Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Jayson Stark has Marlins rumors

Featured Replies

Andrew Miller is going to be our Ace and Volstad could bring Ace stuff to the table as well. Then Olsen, Tucker, and Nolasco can fill 3-5 with solid #2 / #3 type stuff. That is what we call a great rotation.

While I think Salty would be a great addition to our team, I believe the cost would be too great since the Rangers know we'd be looking for more consistency at catcher.

 

Personally, I don't have a problem with a platooning arrangement, as long as the two players in aggregate represent the production of a decent player. As much as I like Matt, he's obviously not having a good season and just doesn't have what it takes to carry the majority of games behind the plate. Rabelo I think is utter garbage, and the only reason he's on the ML roster is to justify the Mega-trade (it's the Jorge Julio effect).

 

So assuming they do something w/ Rabelo (release or sed to the minors), and can't swing a favorble trade, I personally think we already have a solution on the 'Topes: Paul Hoover. I'm a realist, so I wouldn't begin to say he's "the answer" to our catching woes. However, he had pretty good spring, and even though it was just two games at the beginning of the season, looked to have carried his hitting into the regular season. They brought him up June 4th when they sent Tank down, then inexplicably sent him back down 4 days later. In my opinion, Paul could do no worse then Rabelo, and would provide an additional veteran presence behind the plate for our youg pitching staff to complement Matt. While it's one game, he showed at the end of last season he has the ability to come up w/ a clutch hit (breaking up Maine's no-hitter, if you call that clutch), and his .281 current milb avg is respectable.

 

The two biggest problems w/ this option: both he and Matt bat righty, and he appears to no longer be on the 40 man roster (they have him listed s a P, on the 60 day DL ???). I know there's another thread about Baker, who bats lefty, so he could be another solution to our platooning woes, instead of looking outside of the organiation for a backstop.

I would love to see Baker get a real chance , I have nothing against Rabelo, my opinion on catchers has been clear in this forum. However it would be nice to move things around in the catching department. Salty is not on the market imo, the Rangers have plans for him but Max Ramirez would appear to be available. I feel Treanor is better than Hoover, Hoover is like the emergency call up to the majors but Baker would platoon nicely with Treanor. BTW Baker is hitting very well in the PCL softball league

Speaking of catchers (and I only caught a bit of it), anyone hear Gammons yesterday extolling the virtues of a Jason Varitek type catcher, even without the homeruns, as the primary need for the Marlins? "Even if he hits .205..." Gammons went on, the Marlins need to solidify their catcher position with all the young arms coming up through their system.

 

I found it amusing in the sense that I can only imagine how a .205 hitting catcher would go over here at MB.com. :brigginbounce

I would love to see Baker get a real chance , I have nothing against Rabelo, my opinion on catchers has been clear in this forum. However it would be nice to move things around in the catching department. Salty is not on the market imo, the Rangers have plans for him but Max Ramirez would appear to be available. I feel Treanor is better than Hoover, Hoover is like the emergency call up to the majors but Baker would platoon nicely with Treanor. BTW Baker is hitting very well in the PCL softball league

 

He or Teagarden, Salty as this point is a genuine pipe-dream

 

Speaking of catchers (and I only caught a bit of it), anyone hear Gammons yesterday extolling the virtues of a Jason Varitek type catcher, even without the homeruns, as the primary need for the Marlins? "Even if he hits .205..." Gammons went on, the Marlins need to solidify their catcher position with all the young arms coming up through their system.

 

I found it amusing in the sense that I can only imagine how a .205 hitting catcher would go over here at MB.com. :brigginbounce

 

Well Gammons is weird, because, I see that as Treanor pretty much... I might be alone in that, except Treanor hits better than .205... we're looking for (if anything) a catcher that can pull his weight offensively, and I have an idea on how to make that happen, but Im not ready to be flamed for throwing it out there yet

I would love to see Baker get a real chance , I have nothing against Rabelo, my opinion on catchers has been clear in this forum. However it would be nice to move things around in the catching department. Salty is not on the market imo, the Rangers have plans for him but Max Ramirez would appear to be available. I feel Treanor is better than Hoover, Hoover is like the emergency call up to the majors but Baker would platoon nicely with Treanor. BTW Baker is hitting very well in the PCL softball league

 

He or Teagarden, Salty as this point is a genuine pipe-dream

 

Speaking of catchers (and I only caught a bit of it), anyone hear Gammons yesterday extolling the virtues of a Jason Varitek type catcher, even without the homeruns, as the primary need for the Marlins? "Even if he hits .205..." Gammons went on, the Marlins need to solidify their catcher position with all the young arms coming up through their system.

