Everything posted by Valid
-
Berti Option Exercised
Definitely. Good defensively, has speed and knows how to take a walk. Of course I would prefer he doesn't get over 400 PA again, but with the right additions he could be a really valuable bench piece.
-
Peter Bendix Named Pres. Of Baseball Ops
It also leads me to believe that Bruce had his eye on him from the beginning. Bendix was probably the guy he wanted to place over Kim in the FO to begin with.
-
Peter Bendix Named Pres. Of Baseball Ops
And the Marlins haven't done much of either since 2003. I would gladly take regular-season winning with the chance to get hot in the playoffs than not winning at all.
-
Peter Bendix Named Pres. Of Baseball Ops
You're arguing a completely different topic than @SilverBullet and it seems like you're actually doing it on purpose because he literally just explained what he meant.
-
Peter Bendix Named Pres. Of Baseball Ops
Exactly. All it tells me is that Sherman wanted to bring in someone from an organization who knows how to build its own talent. This also falls in line with the report that Sherman wanting to revamp the scouting department.
-
2023/24 Off-Season
I'd take him on a short deal. He was surprisingly good as a starter this year.
-
2023/24 Off-Season
They could have signed Avisail Garcia to the deal the Marlins signed him to and still would have been a very good team. The Astros being very good has nothing to do with the fact that Abreu was a bad signing, and if the Marlins signed him, you would be complaining about how bad he is and how the Marlins gave him too much money.
-
Early 2024 Power Rankings
I also find it funny how people here are saying the Marlins being 22nd makes sense. I guess the Mets somehow being five spots ahead of us in spite of having significantly worse issues makes sense, too?
-
Early 2024 Power Rankings
Can we actually start free agency before coming to these conclusions?
-
Early 2024 Power Rankings
160-170 innings is still plenty and Sandy wasn't even good most of 2023 even when he was available and the Marlins still managed to win 84.
-
Soler Opts Out (Is Also a Silver Slugger Finalist)
Yeah I'm not okay with giving Soler $20 million, even if it's just for one year. Maybe $13-15 million for one season, but certainly not $20 million. He'll probably get a multi-year deal anyway.
-
Soler Opts Out (Is Also a Silver Slugger Finalist)
By that logic, if Josh Bells also opts out, our speed, baserunning and defense will improve. Do you want him to leave, too? Don't get me wrong: I am absolutely not advocating overpaying for Soler. I think some dumb team will overpay and give him something like 2/40 or 3/50, which I would be perfectly fine not matching. But sorry, your logic is a pretty silly way of looking at things. Power does matter, and if Soler is willing to take something like 2/25, I would take him back (provided that the Marlins spend money in other places, of course).
-
2023/24 Off-Season
And thankfully our former GM did not make that signing. Did you see Abreu this year?
-
New GM News, Thoughts & Rumors
You forgot to capitalize PAYROLL. I get it. Honest mistake.
-
New GM News, Thoughts & Rumors
The top three highest payrolls in 2023 belonged to the Mets, Yankees and Padres. None of those three teams even made the playoffs. Meanwhile, the Rays and Orioles were 28th and 29th and finished with two of the best records in baseball. The Diamondbacks were 21st and are in the World Series. The Marlins were 24th and made the playoffs. Only caring about "PAYROLL" is a ridiculous way to operate.
-
2023/24 Off-Season
The fact that the Diamondbacks, who finished with a lower seed than the Marlins, are in the World Series demonstrates precisely what I was saying after the season ended: this team isn't that far off. At all. Anything can happen in the playoffs. Just get there.
-
New GM News, Thoughts & Rumors
Some team is going to pay Soler way more than he's worth. He's pretty much been an every other year type of guy for a while now so I could absolutely see him signing a deal for like 2/40 or 3/50 and absolutely falling on his face next season. If he'll take something like 2/25 I would take him back, but I guarantee another team blows that out of the water.
-
Kim Ng Not Returning
Sorry but this entire post is ridiculous. First of all, it's not "backstabbing"; it's business. Sherman and Ng aren't friends; he was her employer and she was his employee. If the two sides can't come to an agreement and choose to part ways, it's a business decision; not "backstabbing." This happens in the business world all the time, and whether we like it or not, baseball is a business. Additionally, already saying you don't plan on watching the team next season and that you don't have feelings for the team anymore when this year's playoffs haven't even ended yet is silly. How do you know the Marlins aren't going to hire a GM that ends up being far better than Kim? How do you know Sherman doesn't actually have a better plan in view? We already saw the report that Sherman wanted someone else to oversee scouting, which is entirely understandable and demonstrates that he does, in fact, want to improve the team. Sticking with the team through all of the firesales they've had and then bolting just because they let Kim Ng walk is just weird. You're entitled to your opinion of course, but it just doesn't make much sense to me.
-
2023/24 Off-Season
Nah I'm not upset. Never really was. While I thought she was decent at her job, it's not like she was Theo Epstein. She probably wasn't even as good as Larry Beinfest. She was just okay. I definitely think we can upgrade.
-
Who will be the new Marlins GM?
@hovertical It makes too much sense at this point.
-
Jazz Undergoes Turf Toe Surgery
I mean it's entirely possible that Sixto was too lazy to get up and just sent Jazz to fill up a plate for him.
-
2023/24 Off-Season
That's fair but I was specifically responding to the stolen bases part. If this team really wants to steal bases, they are going to have to sign guys who at least have decent speed.
-
2023/24 Off-Season
I mean Fortes had a .263 OBP this season. If we're relying on him to steal bases we have a problem lol. I agree that you don't need to be incredibly fast to steal bases, but you do need some speed, and the Marlins are probably one of the slower teams in baseball.
-
2023/24 Off-Season
Arraez isn't naturally fast. You can't really just "improve" your speed. And for the sake of argument, I would much rather him hit more home runs than be a little bit faster lol.
-
2023/24 Off-Season
Not when basically no one on the team outside of Jazz and Berti actually has the speed to steal bases.