Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Updated: Vick Sentenced to 23 Months

Featured Replies

As a person who's tepidly interested in the NFL, I find it outrageous that Pacman would have the book thrown at him without any advancement (at the time) of any charges, yet Vick's indicted and the process is going to be allowed to play out.

 

What a joke.

As a person who's tepidly interested in the NFL, I find it outrageous that Pacman would have the book thrown at him without any advancement (at the time) of any charges, yet Vick's indicted and the process is going to be allowed to play out.

 

What a joke.

Agreed.

 

Goodell did a dangerous thing giving Pacman the boot for the year, and I don't see how it's fair that Vick gets to let the legal system play out.

As a person who's tepidly interested in the NFL, I find it outrageous that Pacman would have the book thrown at him without any advancement (at the time) of any charges, yet Vick's indicted and the process is going to be allowed to play out.

 

What a joke.

Agreed.

 

Goodell did a dangerous thing giving Pacman the boot for the year, and I don't see how it's fair that Vick gets to let the legal system play out.

 

Vick moves more merchandise.

 

Not saying its fair, just the way of the world.

  • Author

As a person who's tepidly interested in the NFL, I find it outrageous that Pacman would have the book thrown at him without any advancement (at the time) of any charges, yet Vick's indicted and the process is going to be allowed to play out.

 

What a joke.

It just happened yesterday, lets see what happens first.

 

For a while it seemed as if his hands were clean of all this.

  • Author

not arguing with you, but vick has the herpes thing

You have your facts mixed up, that was Ron Mexico.

 

:mischief

Goodell did a dangerous thing giving Pacman the boot for the year, and I don't see how it's fair that Vick gets to let the legal system play out.

Look at the Bears and Tank Johnson. The guy was released because of a speeding ticket.

 

The NFL's most glarring weakness is their fine/punishment system.

 

Of course, the other side of the coin is that a grand jury indictment doesn't mean anything more than that the DA has enough evidence to pursue a case. Clearly, this does not mean Vick is certainly guilty. Also, the charge is a CONSPIRACY to host dog fights. That tells me that the evidence is shaky at best. If they had stronger evidence, they would have a stronger charge than a conspiracy charge.

 

He's probably guilty as heck but it's not what you know, it's what you can prove.

  • Author

I'm no legal expert and I don't have definitive knowledge of this, but I'd be pretty surprised if the feds only had 'shaky evidence' to go ahead and indict him.

 

There is a reason so few people get off free in federal cases.

Goodell did a dangerous thing giving Pacman the boot for the year, and I don't see how it's fair that Vick gets to let the legal system play out.

Look at the Bears and Tank Johnson. The guy was released because of a speeding ticket.

 

The NFL's most glarring weakness is their fine/punishment system.

 

Of course, the other side of the coin is that a grand jury indictment doesn't mean anything more than that the DA has enough evidence to pursue a case. Clearly, this does not mean Vick is certainly guilty. Also, the charge is a CONSPIRACY to host dog fights. That tells me that the evidence is shaky at best. If they had stronger evidence, they would have a stronger charge than a conspiracy charge.

 

He's probably guilty as heck but it's not what you know, it's what you can prove.

 

95% of all fed cases get convictions. so he's probably getting busted. these people don't mess around.

 

side note to any rockie fans here: you are so lucky you didn't pick this loser up. drafted 30th round in 2000 by the rockies.

As a person who's tepidly interested in the NFL, I find it outrageous that Pacman would have the book thrown at him without any advancement (at the time) of any charges, yet Vick's indicted and the process is going to be allowed to play out.

 

What a joke.

Agreed.

 

Goodell did a dangerous thing giving Pacman the boot for the year, and I don't see how it's fair that Vick gets to let the legal system play out.

 

 

PacMan had 10 prior incidents. The "make it rain" incident was just the final straw.

 

Vick hasnt been convicted yet. While I think he should get a game or two because it appears he was semi involved, you cant suspend him for the entire season until the trail is heard. If at that point he is found guilty, then you can suspend him after. It will look worse to suspend an innocent man, than to let him play this season then sit him out next season.

95% of all fed cases get convictions. so he's probably getting busted. these people don't mess around.

Hence the lesser charge. Lesser charge = easier conviction. We'll see what shakes out but this will probably take 8 months to over a year.

Goodell did a dangerous thing giving Pacman the boot for the year, and I don't see how it's fair that Vick gets to let the legal system play out.

Look at the Bears and Tank Johnson. The guy was released because of a speeding ticket.

 

The NFL's most glarring weakness is their fine/punishment system.

 

Of course, the other side of the coin is that a grand jury indictment doesn't mean anything more than that the DA has enough evidence to pursue a case. Clearly, this does not mean Vick is certainly guilty. Also, the charge is a CONSPIRACY to host dog fights. That tells me that the evidence is shaky at best. If they had stronger evidence, they would have a stronger charge than a conspiracy charge.

