Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Why didn't Vlad become a Marlin?...

Featured Replies

Vlad has been my favorite Non-Marlins' player for about 4 years now. He made a mistake, but I wish him all the best.

 

He made a mistake.

I also gotta say Congrats to Vlad and Good Riddance he is out of the NL

though we didn't get vlad, this is the 2nd best scenario- at least he's not in our division anymore- not even in our league either I agree, at least he wont probably play against us.

I also gotta say Congrats to Vlad and Good Riddance he is out of the NL

though we didn't get vlad, this is the 2nd best scenario- at least he's not in our division anymore- not even in our league either I agree, at least he wont probably play against us. i think we play them once

Um, not in 2004 we don't. And not in Spring Training.

 

Unless you're talking World Series 2004...

Um, not in 2004 we don't. And not in Spring Training.

 

Unless you're talking World Series 2004...

i guess i was thinking '03

Yeah, well, Anaheim is pretty close to Disneyland, so that wouldn't have given us an advantage over them.

Yeah, well, Anaheim is pretty close to Disneyland, so that wouldn't have given us an advantage over them.

Disneyworld is better than disneyland- and i'm not saying anything else about disney in the marlin forum

According to the latest reports the Marlins never made a offer!

I beleive it!

No Offer, Zero Chances of landing Vlad.

 

Next it was projected that if the Marlins made an offer to Vlad it would be mostly deferred money until the year 3,000 or so.

Come On, Serious Offers Only.

Latest reports ar saying he turned down a 1-year $13 Million offer.

Unions, in all shapes, forms, and industries, are a detriment to economies. Their main policy is greed, forging it so that it appears as if they are fighting the good fight for their members' employees. Unions in there orginial form were practical and necessary. Unregulated unions are worse for the economy than a monopoly.

 

The baseball union is the strongest in all of sports. Is it a coincidence that baseball is in the worst shape?

 

And I've really had a crappy, crappy ass weekend, and this wasn't even the biggest downfall in it. If you are all wondering, the reason I haven't posted all day is because I haven't been home. I haven't been weeping in a little corner by myself as some of you might have thought/wished. And I really don't feel like posting again on the issue unless something changes, because it's A) still not official and B) I don't care what else. If it happens then oh well, evil wins again. What else is new. If it doesn't happen and he comes here, yay then. I haven't given up hope yet. And I'm sure when he signs officially I'll hear plenty of it. But I frankly don't care.

I cant believe anyone would believe that their is a conspiracy theory here. If you do you have to much time on your hand.

 

Lets see, a team that offers 5 years and 71 million or a team that allegedly offers 1 year at 13. hmmm I wonder which one I am going to take...

I cant believe anyone would believe that their is a conspiracy theory here. If you do you have to much time on your hand.

 

Lets see, a team that offers 5 years and 71 million or a team that allegedly offers 1 year at 13. hmmm I wonder which one I am going to take...

no conspiracy here, just alot of dissappointment man. Life goes on and guess what?

 

 

WE HAVE A TITLE TO DEFEND!!!!!!

I normally trust Ed's reports, but I don't buy this. MLBPA had little to gain from Vlad signing so late. What other free agents are out there that can benefit from the marquee FA setting the tone for this offseason market? If pressing him to accept a $14M wage for the next five years does not help the next five years worth of FAs. He's not making ARod cash. Not even Manny cash. Didn't expect him to. But the MLBPA doesn't benefit that much from locking one of the best players in the game for below their ideal market range until he is past his prime. At best the MLBPA was fighting a small fight, the only fight the could. I'm not saying it's not possible, this fits well into the recent history of the players union but I think the players have more pressing issues than this.

Here is how the MLBPA gets their greed on this:

 

Vlad signs for one year, 13 mil (below other offers).

He is a free agent again next year, dilluting the next class money distribution wise.

Players have to sign for less money in a long term deal, or try the one year deal and back.

Players keep taking the latter, signing one year deals.

The Free Agent class gets to the point where it is incredibly dilluted, and the quality of talent is so high that there isn't enough money to go around.

Players salaries take a drastic turn downward.

 

It would take maybe one or two more contracts after Vlad to establish the precedent, but it would eventually happen if the Big Fish of the class signed for less time and money. The Domino Effect would be in place, and though the fans and owners would be benefitted the Union would not be so they had to stop this. It is feasable.

