December 21, 200619 yr It's three years away. No pressing need for the Marlins to look that far ahead. But if anyone from owner Jeffrey Loria to General Manager Admin Beinfest already has hit the fast forward button, they likely returned to the present in a hurry. In light of the three $100 million contracts awarded this offseason, the idea of Miguel Cabrera as a free agent is more sobering than ever. Assuming the 23-year-old Venezuelan superstar maintained his trajectory, an Albert Pujols-like seven-year, $100 million deal seemed appropriate. But with Alfonso Soriano (eight years, $136 million with the Cubs), Vernon Wells (seven years, $126 million with the Blue Jays) and Carlos Lee (seven years, $100 million with the Astros) achieving three of the top 12 packages in baseball history, Cabrera's earning potential just went from unbelievable to incomprehensible. "Is $200 million out of the realm of possibility? Not whatsoever," said Arkansas-based agent Darek Braunecker, who negotiated A.J. Burnett's five-year, $55 million deal with the Blue Jays in 2005. "If there was one guy I could have to represent over the next five years going into free agency, it would certainly be [Cabrera]because of the combination of age and talent, and being a middle-of-the-lineup run producer." The numbers certainly support that. Soriano (3,902), Wells (3,239) and Lee (4,570) all have more career at-bats than Cabrera (2,106). But project his career numbers to the three players' current at-bat totals and with few exceptions Cabrera dwarfs all three in every major offensive category. Cabrera should have more career runs, hits, doubles, RBI and walks, and a higher batting average, and on-base and slugging percentages than any of the aforementioned players at the same stage. More importantly, Cabrera will be shy of his 27th birthday when he qualifies for free agency. Lee is 30. Wells turned 28 this month. Soriano is three weeks from 31. "Part of you looks at it and says, `This is great. This is wonderful. This is phenomenal. If these guys are getting this, what will we get if the [salaries] continue to stay in line with what they've been?'" said agent Joe Urbon, who heads Octagon's baseball division and represents budding stars Jason Bay and Grady Sizemore. "Then the other part of you is like, will this be like 2000-2001 where you saw A-Rod and [Derek] Jeter and [Todd] Helton and Manny [Ramirez], and didn't see those contracts again until just now? ... You look at Albert Pujols and back then you thought, `Can you believe they gave that guy $100 million?' and now it's a heck of a bargain. It was the timing of the deal." Pujols' contract, one of 13 ever struck worth $100 million or more, bought out all three of his arbitration years. Assuming they exercise a 2011 option, the Cardinals are getting Pujols for $79 million over his first five years of free agency. Neither Beinfest nor team President David Samson would comment, but Pirates General Manager Dave Littlefield offered a front-office perspective. He's in a somewhat similar situation with Bay, who like Cabrera is eligible for free agency after 2009. "We've seen a couple of big [contracts] this offseason, but how many are done and what happens the next couple of years from now, it's tough to say in December 2006 what's going to happen in '09," Littlefield said. "We always plan, and it's important to be able to react accordingly to whatever happens in the marketplace, particularly in our situation in Pittsburgh, but it's too far away to predict what could or couldn't happen." What likely won't happen is as drastic a market correction as the industry saw after the 2000-01 mega-deals, highlighted by Alex Rodriguez's record 10-year, $252 million pact, the only one that has topped the $200 million plateau. Major League Baseball revenues will swell to more than $5 billion this year. The Internet and international markets are rapidly expanding. Through 2013, the sport is guaranteed $5 billon from the national television contract alone. Labor peace is ensured through 2011. The game has set attendance records each of the past three years, and this season's revenue sharing total reached $326 million and is expected to climb. New stadiums and new revenue streams are being forged in Washington, Minnesota and Oakland, which will enhance those franchises' ability to increase payroll. Those factors no doubt will help Cabrera, expected to make about $5 million in arbitration next season, maximize his dollars. Cabrera also needs 2007 free agents Torii Hunter and Andruw Jones to cash in ahead of him. Braunecker and Urbon said they could foresee teams balking at signing premier position players to seven- or eight-year deals. Braunecker said clubs appear willing to go higher on the average annual value (AAV) of contracts in exchange for fewer years. The same team unwilling to give Cabrera a $22 million AAV over eight years ($176 million) may deem six years and a $29 million AAV ($174 million) more palatable. "It's simply a matter of the clubs now assess risk more in terms of years than they do dollars," Braunecker said. "They don't want to be hamstrung multiple years down the road. ... "If [Cabrera] continues to show this sort of consistent production and he betters himself on that, it's really hard to say what kind of money this guy could be looking at." [/size][/font] LINK WOAH now that is a huge number.....i really can't even think that high this early in the morning but it really wouldn't surprise me!!!
