Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Jayson Stark has Marlins rumors

Featured Replies

Gregg's ERA might be low, but it's likely deflated by pitching in the ninth inning instead of more demanding situations. If he were to be moved, I expect that several arms in the pen would put up equal or better numbers in Gregg's place. I could see Lindstrom or Kensing doing fine there.

 

I think Gregg helps this team through the potential talent he'd bring back.

 

 

However, having said that, he still isn't on the top of my list for trade bait if this team is making transactions for a playoff run. I only usually advocate trading ML talent in those situations unless there is a great excess in one area. I suppose the bullpen is the one area where there is remotely an excess, but I don't think it's to high enough a degree.

I suppose the bullpen is the one area where there is remotely an excess, but I don't think it's to high enough a degree.

 

 

I agree with this (that it's where our most depth is, but still isn't that deep at the moment), but that just makes it all the more bothersome that, according to Stark, we're looking to trade for bullpen arms....

...it's not as if we're trading Papelbon.

Remember how Gregg became closer? With no experience...inserted b/c Julio sucked.

It's not rare to see a middle reliever step in, and close...it just happens. And the Marlins have been able to do it plenty of times.

 

If the Rangers offered Salty for Gregg (which is unlikely) you wouldn't do it?

He's not Papelbon. But he is the guy who is pitching the best out of our bullpen. Lowest ERA, lowest WHIP. And I am not ready to give that away to strengthen our bats, who are the 4th best offense in the league.

 

 

We need to strengthen our pitching, not weaken it.

I love the idea of trading with the Rangers. I would be giddy with any of Salty/Ramirez/Teagarden. To get one though we are obviously going to have to part with some pitching, the Rangers are stacked with first baseman hitting prospects, as throwing in a Logan/Gaby doesn't work for them.

 

I'd love to see if they would bite on Scott Olsen for one of the Catchers, but I gotta think they would prefer a Ryan Tucker/Chris Volstad.

I hear Kevin Gregg should get it done. :rolleyes:

 

 

I said Kevin Gregg and perhaps another pitcher. :rolleyes:

I don't see why you're bashing it, considering someone else just mentioned Hendrickson. :rolleyes:

As a throw in/throw away.

 

 

...and then Texas would give us another player, as well...if you read his post.

+ I'd say Texas would 10x prefer Gregg (a decent reliever) over Hendrickson, who well...we know the story.

How about this proposal? Badenhop, Hendrickson and Aaron Thompson for Max Ramirez, Andrew Laughter and John Mayberry

 

 

Hendrickson has to have negative trade value at this point. He is probably going to be released anyway when Johnson/Mitre/Sanchez are activated.

 

If we want a young catcher from Texas we will have to give up pitching. They will be only interested in names such as Nolasco, Olsen, Miller, Volstad, Tucker, De La Cruz, Vanden Hurk.

 

Another name we should be targeting is Bryan Anderson(cards)

I suppose the bullpen is the one area where there is remotely an excess, but I don't think it's to high enough a degree.

 

 

I agree with this (that it's where our most depth is, but still isn't that deep at the moment), but that just makes it all the more bothersome that, according to Stark, we're looking to trade for bullpen arms....

One player I'm torn on trading is Amezaga. He's pretty damn valuable to this team in many ways but if the Marlins solidify CF somehow and Andino can be the least bit trusted with backing up the middle infield, it might be worthwhile.

 

I haven't made up my mind, though.

What do you think it would take to get Bedard or Sabathia? We really need pitching and we can't just sit around and wait for JJ and Sanchez we need someone right now.

I think Gregg helps this team through the potential talent he'd bring back.

 

 

 

AGREED :thumbup

 

Btw, just an extra point I want to make here, (I've said it a couple times before). Talking a little later on (couple years maybe)...but do you some of you guys think Tucker would be better suited, as a closer? I, personally, do. AS OF RIGHT NOW, to me, he only seems to have 2 pitches. 94-97 mph fastball with great movement + a good changeup.

 

I know a starter is more valuable, and Tucker is only 21, but a couple years ago, I remember Baseball America projecting Tucker as our future closer; I also remember a couple days ago when someone posted that he had said in an interview, that he "preferred closing."

 

Thoughts? (Again, this is a bit off topic here...I'm not suggesting to put the 21 year old in the bullpen, yet, just asking...)