Aren't Maddux, Mondesi and Pudge just going to get one year deals anyway?

Maddux yes, because he is old. There is a difference between someone in their high 30's and someone that is 27 and about to enter their prime.

 

Mondesi isn't the crown jewel of any free agent class, he just happens to be left.

 

Pudge, if he signs anywhere, will not be going for a one year deal. For that he can just wait for May 1st. Plus, he is also older and probably past his prime for full season results.

I cant believe anyone would believe that their is a conspiracy theory here. If you do you have to much time on your hand.

 

Lets see, a team that offers 5 years and 71 million or a team that allegedly offers 1 year at 13. hmmm I wonder which one I am going to take...

I'll second that.

Unions, in all shapes, forms, and industries, are a detriment to economies. Their main policy is greed, forging it so that it appears as if they are fighting the good fight for their members' employees. Unions in there orginial form were practical and necessary. Unregulated unions are worse for the economy than a monopoly.

I don't want to go off on a rant here (tm Dennis Miller), or to threadjack, but the best thing that could ever happen to pro wrestling would be for a union to be organized.

The MLBPA must be brought down. No more strong player's assoc. I cannot stand them...all they do is bring down the game.

 

BTW, MLB still has a big IOU to the Marlins for the All Star Game that was snatched away by Selig and given to the Braves because they had a "new" ballpark.

Unions, in all shapes, forms, and industries, are a detriment to economies. Their main policy is greed, forging it so that it appears as if they are fighting the good fight for their members' employees. Unions in there orginial form were practical and necessary. Unregulated unions are worse for the economy than a monopoly.

I don't want to go off on a rant here (tm Dennis Miller), or to threadjack, but the best thing that could ever happen to pro wrestling would be for a union to be organized. Unions are good in the original forms. But they have grown way too powerful and have started to strive for things other than ensuring the right of their members, which should be its most important if not only aspiration. They need to exist, but be regulated as businesses are.

I normally trust Ed's reports, but I don't buy this. MLBPA had little to gain from Vlad signing so late. What other free agents are out there that can benefit from the marquee FA setting the tone for this offseason market? If pressing him to accept a $14M wage for the next five years does not help the next five years worth of FAs. He's not making ARod cash. Not even Manny cash. Didn't expect him to. But the MLBPA doesn't benefit that much from locking one of the best players in the game for below their ideal market range until he is past his prime. At best the MLBPA was fighting a small fight, the only fight the could. I'm not saying it's not possible, this fits well into the recent history of the players union but I think the players have more pressing issues than this.g

 

the union wants every player to accept the most money they could possibly get, because in order for the free agent market to function as a true free capitalist market where players are paid what they are worth, players cannot turn down money, ever. we are not talking about Luis Castillo turning down 500K to play for the Marlins instead of the Mets- we were talking millions of dollars over many more years, and Vlad is the #1 free agent in all of baseball. when a top free agent signs somewhere it sets a precedent, and the high-water mark that Vlad sets with his contract results in a trickle-down effect to everyone else. if he accepts less money b/c he doesn't "like" baltimore, from the union's point of view, this is a very selfish act. the price levels that he sets with his deal impact every deal signed both this year and in years to come.

 

that being said, to say that the Marlins didn't get him b/c the MLBPA said no is just silly. they may have pressed him to not take the Mets's offer, but in the end, he took the best deal, period.

I am truly dissapointed int he Marlins FO. In one of the biggest free agent years in history, they have had let opportunity slip by time after time. So many chances and NOTHING they cleared all this money, and what have they gotten? Benitez. alright nice pick up but remember WE LOST URBINA! so its a replacement not an aquisition in my opinion. Marlins really screwed themselves over this offseason unless they pull something out of their A$$. If they dont get a stadium deal i will just die :banghead

Marlins really screwed themselves over this offseason unless they pull something out of their A$$.

 

I don't see how you can make this statement. Most of the starters were due hefty pay raises, so unloading a few players was inevitable. I believe they made excellent choices for the most part. In hindsight, the only player I wish they would have kept is Lee......and perhaps they would have had they known Pudge was going to pass on their offer.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.