December 21, 200619 yr No, he won't be the first $200 million player. A-Rod is the holder of that title. The Marlins are better off not trying to sign him long-term this offseason. Wait until next offseason or the one after that and hope that salaries go down so we can sign him for about 13-17 million per year for 10 years. Although, to be honest, he should command over $20 million per season in the open market. The fact that he put up .339/.430/.568 as a 23 year old is mind boggling. It's not out of the realm of possibility that in his walk off year he puts up something like .360/.470/.600. Is that worth 20 million per year? I think so.
December 21, 200619 yr What this means to us is that even with sellouts and a new stadium, Miguel will not be a Marlin long term, probably not even into his contract year. Oh well, that is the life of a Marlin fan.
December 21, 200619 yr He may stay with us if we get a stadium. With a brand new stadium, what would our expected payroll be? 80 million? If so, we can afford him.
December 21, 200619 yr I am delusionally holding out hope that Loria is stockpiling his revenue (if you believe David Hyde's column, they make $70 million from the league, TV deals, luxury taxes, etc) - so if they team payroll is $25 million he is keeping 30-40 million in profit last year and this year-- to deal with Cabrera's contract.
December 21, 200619 yr We need a stadium bad so we can keep this guy. Yeah cant wait for us to get a stadium lets get the deal done then sign Cabrera I really hope his price doesnt go over 200mil
December 21, 200619 yr Ugh. Well, I truly think the club is gonna hold on to Miggy through all his arby years, so we have 3 full seasons to get the a stadium deal done.
December 21, 200619 yr Part of the reason why some salaries skyrocketed was the new CBA and the number of years that were guaranteed without shutdown. Like a stock option, next season there will be one less year to factor in and that might begin to mitigate the rising prices of players. Prices may rises but more slowly as the fear of a strike or work stoppage of any sort draws potentially closer. None of the above should be taken that Miggy won't be paid a fortune when he becomes a FA because he will. But prices will not continue to jump by the % they did this off-season from last year after year. It isn't by accident that clubs like the Yankees and other big-spending teams are concentrating more on building or rebuilding their minor league systems. Even they see where this is going. More and more you're going to see Marlinsesque strip downs from bigger and bigger clubs who come to realize the spiral can't continue. I said last season I thought what the Marlins did will change the face of baseball and I believe that more today than the day I said it. It just takes time.
December 21, 200619 yr Part of the reason why some salaries skyrocketed was the new CBA and the number of years that were guaranteed without shutdown. Like a stock option, next season there will be one less year to factor in and that might begin to mitigate the rising prices of players. Prices may rises but more slowly as the fear of a strike or work stoppage of any sort draws potentially closer. None of the above should be taken that Miggy won't be paid a fortune when he becomes a FA because he will. But prices will not continue to jump by the % they did this off-season from last year after year. It isn't by accident that clubs like the Yankees and other big-spending teams are concentrating more on building or rebuilding their minor league systems. Even they see where this is going. More and more you're going to see Marlinsesque strip downs from bigger and bigger clubs who come to realize the spiral can't continue. I said last season I thought what the Marlins did will change the face of baseball and I believe that more today than the day I said it. It just takes time. Then lets wait two more seasons and resign him his last season under contract. Maybe by then the prices will start to fall. In 2001 or whatever the year was that Arod got 250 million, everyone was getting lots of money. I think that was the same season mike hampton got 100 million. In two season or so the prices will start to drop when alot of these players are not playing up to their salary.
