Everything posted by dim
-
****OFFICIAL ACTIVE USER POWER RANKINGS****
Hey guys long time lurker first time poster. Just wanted to say I look forward to the day that I can be among those on this list. All the people listed here, especially the man listed 6th, are legendary posters.
-
Pirates President Frank Coonelly
I just had to butt in to say I hate the term "super cheap 6 year deal". He's making damn near $18 million a year over those 6 years. I understand the sentiment behind the statement ($18 million a year as opposed to the $24-25 million he's probably worth early on), but it still sounds so wrong to call $107 million super cheap. Those first six years alone is still the biggest single contract in Marlins history.
-
Pirates President Frank Coonelly
Also people, one VERY important point. There is NO guarantee Stanton opts out and HE has the control, not Loria. You act like the team can vacate the deal after 6 years and laugh. No, Stanton can stay on and force them to pay all 325 million. Which is the smart move for him, since he'll be making $30 million+ a year for those last seven. I think no matter what Stanton's getting that $325 million. The question is whether Stanton is healthy and playing well when the time comes or if he became an injury prone player, had a decline for whatever reason, or some other thing that makes him a worse player in 2021 than he is was in 2014. If he's playing well, the Marlins will be able to find a team that'll take the contract off his hands and get some prospects back in return. If he's not playing well and/or injury prone, then we're stuck with past his prime Stanton on the biggest AAV deal in the history of Major League Baseball. This is all conditional on Loria being owner at this point in 2021. Who knows if Loria sells the team to a rich owner like a Mark Cuban or whoever and even with Stanton playing well they're perfectly content with paying Stanton that large sum of cash and then some. But if Loria's still owner there's no chance in hell he'll want Stanton for those last seven years. No team in their right mind would want a player for 7 years $218 million for their age 31-38 years. It would basically become the Yankees situation with Alex Rodriguez or the Angels situation with Josh Hamilton where fans resent the players for being signed on long term, big money deals during their down years. But that's a long ways away at the moment for fans to really worry about (although it is obviously a consideration for the Marlins given that $325 million is worth 60% of the Marlins team value if sold today). I'm shocked with all these comments like "At age 31 Stanton will OBVIOUSLY want to opt out for a better deal". Like seriously? Where are you going to find a better deal at age 31 than 7 years $218 million? Does Stanton intend on playing into his 40s? I'm sure that at the end of the day, Stanton can be absolutely content to live the rest of his days of this single $325 million contract. That's more money than fifty people could spend in a lifetime no matter how many bottles of champagne, strip clubs, houses, cars, jets, whatever you spend it on. Yes inflation happens and contracts today could be chump change compared to contracts in 2021, but I'm pretty sure $325 million is a large amount of money no matter what time period your in. Basically, it is very unlikely, no matter what the stats are in six years or how much he hates our front office/ownership/teammates/whoever at that time, that he will opt out of the deal. He basically hit the golden ticket and should probably take full advantage of it.
-
Pirates President Frank Coonelly
Whether or not this actually happened (and it's very debatable that this ever took place), you should've known when the deal was announced that this is what the Marlins were going for. 6 years, $107 million and when Stanton turns 31 he can either opt in, take his full money and get traded to a rich team who'll pay him that crazy amount of money (7 years $200+ million is nuts), opt out and sign a new deal for what teams will feel he's worth at age 31 (probably close to that number but more likely something like 10 years $200 million+), or the third option... Loria did this deal knowing full damn well he will not be owner when the opt out clause comes into play. Loria's net worth as a whole is somewhere north of $500 million. If you factor in the team being worth something in the vicinity of $450 million-$500 million if he were to sell at this moment, then he'd be paying Stanton over the entire deal over 30% of his total net worth. 30% of everything he's got, including the team itself, to a single player. That's simply not smart business. For me this was always a 6 year $107 million deal. That's a hell of a team friendly deal given the season Stanton's coming off of and it's 4 years more than I ever expected to have Stanton for. I see Stanton opting in and whoever the ownership group/front office at the time of the opt out will find a Yankees/Cubs/Red Sox/Dodgers team to pawn Stanton's newfound nuts $30 million a year for 7 years contract onto. The good thing is we're getting all of Stanton's prime years for an average of $18 million a year. Whether this is a case of a thrifty front office, a cheap owner, or just basic economics, the truth of the matter is that the deal is genius for the Marlins. The one of the worst case scenarios for Miami is Stanton opting in whenever the time comes and no team is willing to touch his contract. But this is baseball and there's always gonna be rich owners willing to throw big money at a productive power bat. There'll be a market for Stanton when the time comes. Unless Stanton has an injury, stops hitting, pulls a Josh Hamilton, whatever between now and 2021. At that rate Stanton opts in and the Marlins are on the hook for that massive 7 year backloaded part of the contract on an unproductive player who hamstrings the teams payroll for many years to come. But right now that's the least of our concerns.