What do you think it would take to Bedard or Sabathia? We really need pitching and we can't just sit around and for JJ and Sanchez we need someone right now.

Bedard is absolutely impossible.

 

The Mariners gave up 5 players to get him in the offseason, paying him $7 million to avoid arbitration, and he's playing well. They have the advantage of asking a lot from a team looking to be a buyer.

 

I don't know offhand what Sabathia's contract status is like offhand to comment.

...it's not as if we're trading Papelbon.

Remember how Gregg became closer? With no experience...inserted b/c Julio sucked.

It's not rare to see a middle reliever step in, and close...it just happens. And the Marlins have been able to do it plenty of times.

 

If the Rangers offered Salty for Gregg (which is unlikely) you wouldn't do it?

He's not Papelbon. But he is the guy who is pitching the best out of our bullpen. Lowest ERA, lowest WHIP. And I am not ready to give that away to strengthen our bats, who are the 4th best offense in the league.

 

 

We need to strengthen our pitching, not weaken it.

 

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree here, Rab.

I don't think there's really a wrong, here. A switch-hitting catcher like Saltalamacchia is, rather, rare to find.

What do you think it would take to Bedard or Sabathia? We really need pitching and we can't just sit around and for JJ and Sanchez we need someone right now.

 

 

...well, really...there's no chance of that.

Bedard = deplete the farm.

Sabathia...Beinfest would just be dumb to trade prospects for a guy who's

a) struggled this year

b) most likely won't re-sign with us at the end of the year

 

It's, rather, pointless.

What about Gaby Sanchez, Gaby Hernandez, Ryan Tucker and Josh Willingham for Josh Hamilton and Jarrod Salty.

 

 

Good luck with that...

I suppose the bullpen is the one area where there is remotely an excess, but I don't think it's to high enough a degree.

 

 

I agree with this (that it's where our most depth is, but still isn't that deep at the moment), but that just makes it all the more bothersome that, according to Stark, we're looking to trade for bullpen arms....

One player I'm torn on trading is Amezaga. He's pretty damn valuable to this team in many ways but if the Marlins solidify CF somehow and Andino can be the least bit trusted with backing up the middle infield, it might be worthwhile.

 

I haven't made up my mind, though.

 

Do you know of any recent deadline deals of good utility players?

 

If there's been a history of them getting B prospects, hell even just B- prospects, I'd think you'd have to shop him. I mean, I agree that he's very valuable to the team, and I love love love his defense (I wish he'd be used more as a defensive replacement). But fact remains he is just a bench player.

...it's not as if we're trading Papelbon.

Remember how Gregg became closer? With no experience...inserted b/c Julio sucked.

It's not rare to see a middle reliever step in, and close...it just happens. And the Marlins have been able to do it plenty of times.

 

If the Rangers offered Salty for Gregg (which is unlikely) you wouldn't do it?

He's not Papelbon. But he is the guy who is pitching the best out of our bullpen. Lowest ERA, lowest WHIP. And I am not ready to give that away to strengthen our bats, who are the 4th best offense in the league.

 

 

We need to strengthen our pitching, not weaken it.

 

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree here, Rab.

I don't think there's really a wrong, here. A switch-hitting catcher like Saltalamacchia is, rather, rare to find.

We do have a switch hitting catcher. He just sucks.

 

 

But you honestly think that our weakness, what we need to shore up, is the 8th spot in our lineup? The 4th best hitting lineup in the league?

 

I would love to get Salty, I am ready to ship Jacobs right up out of here. But I don't want to weaken our pitching, which is our main weakness weakness, going on a playoff run.

I love the idea of trading with the Rangers. I would be giddy with any of Salty/Ramirez/Teagarden. To get one though we are obviously going to have to part with some pitching, the Rangers are stacked with first baseman hitting prospects, as throwing in a Logan/Gaby doesn't work for them.

 

I'd love to see if they would bite on Scott Olsen for one of the Catchers, but I gotta think they would prefer a Ryan Tucker/Chris Volstad.

I hear Kevin Gregg should get it done. :rolleyes:

 

 

I said Kevin Gregg and perhaps another pitcher. :rolleyes:

I don't see why you're bashing it, considering someone else just mentioned Hendrickson. :rolleyes:

As a throw in/throw away.

 

 

...and then Texas would give us another player, as well...if you read his post.

+ I'd say Texas would 10x prefer Gregg (a decent reliever) over Hendrickson, who well...we know the story.

