi just reminds us of sewage, and rightfully gives us a smidge of PTSD. But we don't really know what Pepsi tastes like.

 

What I'm saying is I find it difficult to agree with this sentiment: "This rebuild is going great; let's fire the top executives."

 

Without inside knowledge of who does what, how they perform in their tasks, and so on, I'd say the desire to call for Mr. Hill's firing is misplaced.

 

 

I had a music teacher who, when berating the poor performance of the woodwinds, once asked how much sewage does it take to turn a glass of Pepsi into sewage? I contend that anything greater than a molecule or two of doody-water changes the drink from soda to sewage. Even a 10th of a teaspoon.

 

His purpose was to get the clarinets to tune their dang instruments, but the analogy is relevant here. We know, without much doubt, that Loria was a very bad owner, an unqualified meddler and a penny pincher -- the worst combo. And yet, after a sip of the sewage Pepsi, we are now confident we don't like Pepsi. In reality, though, Pepsi just reminds us of sewage, and rightfully gives us a smidge of PTSD. But we don't really know what Pepsi tastes like.

 

What I'm saying is I find it difficult to agree with this sentiment: "This rebuild is going great; let's fire the top executives."

 

Without inside knowledge of who does what, how they perform in their tasks, and so on, I'd say the desire to call for Mr. Hill's firing is misplaced.

 

What instrument did you play?

 

 

Sabean? NO. Please god no. Someone a little more analytically minded, please.

 

Denbo is fine I guess.

 

If you had to choose, would you pick Sabean or Dombrowski?

 

 

I think the next GM should be a committee of members of this forum. Between all of us combined we are experts on everything. 

 

 

I think the next GM should be a committee of members of this forum. Between all of us combined we are experts on everything. 

 

Just remember this. Always collective intelligence did NOT make a correct decision.

 

 

I think the next GM should be a committee of members of this forum. Between all of us combined we are experts on everything. 

 

but only the members who are paying for the ad-free version of the site

 

 

but only the members who are paying for the ad-free version of the site

 

There's a subscription service on this site?

 

 

There's a subscription service on this site?

 

Yes, send me 10 bucks a month and I'll show you how to access it. 

 

 

I'm not a racist, but I don't like Hill's "flattery" face. How much did he flatter former owner Loria and prez Samson? A scumbag.

 

 

I'm not a racist, but I don't like Hill's "flattery" face. How much did he flatter former owner Loria and prez Samson? A scumbag.

 

[ATTACH]3230._xfImport[/ATTACH]

 

371529140_ZomboMeme02082019164648.thumb.jpg.d3644b945c79760040b30bb2726333f9.jpg

But the Giants have many WS titles under him. 

 

But as I understand, the Giants get to keep those. They won't stay underneath Sabean forever.

 

 

A classic opening for a regrettable post.

 

Not even sure why he said that as it wasn't a racist post. So random. He warns against racism then doesn't show it so I'm here wondering if I'm the one missing the racist part of it. And then I'm thrown off by the thought that Hill only got to where he is today because of how he looked at Samson and Loria? And on top of that apparently that would have made him a scumbag for all this? I'm so lost.

 

 

But the Giants have many WS titles under him. 

 

Sure, they hit on a couple draft picks and signings, got hot at the right time three separate times. Some of it luck, some of it just their experience at the time. Just not a fan of him.

 

 

Sabean did an ok for the Giants,  did a few moves that were highly questionable, he was promoted to Baseball Ops .then Bobby Evan came along and turned everything to shit 

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.