Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

EricWiener

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by EricWiener

  1. Hill is certainly missed. I also think this team needs a hardass somewhere on the coaching staff. If not manager, then bench coach.
  2. At their peak, this is what I'd want C: Pudge 1B: Lee 2B: Uggla 3B: Cabrera SS: Ramirez LF: Alou CF: Kotsay RF: Sheff 1B/OF: Conine IF: Abbot IF: Arias IF/OF: Eisenreich C: Zaun SP: Brown SP: Willis SP: Penny SP: Pavano SP: Leiter RP: Nen RP: Hoffman RP: Looper RP: Urbina RP: Cook RP: Harvey RP: Powell
  3. What's not to like?
  4. Yeah if you compare our potential 2008 1-5 against the rest of the NL East, we should be very competitive that was the case a year ago we know what happened If the SP is as injury plagued next season, it will be every bit as frustrating. If it isn't, we can pitch with anyone. The team, with the black-hole at Catcher and CF (most of the year anyhow) can already hit with anyone. If this team is healthy, and if we get a Catcher, this team is good enough to win. I still want to see: Hermida (he can flat get on base, has the pop to pick up DeAza and Treanor's .350 OBP for runs) Jacobs (his ground balls are almost always pulled) Ramirez (team has a winning record with Hanley in the 3 hole) Cabrera (MVP - along with Hanley) Uggla (Willy will still get him pitches, and he's a power machine) Willingham (Willy doesn't need lineup protection, he's got a good eye) De Aza (Exciting to watch) Treanor (Can get on base, better catcher than Olivo)
  5. BTW, most good players are already good at 23. That doesn't hold up under scrutiny. Perhaps, and I do mean perhaps, most GREAT players were already good at 23, but that would take more scrutiny than I want to invest. But using Hermida's .800 OPS as a standard, it doesn't hold for Craig Biggio, Tony Gwynn, Derek Jeter, Jason Giambi, Admin Walker, Jim Edmonds, Barry Larkin, David Ortiz, and Moises Alou (guys I looked at to try to find great players that were good at 23). There are maybe 30 out of 254 starting lineup players that fit the mold of "as good or better than Jeremy Hermida at age 23", that is an elite distinction right there. If he avoids future injury, Jeremy Hermida will be a reliable high-OBP LH bat with decent, but not great, power and some speed. That is a tremendously valuable player.
  6. I think Jacobs is misused and injury plagued. As a result, we have no idea what he'll do, but he has all the makings of an .850 hitter. Holy sh*t, Jacobs is going to hit .850? Sign that dude up long term right now. I don't pay attention to meaningless stats. The .850 is OPS potential.
  7. Nice body, sure. Just haven't been able to looj past that man-face. Sue me for being in the minority. That comment may have just put you on the gaydar screen. :whistle
  8. Here are a few more.. with 4 or 5 of them it may be debatable as to whether they are / were better than Hermida at age 23 but with most of them it's not debatable. The point is that some of you make it seem as if only hall of famers are good at age 23 and taht's nonsense, in my opinion. Dustin Pedroia Robinson Cano Melky Cabrera Troy Glaus Frank Thomas B.J. Upton Gary Sheffield Jhonny Peralta Joe Mauer Justin Morneau Paul Konerko Vladimir Guerrero Garret Anderson Brian McCann Andruw Jones Jeff Francoeur Ryan Zimmerman Prince Fielder Ryan Braun Aramis Ramirez Scott Rolen Adam Dunn Luis Gonzalez James Loney Ryan Klesko The boldfaced guys (and some that I missed) are either players that were not better at 23, are currently 23 and might not do any better than Hermida will be season's end, or pitchers. Looking at the guys that are not boldfaced... are there any of them that we wouldn't want in the lineup (if they could indeed play RF) either right now or during their prime? BTW, this is a list of players that includes a large number of HoF candidates.
  9. I think Jacobs is misused and injury plagued. As a result, we have no idea what he'll do, but he has all the makings of an .850 hitter.
  10. Can someone explain why Treanor is better at handling pitchers? I admit that Tommy and Rich going gaga over Treanor talking to the pitcher in the dugout between innings didn't convince me. The performance of pitchers while Treanor is catching is better than when Olivo is catching. I can't tell you why he is better, but it is easy to demonstrate that he is.
  11. Offensively, I agree that Treanor would not put up those same numbers if starting him everyday, but the fact that he will give you a quality at bat at least a reasonable percentage of the time deserves some credit. Olivo just looks overmatched everytime he is in the box unless he gets a fastball down the middle or a lefty misses with a slider. Overmatched Guy (Olivo) has a higher career OPS than Quality At Bat Guy (Treanor). Overmatched Guy also has the higher career RISP OPS than Quality At Bat Guy. Career OBP of Treanor though is much higher, which is in actuality much more telling of a quality AB than OPS as a whole. Treanor does get on base more often but overall Olivo is the "better" hitter. Except that he's not the better hitter. Except for last season, he's never demonstrated the ability to do anything at the plate other than suck.
