Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins WC Chase

Featured Replies

the way I see it is this road trip is EXTREMELY important...we have to win 5/8 out least! 2/3 vs Atlanta, and 3/5 vs Philadelphia...preferably 4/5 but I'll take 3/5. If we can do that we can still dream wild card, if we can't do that I think we can concede it. And Atlanta will be tough this time too.

the way I see it is this road trip is EXTREMELY important...we have to win 5/8 out least! 2/3 vs Atlanta, and 3/5 vs Philadelphia...preferably 4/5 but I'll take 3/5. If we can do that we can still dream wild card, if we can't do that I think we can concede it. And Atlanta will be tough this time too.

 

:thumbup

 

Atlanta has gotten much better since the last time we played them. They'll be tough this time for sure.

6 back, 5 in the loss column. 9 teams to leapfrog.

 

However, a good week (5 of 8) conceivably means that this time next week we're ahead of both Atlanta and Philadelphia, and quite possibly Colorado as Colorado has St. Louis and San Diego.

 

Team has to get hot now and stay hot for about 2 months to make a run of this, but I'm no longer officially in the "impossible" camp.

we won't contend this year..next year we have a shot ..hopefully

 

 

Next year we have a huge chance with this pitching! We just need a few pieces like CF.

ya..and olivo needs to be resigned (he's a FA at the end of the year right)...he's played well this year and should be resigned. he doesn't HAVE to be the starter, if he doesn't perform..fine, he can be the backup, but if he is we need to have a competent starting catcher (which isn't treanor). you think we'll have some spending money this offseason? i hope so..

we won't contend this year..next year we have a shot ..hopefully

 

 

Next year we have a huge chance with this pitching! We just need a few pieces like CF.

ya..and olivo needs to be resigned (he's a FA at the end of the year right)...he's played well this year and should be resigned. he doesn't HAVE to be the starter, if he doesn't perform..fine, he can be the backup, but if he is we need to have a competent starting catcher (which isn't treanor). you think we'll have some spending money this offseason? i hope so..

 

Only resign him at league minimum. His career, which pretty much says this season is an anomoly at the plate, shows he wont be worth whatever big money he might get after this season. Plus his defense is still offensive.

 

If we can unload Borowski and Helms and get CF and C ready prospects, I'd do it. And since Olivo's value will never be higher, I'd trade him as well.

 

And as much as I like this team, I doubt it'll be a playoff contender. We have to sustain a high level of a play, while a good # of other teams would have to slip a bit for a few series. I am hopeful for this year, but wont be disappointed if we dont make it, but fully expect us to make a strong push for it next year.

 

It would also help to get some players ready to contribute from Borowski, Helms, and Herges if we can at the deadline.

Spike, ever think that he has improved? Girardi and Tuck have done a lot with Olivo this year and quite frankly, there is NO capable replacement in the Marlins system or that could be had back as cheaply as Olivo.

Obviously Girardi and Tuck havent done that much with Olivo, because he is still crap defensively.

 

And, he will be making in the $3 mil range next season...thats way to much $$ for a guy who will very likely digress into his normal self and be bad at the plate and still play crap defense.

Obviously Girardi and Tuck havent done that much with Olivo, because he is still crap defensively.

 

And, he will be making in the $3 mil range next season...thats way to much $$ for a guy who will very likely digress into his normal self and be bad at the plate and still play crap defense.

 

maybe he's just an NL hitter, or OMG a prospect who finally figured it out a little later

 

just a thought...

He isnt a prospect. He's a journeyman. Playing for 4 teams in 5 seasons will do that.

 

And the NL/AL difference wont have that much of an effect. He also put up similar #s as this year in Chicago, then went to pure crap yet again.

 

Is he really worth taking a chance on? A guy who plays bad defense and is more likely to hit poorly than good? Me thinks not, espicially for a high price tag.

He isnt a prospect. He's a journeyman. Playing for 4 teams in 5 seasons will do that.

 

And the NL/AL difference wont have that much of an effect. He also put up similar #s as this year in Chicago, then went to pure crap yet again.

 

Is he really worth taking a chance on? A guy who plays bad defense and is more likely to hit poorly than good? Me thinks not, espicially for a high price tag.

