Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Beinfest regretful about not trading A.J.
Hey guys, first time poster. That White Sox trade looks extremely tasty now, but hindsight is a luxury. I'm just glad we didn't end up doing that "blockbuster" trade with the Orioles that was almost a done deal - trading Lowell and A.J for Admin Bigbie, Julio Jorge and some prospect whose name escapes me. As much as Lowell has sucked this year, that would've been the worst trade ever. Welcome aboard and you nailed it on your first post.
-
McKeon on the Marlin's Pre Show
I dont know why people dont think Aguila can get the job done in CF, but almost demand that Willingham be the starting LF next season I don't know if it's CF or one of the corner outfield positions but for me there's little question that Aguila can play MLB outfield and contribute offensively, and is further ahead of both Hermida and Willingham. He gets a good jump on the ball, has a strong arm and a solid stroke which led to tremendous minor league numbers. If you believe Willingham and Hermida's ML numbers are an indication of what kind of player they could mature into at the MLB level, the same could be said of Aguila, who has also had the benefit of being on a MLB roster almost alll season. Assuming there's at least one OF position up for grabs (RF, maybe LF as well) in the 2006 it will be interesting to see how the three do in head to head competition. Barring injury I'd bet on Aguila.
-
Beinfest regretful about not trading A.J.
I'm baffled by the choice of words, specifically "rectify". If he was getting a starter back, Arroyo, who at the time Fiends of Sam Horn fans would have gladly traded as would most basball people for AJ, I keep thinking he meant he couldn't add another starter (beside Arroyo) to sell it internally. My read was that Arroyo wasn't considered enough (pitching-wise and putting Sanchez aside for a moment) to by himself replace AJ. And as for the White Sox offer, the way Gammons presents it, it sounds as if he's getting that info from the White Sox side and not from Beinfest.
-
Andino or Gonzalez
I really like Andino's makeup but I'm not sure he's ready for the bigs, and more, I can't guarantee he ever will be. I'd like to see him play everyday in winter ball if he's not too exhausted or spend another year in AA/AAA polishing his offensive abilities and his defensive skills. He knows now what's expected of him and the onus is on him to step up. Would I be upset to see a Clayton come in here for a year or for Gonzo to come back under the right terms? No. Not at all.
-
Good Article that sums up my feelings towards AJ
I loved it and wrote him to say so. Those of you who listen to him on 790, as was said about Jim Rome's comments yesterday, could just hear him as you read it. It pretty much says it all. Well done :thumbup
-
Is AJ the first "former Marlin" that...
How about Cliff "I tried and failed to extort the new owners out of $45 million so I'm going to bad-mouth them from now on" Floyd? I would say his comments on his way out the door and in subsequent years (boy was he jealous that the Fish went on to and won the World Series without him) really set a benchmark it may be difficult for even AJ to match, although no doubt he'll try.
-
Do we REALLY want Dontrelle to win the Cy Young?
2003, I think Dontrelle will be eligible for arbitration after this season because he qualifies as a "Super Two." He'll probably get $2-3 million in arbitration. We should just sign him to a four or five year contract. He deserves it. You may be right on that (mental lapse, it was Cabrera who isn't a super 2) but again the basic scenario remains vaild in that there is a ceiling on what he can make in his first year of arbitration, and that for DW signing a contract that spares all the arby stuff and rewards him now at a higher rate than he would otherwise receive, in exchange for a lower rate than he may receive in the out years,might make sense. I'm just speculating and recounting earlier reports that the Fish had an interest in a multi-year deal with DW.
-
Do we REALLY want Dontrelle to win the Cy Young?
No way Dontrelle makes $4million in his first year of arbitration regardless of whether he wins the Cy Young back to back. I believe the number you indicated was a proposed long term contract number that was floated earlier this year. If say DW was to get $800k next year, $1.5 in first arby, then $2.5, then $5, then $10mil (just using numbers for illustration) all parties might be satisfied to smooth out that curve and give the kid some financial security.