  12. He's 40th in OPS among ML OFers and his defense is horrendous. He still has yet to justify all the hype he came into 06 with. Ok, he's young and still has plenty of time, whatever. The point is that it takes more than a month to be able to say that "he has arrived" Yet one typically has to look to first ballot hall of fame players with better age 23 performance. There is nothing wrong with Jeremy Hermida that playing time will not fix. As long as nobody tried to make him more aggressive (like last season) we are going to have a reliable .850+ OPS left-handed hitter playing in a park that is death on lefties. Tony Gwynn wasn't a reliable .800 OPS player until his 30s, by that time he wasn't a reliable everyday player, he routinely missed 20-40 games every year. I think you're way off on that. Just guessing but I think there must be somewhere around 20 position players in MLB right now who were better at 23 than Hermida is right now adn I doubt all these guys will be first ballot hall of famers. Maybe not first ballot guys (though there is a lot of candidates here), but these are elite players and Hermida may surpass some of these guys' age 23 OPS performance. Miguel Cabrera Hanley Ramirez Albert Pujols Jose Reyes Grady Sizemore Ken Griffey, Jr. Alex Rodriguez Jim Thome Barry Bonds Scott Rolen David Wright Manny Ramirez He's 23. Most players, even future hall-of-fame guys, are not major league starting position players (much less good hitting ones) at age 23, and Hermida is a good hitting starting position player. The Marlins have several very special young hitters, and Hermida is one of them. This team will have an outstanding offense for as long as this core is maintained.
  13. Treanor is a better catcher. Treanor handles pitchers better. Treanor works farther into counts and gets on base more often. Treanor is not the answer, unless the question is, "How can the Marlins improve immediately at catcher."
  14. so hermida is the next tony gwynn? Point >here< You >here< The point was, and is, that even great players take time to develop, and Hermida is WAAAAAAAAAAAAY ahead of the curve. BTW, for the record, I hope that Hermida remains ahead of Tony Gwynn in that he stays a reliable .800 OPS player from now on, AND plays 150+ games each season from now on.
  15. He's 40th in OPS among ML OFers and his defense is horrendous. He still has yet to justify all the hype he came into 06 with. Ok, he's young and still has plenty of time, whatever. The point is that it takes more than a month to be able to say that "he has arrived" Yet one typically has to look to first ballot hall of fame players with better age 23 performance. There is nothing wrong with Jeremy Hermida that playing time will not fix. As long as nobody tried to make him more aggressive (like last season) we are going to have a reliable .850+ OPS left-handed hitter playing in a park that is death on lefties. Tony Gwynn wasn't a reliable .800 OPS player until his 30s, by that time he wasn't a reliable everyday player, he routinely missed 20-40 games every year.
  16. No matter how 'good' his ideas may be, we aren't gonna have Elmer Fudd for President.
  17. He should have been shut down weeks ago, he came off of injury last season and we are cranking up the stress on his arm.
  18. Real pitchers duel today, eh?
  19. This 'threat' is as empty as a bottle of scotch in Joe Namath's house. China has a lot to lose, infact too much to lose to do this. They just like to talk and hear themselves speak. we're more dependent on china then they are on us. Their biggest trade partner is the EU, so they could afford it more than we can. It would certainly hurt us, but it would destroy China's economy.
  20. She is one of a small number of women that I consider to be ideal in looks.
  21. Hermida Jacobs Ramirez Cabrera Uggla Willingham Treanor DeAza VandenHurk needs to be shut down, he's been overused given his surgery last season, and Barone should get a look.
  22. Borchard was horrible this year, even agianst RHP. He still had his normal BB rate (walked 10.7% of the time, career 10.4%) and his K-rate was online too (Career 28.8%, this year 29.9%), but still had a sub-.300 OBP and a very unimpressive .333 SLG mostly thanks to only have a 41.75 PA/HR rate. He just plain wasn't hitting the ball. And his BABIP isn't very low (.267, career .274), so you can't discredit this year because of that. I mean really, looking at the numbers, you really have to credit last year just being an anomaly and this right here is the real Joe Borchard, as unfortunate as that is. He was certainly bad this year, but I don't know how much of that was due to overuse and misuse forced upon the team by injury. Regardless, he doesn't fit into this teams future, and Ross is just better than him.
  23. forget it, I'm on the train he's fantastic and I love watching him He certainly looked good today, that's for sure.
  24. If DeAza and Ross avoided injury, the Borch/Ross platoon would have done just fine. Unfortunately with those 2 guys out we were putting Alfredo and Borchard out there every day against lefties and they were stinking up the place. JoBo was a perfectly fine 4th/5th OF to use exclusively against RHP. That said, he has no place in this team's long-term plans and Linden and DeAza may be part of the future.
  25. Olivo batting 4th made a bit of sense in this case, tonight only. Except that Olivo shouldn't ever start after an off day, because he should be our back up catcher. Make him eat double headers and day games.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.