Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Olivo & Treanor -- Playing Time Split

Featured Replies

Can't root? Are you kidding me? You can root for anyone you please.

 

.319 OBP is terrible in any league in the modern era. And it's not just one poor stat. It means a whole lot more than '.291' or '8 HRs' or 8th in this or that. 8th place of 16? So it's a bad year for catchers, which also makes Treanor look a bit better. What does that have to do with Olivo? Do you expect that always to be the case? Should we sign up Olivo now because catchers will continually get worse? Yes, Olivo is doing okay relative to other catchers. But what does that mean? To me, it doesn't mean he's earned a 4th start each turn of the rotation or contract extension or anything like that.

 

And you didn't answer my question. Why should Olivo be rewarded? Aside from making a move to make you feel better, there's really no reason to.

Can't root? Are you kidding me? You can root for anyone you please.

 

.319 OBP is terrible in any league in the modern era. And it's not just one poor stat. It means a whole lot more than '.291' or '8 HRs' or 8th in this or that. 8th place of 16? So it's a bad year for catchers, which also makes Treanor look a bit better. What does that have to do with Olivo? Do you expect that always to be the case? Should we sign up Olivo now because catchers will continually get worse? Yes, Olivo is doing okay relative to other catchers. But what does that mean? To me, it doesn't mean he's earned a 4th start each turn of the rotation or contract extension or anything like that.

 

And you didn't answer my question. Why should Olivo be rewarded? Aside from making a move to make you feel better, there's really no reason to.

 

 

In the short term, Olivo should be given more playing time because of the hot streak he is on. In June, Olivo is batting .408 (20 for 49) with 3 homeruns and 16 RBIs.

 

Long term (this season) he should be rewarded by being named the Marlin's regular starting catcher (with Treanor filling in only when he is tired or injured) because while they are both good defensively, he stands heads and tails above Treanor offensively.

 

You say .319 is a terrible OBP (I agree), but then what do you consider Treanor's .287 OBP? How does Treanor's .214 AVG compare to Olivo's .291 AVG in your mind? Not much of a difference? How about Olivo's 8 HR to Treanor's one miracle shot? And what about the fact that Olivo's .811 OPS dwarfs Treanor's .585 OPS? Olivo also has more speed on the basepathes and has grounded into less double plays (Olivo has 1 GDP in 179 AB while Treanor has 3 GDP in 84 AB).

 

Don't hate Olivo just because the Marlins decided to not make Willingham their catcher like you wanted. Thats just the way things worked out.

That hot streak is coinciding with the hot streak of the player you're taking at bats from. Prior to last night, Matt Treanor has a .958 OPS and Olivo 1.000 over the past week or so. Both are from a small sample size as all period-based stats are. Both suggest they're playing over their heads. However, neither points in one player's favor.

 

 

And, yes, .319 = terrible = .287 in my book. I wasn't aware that last night's game pushed Olivo over the .811 mark in OPS, which is roughly what I predicted from Willingham from that spot, so perhaps it's fair to say he's having a productive season. I certainly wouldn't have said he was having a bad season prior to last night. Still not enough to keep the team from seeking his replacement.

We have a catcher who is slugging just under .500 and throws out over 40% of baserunners...and you have the audacity to complain about his OBP? hysterical.

we don't have any catchers in the high minors that could be considered a long or short term option for us. The guys we have in the low minors arn't considered top or even good prospects (dont know about the 2006 draftees). Therefore, if Olivo can put up 280/320/480, control the running game, and help us in a few smaller ways with speed it's not a bad thing. Just go year to year with him and let him go when he gets too expensive. Rferry's adjusted point, I agree with...but I don't think anyone was saying to lock him up long-term. I also agree that the 60/40 start split should remain intact as long as our pitchers are comfortable with the arrangement.

That hot streak is coinciding with the hot streak of the player you're taking at bats from. Prior to last night, Matt Treanor has a .958 OPS and Olivo 1.000 over the past week or so. Both are from a small sample size as all period-based stats are. Both suggest they're playing over their heads. However, neither points in one player's favor.

To even attempt to calculate an OPS from 9 plate appearances while noting that "a small sample size" exists suggests such a hideous misunderstanding of baseball statistics that it's not even worth the time to argue.

 

 

He is, but not by a wide margin at all. Why the need for a change?

Why even cite the difference? They're both pretty crappy in my book.

 

200-point difference and .280 average or not, a .316 OBP is terrible. And belongs nowhere near the word "better" even if it is in relation to a guy with a .200 point difference in OPS. Crap is crap. Why give the slightly less smelly pair of drawers more starts? Why change a damn thing when we're winning? Is somehow that move from uber-crap to crap going to help the team incredibly? No. So what's the point of making the change?

 

Anyways, .958 - 1.000 OPS in the past week.

 

I certainly wouldn't have said he was having a bad season prior to last night. Still not enough to keep the team from seeking his replacement.

That sounds like an interesting new topic for discussion.

That hot streak is coinciding with the hot streak of the player you're taking at bats from. Prior to last night, Matt Treanor has a .958 OPS and Olivo 1.000 over the past week or so. Both are from a small sample size as all period-based stats are. Both suggest they're playing over their heads. However, neither points in one player's favor.

To even attempt to calculate an OPS from 9 plate appearances while noting that "a small sample size" exists suggests such a hideous misunderstanding of baseball statistics that it's not even worth the time to argue.

Odd. Some people are using the same argument (others are overemphasizing batting average and power) for the point I question.

 

Will someone (anyone!) answer the question: what has Olivo done and/or Treanor not done to justify making a change to a formula that has coincided with the success of the team?

