Everything posted by jonnylons
-
The NL East
I like this team though. We have some guys who know how to get it done against the NL West. I think we also have a lot of heart and can get a lot of things to fall our way. I really like Lo Duca a lot. I think he is going to be a great fit on this team. Between he, Conine and Lowell - there wont be any room for BS on this squad. Plus, Beckett and Burnett could be the most dominating duo in all of baseball when they are on. And I think we just flicked the switch, baby... I'm pumped. I think the past couple days off are going to be a good thing for this team - people will catch their breath and be ready to get back to work. There is no team like the Marlins when their back is to the wall. BELIEVE>>>>
-
Do you think we can resign...
Willingham has to develop his defensive game. Until he does that, he wont make it with this team - mark my words. Unless we deal away some guys in front of him. He wont beat out Stokes for 1B and he certainly wont beat out Conine. Contracts are signed and demand players to perform. He wont get in front of our upper prospects in the OF either. Hermida, Reed - these guys are our future out there. Cabs is going to learn his craft as his value is as an OF and NOT a 1B. There is a reason why Willy was moved to catcher - he has the best chance of being a regular MLBer at that spot. We have guys better at every other position he is eligible to play. So, he has to develop his game-calling and his defense (especially throwing out base runners). Right now he is another Piazza, good offense catcher but poor defensive skills. And this organization is re-signing Lo Duca. They didnt give away Penny for a rental. We need a catcher and we need one that can produce offensively. As a 'small market' team, you have to get contributions from the entire lineup as opposed to having a few heavy hitters surrounded by average/above average talents. This also marks Willingham's future as a possible back-up next season or for the next few seasons or as a tradable commodity. Castro also could be a tradable commodity. Redmond may not be back, pending the FO's decision about Willy and Treanor could be a cheaper, adequate option to replace Redmond.
-
Did any one listen to Fat Hank show today?
Hank is a betting man - but loses a lot more than he wins. And he would lose betting against the Marlins. This deal made the team better. All the holes were filled. We didnt take on any significant payroll to do it either. This team is better NOW than it was before the trade. I dont see how anyone makes any objections other than did we give up too much future talent for present circumstances. Again, I would answer by saying that you have to pay to win. The window for this team is now and they have to do everything they can to win now. Penny has great value in that he is young as does Choi. I have no problem parting with Penny, but Choi I would rather us have kept. But the fact is we have to play Conine with the money we are paying him and Choi becomes expendable because we are NOT the Yankees. Until people show a willingness to understand the context in which these deals are made, they will always just be blowhards in my book.
-
Budget Info
I think all the arbitration guys make it back. And of the FA's, only Pavs needs to be re-signed. Benitez is gone, unless he is going to take a lot less money to stay here - and I dont think he will be taking off for NY or any other big market team. So dont discount the Marlins' ability to negotiate with him - but I dont think he will be back and Mota is going to be our future closer. Remember, Mota also came from the Expos org. and they know him pretty well here. And he also WANTS to be a closer.
-
Do you think we can resign...
Again, I dont think the Marlins made this deal to let Lo Duca - or Mota - go. These guys figure into the future of this franchise. We need Lo Duca as he also buys time for Willingham to develop - and we need him to develop defensively as well as offensively. I dont know what Burnett's status is, but I am sure we re-sign him. Beckett is still under our control through '05 I believe. To me, we need to keep at all possible cost Burnett, Beckett and Pavano. Just like the Braves who had their big 3. Willis is necessary too, I just hope he isnt Steve Avery. That is why I didnt have a problem dealing Penny - to me, best case, he is Kevin Millwood.
-
The Trade
And necessary in order for that deal to even break even. And considering how we rushed Dtrain, who knows how confident people would be with Beinfest at the helm.
