October 1, 200521 yr Finally someone gets my point...Willingham is nothing short of really bad behind the plate. He cant hold Treanor's jock there.
October 1, 200521 yr Finally someone gets my point...Willingham is nothing short of really bad behind the plate. He cant hold Treanor's jock there. Well, that's not exactly what I said. They both suck spectacularly in their own ways if we're talking about being a back-up, so I guess it's pick your poison...my point was that there are glaring reasons why neither of them should be used as the back-up on a small market, low-scoring, defense oriented team.
October 1, 200521 yr Finally someone gets my point...Willingham is nothing short of really bad behind the plate. He cant hold Treanor's jock there. Well, that's not exactly what I said. They both suck spectacularly in their own ways if we're talking about being a back-up, so I guess it's pick your poison...my point was that there are glaring reasons why neither of them should be used as the back-up on a small market, low-scoring, defense oriented team. I agree. There are so many catchers out there that are good behind the plate and at least have the ability to swing the bat every now and then. They might not hit anything over .250 but they'll knock a few out.
October 1, 200521 yr I like WIllinghams bat as much as you guys, but I am also realistic when I say that, a guy that wasn't a catcher until he was what...25? Has no real value at that position, even as a backup. I'll take Treanor behind the plate over Willingham anyday. wow.....you criticize Willy for being an older minor leaguer yet you'd rather have the journeyman behind the plate.....please....Treanor isn't fit to hold Willy's jock. That has to go down in the annals of MB.com as one of the least informed posts in 2005. You don't have even the faintest idea what you're talking about if you really believe that. Either that or you live downwind from Three Mile Island. While Treanor's BA is woeful, he's batting over .300 with runners in scoring position, catches well, calls a good game and has a strong arm. Willingham should pray that one day he can play the game as well as Treanor does today.
October 2, 200521 yr It was a great game for all the kids. Willy's clutch single and Hermida's HR certainly gives us fanssomething to look forward to in 2006. Unless Hermida falls on his face in ST you have to pencil him in in RF next season and then you have Aguila and Willy, both of whom have skills of one kind or another to contribute big time. Messenger is still a work in progress. If they can fix his stride and help him show some movement of his fastball to go with this changeup and curve he can drop in there, he could be extraordinary. Unfortunately, until someone works on his mechanics he's just ordinary.
October 2, 200521 yr Mesertsengeeewr is whawt man what r yu takin about./...and eo yu really dsislike hermiea evetylong? cuz ythat si messead up bueddy
October 2, 200521 yr Author as the resident Willingham fanboy, I gotta say that single he had tonight was off the heez... man did that pump me up and Hermida is just so smooth isnt he? next year is gonna be lots of fun
October 2, 200521 yr as the resident Willingham fanboy, I gotta say that single he had tonight was off the heez... man did that pump me up and Hermida is just so smooth isnt he? next year is gonna be lots of fun It was at a clutch time....but a little bloop is "off the heez"???? Hermidia continues to impress offense and defense.
October 2, 200521 yr The thing that impresses me most about Hermida is his age. We (at least I do sometimes) forget he's 21 years old. It just blows me away that he's this good at this age. I don't want to start making comparisons to Miggy or suggest he'll mimic Cabrera's rise to fame but it's almost impossible not to.
October 2, 200521 yr The thing that impresses me most about Hermida is his age. We (at least I do sometimes) forget he's 21 years old. It just blows me away that he's this good at this age. I don't want to start making comparisons to Miggy or suggest he'll mimic Cabrera's rise to fame but it's almost impossible not to. Well, we'll certainly be very pleased if he ends up drawing some comparisons to Miggy this time next year. :thumbup
October 2, 200521 yr Mesertsengeeewr is whawt man what r yu takin about./...and eo yu really dsislike hermiea evetylong? cuz ythat si messead up bueddy Your such an idiot.....Still want to hate on Willy???
October 2, 200521 yr Mesertsengeeewr is whawt man what r yu takin about./...and eo yu really dsislike hermiea evetylong? cuz ythat si messead up bueddy Your such an idiot.....Still want to hate on Willy??? For oen I dont hate on Willy, I just say he has no defnesive value.
October 2, 200521 yr Author the youngsters really energized this team didnt they? cant wait for next year
October 2, 200521 yr the youngsters really energized this team didnt they? cant wait for next year They did. I am looking forward to seeing Hermi in RF and Josh competing for a starting job in LF. I hope we bring Conine back because he provides versatility - can play LF and 1B.
October 2, 200521 yr I dont think Willingham will compete with Hermida for a job. Hermida is already the starting LF, Willingham will spot Conine(or whoever we have in LF) and Lo Duca every now and then.
October 2, 200521 yr Author I dont think Willingham will compete with Hermida for a job. who said he would?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.