December 21, 200619 yr What I've been reading is that prices paid this off-season were a reaction not just to the new CBA and the extended period of security but also because relatively speaking prices were being held *down* incrementally for fear of a labor disruption if there was trouble negotiating this last one. Sort of like uncoiling the slinky. * edit
December 21, 200619 yr Part of the reason why some salaries skyrocketed was the new CBA and the number of years that were guaranteed without shutdown. Like a stock option, next season there will be one less year to factor in and that might begin to mitigate the rising prices of players. Prices may rises but more slowly as the fear of a strike or work stoppage of any sort draws potentially closer. None of the above should be taken that Miggy won't be paid a fortune when he becomes a FA because he will. But prices will not continue to jump by the % they did this off-season from last year after year. It isn't by accident that clubs like the Yankees and other big-spending teams are concentrating more on building or rebuilding their minor league systems. Even they see where this is going. More and more you're going to see Marlinsesque strip downs from bigger and bigger clubs who come to realize the spiral can't continue. I said last season I thought what the Marlins did will change the face of baseball and I believe that more today than the day I said it. It just takes time. the bigger factor is that baseball made 7 billion dollars last year.
December 21, 200619 yr Just give him his money now. We're in such a viscious catch-22 here it's ridiculous. Free agents won't come here because we lack "credibility." Letting Miggy walk certainly woulnd't help that, and with or without a new stadium, no Miguel might as well be the eulogy for baseball in Miami. Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me.... The Marlins are better off not trying to sign him long-term this offseason. Wait until next offseason or the one after that and hope that salaries go down so we can sign him for about 13-17 million per year for 10 years. I agree in principle with what you're saying, but in practice it's damn near suicidal. The closer you let someone like Cabrera get to free agency, the more and more he starts "playing out the chain" until he can get that $200 million contract...there's a human factor here. Even if there will be a market correction by the offseason of '08, it may not be enough to sway him to stay.
December 21, 200619 yr Just give him his money now. We're in such a viscious catch-22 here it's ridiculous. Free agents won't come here because we lack "credibility." Letting Miggy walk certainly woulnd't help that, and with or without a new stadium, no Miguel might as well be the eulogy for baseball in Miami. Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me.... I agree. Give him his money now and be done with it. We are not going to get him any cheaper next year, or before he hits free agency. A creative deal can be put in place to buy off his arbi years (at a similar projected amount), and then add a 5-7 years at a reasonable amount (keeping in mind risk-reward). If Miguel wants to stay, he should be reasonable about it.
December 21, 200619 yr IIRC they are trying to sign him long term as we speak (as in visavis settling arbitration and winding up with a long term contract).
December 21, 200619 yr If we get a stadium we might be able to work something out. i wonder if the marlins are working something out to pay him a little more over the next three arb years and then do something like add a 4th year and 5th year? Then at age 28 let him go after whatever contract he wants if he wont stay here.
