Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

State of 1B

Featured Replies

I've seen enough of Jacobs. Move Willingham to first, go out and get a left fielder next year. Trade Jacobs for some prospect.

and I can't believe I am actually "going to bat" for Jake here but... 700 at bats and you're ready to move from Jake?

 

if we have a legit LF come in, then by all means... but until Barry or Moises or Carlos Lee come through the door, there is no one he is blocking anyway

 

(unless Brett Carroll is for real.... which seems like a long shot)

 

Trust me, I'd like to see what Jacobs can do...

 

But if we are looking to WIN next season, we don't have the time to wait around. Sign a legit LFer, trade out Jacobs. If he succeeds somewhere else, good for him, we'll kick ourselves then. But we can't be patient if winning is our goal.

If Alou's club option isn't picked up (Doubtful with all the youth in the OF the Mets have), I could see him coming here.

 

He wouldn't be that expensive, actually when you consider his production with the bat he's a bargain.

 

His knees are another story though. And that's the snag. It doesn't look like he'll play 100+ games in a season again.

 

Really, Alou needs to be a DH. Twins or another small market AL team should jump all over him.

I wonder how Barry Bonds would do at 1B. I'm sure he wouldnt want to do it, but it's an interesting thought to me regardless.

If the Marlins sign Bonds is very likely I stop being a Marlins fan.

 

Dont need scum like that on the Fish.

 

 

 

Don't let the door hit ya in the a**.

 

 

 

 

Anyways, I agree with Swift to an extent. Yeah, move Hammer to 1B, make a big signing in the offseason for LF. As far as printing playoff tickets.........thats a big stretch.

 

JJ is out practically forever, Olsen is Olsen and we don't know how Willis is going to look after the inevitable offseason wind up overhaul. And those are just SOME of the "unknowns" about the starting pitching for 2008.

If the Marlins sign Bonds is very likely I stop being a Marlins fan.

 

Dont need scum like that on the Fish.

 

 

 

Don't let the door hit ya in the a**.

 

 

 

 

Anyways, I agree with Swift to an extent. Yeah, move Hammer to 1B, make a big signing in the offseason for LF. As far as printing playoff tickets.........thats a big stretch.

 

JJ is out practically forever, Olsen is Olsen and we don't know how Willis is going to look after the inevitable offseason wind up overhaul. And those are just SOME of the "unknowns" about the starting pitching for 2008.

 

Anibal Sanchez is a true difference maker who should be in the rotation by June at the latest, who will also have a full offseason of proper rehab under his belt, which is a huge difference from what Anibal and JJ went through last offseason.

 

Plus a healthy Ricky Nolasco is better than 3/5 of what we have now, and Gaby should be ready to be a 5 starter.

 

IMO, Dontrelle/Anibal/Olsen/Nolasco/Gabby or RVH is a better 1-5 than any team in the NL East can pencil in, with certainty, for next season. And that offense should be able to hang, especially if De Aza is for "real."

I think you guys are forgetting about how bad our defense is (and would be if we signed Bonds or Alou). I don't think this team can make the playoffs without at least average defense.

I think you guys are forgetting about how bad our defense is (and would be if we signed Bonds or Alou). I don't think this team can make the playoffs without at least average defense.

 

Error totals are high, but individual defense is trending upward from the start of the season (except for Uggla, especially his throws home).

I think Jacobs is misused and injury plagued. As a result, we have no idea what he'll do, but he has all the makings of an .850 hitter.

 

Holy sh*t, Jacobs is going to hit .850? Sign that dude up long term right now.

 

If the Marlins sign Bonds is very likely I stop being a Marlins fan.

 

Dont need scum like that on the Fish.

 

Says the biggest Scott Olsen supporter on the board?

 

Hermida no good. I have no use for a RF that's the worst defense I've ever seen out there since Ron Swoboda, and I've had enough of his clutch walks, or meaningless hit in a walkover game.

 

Way to not pay attention to baseball games.

If the Marlins sign Bonds is very likely I stop being a Marlins fan.

 

Dont need scum like that on the Fish.

 

 

 

Don't let the door hit ya in the a**.

 

 

 

 

Anyways, I agree with Swift to an extent. Yeah, move Hammer to 1B, make a big signing in the offseason for LF. As far as printing playoff tickets.........thats a big stretch.

 

JJ is out practically forever, Olsen is Olsen and we don't know how Willis is going to look after the inevitable offseason wind up overhaul. And those are just SOME of the "unknowns" about the starting pitching for 2008.

 

Anibal Sanchez is a true difference maker who should be in the rotation by June at the latest, who will also have a full offseason of proper rehab under his belt, which is a huge difference from what Anibal and JJ went through last offseason.