 

I really hate debating you on any point, but you've continually used this definition when referring to Olivo as a journeyman....and it's idiotic. You can call Olivo a journeyman all you want, but at least get a somewhat workable definition.

 

Andy Marte has played for 3 teams in less than a year. Journeyman?

 

Carlos Delgado has played for 3 teams in 3 years. Journeyman?

 

Armando Benitez and Todd Jones also did 3 teams in 3 years. Journeymen?

 

Hell, in his prime Mike Piazza did 3 teams in about a week.

 

Because you move around alot doesn't make you worthless. In this case of Olivo you could argue his defense and OBP make him not the greatest catcher to ever live....but he's better than the alternative (Matt Treanor) right now.

He isnt a prospect. He's a journeyman. Playing for 4 teams in 5 seasons will do that.

 

And the NL/AL difference wont have that much of an effect. He also put up similar #s as this year in Chicago, then went to pure crap yet again.

 

Is he really worth taking a chance on? A guy who plays bad defense and is more likely to hit poorly than good? Me thinks not, espicially for a high price tag.

 

who said he was a prospect? what does being a journeyman have to do with anything?

 

he has been a far superior hitter in the NL as opposed to the AL, maybe things are finally clicking

 

and why isnt he worth taking a chance on? we have no one close to him in the minors, and dollar for dollar, he is one of the better catchers out there

He isnt a prospect. He's a journeyman. Playing for 4 teams in 5 seasons will do that.

 

And the NL/AL difference wont have that much of an effect. He also put up similar #s as this year in Chicago, then went to pure crap yet again.

 

Is he really worth taking a chance on? A guy who plays bad defense and is more likely to hit poorly than good? Me thinks not, espicially for a high price tag.

 

I really hate debating you on any point, but you've continually used this definition when referring to Olivo as a journeyman....and it's idiotic. You can call Olivo a journeyman all you want, but at least get a somewhat workable definition.

 

Andy Marte has played for 3 teams in less than a year. Journeyman?

 

Carlos Delgado has played for 3 teams in 3 years. Journeyman?

 

Armando Benitez and Todd Jones also did 3 teams in 3 years. Journeymen?

 

Hell, in his prime Mike Piazza did 3 teams in about a week.

 

Because you move around alot doesn't make you worthless. In this case of Olivo you could argue his defense and OBP make him not the greatest catcher to ever live....but he's better than the alternative (Matt Treanor) right now.

 

Olivo is a guy in his mid 20's playing on his 4th team in 5 years. Who has never been good sans this stop. That makes him a journeyman.

 

 

He isnt a prospect. He's a journeyman. Playing for 4 teams in 5 seasons will do that.

 

And the NL/AL difference wont have that much of an effect. He also put up similar #s as this year in Chicago, then went to pure crap yet again.

 

Is he really worth taking a chance on? A guy who plays bad defense and is more likely to hit poorly than good? Me thinks not, espicially for a high price tag.

 

who said he was a prospect? what does being a journeyman have to do with anything?

 

he has been a far superior hitter in the NL as opposed to the AL, maybe things are finally clicking

 

and why isnt he worth taking a chance on? we have no one close to him in the minors, and dollar for dollar, he is one of the better catchers out there

You actually said he was a prospect:

maybe he's just an NL hitter, or OMG a prospect who finally figured it out a little later

 

just a thought...

 

And while he might be dollar for dollar this year. But he only makes $700K. When you consider it is very unlikely that he will hit worth a crap next season(hits decently one season, garbage for a few of the seasons after that), and will still play crap defense, will he really be worth $3 or 4 million?

He isnt a prospect. He's a journeyman. Playing for 4 teams in 5 seasons will do that.

 

And the NL/AL difference wont have that much of an effect. He also put up similar #s as this year in Chicago, then went to pure crap yet again.

 

Is he really worth taking a chance on? A guy who plays bad defense and is more likely to hit poorly than good? Me thinks not, espicially for a high price tag.

 

I really hate debating you on any point, but you've continually used this definition when referring to Olivo as a journeyman....and it's idiotic. You can call Olivo a journeyman all you want, but at least get a somewhat workable definition.