-
Marlins Acquire Mat Latos
Kolek is literally 18 years old. If he's the best we have in our system at the moment, and it's not even a close #2, there are serious, SERIOUS problems in our minor league system. It'll take two or three years to rebuild the system back to something resembling respectability.
-
Rule V Draft
Canha is being called a "limited ceiling but ready to play now first baseman" Seems like we could have used one of those, huh? While Canha has played 1B a lot I've always thought his numbers had more value at 3B with the occasional ability to play one of the corner outfield positions. While defensively he's best at 1B, I feel like that's a waste of his talent.
-
Rule V Draft
Mark Canha in Colorado should be nice to watch. He's a good hitter who was never given a real shot, always reminded me of Gaby Sanchez in our system... *Reads through more posts* Mark Canha in Oakland should be nice to watch. Billy Beane knows when to acquire talent and Canha is just that.
-
BA Top 20 prospects
So from my personal top 20 prospects list the Marlins have traded or let go #1 (Heaney), #2 (Moran), #7 (Desclafani), #13 (Wallach), #14 (Barnes), and #15 (Canha). Well it was fun having a minor league system. Next year's Adopt a Marlin Draft should be full of scotch and broken dreams.
-
Justin Morneau?
Pass on Alvarez, and if Rockies want too much for Morneau (aka Eovaldi and everything left in the barren wasteland that is our minor league system) then Michael Morse needs to be priority #1.
-
Marlins Acquire Mat Latos
You missed Haren. You're funny.
-
Marlins Acquire Mat Latos
I think that it's going to be hard to keep Latos if he ends up having a good year. We're talking about a guy who has had a 3.31 ERA over the last 3 seasons while pitching in a bandbox. He had a couple injuries this past year but before that it was mostly smooth sailing. Either we extend him early or not at all. If we let him get through most of the season and he does well, there is no reason for him not to try free agency. This is going to be a one year rental. If we needed $12.5 million just to afford free agents in the first place then we won't have the $100 million+ to re-sign Latos if he posts a low 3 or high 2 ERA after this season. It's a great trade if you are desperate to make the playoffs next year like the Marlins seem to be, and Disco seems destined for the bullpen and Chad Wallach is 2 and a half years from MLB consideration anyway. THESE are the kind of prospects you trade for established talent even for the short term.
-
Marlins Acquire Mat Latos
I mean I love Wallach. Those who follow what I say in the minor league threads know that I thought him and Romero could be two of the top prospects in the system come next year. But he's far from a finish prospect, and if this team is in win now mode, which apparently the front office is definitely in, and all it costs for Latos even for just a single year is Disco and Wallach I think I'm ok with it. I'd love for them to re-sign Latos after this but I'm guessing that is unreasonable to expect from the Marlins. The transition from Great American Ball Park to Marlins Park is going to be absolutely fun to watch. We saw what the change from Minute Maid Park to Marlins Park did for Cosart. So next season we'll have... 1. Alvarez 2. Latos 3. Cosart 4. Eovaldi 5. Koehler Don't know if I'm missing anybody but I like the rotation next season. the 1/2 punch of Alvarez is really really nice, Cosart, if he pitches even half as good as he did for us last season is a solid #3, Eovaldi is due for a bounce back and even with regression Koehler should be fine as the #5 until Jose gets back.\ Good trade, although it's fun and scary at the same time how short sighted the Marlins are thinking at the moment. Our minor league system is a complete barren wasteland now with Justin Nicolino and Avery Romero being our top 2 prospects.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
The thing that sickens me in all this, more than anything, is that Dee Gordon is slotted into the leadoff spot no questions asked. That is pretty disgusting in and of itself. 64 stolen bases does that. While I'd obviously rather have somebody who gets on base at something like a .350+ clip you're wasting Dee Gordon's biggest asset, his ability to steal bases and mess with opposing pitchers, anywhere in the lineup but the leadoff spot.