-
The NL East
My prediction: Braves lose NL East to the Marlins. We can make up six games, especially with all the games we play against the Braves. Remember, Smoltz himself didnt think the Braves could contend with the pieces they had - and still have. They are getting insane production from a lot of guys who are playing out of their minds. Some may have said the same about us last year, but it is clearly not a good comparison when you consider we had Burnett injured last year and Beckett was consistently on the DL and inconsistent as a starter until the 2nd half of the season. If there is one thing you need to know about this Marlins team is that they have a lot of 'gamers' on this team now. That means, as it gets hotter, so do the Marlins. The Braves dont have as many guys like that as we do. I gurantee you Burnett, Beckett, Pavano, Mota, Benitez, Conine, Lowell, Cabs, Pierre, Lo Duca all show up when it matters. You cannot discount Willis' heart. Nor McKeon's ability to make the right call - and he is due. This team can only get better. That is all I need to know.
-
The Trade
Lo Duca and Mota are not bad contracts. We possibly could re-sign both for as much as Penny was going to get by himself. Pavano is the better pitcher between he and Penny. Most of you know I am not the biggest Penny fan out there - he doesnt have the heart to put it all together. Pavano is a more complete pitcher and will have better value for this franchise. Besides, when will Penny EVER date a model/actress like Alyssa Milano? :mischief Encarnacion for Choi. That is how you have to look at this part of the deal. Sure, we inherit a big contract that we didnt want to pay for in the first place - but Loria wouldnt ok this deal if they didnt feel they could swing it. Also, Enc makes the team better as his offense is comparable to Choi's but he puts Cabs in the more comfortable LF and Conine goes to 1B. The team defense gets better, not to mention our baserunning and team speed gets A LOT better with Lo Duca and Enc on this team.
-
Glad Choi is Gone!
Choi is a fine, young hitter. He makes me think of Palmeiro - another ex-Cub 1B. I support this trade, but I would have liked to have kept Choi. Calling Enc an upgrade though is true, although very slight and not necessarily so for the long run.
-
Do you think we can resign...
Make no mistake, the Marlins brass LOVES Lo Duca. He will be re-signed. Also, Mota will be re-signed. That means Benitez is gone. We cant afford him and Pavano and Pavs is a huge priority now especially with Penny gone. Plus, we still have Koch and Spooney who can both stabilize that bullpen. Enc IS our RF because he is under contract. And stop hating on the guy, he is better than he has played for LA (it was all a part of Beinfest's diabolical plan...)
-
LeBatard is at it again!
Look, negativity is a good sign from Le Bastard for the Marlins. Remember his reaction to the Fudge signing? "Breast implants on a corpse" he so-elequently depicted it. Giving us a view of his sick mind (and his penchant for necrophilia). This deal is a good deal in the sense it helps the Marlins win NOW. Sure, I would have rathered us throw in Stokes instead of Choi and got Werth instead of Encarnacion. But it didnt happen and this trade still helps us. Lo Duca is a gamer and will produce in the clutch. And could you imagine how bad things would be with Benitez now on the DL?
-
Rotoworld's take on the trade
You're right, we do disagree here. This team gets a lot better NOW, no doubt about it. Because what you failed to address is the moves you dont have a problem with. If you dont have a problem trading for a starter and a reliever, then you understand that one of those moves was made to address a hole made by the very deal you DONT like. Let's face it, Penny has been inconsistent for his career. He has the tools, but I dont know if he has the heart or the mentality to ever put those things together. That said, he has 3.15 ERA and is 8-8. With an ERA like that, you would think he would have gotten better results. So, how much of a hole is really left? We dealt: Travis Chick Abraham Nunez Hee Seop Choi Brad Penny Bill Murphy for: Paul Lo Duca Guillermo Mota Juan Encarnacion Ismael Valdez Seanez We gave up 2 prospects, a lame-duck OFer, a young talented 1B and starter to get an Allstar catcher, a top notch reliever, a gold-glove caliber OF, a solid starter and a righty specialist. No contracts are killing us. Sometimes to win, you have to give up something.
-
Question: How many games did we lose last year?
P.S. I'll eat crow if Beinfest, LoDuca, Enc and the rest show me up. 487267[/snapback] But until then, you are going to give this deal a chance and not form an opinion... :mischief
-
Rotoworld's take on the trade
One more thing: We won it all last year without AJ Burnett. And he is WAY more talented than Penny is.