 

Andy Marte has played for 3 teams in less than a year. Journeyman?

 

Carlos Delgado has played for 3 teams in 3 years. Journeyman?

 

Armando Benitez and Todd Jones also did 3 teams in 3 years. Journeymen?

 

Hell, in his prime Mike Piazza did 3 teams in about a week.

 

Because you move around alot doesn't make you worthless. In this case of Olivo you could argue his defense and OBP make him not the greatest catcher to ever live....but he's better than the alternative (Matt Treanor) right now.

 

Olivo is a guy in his mid 20's playing on his 4th team in 5 years. Who has never been good sans this stop. That makes him a journeyman.

Wrong. His .304/.341/.487/.828 in San Diego last year says otherwise. Sure, it's a small sample size of abou 150 AB's...but he did hit there.

 

He also hit well with the Sox in 2004 before he got traded (.270/.316/.496/.812). Again there are sample size issues, but when you combine that with his numbers in SD and FLA it does look like he's got some potential to be a league average if not better (at least in the power department ) performer. I do wish he would be more patient at the plate though.

Might as well factor in his awful first half of the season in 2005.

 

And, in more ab's here than he had in San Diego, he has also digressed from the #'s he put up there, as NL pitchers have seen more of him. It is just as likely his #'s will continue to backtrack as it is that they will stay the course.

He isnt a prospect. He's a journeyman. Playing for 4 teams in 5 seasons will do that.

 

And the NL/AL difference wont have that much of an effect. He also put up similar #s as this year in Chicago, then went to pure crap yet again.

 

Is he really worth taking a chance on? A guy who plays bad defense and is more likely to hit poorly than good? Me thinks not, espicially for a high price tag.

 

I really hate debating you on any point, but you've continually used this definition when referring to Olivo as a journeyman....and it's idiotic. You can call Olivo a journeyman all you want, but at least get a somewhat workable definition.

 

Andy Marte has played for 3 teams in less than a year. Journeyman?

 

Carlos Delgado has played for 3 teams in 3 years. Journeyman?

 

Armando Benitez and Todd Jones also did 3 teams in 3 years. Journeymen?

 

Hell, in his prime Mike Piazza did 3 teams in about a week.

 

Because you move around alot doesn't make you worthless. In this case of Olivo you could argue his defense and OBP make him not the greatest catcher to ever live....but he's better than the alternative (Matt Treanor) right now.

 

Olivo is a guy in his mid 20's playing on his 4th team in 5 years. Who has never been good sans this stop. That makes him a journeyman.

 

 

He isnt a prospect. He's a journeyman. Playing for 4 teams in 5 seasons will do that.

 

And the NL/AL difference wont have that much of an effect. He also put up similar #s as this year in Chicago, then went to pure crap yet again.

 

Is he really worth taking a chance on? A guy who plays bad defense and is more likely to hit poorly than good? Me thinks not, espicially for a high price tag.

 

who said he was a prospect? what does being a journeyman have to do with anything?

 

he has been a far superior hitter in the NL as opposed to the AL, maybe things are finally clicking

 

and why isnt he worth taking a chance on? we have no one close to him in the minors, and dollar for dollar, he is one of the better catchers out there

You actually said he was a prospect:

maybe he's just an NL hitter, or OMG a prospect who finally figured it out a little later

 

just a thought...

 

And while he might be dollar for dollar this year. But he only makes $700K. When you consider it is very unlikely that he will hit worth a crap next season(hits decently one season, garbage for a few of the seasons after that), and will still play crap defense, will he really be worth $3 or 4 million?

Id rather pay him than see Matt Treanor back there for 110 games... and I meant that he was a prospect that figured it out late, not that he still is one

Might as well factor in his awful first half of the season in 2005.

 

And, in more ab's here than he had in San Diego, he has also digressed from the #'s he put up there, as NL pitchers have seen more of him. It is just as likely his #'s will continue to backtrack as it is that they will stay the course.