How about this proposal? Badenhop, Hendrickson and Aaron Thompson for Max Ramirez, Andrew Laughter and John Mayberry

 

 

Hendrickson has to have negative trade value at this point. He is probably going to be released anyway when Johnson/Mitre/Sanchez are activated.

 

If we want a young catcher from Texas we will have to give up pitching. They will be only interested in names such as Nolasco, Olsen, Miller, Volstad, Tucker, De La Cruz, Vanden Hurk.

 

Another name we should be targeting is Bryan Anderson(cards)

I was thinking Jake fits perfectly with the Rangers but I wouldn't trade him

I dont care who we trade for who we need for who we want for who is who.

 

Just win ball games and whoever is playin so be it.

...it's not as if we're trading Papelbon.

Remember how Gregg became closer? With no experience...inserted b/c Julio sucked.

It's not rare to see a middle reliever step in, and close...it just happens. And the Marlins have been able to do it plenty of times.

 

If the Rangers offered Salty for Gregg (which is unlikely) you wouldn't do it?

He's not Papelbon. But he is the guy who is pitching the best out of our bullpen. Lowest ERA, lowest WHIP. And I am not ready to give that away to strengthen our bats, who are the 4th best offense in the league.

 

 

We need to strengthen our pitching, not weaken it.

 

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree here, Rab.

I don't think there's really a wrong, here. A switch-hitting catcher like Saltalamacchia is, rather, rare to find.

We do have a switch hitting catcher. He just sucks.

 

 

But you honestly think that our weakness, what we need to shore up, is the 8th spot in our lineup? The 4th best hitting lineup in the league?

 

I would love to get Salty, I am ready to ship Jacobs right up out of here. But I don't want to weaken our pitching, which is our main weakness weakness, going on a playoff run.

 

 

a) That's the difference between Rabelo and Saltalamacchia, lol.

b) If it's Jacobs...fine. But if Texas wants Gregg, I definitely wouldn't say no, either. I believe someone else could step in, and fill Gregg's "shoes," if that's the case b/c a catcher like Salty certainly isn't worth passing up when the other organization is asking for a guy like Kevin Gregg.

I imagine that Jacobs could be dealt (I don't really know what he'd get considering he's not a very good hitting 1B, relatively speaking), but the Marlins need to be damn sure that they would get equal production from Helms, McPherson, or whomever else they feel is ready.

...it's not as if we're trading Papelbon.

Remember how Gregg became closer? With no experience...inserted b/c Julio sucked.

It's not rare to see a middle reliever step in, and close...it just happens. And the Marlins have been able to do it plenty of times.

 

If the Rangers offered Salty for Gregg (which is unlikely) you wouldn't do it?

He's not Papelbon. But he is the guy who is pitching the best out of our bullpen. Lowest ERA, lowest WHIP. And I am not ready to give that away to strengthen our bats, who are the 4th best offense in the league.

 

 

We need to strengthen our pitching, not weaken it.

 

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree here, Rab.

I don't think there's really a wrong, here. A switch-hitting catcher like Saltalamacchia is, rather, rare to find.

We do have a switch hitting catcher. He just sucks.

 

 

But you honestly think that our weakness, what we need to shore up, is the 8th spot in our lineup? The 4th best hitting lineup in the league?

 

I would love to get Salty, I am ready to ship Jacobs right up out of here. But I don't want to weaken our pitching, which is our main weakness weakness, going on a playoff run.

 

 

a) That's the difference between Rabelo and Saltalamacchia, lol.

b) If it's Jacobs...fine. But if Texas wants Gregg, I definitely wouldn't say no, either. I believe someone else could step in, and fill Gregg's "shoes," if that's the case b/c a catcher like Salty certainly isn't worth passing up when the other organization is asking for a guy like Kevin Gregg.

See, that's the difference that I guess we need to agree to disagree on.

 

I don't want to weaken the weakest part of the team, and you want to strengthen the strongest part of the team.

I imagine that Jacobs could be dealt (I don't really know what he'd get considering he's not a very good hitting 1B, relatively speaking), but the Marlins need to be damn sure that they would get equal production from Helms, McPherson, or whomever else they feel is ready.

There is always the option of putting Hammer at 1st and leaving Cantu at third with Gonzo in left. I don't particularly like Gonzo's arm out there, but that is one solution.

...it's not as if we're trading Papelbon.