-
Thank you Beinfest
I don't think he has pride. He talks crap about the fans and then pitches his worst when it counts. I hope he learns how to pitch instead of throw hard for his next team or he will always be sub-500. I was talking about Beinfest who isn't exactly known for his peoples' skills Rferry, where do you get this from? I've seen you alluding to this in a couple of posts now and I'm curious (not a trap) why you've come to this conclusion? I thought the general consensus was that Beinfest was respected among his peers as well as in the media generally. Have I missed something besides perhaps a rant by Steve "I'm the failed ex-GM everyone expected me to be" Phillips?
-
Trade Ideas
I know we're about to enter a season of discontent where everyone and anyone will be blamed for sins real and imagined, but let's not forget that injuries played a big part in the downfall of the pen as well as everyday players. Until Mecir tore his rotator cuff he was pitching quite effectively, AA was hurt multiple times and like Mecir is injured right now, Mota and Resop ditto, the list is endless. Being injured and being asked to pitch (or for that matter play second base or another position) because the front office can't/won't find adequate replacements doesn't mean that player sucks, in fact often times is the case that the opposite is true. A Jim Mecir or a AA should be lauded for going out there when asked and giving their best when in fact they should be on the DL. The result may be unpleasant for the fans and leaves the player open to criticism but in many cases if we knew how banged up these guys were I believe most rational people here would feel differently than they do. Recently I was at a game where I watched as Encarnacion's ankle was being taped mid-inning in the dugout with about a 1/2 inch thick of athletic tape. It looked more like a cast than just support. But he went out in the bottom of the inning and played. The media seldom reports the everyday injuries that plague professional players, for obvious reasons. And of course this stuff happens on every team playing a 162 game season. If I find fault with any one person for our September swoon I would have to look to Admin Beinfest, who for reasons only known to himself and ownership did virtually nothing at the trade deadlines (Ron Villone and Paul Quantrill ??? OMG) to improve the obvious weaknesses of the team. One can blame Jack for bullpen mismanagement all you want but first you have to have a bullpen to mismanage and McKeon, from the middle of July certainly didn't have one. Where the blame lays for our failed offense remains to be determined. McKeon, Robinson (it sure seemed that Lowell and Agon and several others all strangely seemed to be mimicing the same approach at the plate this year with the same result after years of success of one type or another with there own unique batting stances and approaches at the plate), bad luck, simultaneous regression to the mean, who knows? But it can't happen again. I guess where I'm going with all this is to beseech all of us to keep the epithets regarding players to a minimum (he's a "bum", he "sucks", "garbage", etc.) as the debate warms up. And I for one, someone who has been more than happy to allow Admin B. a place on a pedestal, will certainly be more suspect of his work from now on. As long as this doesn't happen in 2006, I'm willing to forgive and forget 2005. I hope others will as well.
-
AJ to Sit Friday
:thumbdown Give the fans one last chance to say good-bye. I don't think AJ's been a model citizen, but anyone who fails to recognize his accomplishments simply was either not here during the rough times, or is just fickle beyond reason. AJ's an ass-hole, but for 7 years, he was our ass-hole. It's sad that he absolutely positively will not be back next year, if he made that final start, the chance remained slim, now it's at none. :notworthy Thats why you are one of 3 great marlin posters on this board. Hey "Passion" why not get some more lipstick since you have been kissing AJs a@@ now that hes probably leaving to Boston. :lol I was proping Swift on a statement that is true and that I agree with. And Ive thought since mid-season that AJ will be a Detroit Tiger next year. But good call! You mean, you "believe" it to be true and so you agree with it. That is unless you hold yourself out as the sole determiner of what is "the truth" and what isn't.
-
Burnett Asked to Leave by Marlins
Great to see the FO is letting the people that stuck around to watch him pitch for six years say goodbye. Juanky, you and I are almost always on the same page but on this one I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. By disposing of AJ this way I believe the FO did exactly the right thing and had they done less, (knowing you disagree) I would have been disappointed.