Trying to discuss anything, but especially catchers, for whom Rferry has always shown complete disdain, and a chronic ignoring of the onfield tasks of the position, is like trying to stay afloat in quicksand, so deftly does he redefine not only his own position, statements and conclusions, but the matter at hand generally.

Call it hatred, call it ignorance, but from my perspective catchers have a nominal impact on the game. Catch, throw, block. It's hard. Incredibly hard. I played catcher for one game and HATED it. Hated not being part of the action, but also hated being hit everywhere. And to think you have to go through that all the time? Warming up pitchers? Sucks. And then facing intensive inspection from coaches? And the fears of injury among managers and players?

It all leads to a very small population that are allowed to catch in the majors, with their skill levels not straying too far from the mean, offensively as well as defensively. Thus below-average becomes regarded 'terrible' and above-average 'great'. Really, I find it hard to believe there's much difference between Yadier Molina and Mike Piazza and Paul LoDuca, or Matt Treanor and Miguel Olivo and Josh Willingham defensively. (I can point out the differences between Derrek Lee and Hee=Seop Choi and Carlos Delgado and I've never played first base.) Atleast when it comes to measurable skills, such as arm strength, transfer and release speed and blocking pitches (which as Juanky has explained is a lost art).

 

What they do can hardly be measured in numbers, and what can not can vary widely from scout to scout, let alone from fan to fan. It has been attempted in rough calculations of pitcher performance with certain catchers and the results didn't suggest a significant difference of impact.

 

My argument with catchers is not that they aren't important. It's that they don't give you much value over their replacements and the back-up catcher spot should not be ignored and regulated as the 25th guy on the roster. He starts more often than any other reserve. He gets more at bats than most other reserves. And you're going to hand the good-character bad-bat average-defense guy those 150+ at bats? Why?!?

My proposal of a two or three-headed catcher platoon (and trust me, Olivo and Treanor are not my dream pair) is not a sign of a disdain for catchers. It's a recognition of their hard work in the past and present.

Honestly, players such as Miguel Olivo and the like who are promoted as 'starting catchers' do a disservice to the efforts of the true stars of the position (who start and deserve to start 130+ games a year) to promote the position.

Rferry....I think the only point you proved in that last post was that Marlins2003 was spot on with his comment above. I think you contradicted yourself 3 times. Talk about circular reasoning. I'm dizzy after reading that one. If that post was ever on the reading comprehension part of an SAT the answer would have to be "all of the above" to every question.

Luckily for us, Hermida_Rules27 hasnt been able to chime in with any "Olivo is a below average defensive catcher" nonsense to go along with Rferry's insistence that Treanor is Olivo's equal at the plate.

 

 

 

Olivo is a below average defensive catcher. You just look at the arm and forget to notice that the rest of his skill set behind the plate is awful at times. Throwing hard has nothing to do with a catchers defense, and defense overall is where Olivo is lacking.

For what it's worth, I'd take Miguel Olivo this year over Paul Lo Duca this year.

 

And what is the difference in salary agian? :shifty :mischief

  • Author

The OPS gap is now .241.

 

Olivo - .829

Treanor - .588

 

The quickest way to improved the team hitting is to play Olivo more and Treanor less.

Rferry....I think the only point you proved in that last post was that Marlins2003 was spot on with his comment above. I think you contradicted yourself 3 times. Talk about circular reasoning. I'm dizzy after reading that one. If that post was ever on the reading comprehension part of an SAT the answer would have to be "all of the above" to every question.

 

How so? Catchers have a hard job. Therefore there's less talent that gets to assume the job. Many are sent to other positions. Some even quit. This reduces talent at the position (restraining the talent variability) and standardizes the position. Sorry if I don't fall into the trap of citing the 15th or 30th best "starting catcher". They're not really good. Often they're below average defensively and weak offensively. And in all sense they aren't much better than the top or 15th or 30th "backup catcher". But if some want to quimble about the size of black holes for star role modeling or hero worship or their ideas of "everyday players" and "bench players" and "AAA stock", go ahead. I would expect nothing less from people who posted "Alex Gonzalez vs. Mike Lowell/Mike Redmond/Todd Hollandsworth" polls. I don't waste my time comparing mediocrity.

Rferry....I think the only point you proved in that last post was that Marlins2003 was spot on with his comment above. I think you contradicted yourself 3 times. Talk about circular reasoning. I'm dizzy after reading that one. If that post was ever on the reading comprehension part of an SAT the answer would have to be "all of the above" to every question.

 

How so? Catchers have a hard job. Therefore there's less talent that gets to assume the job. Many are sent to other positions. Some even quit. This reduces talent at the position (restraining the talent variability) and standardizes the position. Sorry if I don't fall into the trap of citing the 15th or 30th best "starting catcher". They're not really good. Often they're below average defensively and weak offensively. And in all sense they aren't much better than the top or 15th or 30th "backup catcher". But if some want to quimble about the size of black holes for star role modeling or hero worship or their ideas of "everyday players" and "bench players" and "AAA stock", go ahead. I would expect nothing less from people who posted "Alex Gonzalez vs. Mike Lowell/Mike Redmond/Todd Hollandsworth" polls. I don't waste my time comparing mediocrity.

 

You sure do write a lot about things you don't waste your time on.

if im not mistaking, i believe treanor catches the lefties...and he is more familiar with them...so despite a lack of offense from big matt...i dont mind him getting two days a week...especially as the dog days loom

 

You are right, he cathes when D-Train and Olsen picthes. Keep it the way it is unless Matt is in a long slump.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.