Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Olivo & Treanor -- Playing Time Split

Featured Replies

Crap is crap. Why give the slightly less smelly pair of drawers more starts?

 

I disagree Olivo is crap. Coming into the season I saw him as a backup but he has been a very pleasant surprise and has played very well. He's actually doing better than what Lo Duca did for us in '04 or '05.

You say that as if it means anything. Yes, OLivo has surprised me, but still he has not performed so well for the team to stop seeking a replacement or distanced himself from Treanor to become the exclusive starting catcher.

Two things:

1. I don't think we should change a thing about the catching situation.

2. Rferry will never admit he was wrong about any statement he makes...no matter how many facts get in the way.

Treanor's hitting about as well as Olivo anyway

 

 

dont say sh*t just to say it...

Olivo is hitting .291 and Treanor is hitting .214

 

 

 

...damn you Marlins2003. :lol

There I fix it.

Great timing for this topic!! It's almost as if Olivo himself were reading these posts earlier today.. I agree that Olivo should get more starts. And not just because of today's performance. Perhaps he should catch the D-train since it would probably effect him much less than Olsen to switch catchers at this point. They are both decent defensively, with Olivo having the plus arm. Offensively it's not even close. Olivo has much more pop in his bat, and runs well which can keep him out of double plays. Olivo is no all star but he is by far the best we have. Especially for the small salary he is making. These are exactly the kinds of players the Marlins try find all the time. Players that out perform their contracts. Olivo is doing that hands down.

Rferry's absolutely correct.

 

I mean, I realize Matt Treanor's .298 slugging percentage is 200 points lower than Olivo's and Treanor hit his first career home run just last week, but damn, he crushed that ball.

 

Treanor's hitting = Olivo's hitting

I much prefer Olivo starting and Treanor backing up. I'm not even comfortable with giving Treanor 50/50 playing time with Olivo; Matty is a quintessential backup.

Olivo is putting up some numbers

 

 

yeah, i've been really impressed.

 

i was skeptical at the begining of the season, because i remember he did real good with the Pads last year after doing not so good with the Mariners at the begining of the year, and his numbers there were higher than any in his career, so i figured it was a fluke.

 

but he's deffinately become a good hitter with a ton of pop. glad we got him.

sigh.. i knew the stat heads would say something. he's still hitting .292 with 8 dongs as a catcher who splits time and bats 8th. if you complain about that, you've got problems.

I have been wondering why Treanor is playing so often. Girardi started out 60/40 because neither was hitting at the start of the season. That's not the case now. Treanor is an offensive black hole. He should get 20% starts.

Treanor catches Olsen and Willis.

 

 

 

Catcher is a defensive position. Any offense you get from it and you are in business. And Treanor is very solid defensively and Olivo has made tremendous strides in that regard.

If this continues, then I was way off on Miguel Olivo & I'm happy to admit it. I was always psyched to see that arm, but didn't think he could hit & play all-around defense behind the plate enough to be anything worth mentioning.

 

I don't know if it'll last, and I still have issues with passed balls and the way he blocks the plate, but the little bit of pop and speed he can bring to the plate is enough for me to overlook his refusal to take a walk. Like Sea Bass before him, taking a walk before the pitcher spot is pretty useless anyway so if you get 15-20 homers from that spot, take it & run. The fact that he's hitting .285 or whatever is all the better because his .obp will always be low.

 

I still can't believe anyone throws 1st pitch fastballs to him.... don't teams have scouting reports anymore? :blink:

Luckily for us, Hermida_Rules27 hasnt been able to chime in with any "Olivo is a below average defensive catcher" nonsense to go along with Rferry's insistence that Treanor is Olivo's equal at the plate.

 

 

 

I like Matt Treanor. I actually think he's relatively clutch. But Olivo is a better overall catcher than Treanor. And that has nothing to do with the fact that he hit 2 HR's late nite.

sigh.. i knew the stat heads would say something. he's still hitting .292 with 8 dongs as a catcher who splits time and bats 8th. if you complain about that, you've got problems.

 

well maybe an unjustified comparison here...but Jason Varitek's stats are .250 BA, 7 Hrs, 36 rbi's, 30 runs and 1 SB while playing marginal defense behind the plate and Olivo is hitting . 291, 8 hrs, 29 rbi's, 21 runs and 2 sb...Tek has played in 62 games and Olivo in 55 games...funny...i dont hear anyone wanting to replace Varitek... :whistle

He is, but not by a wide margin at all. Why the need for a change?

Why even cite the difference? They're both pretty crappy in my book.

 

 

I like Olivo not only for his bat but he has a pretty good gun. I have seen him make some perfect throws to get some fast runners. I don't think we should change anything that is working as well but I think Olivo is better than he gets credit for and should be playing even more than he is. I have tried to like Treanor but he has killed a few rallies with his bat this year.

Sometimes Rferry you're almost like a troll, and I know you're not, but to continue to argue (what seems to be for argument sake) that Olivo is not doing well at the plate ignores what's happening right before your eyes.

