August 2, 200719 yr Cantonized: The List 1-50 1. Brett Favre 2. Tom Brady 3. Peyton Manning 4. Admin Allen 5. Ray Lewis 6. Richard Seymour 7. Jonathan Ogden 8. Marvin Harrison 9. LaDainian Tomlinson 10. Adam Vinatieri 11. Brian Urlacher 12. Orlando Pace 13. Michael Strahan 14. Junior Seau 15. Tony Gonzalez 16. Dwight Freeney 17. Champ Bailey 18. Derrick Brooks 19. Warren Sapp 20. Torry Holt 21. Shawne Merriman 22. John Lynch 23. Alan Faneca 24. Steve Hutchinson 25. Brian Dawkins 26. Walter Jones 27. Jason Taylor 28. Shaun Alexander 29. Julius Peppers 30. Antonio Gates 31. Troy Polamalu 32. Randy Moss 33. Ed Reed 34. Reggie Bush 35. Ty Law 36. Terrell Owens 37. Edgerrin James 38. Carson Palmer 39. Vince Young 40. Calvin Johnson 41. Matt Leinart 42. Rod Smith 43. Hines Ward 44. Chad Johnson 45. Lofa Tatupu 46. DeMarcus Ware 47. Admin Johnson 48. Steven Jackson 49. A.J. Hawk 50. Adrian Peterson Yeah, i don't think you can say the bolded guys are anywhere near of the Hall of fame yet.
August 2, 200719 yr Cantonized: The List 1-50 1. Brett Favre 2. Tom Brady 3. Peyton Manning 4. Admin Allen 5. Ray Lewis 6. Richard Seymour 7. Jonathan Ogden 8. Marvin Harrison 9. LaDainian Tomlinson 10. Adam Vinatieri 11. Brian Urlacher 12. Orlando Pace 13. Michael Strahan 14. Junior Seau 15. Tony Gonzalez 16. Dwight Freeney 17. Champ Bailey 18. Derrick Brooks 19. Warren Sapp 20. Torry Holt 21. Shawne Merriman 22. John Lynch 23. Alan Faneca 24. Steve Hutchinson 25. Brian Dawkins 26. Walter Jones 27. Jason Taylor 28. Shaun Alexander 29. Julius Peppers 30. Antonio Gates 31. Troy Polamalu 32. Randy Moss 33. Ed Reed 34. Reggie Bush 35. Ty Law 36. Terrell Owens 37. Edgerrin James 38. Carson Palmer 39. Vince Young 40. Calvin Johnson 41. Matt Leinart 42. Rod Smith 43. Hines Ward 44. Chad Johnson 45. Lofa Tatupu 46. DeMarcus Ware 47. Admin Johnson 48. Steven Jackson 49. A.J. Hawk 50. Adrian Peterson Yeah, i don't think you can say the bolded guys are anywhere near of the Hall of fame yet. Added in some edits....
August 2, 200719 yr Where the hell is Zach Thomas?!? How can you have rookies who have yet to take a snap and 2nd year players who haven't even sniffed being a top-15 player for their position in over a guy like Zach Thomas?
August 2, 200719 yr Not that list means anything, but leaving Zach Thomas off is an outrage. The fact that Jason Taylor is listed behind Merriman is a joke too.
August 2, 200719 yr taylor over thomas is laughable Um no, more like the rookies WHO HAVE NEVER PLAYED A SNAP over Thomas is laughable.
August 2, 200719 yr ESPN gets so bored when only baseball is on. Between "Who's Now?" and this list, I wish they offered ala carte cable TV. Thank God for ESPNews.
August 2, 200719 yr ESPN gets so bored when only baseball is on. Between "Who's Now?" and this list, I wish they offered ala carte cable TV. Thank God for ESPNews. Be careful what you wish for. ESPN is the only sports channel thats any good.
August 2, 200719 yr ESPN gets so bored when only baseball is on. Between "Who's Now?" and this list, I wish they offered ala carte cable TV. Thank God for ESPNews. Be careful what you wish for. ESPN is the only sports channel thats any good. I disagree with the notion that ESPN is even almost good
August 2, 200719 yr ESPN gets so bored when only baseball is on. Between "Who's Now?" and this list, I wish they offered ala carte cable TV. Thank God for ESPNews. Be careful what you wish for. ESPN is the only sports channel thats any good. I disagree with the notion that ESPN is even almost good Name a better sports channel than the ESPN family of networks
August 2, 200719 yr ESPN gets so bored when only baseball is on. Between "Who's Now?" and this list, I wish they offered ala carte cable TV. Thank God for ESPNews. Be careful what you wish for. ESPN is the only sports channel thats any good. I disagree with the notion that ESPN is even almost good Name a better sports channel than the ESPN family of networks Just cause there isnt better doesnt mean it isnt bad. Not to have Zach on the list and to have JT so low is an insult. ESPN seriously has no credibility in my book. Not just of this but because of everything these people stand for and do. I only watch if a game is on or to see highlights. Everything else ESPN has is pure crap.