 

He's probably guilty as heck but it's not what you know, it's what you can prove.

 

95% of all fed cases get convictions. so he's probably getting busted. these people don't mess around.

 

side note to any rockie fans here: you are so lucky you didn't pick this loser up. drafted 30th round in 2000 by the rockies.

 

where did you get that number? I'm curious for something completely unrelated.

Goodell did a dangerous thing giving Pacman the boot for the year, and I don't see how it's fair that Vick gets to let the legal system play out.

Look at the Bears and Tank Johnson. The guy was released because of a speeding ticket.

 

The NFL's most glarring weakness is their fine/punishment system.

 

Of course, the other side of the coin is that a grand jury indictment doesn't mean anything more than that the DA has enough evidence to pursue a case. Clearly, this does not mean Vick is certainly guilty. Also, the charge is a CONSPIRACY to host dog fights. That tells me that the evidence is shaky at best. If they had stronger evidence, they would have a stronger charge than a conspiracy charge.

 

He's probably guilty as heck but it's not what you know, it's what you can prove.

 

95% of all fed cases get convictions. so he's probably getting busted. these people don't mess around.

 

side note to any rockie fans here: you are so lucky you didn't pick this loser up. drafted 30th round in 2000 by the rockies.

 

where did you get that number? I'm curious for something completely unrelated.

 

cowherd said it during the show.

cowherd said it during the show.

He does tend to exagerate a tad. :mischief

 

Update: 95% of federal criminal defendants work out a plead deal or plead guilty. Only 9 in 10 are convicted. So see? There's a 10% chance Vick will be found completely innocent.

 

Weak source: http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburgh...n/s_464095.html

 

A slightly better source and quote: http://www.hmichaelsteinberg.com/federalcrimes.htm

What are the chances for a "Not Guilty" verdict if a federally charged criminal defendant takes the case to trial?

Statistically not very good. Currently federal prosecutors tout above a 95% conviction rate. This is primarily due to the fact that most cases never make it to trial. Most defendants end up taking a plea bargain rather then risk a potentially much greater prison sentence which could be dealt them if they actual went to trial and lost. Another factor is the empowerment and impunity given to both investigating authorities and prosecutors, along with an interesting trial maneuver called "Jury Instructions". Jury instructions are basically parameters that the judge provides the jury which can greatly affect the outcome of a verdict.

As a person who's tepidly interested in the NFL, I find it outrageous that Pacman would have the book thrown at him without any advancement (at the time) of any charges, yet Vick's indicted and the process is going to be allowed to play out.

 

What a joke.

Agreed.

 

Goodell did a dangerous thing giving Pacman the boot for the year, and I don't see how it's fair that Vick gets to let the legal system play out.

 

 

PacMan had 10 prior incidents. The "make it rain" incident was just the final straw.

 

Vick hasnt been convicted yet. While I think he should get a game or two because it appears he was semi involved, you cant suspend him for the entire season until the trail is heard. If at that point he is found guilty, then you can suspend him after. It will look worse to suspend an innocent man, than to let him play this season then sit him out next season.

 

according to goodell's policy and its use thus far, you can and should suspend vick for the entire season regardless of whether or not the trial has taken place. sure, it will look bad if vick is found not guilty, but what if pacman is found not guilty on his charges?

 

goodell made this policy, now he has to enforce it equally across the board regardless of who is the player involved

As a person who's tepidly interested in the NFL, I find it outrageous that Pacman would have the book thrown at him without any advancement (at the time) of any charges, yet Vick's indicted and the process is going to be allowed to play out.

 

What a joke.

Agreed.

 

Goodell did a dangerous thing giving Pacman the boot for the year, and I don't see how it's fair that Vick gets to let the legal system play out.

 

 

PacMan had 10 prior incidents. The "make it rain" incident was just the final straw.

 

Vick hasnt been convicted yet. While I think he should get a game or two because it appears he was semi involved, you cant suspend him for the entire season until the trail is heard. If at that point he is found guilty, then you can suspend him after. It will look worse to suspend an innocent man, than to let him play this season then sit him out next season.

 

according to goodell's policy and its use thus far, you can and should suspend vick for the entire season regardless of whether or not the trial has taken place. sure, it will look bad if vick is found not guilty, but what if pacman is found not guilty on his charges?

 

goodell made this policy, now he has to enforce it equally across the board regardless of who is the player involved

 

Well the difference is that pacman had been picked up or arrested 10 times since he has been in the NFL. People actually saw him "make it rain" at the strip club, and people saw one of his men kill a bouncer. So atleast their are witnesses that saw that he was a part (I dont know how larger) of the incident. If he hadnt already had 9 other altercations with the police, he may not be banned for the season.