 

Just for the heck of it, I took Olivo's numbers and compared them Paul LoDuca based on at bats. While LoDuca's OBP is four percentage points (.004) higher than Olivo, LoDuca (at almost ten times the salary) trails Olivo in average, SLG by almost 100 points, and in hits, home runs, RBIs and total bases.

 

Where LoDuca excells is strikeouts and walks but for the price differential it's no contest.

 

Your response will no doubt be, because you despised LoDuca (but then again you despise all catchers and I suspect if you could put one of those trampoline-like nets behind home plate you'd advocate for it so palpable is your underestimation of the value of the position) that he isn't a fair comparison.

 

So, anticipating your response as noted above, if you were to look at all national league catchers with at least as many ABs as Olivo you would find him fifth in the league in average, first in homeruns, fourth in RBIs and third (giving McCann his due even though he has less at bats) in SLG.

 

I think those are pretty successful numbers by any rational criteria.

c'mon man Treanor is NOT a hole. He is a solid backup catcher. He has guided our pitching staff and can throw out baserunners.

 

Who cares if he doesn't hit .300....he isn't that bad of a hitter (doesn't K much). Reggie on the other hand is NOT ready for the show!

sigh.. i knew the stat heads would say something. he's still hitting .292 with 8 dongs as a catcher who splits time and bats 8th. if you complain about that, you've got problems.

 

If you think a player with a .319 OBP is anything but a black hole in the lineup, you must be living in the dead ball era. And when it comes to black holes, they all suck. Yet some people want to give him even more starts? Last I checked you have to earn a promotion. And Olivo hasn't been blowing away his competition recently. Nor has anything about Olivo's previous history suggest he (or Treanor, mind you) will keep this up.

 

For those who want to make a change - designate Olivo the starter, shift one of the lefties to him, give him a contract extension, whatever - I ask why. What has happened to demand a change be made? Are we losing under the current system? Is it something Olivo has done? Something Treanor has not? Anything at all? It just seems your latching on too quickly too firmly to too little success.

He is a hole in the lineup. How is he not? He just hit his first homer and I remember him playing in 2004. I agree he calls a good game but I think, like Abercrombie, he is a hole in the lineup. He's not only not hitting .300 but he's pretty close to the Mendoza line so I would say he is a hole. He is not a pitcher who is not expected to hit .300, he is a position player.

He is a hole in the lineup. How is he not? He just hit his first homer and I remember him playing in 2004. I agree he calls a good game but I think, like Abercrombie, he is a hole in the lineup. He's not only not hitting .300 but he's pretty close to the Mendoza line so I would say he is a hole. He is not a pitcher who is not expected to hit .300, he is a position player.

 

Sorry about the multy post.

sigh.. i knew the stat heads would say something. he's still hitting .292 with 8 dongs as a catcher who splits time and bats 8th. if you complain about that, you've got problems.

 

If you think a player with a .319 OBP is anything but a black hole in the lineup, you must be living in the dead ball era. And when it comes to black holes, they all suck. Yet some people want to give him even more starts? Last I checked you have to earn a promotion. And Olivo hasn't been blowing away his competition recently. Nor has anything about Olivo's previous history suggest he (or Treanor, mind you) will keep this up.

 

For those who want to make a change - designate Olivo the starter, shift one of the lefties to him, give him a contract extension, whatever - I ask why. What has happened to demand a change be made? Are we losing under the current system? Is it something Olivo has done? Something Treanor has not? Anything at all? It just seems your latching on too quickly too firmly to too little success.

are you saying we shouldnt root for olivo because his past shows that his future isnt too bright? Maybe...just Maybe, Olivo is becoming the catcher everyone expected him to be when the White Sox drafted him

He is a hole in the lineup. How is he not? He just hit his first homer and I remember him playing in 2004. I agree he calls a good game but I think, like Abercrombie, he is a hole in the lineup. He's not only not hitting .300 but he's pretty close to the Mendoza line so I would say he is a hole. He is not a pitcher who is not expected to hit .300, he is a position player.

 

Sorry about the multy post.

 

Treannor he shouldnt be playing as much as he is but I think its to keep Olivo fresh or something up Giardi sleeve

Rferry: "If you think a player with a .319 OBP is anything but a black hole in the lineup, you must be living in the dead ball era."

 

Just keep holding onto the one poor stat like you do your teddy bear at night and maybe it will be comforting for you.

 

But truth be told, even in OBP, Olivo still ranks eighth (with three tied at an OBP of .323, a measley four percentage (.004) points higher, and another at .321 OBP, a scant .002 higher) among national league catchers with at least as many at bats.

 

The fact is when you compare NL catchers across the board, Olivo compares well in almost every offensive category. Tied for third in HRs, 4th in SLG, 5th in average, fifth in RBI, sixth in doubles, among catchers with near or equivalent at bats.

 

But keep throwing out that OBP number like it's the holy grail but don't be surprised when no one takes anything you post seriously.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.