August 2, 200719 yr Walter Jones at 26??? He's only the greatest left tackle of all time!! Ehh. I think Johnathan Ogden was better in his prime. Richard Seymour, Dwight Freeney and Adam Vinatari are way too high, IMO. And holy sh*t at Lofa Tatupu, Matt Lienart, Vince Young, A.J. Hawk, Calvin Johnson and Adrian Peterson being on that list. And, I say again, where the hell is Zach Thomas?
August 2, 200719 yr Boog is absolutely going nuts on 790 right now. He seriously thinks that whoever made this list just somehow completely forgot about Zach Thomas, because apparently he wasn't even on the bubble to make the top 50. I'm getting so tired of ESPN its not even funny, just report the sports and show the highlights. This past month has been a joke for their station. First it was leading off SportsCenter with Paris Hilton being thrown back in jail, then its the stupidity of the "Who's Now?" and now quite possibly the most idiotic list of all time with this crap. ESPN is going "Hollywood" and it sucks.
August 2, 200719 yr ESPN gets so bored when only baseball is on. Between "Who's Now?" and this list, I wish they offered ala carte cable TV. Thank God for ESPNews. Be careful what you wish for. ESPN is the only sports channel thats any good. I disagree with the notion that ESPN is even almost good Name a better sports channel than the ESPN family of networks Just cause there isnt better doesnt mean it isnt bad.
August 2, 200719 yr I'm getting so tired of ESPN its not even funny, just report the sports and show the highlights. This past month has been a joke for their station. First it was leading off SportsCenter with Paris Hilton being thrown back in jail, then its the stupidity of the "Who's Now?" and now quite possibly the most idiotic list of all time with this crap. ESPN is going "Hollywood" and it sucks. me too. espn is more focused on their celebrity stories and other junk that the sports actually is put behind. i didn't watch espn for stories about hilton, if i wanted that, i would watch extra or another gossip show. we have enough of those shows already. i turned off espn years ago expect for ath, pti and games (sometimes sc if they have something really interesting). and btw, why is the roider merriman on the list? he cheated and failed a drug test (something bonds has yet to do).
August 2, 200719 yr 1. Brett Favre - Yes 2. Tom Brady - Yes 3. Peyton Manning - Yes 4. Admin Allen - Yes 5. Ray Lewis - Yes 6. Richard Seymour - Most likely 7. Jonathan Ogden - Yes 8. Marvin Harrison - Yes 9. LaDainian Tomlinson - Maybe 10. Adam Vinatieri - No, No kicker (pure kicker) has ever gone in 11. Brian Urlacher - Maybe 12. Orlando Pace - Yes 13. Michael Strahan - Yes 14. Junior Seau - Yes 15. Tony Gonzalez - Maybe 16. Dwight Freeney -No 17. Champ Bailey - Maybe 18. Derrick Brooks - Yes 19. Warren Sapp - Yes 20. Torry Holt - Maybe 21. Shawne Merriman - No 22. John Lynch - No 23. Alan Faneca - Maybe 24. Steve Hutchinson - No 25. Brian Dawkins - No 26. Walter Jones - Maybe 27. Jason Taylor - Yes 28. Shaun Alexander - No 29. Julius Peppers - Maybe 30. Antonio Gates - Maybe 31. Troy Polamalu - No 32. Randy Moss - Maybe 33. Ed Reed - Maybe 34. Reggie Bush - Not even deserving a response 35. Ty Law - No 36. Terrell Owens - Maybe 37. Edgerrin James - No 38. Carson Palmer - Maybe 39. Vince Young - Not even deserving a response 40. Calvin Johnson - No 41. Matt Leinart - Not even deserving a response 42. Rod Smith - Maybe 43. Hines Ward - Maybe 44. Chad Johnson - No 45. Lofa Tatupu - No 46. DeMarcus Ware - No 47. Admin Johnson - Maybe 48. Steven Jackson - Maybe 49. A.J. Hawk - Not even deserving a response 50. Adrian Peterson - Not even deserving a response Zach Thomas isnt on that list is pretty amusing
August 2, 200719 yr Walter Jones at 26??? He's only the greatest left tackle of all time!! No he is not, not even close
August 2, 200719 yr It's a list of predictions, not the 50 players right this second and their order of HOF eligibility. Plus, they devised a points system to go with it.
August 2, 200719 yr It's a list of predictions, not the 50 players right this second and their order of HOF eligibility. Plus, they devised a points system to go with it. No wayy man, this list is stupid and ESPN is teh suck!!!!!!11
August 2, 200719 yr :lol I love how they even put this in their own article: Before you post a snarky comment at the bottom of this page ? understand that these are predictions. Very few active players would be locks for the Hall of Fame if they retired today. That leaves the door open to interpretation on who else will fill the field of 50 -- even a couple players who have yet to take a regular-season snap. They were certaintly on point.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.