December 21, 200619 yr Part of the reason why some salaries skyrocketed was the new CBA and the number of years that were guaranteed without shutdown. Like a stock option, next season there will be one less year to factor in and that might begin to mitigate the rising prices of players. Prices may rises but more slowly as the fear of a strike or work stoppage of any sort draws potentially closer. Sure, and factor in, in 1-2 years, when all of these clubs (for example, the cubs) are not winning championships while spending a bazllion dollars on Ted Lilly, etc, they won't be as aggressive in the market. It came down after the mega Arod/Jeter deals, and it'll happen again in a season or two. This will work out perfectly for us as we hopefully have a new stadium, Volstad and company are ready 08/09 for a crazy contending squad, and the missing piece can be had for a salary lower than this off season's cost level. However, I still think it's a very good idea to sign Cabrera as soon as possible. And it's not just because he's awesome. Well, that has a lot to do with it, but it's very important for him to sign a large contract right now. I thought before the spending this off season we could get him for a 7/$95 or 8/$108 deal (or representing 98-99% of the contract Pujols signed with the Cardinals to buy out his final 3 years of arbitration), but now I'd imagine the final 3-5 seasons in a 7 year deal with a buyout have risen a bit. The arbitration won't be that effected... I'd imagine right now he's worth about $6.5, $9, $14, $18, $18.5, $20, $20, option $20 (buyout $5). That's 7/$111 or 8/$126. Which sounds about right. That's a substantial 15-20% jump from if they did this during the season which they should have done and why our policy of not buying out arbitration is phenomenally stupid, but he'd be absolutely crazy not to take that. That contract is very market competitive, he'd be a free agent around 30/31 years old, and that's the perfect age for a second mega contract to maximize his earnings potential as a player. If the Marlins hold onto him for 3 more years going year to year, he'd be a free agent at 27, then again at 33+, after a 7-8 year contract. This doesn't help his future earnings potential as teams will probably be less likely to offer a longterm crazy money deal with a player exiting his prime the last few seasons of a contract. Money right now, is worth more than money in the future. It's in his best interest to try and get a deal within the next 2 years to ensure that second huge contract and not one that's more diluted only over say, 5 years. It's not like Cabrera would become unmovable with this contract either, so even if we don't get a stadium and have to slash costs again, I'm pretty sure another team would take him. In fact, I think all of baseball would be lining up to take him. I'd even argue he becomes MORE valuable with a longterm deal because another team won't have to worry about impending free agency, ala how the Nationals got junk offers for Soriano this past season. Obviously increases Marlins credibility in the community, etc etc.. It's a win-win anyway you look at it. And I'll go further and say give Hanley a 5/$15 deal right now so you don't have to deal with him in the future. Then reassess Olsen, Anibal, JJ, and Hermida post 2007 and see if any of them turn into core-core players. No one else on the squad needs buyout deals. Just those 2 right now. Dontrelle is lost at this point. Not worth it to give him a contract with the pitching depth coming up and sky rocketing salaries.
December 21, 200619 yr Part of the reason why some salaries skyrocketed was the new CBA and the number of years that were guaranteed without shutdown. Like a stock option, next season there will be one less year to factor in and that might begin to mitigate the rising prices of players. Prices may rises but more slowly as the fear of a strike or work stoppage of any sort draws potentially closer. Sure, and factor in, in 1-2 years, when all of these clubs (for example, the cubs) are not winning championships while spending a bazllion dollars on Ted Lilly, etc, they won't be as aggressive in the market. It came down after the mega Arod/Jeter deals, and it'll happen again in a season or two. This will work out perfectly for us as we hopefully have a new stadium, Volstad and company are ready 08/09 for a crazy contending squad, and the missing piece can be had for a salary lower than this off season's cost level. However, I still think it's a very good idea to sign Cabrera as soon as possible. And it's not just because he's awesome. Well, that has a lot to do with it, but it's very important for him to sign a large contract right now. I thought before the spending this off season we could get him for a 7/$95 or 8/$108 deal (or representing 98-99% of the contract Pujols signed with the Cardinals to buy out his final 3 years of arbitration), but now I'd imagine the final 3-5 seasons in a 7 year deal with a buyout have risen a bit. The arbitration won't be that effected... I'd imagine right now he's worth about $6.5, $9, $14, $18, $18.5, $20, $20, option $20 (buyout $5). That's 7/$110 or 8/$128. Which sounds about right. That's a substantial 15-20% jump from if they did this during the season which they should have done and why our policy of not buying out arbitration is phenomenally stupid, but he'd be absolutely crazy not to take that. That contract is very market competitive, he'd be a free agent around 30/31 years old, and that's the perfect age for a second mega contract to maximize his earnings potential as a player. If the Marlins hold onto him for 3 more years going year to year, he'd be a free agent at 27, then again at 33+, after a 7-8 year contract. This doesn't help his future earnings potential as teams will probably be less likely to offer a longterm