 

I found it amusing in the sense that I can only imagine how a .205 hitting catcher would go over here at MB.com. :brigginbounce

 

Well Gammons is weird, because, I see that as Treanor pretty much... I might be alone in that, except Treanor hits better than .205... we're looking for (if anything) a catcher that can pull his weight offensively, and I have an idea on how to make that happen, but Im not ready to be flamed for throwing it out there yet

 

as someone mentioned before, bengie molina would be a good fit over here. He is great defensivley and is very good with the bat

as someone mentioned before, bengie molina would be a good fit over here. He is great defensivley and is very good with the bat

 

Correct me if Im wrong, but getting Molina provides us with an interesting situation.

 

First of all he has a 6.25M contract, Im thinking we'd absorb about half of that

Secondly he's in the last year of his contract

Thirdly, we are a young team, and IMPROVING at least a little bit, EVERY GAME

 

 

So... what happens next year, when we SHOULD be better, I mean, think of how we'd be right now with a fully year of a healthy JJ and Andrew Miller not pitching BP the first month...

 

Next year, we still don't have a catcher, and given Molina's production (.900+OPS away from AT&T park) he will command a large contract that for all intents and purposes, we won't give out...

 

This is just kind of a pseudo-Teach-A-Man-To-Fish type situation IMO

Why does it seem that Willingham's trade value is huge?

 

Career .850 OPS batters that could feasibly DH for an AL team allowing him to play the whole season, has some value

 

Oh, and he's cheap too

Why does it seem that Willingham's trade value is huge?

 

Career .850 OPS batters that could feasibly DH for an AL team allowing him to play the whole season, has some value

 

Oh, and he's cheap too

 

Or as a a rent-a-player for a stretch run on a team in contention.

as someone mentioned before, bengie molina would be a good fit over here. He is great defensivley and is very good with the bat

 

Correct me if Im wrong, but getting Molina provides us with an interesting situation.

 

First of all he has a 6.25M contract, Im thinking we'd absorb about half of that

Secondly he's in the last year of his contract

Thirdly, we are a young team, and IMPROVING at least a little bit, EVERY GAME

 

 

So... what happens next year, when we SHOULD be better, I mean, think of how we'd be right now with a fully year of a healthy JJ and Andrew Miller not pitching BP the first month...

 

Next year, we still don't have a catcher, and given Molina's production (.900+OPS away from AT&T park) he will command a large contract that for all intents and purposes, we won't give out...

 

This is just kind of a pseudo-Teach-A-Man-To-Fish type situation IMO

 

honestly, i have no idea what you just said, lol

as someone mentioned before, bengie molina would be a good fit over here. He is great defensivley and is very good with the bat

 

Correct me if Im wrong, but getting Molina provides us with an interesting situation.

 

First of all he has a 6.25M contract, Im thinking we'd absorb about half of that

Secondly he's in the last year of his contract

Thirdly, we are a young team, and IMPROVING at least a little bit, EVERY GAME

 

 

So... what happens next year, when we SHOULD be better, I mean, think of how we'd be right now with a fully year of a healthy JJ and Andrew Miller not pitching BP the first month...

 

Next year, we still don't have a catcher, and given Molina's production (.900+OPS away from AT&T park) he will command a large contract that for all intents and purposes, we won't give out...

 

This is just kind of a pseudo-Teach-A-Man-To-Fish type situation IMO

 

honestly, i have no idea what you just said, lol

 

Simply put, what do we do next year when the problem arises again? I'd MUCH rather get a Max Ramirez type that we can hold onto for awhile, if we're THIS good this year, we should be better next year, meaning MORE likely to contend

Well Gammons is weird, because, I see that as Treanor pretty much... I might be alone in that, except Treanor hits better than .205... we're looking for (if anything) a catcher that can pull his weight offensively, and I have an idea on how to make that happen, but Im not ready to be flamed for throwing it out there yet

 

I think what Gammons was saying was that we could have a .205 hitting catcher that has the defensive skills of a Varitek and be alright with that. The unfortunate thing is both Treanor and Rabelo are not that good defensively.

Why does it seem that Willingham's trade value is huge?

 

I always find it strange too, because while it seems he's serviceable, it doesn't seem that he has "STAR" written anywhere on his game. Then again I am just a fan, and not an MLB scout.

Why does it seem that Willingham's trade value is huge?

 

I always find it strange too, because while it seems he's serviceable, it doesn't seem that he has "STAR" written anywhere on his game. Then again I am just a fan, and not an MLB scout.

It's usually not big stars that are being traded, it is middle men who fill holes. He could fill a few holes for a bunch of teams.

 

That said, it's weird to me, concidering he is coming of losing two months to a reoccurring back injury.

Well Gammons is weird, because, I see that as Treanor pretty much... I might be alone in that, except Treanor hits better than .205... we're looking for (if anything) a catcher that can pull his weight offensively, and I have an idea on how to make that happen, but Im not ready to be flamed for throwing it out there yet

 

I think what Gammons was saying was that we could have a .205 hitting catcher that has the defensive skills of a Varitek and be alright with that. The unfortunate thing is both Treanor and Rabelo are not that good defensively.

 

Correct...and the second half is that that catcher would be with the team for an extended period of time (years as the pitchers develop).

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.