Remember how Gregg became closer? With no experience...inserted b/c Julio sucked.

It's not rare to see a middle reliever step in, and close...it just happens. And the Marlins have been able to do it plenty of times.

 

If the Rangers offered Salty for Gregg (which is unlikely) you wouldn't do it?

He's not Papelbon. But he is the guy who is pitching the best out of our bullpen. Lowest ERA, lowest WHIP. And I am not ready to give that away to strengthen our bats, who are the 4th best offense in the league.

 

 

We need to strengthen our pitching, not weaken it.

 

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree here, Rab.

I don't think there's really a wrong, here. A switch-hitting catcher like Saltalamacchia is, rather, rare to find.

We do have a switch hitting catcher. He just sucks.

 

 

But you honestly think that our weakness, what we need to shore up, is the 8th spot in our lineup? The 4th best hitting lineup in the league?

 

I would love to get Salty, I am ready to ship Jacobs right up out of here. But I don't want to weaken our pitching, which is our main weakness weakness, going on a playoff run.

 

 

a) That's the difference between Rabelo and Saltalamacchia, lol.

b) If it's Jacobs...fine. But if Texas wants Gregg, I definitely wouldn't say no, either. I believe someone else could step in, and fill Gregg's "shoes," if that's the case b/c a catcher like Salty certainly isn't worth passing up when the other organization is asking for a guy like Kevin Gregg.

See, that's the difference that I guess we need to agree to disagree on.

 

I don't want to weaken the weakest part of the team, and you want to strengthen the strongest part of the team.

Rabb I am with you on this one, Gregg has done his job there is no reason to trade him

...it's not as if we're trading Papelbon.

Remember how Gregg became closer? With no experience...inserted b/c Julio sucked.

It's not rare to see a middle reliever step in, and close...it just happens. And the Marlins have been able to do it plenty of times.

 

If the Rangers offered Salty for Gregg (which is unlikely) you wouldn't do it?

He's not Papelbon. But he is the guy who is pitching the best out of our bullpen. Lowest ERA, lowest WHIP. And I am not ready to give that away to strengthen our bats, who are the 4th best offense in the league.

 

 

We need to strengthen our pitching, not weaken it.

 

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree here, Rab.

I don't think there's really a wrong, here. A switch-hitting catcher like Saltalamacchia is, rather, rare to find.

We do have a switch hitting catcher. He just sucks.

 

 

But you honestly think that our weakness, what we need to shore up, is the 8th spot in our lineup? The 4th best hitting lineup in the league?

 

I would love to get Salty, I am ready to ship Jacobs right up out of here. But I don't want to weaken our pitching, which is our main weakness weakness, going on a playoff run.

 

 

a) That's the difference between Rabelo and Saltalamacchia, lol.

b) If it's Jacobs...fine. But if Texas wants Gregg, I definitely wouldn't say no, either. I believe someone else could step in, and fill Gregg's "shoes," if that's the case b/c a catcher like Salty certainly isn't worth passing up when the other organization is asking for a guy like Kevin Gregg.

See, that's the difference that I guess we need to agree to disagree on.

 

I don't want to weaken the weakest part of the team, and you want to strengthen the strongest part of the team.

 

 

more like getting a switch hitting catcher, who will not only help us this year, but in the next years, as well.

By the way, since when is the bullpen the "weakest part of the team?" They're Top 12 in ERA in the big leagues (ABOVE average) despite the fact that they are Top 3 in innings pitched. How exactly are they so "weak?"

 

You don't think ONE (1) of our middle relievers could convert saves, just like Gregg? I do...I don't know exactly who...but I'm sure someone can. If you can be successful in the middle innings, you could do it, in the 9th, as well. Heck, Joe Nelson got "closing" experience in Kansas City, and didn't do all that terrible. It's not the phenomenon some people make it out to be, in the 9th inning...and Gregg is just an average closer, to begin with.

How about this trade.

 

Reds get; John Raynor, Josh Willingham and Chris Volstad

 

Marlins get; Ryan Freel

 

 

Wow...I hope that was a joke.

 

 

Not only do we trade a top 100 prospect (A.K.A probably our best pitching prospect, Volstad), but we also trade one of our best hitters with .RISP (Willingham), and Raynor, who's done well in the minors?

 

For Ryan Freel? The same Ryan Freel, who's nothing more than a nice utility player?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.