-
AJ to Sit Friday
doubtful on Delgado and LoDuca. My guess is some of our bullpen buddies. Maybe JP? I don't think JP would do it, but he is not having much fun out there I would tend to agree. LoDuca, from all the comments he's made to the media and in pregame/post game shows does not seem to have anything but the highest regard for McKeon. Delgado is much too saavy to get drawn into this kind of mess. I'd been very disappointed to hear it's JP. Even in an off season I just can't see him as a guy who blames anyone but himself for his problems this season.
-
Nice Job by Vargas
BTW, for those of you at the game tonight, did you notice the field is in even worse condition than the last homestand (if that's possible)? The ruts in left field were beyond belief, the seams in the infield are a total joke. Last homestand I said I had never seen the field in such awful shape in thirteen years, well guess what, it's worse!
-
AJ Wants To Leave
The fact is there is a significant chance that as many as ten or eleven players on the 25 man roster could be gone next year, and that turnover, whether it makes sense (from an on-field perspective) or not may very well be characterized by some, inside the media and among baseball fans as a "firesale". It may not be accurate, it may not be fair, but the odds are you're going to hear it more than once during the off-season.
-
Nice Job by Vargas
Well, that certainly was a fun night If y'all don't go to another game this season I hope you'll all be there tomorrow for Dontrelle.
-
Going to Tonight's Game
I certainly will be there.
-
AJ Wants To Leave
Interesting. When AJ had won 7 in a row...I never saw anyone calling out his lack of heart and how poor of a pitcher he was. When it comes down to it, those 7 wins are as critical now as they were then. The guy has just become the personal whiiping boy of the Marlin fan base because he is outspoken and will go and get his money in the off-season lke anyother person in his situation will do. I am sure he will enjoy moving on to a franchise where he can be appreciated and not berated after everything he does. LMAO
-
AJ Wants To Leave
If players fed off of huge crowds at home the Cubs and Red Sox would have had world titles long ago. The Red Sox are scheduled to win one again in 2102. The Cubs well they're cursed aren't they?
-
AJ Wants To Leave
How do you know he feeds off the energy in the ballpark? I've never seen him do it... and certainly in big games with big crowds he choked. I dont "know" per say, but I think a guy who publicly makes alot of comments about fan support and calls it depressing, obviously wants to pitch in a great atmosphere. I just find it hysterical how a 28 year old with his numbers this season, can catch so much flak. He pitched many nights before 30,000+ cheering fans during his career and he still choked. And as Jack so aptly put it, once in a while you've got to look in the mirror and admit you're the problem, not the fans, not the mangement, not the organization, you.
-
AJ Wants To Leave
He will thrive in a place with energy. The only place he'll thrive is Bank of America.
-
Josh Johnson
Not Jack' style One last "F*** you" on McKeon's part (from some of us as well) towards AJ I hope your wrong. I'd love to see Jack just sit the creep down or suspend him without pay.
-
Marlins Xtra tonight 6:30-7:30
Anyone record it or can anyone get a copy of the feed?
-
AJ Wants To Leave
My favorite line of all this is...``It's depressing around here,'' he said. ``There's nothing positive around here. There's nothing positive on the staff now." Could it be he's jealous of Dontrelle? He can't possibly not notice all the notireity DW is getting FOR SUCCEEDING. I suspect he know's he's cost himself several million dollars (which is not to say he won't get a big paycheck), perhaps $4-5 million over the life of his new contract with his performance over the last 8-10 games. He desperately needs to find a fallguy for his failures. Personally, I'd like to see Jack either fine him or better yet bench him for the rest of the season, or even just send him home (boy that would really frost his selfish, egocentric little ass wouldn't???? hehe). He's done everything he can do to insult the fans, the organization and let his teammates down for a month and half, time for payback. I'll be going to all our remaining games and if he does pitch (which I hope he doesn't), and as uncharacteristic as it is for me to do it, I intend to boo him from the moment he steps on the playing field. Some may disagree, but enough is enough.
-
Marlins Xtra tonight 6:30-7:30
Me too...who hosted this? what exactly did he say? Who else was there beside AJ?