 

 

 

Yeah, he sucked in Seattle in the beginning of 2005 - also did in 2004. However if you're using that against him, which you should, you also have to give him the credit for performing well in the second half of 2005, the first half of 2004, and this year. You can't selectively interpret the numbers to say he sucks, just like you can't say he's the next big thing. He does judging by his numbers have the potential to hit - as some of the numbers show.

 

And I'm not so sure pitchers have "figured him out." Look at his month to month numbers from this year. Excellent April, poor may, FANTASTIC June, and subpar July. Inconsistent but not indicative of him being "figured out."

Never underestimate Spike's ability to completely ruin any discussion with his repetitious bashing of Olivo and Willingham while putting Olsen on a pedistal.

i totally agree that we can make a run but damn it get those reds to lose one

 

 

I know. I love how those nationals bull pen players have sucked for them though. That team is not going to win the wild Card whwn it's all said and done.

Don't know if this has been mentioned anywhere but with today's win our home record is now above .500 at 25-24. Baby steps... baby steps.

Obviously Girardi and Tuck havent done that much with Olivo, because he is still crap defensively.

 

And, he will be making in the $3 mil range next season...thats way to much $$ for a guy who will very likely digress into his normal self and be bad at the plate and still play crap defense.

 

 

He has improved behind the plate during the season. Early, he couldn't be relied upon the catch pitches, much less block balls. He is still below-average, but much less so than April / May. Also, his ability to throw out basestealers is impressive. I also expect him to keep hitting. Olivo is not a major hole on this team, there are only a dozen or so players that would be an upgrade out there.

 

CF is a disaster, and we will need some more bullspen stability, but otherwise this team will only be better with another year's experience. Right now, a top reliever (maybe 2) and a solid all-around CF could put this team into the playoffs.

We have a little run going here...hopefully we can win a couple more games in a row although Atlanta is playing good ball right now. It'd be interesting to see what the FO does on the deadline, if they do anything at all.

I seriously CAN NOT BELIEVE anyone is complaing about Olivo.. like Ramp said, dollar for dollar, we have ourselves a friggin bargain. And to have Girardi as his manager.. with the next 2 or so years as his defined "prime".. are you kidding me? We should be happy we have a bargain catcher who works with a manger who was a catcher, hopefully for the next 2 years. How on earth can you complain when we have nobody completely close to him in the minors? And Spike, you think you're smart by looking at Cardinal minor player stats when their name comes up in the DTrain trade.. "oh yea, bryan anderson".. dude, i watch that guy every week in davenport, he's a defensive catcher at best who splits time.. quit freakin goin by minor league stats.

 

What on earth do you want from him? He's our NUMBER 8 HITTER, 7 at best.. who is hitting .280 with a handful of bombs and is playing better than, im guessing, 75% of the catchers that make more money than him.. what on earth more do you want? Joe Mauers don't show up on your front door step everyday buddy

I seriously CAN NOT BELIEVE anyone is complaing about Olivo.. like Ramp said, dollar for dollar, we have ourselves a friggin bargain. And to have Girardi as his manager.. with the next 2 or so years as his defined "prime".. are you kidding me? We should be happy we have a bargain catcher who works with a manger who was a catcher, hopefully for the next 2 years. How on earth can you complain when we have nobody completely close to him in the minors? And Spike, you think you're smart by looking at Cardinal minor player stats when their name comes up in the DTrain trade.. "oh yea, bryan anderson".. dude, i watch that guy every week in davenport, he's a defensive catcher at best who splits time.. quit freakin goin by minor league stats.

 

What on earth do you want from him? He's our NUMBER 8 HITTER, 7 at best.. who is hitting .280 with a handful of bombs and is playing better than, im guessing, 75% of the catchers that make more money than him.. what on earth more do you want? Joe Mauers don't show up on your front door step everyday buddy

 

 

Because the Cardinals farm system isnt good at all. He's one of the few bright spots. And he is hitting well in A ball. And is ready for a promotion. Reyes has good stuff, but is injury prone and we have a ton of good to great pitchers in the organization already. Duncan is a 4th outfielder/utility man who is benefitting by hitting in front of Pujols. Rasmus has struggled since being promoted. 19 and a ways away anyway.

 

We can get alot better deals from alot of other teams.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.