- Justin Morneau?
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
Yeah we got the worse 2B but the years of control for cheap and extra money. As everyone's already said money can get you nice things sometimes.
-
Winter Meetings 2014
EDIT: Apparently the Angels really value Barnes. DiPietro must've saw something in him that the Marlins didn't.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
They get a guy coming off a 5.4 WAR season. But outside that Kendrick is a consistent good, never great 2B. Kendrick is also making $8 million+ a year through 2016. Gordon's under team control until 2019. Kendrick's the better bet to be good, but Gordon all things considered is probably the better value for the Marlins since we obviously can't afford an $8 million a year 2B.
-
Winter Meetings 2014
Yeah...that guy who hasn't yet posted an OBP under .367 never deserved a chance. Instead of fast tracking him (three years at Arizona State, two year starter), they've had him spend four years in the minors. Outside his Jamestown and Jupiter appearances he has not posted an OPS under .800 in the minors. I've already said he wasn't a guaranteed good MLB starter but he most certainly deserved better treatment (aka being moved through the system faster and given a consistent position). He's a better prospect than given credit for and given that Andrew Friedman wanted him I think that helps validate the point that he is underrated. I fully expect him to see time in the majors with the Dodgers sometime late 2015.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
Everybody's playing hot potato with Andrew Heaney. VERY interested to see what they got in return for him.
-
Winter Meetings 2014
If you're saying Barnes hasn't been worth giving a shot then you're just being stupid.
-
Winter Meetings 2014
Or...you know...Josh Willingham. Or Gaby Sanchez. Seriously, Marlins don't have the best track record with calling up prospects, whether it be too early or not notice until too late.
-
Winter Meetings 2014
Except it's not really prospects. It's three guys who have already played at the major league level in some way and Austin Barnes, who's 25 and should've probably been given that shot already at some point. These are some A+ balls we go rid of. But I understand and agree to an extent with the sentiment.
-
Winter Meetings 2014
If it's not Eovaldi or Nicolino the biggest thing I'm afraid of is trading German+. German has been our hidden gem in the minors and I'm really excited to see him pitch in Jupiter. Really wish to see him stay on the team. Also want to see Eovaldi stay since I see last season as a bit of a fluke.
-
Marlins Acquire Dee Gordon for Andrew Heaney
Again, I said it wasn't exactly ideal. But I'd rather improve our team by trading Nicolino for Morneau and testing the injury bug and the rest of our minor league pitching depth than sign Morse, simply because Morneau is a better bet to be successful. The Marlins basically gave a big FU to depth when they traded there SP depth in Heaney, their 2B depth in Hernandez, their C/2B/utility depth in Barnes, and their bullpen depth in Hatcher to get Dee Gordon to fill 2B and $12.5 million cash. Can't speak about depth when the Marlins pretty much gave that talk the middle finger. If you are gonna talk about going all in to win, you can't let Justin Nicolino hold you back. Even if he pans out, Nicolino will not be a viable good starter with the major league rotation until 2016. He is not really in discussion to be a starter outside of worst case scenario next season. I'd rather trade Disco or Conley or even Urena to be completely honest, but I wouldn't let Nicolino be the complete stop to negotiations for Morneau. If push came to shove I'd trade him for a good 1B in a heartbeat.
-
Winter Meetings 2014
We have no other assets to really give up for Morneau, and Frisaro is saying the talks with the Rockies are 'hot' at the moment. The Rockies need pitching, and our main prospects/players to trade away still are pitchers, so I have absolutely no doubt in my mind the Marlins are discussing trading Eovaldi/Nicolino. I would be absolutely shocked if all it took was Disco/Conley. It doesn't make sense for the Rockies to trade Morneau for pitchers whose career's likely lead them to the bullpen.