-
Question: How many games did we lose last year?
Rferry, normall you are right on, but this one you are way off. We started terribly last year WITH Fudge and Enc but NO CABRERA. Check after May what happened last year. And then, get a W/L record with Cabs, Fudge, and Enc in the same lineup. You may be surprised.
-
Rotoworld's take on the trade
I disagree and here is why: Did we give up a lot of future talent? Yes. Did we help our chances of winning right now? Yes. If you know anything about baseball and its history, teams normally have to give up something to win. Last year, some were crying about the Conine and Urbina deals. We gave up too much in prospects. But you know what? It paid off. Did we give up a lot? Sure - if all those players pan out. Look at what we gave up here. We gave up 2 MLB players for 3 PROVEN MLB'ers. One is an all-star the other is arguably one of the better relief arms IN THE GAME. Choi for Mota? Penny for Lo Duca? You could argue for or against either one of those deals - but you have to take into consideration the context with which those deals are made. We have Conine who can play 1B. We just acquired Valdez to pitch for Penny while also getting the upgrade at catcher that this team does need. Now, I said all along that the bullpen wasnt as bad as some made it out to be. But Benitez was not going to hold up for the rest of the season and possibly the playoffs at that rate. Mota can spell him from time to time and his presence also increases the effectiveness of guys like Koch, Howard, Bump, Manzanillo who all dont have to pressure themselves to hold on to shutouts to do their jobs. Not to mention, the offense gets better. Yes, it does. The offense gets better because Lo Duca helps spread the wealth and the repsonsibility on offense. If you wedge him between Lowell and Castillo at 3, you now have 1-5 hitting around or above .300. The OBP also looks good. Factor in a healthy and hot hitting Conine at the 6, a wildcard Enc at 7 and a streaky AGon at 8 and this offense is much improved. So lets see: we needed a stronger bullpen, a more potent offense and better defense. We got all that in this deal while also increasing our team speed and baserunning, as well as acquired a solid starter to plug the hole left by Penny in the rotation. I fail to see how this is a bad deal. Plus, if you think about the finances, we were NOT going to keep Penny and Pavano after this season. Penny we would have more control over, in that we would have his rights, but he was going to get an increase in pay anyway. We would have been forced to pay him whatever arbitration said. With Pavano, we risk losing him but getting a draft pick as compensation. I like our chances of re-signing him if we win though. Lo Duca and Mota are cheap ($4M and $1.5M, respectively). Both are arby eligible and with Benitez on his way out, more than likely, we have insureance with Mota as our closer. Enc has a contract through next year but could always be dealt again to free up money. So, we were not going to keep Penny, most likely, and eventhough Choi is young and very talented, he is apparently not irreplaceable (Conine, Cabrera, Stokes, Willingham all options to play 1B at this point). I dont see how this is damaging for this franchise.
-
Why Walker trade didnt go down
BS. It didnt happen because of money. If there was more time needed, I think they would have found a way to push it through with the ability to work out the finer stuff later...
-
The effects of the deals
Someone either merge this with the other, later, trade review threads - please.
-
Countdown
Remember, the Valdez deal still isnt posted on the MLB site...
-
Countdown
i agree, deals may not be being announced just yet. I will give us 15 mins...then I am out of here. I think Cj rejecting the deal may make the Walker deal more imperative, as they will want to get rid of money for financial flexibility. But, what do I know...
-
Countdown
I agree, no matter what happens, this team is much better off today than it was yesterday. We should have a lot of help getting back to the playoffs and hopefully the World Series.
-
Countdown
Walker is on a plane signing the last bits of the deal...
-
Valdez Acquired
Hopefully it all works out...and I think it will. The FO has addressed all of our needs thus far. If they pull off Walker, this is a grandslam.
-
The effects of the deals
Saenez for Nunez... Valdez for single A pitcher (who?)... Is Walker next?
-
Hey Jonnylons,
HAHAHA...sure. The finger stays - it is for Beckett! But the spider goes... Now we got Valdez...soon, Walker.