crazy money deal with a player exiting his prime the last few seasons of a contract. Money right now, is worth more than money in the future. It's in his best interest to try and get a deal within the next 2 years to ensure that second huge contract and not one that's more diluted only over say, 5 years. It's not like Cabrera would become unmovable with this contract either, so even if we don't get a stadium and have to slash costs again, I'm pretty sure another team would take him. In fact, I think all of baseball would be lining up to take him. I'd even argue he becomes MORE valuable with a longterm deal because another team won't have to worry about impending free agency, ala how the Nationals got junk offers for Soriano this past season. Obviously increases Marlins credibility in the community, etc etc.. It's a win-win anyway you look at it. And I'll go further and say give Hanley a 5/$15 deal right now so you don't have to deal with him in the future. Then reassess Olsen, Anibal, JJ, and Hermida post 2007 and see if any of them turn into core-core players. No one else on the squad needs buyout deals. Just those 2 right now. Dontrelle is lost at this point. Not worth it to give him a contract with the pitching depth coming up and sky rocketing salaries. Right on the money. Specialy this line "I'd even argue he becomes MORE valuable with a longterm deal"
December 21, 200619 yr Part of the reason why some salaries skyrocketed was the new CBA and the number of years that were guaranteed without shutdown. Like a stock option, next season there will be one less year to factor in and that might begin to mitigate the rising prices of players. Prices may rises but more slowly as the fear of a strike or work stoppage of any sort draws potentially closer. Sure, and factor in, in 1-2 years, when all of these clubs (for example, the cubs) are not winning championships while spending a bazllion dollars on Ted Lilly, etc, they won't be as aggressive in the market. It came down after the mega Arod/Jeter deals, and it'll happen again in a season or two. This will work out perfectly for us as we hopefully have a new stadium, Volstad and company are ready 08/09 for a crazy contending squad, and the missing piece can be had for a salary lower than this off season's cost level. However, I still think it's a very good idea to sign Cabrera as soon as possible. And it's not just because he's awesome. Well, that has a lot to do with it, but it's very important for him to sign a large contract right now. I thought before the spending this off season we could get him for a 7/$95 or 8/$108 deal (or representing 98-99% of the contract Pujols signed with the Cardinals to buy out his final 3 years of arbitration), but now I'd imagine the final 3-5 seasons in a 7 year deal with a buyout have risen a bit. The arbitration won't be that effected... I'd imagine right now he's worth about $6.5, $9, $14, $18, $18.5, $20, $20, option $20 (buyout $5). That's 7/$111 or 8/$126. Which sounds about right. That's a substantial 15-20% jump from if they did this during the season which they should have done and why our policy of not buying out arbitration is phenomenally stupid, but he'd be absolutely crazy not to take that. That contract is very market competitive, he'd be a free agent around 30/31 years old, and that's the perfect age for a second mega contract to maximize his earnings potential as a player. If the Marlins hold onto him for 3 more years going year to year, he'd be a free agent at 27, then again at 33+, after a 7-8 year contract. This doesn't help his future earnings potential as teams will probably be less likely to offer a longterm crazy money deal with a player exiting his prime the last few seasons of a contract. Money right now, is worth more than money in the future. It's in his best interest to try and get a deal within the next 2 years to ensure that second huge contract and not one that's more diluted only over say, 5 years. It's not like Cabrera would become unmovable with this contract either, so even if we don't get a stadium and have to slash costs again, I'm pretty sure another team would take him. In fact, I think all of baseball would be lining up to take him. I'd even argue he becomes MORE valuable with a longterm deal because another team won't have to worry about impending free agency, ala how the Nationals got junk offers for Soriano this past season. Obviously increases Marlins credibility in the community, etc etc.. It's a win-win anyway you look at it. And I'll go further and say give Hanley a 5/$15 deal right now so you don't have to deal with him in the future. Then reassess Olsen, Anibal, JJ, and Hermida post 2007 and see if any of them turn into core-core players. No one else on the squad needs buyout deals. Just those 2 right now. Dontrelle is lost at this point. Not worth it to give him a contract with the pitching depth coming up and sky rocketing salaries. I do really wonder if Cabrera is looking more to just play out his time on the Marlins and cash in once he hits free agency at this point rather than sign any type of long term deal with us. Probably not yet, but as time goes on and free agency gets closer and closer the likelihood of that being the case increases (as does the money he would be asking for). The 7/$111 or 8/$126 seems a little conservative on what it would take to take to sign Miguel. I'd say the Marlins would have tack on an extra $10-15 milllion for a 7 year deal and an extra $15-$20 million for an 8 year deal. He should be locked up now though, that is certain. As far as Hanley goes, a 5/$15 deal would be nice. But as far as I know, he is a Boras client and I couldn't see Boras advising him to sign such a cheap contract coming off one of the best rookie campaigns in baseball history. Something like 6/$25 seems like it would be more workable.