 

The vick situation is up in the air. A few weeks ago it appeared like he was not going to be charged with anything because his involvement was unclear. I think as punishment he will see a a few games suspension. However, not until he is found guilty will we see him miss the entire season.

Wow if it's true Vick did to dogs what he's been accused, Vick is completely screwed. The animal right groups are going to come after Vick hard, and when they do, Vick will never play in the NFL again.

Having thought about this a little, Goodell's primary responsibility here is to make the right decision and a fair decision. We can argue as to what the right and fair decision is. This responsibility supercedes whatever responsibility we think he has to be consistent. In other words, better to be right than consistent. So, we can argue back and forth about whether the Pacman decision was just. For the record, I believe it was. But I don't think too many people would make the argument that--based on what we know right now--Vick deserves to be suspended for a year before receiving a trial. If Goodell made a mistake with Pacman, he shouldn't then make the same mistake with Vick.

 

I've been avoiding the details of this case just because the whole thing sickens me. But I caught some of it on my drive home listening to Lebatard's show. Drowning and electrocuting dogs that wouldn't fight? Throwing a dog on the ground until it died? I mean, that's a sickening lack of humanity. I don't know what Vick's hand in all of this is, but if he's even indirectly responsible, I would think a year-long suspension would be the least of his worries if found guilty. He could be facing a much longer prison sentence and possibly the end of his career. In any case, he is no longer a marketable athlete, and even without a conviction here, he's losing millions upon millions of dollars. And he's already become one of the most shamed and hated athletes of our time. He'll be paying a big price no matter what happens from here on out.

I've been avoiding the details of this case just because the whole thing sickens me. But I caught some of it on my drive home listening to Lebatard's show. Drowning and electrocuting dogs that wouldn't fight? Throwing a dog on the ground until it died? I mean, that's a sickening lack of humanity.

 

That is absolutely disgusting and shameful.

I've been avoiding the details of this case just because the whole thing sickens me. But I caught some of it on my drive home listening to Lebatard's show. Drowning and electrocuting dogs that wouldn't fight? Throwing a dog on the ground until it died? I mean, that's a sickening lack of humanity.

 

That is absolutely disgusting and shameful.

 

Its all of the above, however lets just make sure it was Vick doing this before we call for his head.

 

I am sure vick is guilty of something, but I want to wait and see if he took part in killin the animals.

if hes guilty of anything with dogfighting, then he took part in killing the animals

Vick may be asked to take a paid leave of absence from the team.

 

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=2943276

 

Honestly, that's probably the best scenario until the legal process can play its way out. On Boog Sciambi's radio show, he had on a radio host from Atlanta who says there are already Falcons season ticket holders petitioning to have him off the team and have considered standing with their dogs in front of Falcons training camp in protest.

Vick may be asked to take a paid leave of absence from the team.

 

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=2943276

 

Honestly, that's probably the best scenario until the legal process can play its way out. On Boog Sciambi's radio show, he had on a radio host from Atlanta who says there are already Falcons season ticket holders petitioning to have him off the team and have considered standing with their dogs in front of Falcons training camp in protest.

 

 

That can mean like 10 fans. I am sure most of them want vick to play because their team will be terrible without him.

if hes guilty of anything with dogfighting, then he took part in killing the animals

 

Thats not true. He could have just owned the property and bet on the fights. That doesnt mean he literally killed the dogs with his bare hands, that could have been the other three men.

Vick may be asked to take a paid leave of absence from the team.

 

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=2943276

 

Honestly, that's probably the best scenario until the legal process can play its way out. On Boog Sciambi's radio show, he had on a radio host from Atlanta who says there are already Falcons season ticket holders petitioning to have him off the team and have considered standing with their dogs in front of Falcons training camp in protest.

 

 

That can mean like 10 fans. I am sure most of them want vick to play because their team will be terrible without him.

 

And they're a mediocre team with him. I mean it's not like they're going to the Super Bowl if he's on the team this year. Letting him stay on the team is a PR nightmare for the organization. Nike has already stopped production on his shoe, and I'm sure more endorsers will do the same. No one right now wants to get anywhere near this guy and I think that goes for the organization too. It's in Vick's best interest to take the leave of absence. It lets him focus on his trial, lets his team go about their business without having to deal with his mess, and doesn't penalize him with a formal suspension or revoke his paycheck (what's really matters 99% of the time for any athlete). The only thing a leave of absence hurts is Vick's marketability, but I mean I think that's pretty much shot whether he comes out of this innocent or guilty. As for the team, do you think they're willing to go through all the offseason crap that accompanies having Vick on their team to go from a 4-6 win season (where they probably are without Vick) to a 7-8 win season (where they are with him)?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.