 

Plus a healthy Ricky Nolasco is better than 3/5 of what we have now, and Gaby should be ready to be a 5 starter.

 

IMO, Dontrelle/Anibal/Olsen/Nolasco/Gabby or RVH is a better 1-5 than any team in the NL East can pencil in, with certainty, for next season. And that offense should be able to hang, especially if De Aza is for "real."

 

 

 

Ok, I see where your coming from now. Yeah if you compare our potential 2008 1-5 against the rest of the NL East, we should be very competitive.

 

And someone else mentioned the defense. Look at it this way, the defense can't get any worse than it is now so improvement will be the only thing we will see.

 

 

If the FO makes NO moves in the offseason (a very real possibility), I don't really see 2008 as "our" year. If we move Hammer to 1B and add a proven power bat in LF (also offering Miggy more protection), then our offense can offset our defensive insufficiencies.

But every single one of our players is the worst defensive player ever, and aside from the Yankees for the last like half decade, the A's in the same time, the Angels for the past few years, the Cardinals last year and the White Sox in 05, no team with below average defense has ever done anything!!

 

Our 05 team had 2 gold glovers and probably should've had a 3rd in Agon (and arguably a 4th in Dontrelle). And we sucked.

Hermida no good. I have no use for a RF that's the worst defense I've ever seen out there since Ron Swoboda, and I've had enough of his clutch walks, or meaningless hit in a walkover game.

 

1) Swoboda made up for it when it counted.

2) Thank Jeebus you aren't in the FO.

jury is still out on jake, i think the fact that his children spend every night in a hospital could weigh on him a little bit. duh. (outrageous understatement of the day). jake's a keeper for now.

 

hammer is awesome, he keeps improving and is the 3rd best hitter on the team behind the mega-studs, really hope he gets 100+ rbi

If the Marlins sign Bonds is very likely I stop being a Marlins fan.

 

Dont need scum like that on the Fish.

 

 

 

Don't let the door hit ya in the a**.

 

 

 

 

Anyways, I agree with Swift to an extent. Yeah, move Hammer to 1B, make a big signing in the offseason for LF. As far as printing playoff tickets.........thats a big stretch.

 

JJ is out practically forever, Olsen is Olsen and we don't know how Willis is going to look after the inevitable offseason wind up overhaul. And those are just SOME of the "unknowns" about the starting pitching for 2008.

 

Anibal Sanchez is a true difference maker who should be in the rotation by June at the latest, who will also have a full offseason of proper rehab under his belt, which is a huge difference from what Anibal and JJ went through last offseason.

 

Plus a healthy Ricky Nolasco is better than 3/5 of what we have now, and Gaby should be ready to be a 5 starter.

 

IMO, Dontrelle/Anibal/Olsen/Nolasco/Gabby or RVH is a better 1-5 than any team in the NL East can pencil in, with certainty, for next season. And that offense should be able to hang, especially if De Aza is for "real."

Not to mention Volstud will be ready next year by mid season at most.

If the Marlins sign Bonds is very likely I stop being a Marlins fan.

 

Dont need scum like that on the Fish.

 

 

 

Don't let the door hit ya in the a**.

 

 

 

 

Anyways, I agree with Swift to an extent. Yeah, move Hammer to 1B, make a big signing in the offseason for LF. As far as printing playoff tickets.........thats a big stretch.

 

JJ is out practically forever, Olsen is Olsen and we don't know how Willis is going to look after the inevitable offseason wind up overhaul. And those are just SOME of the "unknowns" about the starting pitching for 2008.

 

Anibal Sanchez is a true difference maker who should be in the rotation by June at the latest, who will also have a full offseason of proper rehab under his belt, which is a huge difference from what Anibal and JJ went through last offseason.

 

Plus a healthy Ricky Nolasco is better than 3/5 of what we have now, and Gaby should be ready to be a 5 starter.

 

IMO, Dontrelle/Anibal/Olsen/Nolasco/Gabby or RVH is a better 1-5 than any team in the NL East can pencil in, with certainty, for next season. And that offense should be able to hang, especially if De Aza is for "real."

Not to mention Volstud will be ready next year by mid season at most.

 

Jesus, I feel incompetent for overlooking him.

 

Man really was just bored/distracted in Jupiter, he's a beast.

If the Marlins sign Bonds is very likely I stop being a Marlins fan.

 

Dont need scum like that on the Fish.

 

 

Olsen is much higher up on the scum-o-meter, but whatever.

But every single one of our players is the worst defensive player ever, and aside from the Yankees for the last like half decade, the A's in the same time, the Angels for the past few years, the Cardinals last year and the White Sox in 05, no team with below average defense has ever done anything!!

 

Our 05 team had 2 gold glovers and probably should've had a 3rd in Agon (and arguably a 4th in Dontrelle). And we sucked.