December 21, 200619 yr How much should cabrera be getting the next three seasons? If he went to arbitration for the next three seasons I could see something like $7-8 million, $10-11 million, $14-15 million happening.
December 21, 200619 yr How much will cabrera be getting the next three seasons? Probably this: 2007 - $6 million; 2008 - $9 million; 2009 - $12 million.
December 21, 200619 yr How much should cabrera be getting the next three seasons? If he went to arbitration for the next three seasons I could see something like $7-8 million, $10-11 million, $14-15 million happening. I wonder if we offered 10, 14, 15 and then add a 4th year at 16 if he would take that? 4 years at 55 mil? Basically add 2-3 million over what he would get in arbitration for the next three years. Then its basically a one year deal for 16 million or something like that. I wonder if that would work.
December 21, 200619 yr I do really wonder if Cabrera is looking more to just play out his time on the Marlins and cash in once he hits free agency at this point rather han sign any type of long term deal with us. Probably not yet, but as time goes on and free agency gets closer and closer the likelihood of that being the case increases (as does the money he would be asking for). The 7/$111 or 8/$126 seems a little conservative on what it would take to take to sign Miguel. I'd say the Marlins would have tack on an extra $10-15 milllion for a 7 year deal and an extra $15-$20 million for an 8 year deal. He should be locked up now though, that is certain. As far as Hanley goes, a 5/$15 deal would be nice. But as far as I know, he is a Boras client and I couldn't see Boras advising him to sign such a cheap contract coming off one of the best rookie campaigns in baseball history. Something like 6/$25 seems like it would be more workable. I'm going to have to disagree with everything except, as each season passes, Cabrera commands a higher salary. That's just obvious though as he sheds arbitration years. Jimmy Rollins made about $14.25 million years 2-6 in the league. Jose Reyes, $13 million first six. $15 represents a higher total than Crosby and Peralta's buyouts, which are the two most recent contracts. $15 is an extremely generous offer, let alone asking him to eat a year of free agency where he could get a huge guaranteed contract sooner, which is what Mr. Boras will want. Besides, he'd be pretty pumped up to put, "largest arbitration buyout for a SS in baseball history" on his resume. If they wait till next off season, or even two, starting to look into free agency years might make sense, but it doesn't right now. Maybe $15 is to low, but $16? $17? Just because of his crazy rookie year? But really, that's it. And it's totally worth it because if he starts slamming 20-25 HR a year, or god willingly more, we've saved literally $5-10 million on his deal over years 3-5. Cabrera has very little room for payroll growth the next 3 seasons, and I say that in relation to approaching the $16-20 payroll threshold he would get annually on the open market right now. Big Teix and Pujols getting their buyouts is a very strong argument for the Marlins, and they won't have to jump high until year 6 of arbitration. Cabrera is worth $15-16 in present money over the next two seasons, and approx $30 million until free agency. Maybe $32-33 if spending stays bonkers next two off seasons as well, which as me and 03 were musing earlier in this thread, we both doubt happens. Taking on 4 additional years at $76-77 million, seems pretty solid with a substantial buyout and huge option. It's not going to cost the extra $10-20 you suggest. Everyone thought Wells was going to turn his deal down, and wait for a $150 next off season, but greater minds prevailed and they made the right decision. If anything, I think I'm overvaluing Cabrera at $5-10 over 7-8 seasons, and we could probably get him slightly cheaper with annual $17-19 salaries years 4-7, with especially not going all the way to $20 on the final two years and the option. There is absolutely no way with 3 arbitration years left in him, he is worth 7/$121 or 8/$146, which represents your low and high suggestion. No way.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.