 

 

 

 

To call the 2007 Marlins "below average defensively" is a gross understatement.

I like Jake. I think he can hit .270 with 20+ homers. He's just gotta stay healthy. I think the 0-30 thing can be chalked up as a fluke. Plus as someone mentioned, he's hitting lefties pretty well. Thing is, if we plan to contend next year, do we take a chance? There are a lot of options in the off-season as far as what to do with him, and it should be interesting to see what the front office chooses to do.

If the Marlins sign Bonds is very likely I stop being a Marlins fan.

 

Dont need scum like that on the Fish.

 

 

Olsen is much higher up on the scum-o-meter, but whatever.

:lol :lol :lol

I like em both.... but there's a difference between someone who drives drunk and fights with cops than someone who allegedly has stuck needles in his tush

I think Jacobs is misused and injury plagued. As a result, we have no idea what he'll do, but he has all the makings of an .850 hitter.

 

Holy sh*t, Jacobs is going to hit .850? Sign that dude up long term right now.

 

I don't pay attention to meaningless stats. The .850 is OPS potential.

So not putting on a little angel act towards the media now makes people scum?

I think Jacobs is misused and injury plagued. As a result, we have no idea what he'll do, but he has all the makings of an .850 hitter.

 

Holy sh*t, Jacobs is going to hit .850? Sign that dude up long term right now.

 

I don't pay attention to meaningless stats. The .850 is OPS potential.

 

I was just joshing you. I know.

Here's a random thought - Jacobs was a catcher in the minors I believe. Why not give him a try there? If not in workouts this year, then maybe next Spring? The few times I've seen him make throws to 3B suggest that he has a decent arm, and if he can handle the staff ok, he would certainly bring to that job better production than our current catching squad. Suppose such a move works out, and you improve the C offense, have Hammer at 1B, and bring in a LF Bat and then we only end up losing Olivo or Treanor (take your pick).

Here's a random thought - Jacobs was a catcher in the minors I believe. Why not give him a try there? If not in workouts this year, then maybe next Spring? The few times I've seen him make throws to 3B suggest that he has a decent arm, and if he can handle the staff ok, he would certainly bring to that job better production than our current catching squad. Suppose such a move works out, and you improve the C offense, have Hammer at 1B, and bring in a LF Bat and then we only end up losing Olivo or Treanor (take your pick).

He had shoulder surgery which moved him out from behind the plate (torn labrum), had sh*tty catching skills, slow release, and not much mobility behind the plate

 

he would be a nightmare back there

If the Marlins sign Bonds is very likely I stop being a Marlins fan.

 

Dont need scum like that on the Fish.

 

 

 

Don't let the door hit ya in the a**.

 

 

 

 

Anyways, I agree with Swift to an extent. Yeah, move Hammer to 1B, make a big signing in the offseason for LF. As far as printing playoff tickets.........thats a big stretch.

 

JJ is out practically forever, Olsen is Olsen and we don't know how Willis is going to look after the inevitable offseason wind up overhaul. And those are just SOME of the "unknowns" about the starting pitching for 2008.

 

Anibal Sanchez is a true difference maker who should be in the rotation by June at the latest, who will also have a full offseason of proper rehab under his belt, which is a huge difference from what Anibal and JJ went through last offseason.

 

Plus a healthy Ricky Nolasco is better than 3/5 of what we have now, and Gaby should be ready to be a 5 starter.

 

IMO, Dontrelle/Anibal/Olsen/Nolasco/Gabby or RVH is a better 1-5 than any team in the NL East can pencil in, with certainty, for next season. And that offense should be able to hang, especially if De Aza is for "real."

 

 

 

Ok, I see where your coming from now. Yeah if you compare our potential 2008 1-5 against the rest of the NL East, we should be very competitive.

 

And someone else mentioned the defense. Look at it this way, the defense can't get any worse than it is now so improvement will be the only thing we will see.

 

 

If the FO makes NO moves in the offseason (a very real possibility), I don't really see 2008 as "our" year. If we move Hammer to 1B and add a proven power bat in LF (also offering Miggy more protection), then our offense can offset our defensive insufficiencies.

I think pitching will be a big question mark.

 

I guess based on potential our rotation has a high ceiling but I wouldn't look at it based on potential. I prefer to look at it based on waht's reasonable to expect out of each guy.

 

Will Sanchez stay healthy and if healthy how will he pitch? The 120 innings or wahtever he pitched in '05 is not that much of a track record. Will DTrain bounce back? I wouldn't expect Nolasco and Olsen to be better than 5th type starters. If they pitch better than that it would be a pleasant surprise. RVH has proven he's not a MLB pitcher. Will he along with any of the minor leaguers be ready next year? Noone knows. Which Mitre will show up?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.