Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

If Castillo walks...

Featured Replies

Not to mention Luiy could turn a double play, while on the defensive side of the field Soriano did not know where second base was.

Not to mention Luiy could turn a double play, while on the defensive side of the field Soriano did not know where second base was.

:lol

according to ESPN Soriano made $800,000 this year, Luis $4.5 million.

 

Soriano made 19 errors, Luis 10

 

Soriano had 38 home runs, Luis had 6

 

Soriano had 35 stolen bases, Luis had 21

Luis also K'ed about half as much, and had a higher average.

 

And those error numbers are misleading, seeing that Luis is about to win the GG and Alfonso is far from it.

I'm not making any value judgements or presenting a full case for or against, just threw those out randomly

according to ESPN Soriano made $800,000 this year, Luis $4.5 million.

 

Soriano made 19 errors, Luis 10

 

Soriano had 38 home runs, Luis had 6

 

Soriano had 35 stolen bases, Luis had 21

Luis also K'ed about half as much, and had a higher average.

 

And those error numbers are misleading, seeing that Luis is about to win the GG and Alfonso is far from it.

I'm not making any value judgements or presenting a full case for or against, just threw those out randomly Well, it depends what type of player you're looking for. If you want a guy that will always put the bat on the ball and in play, someone who always gets on base, and will score a ton of runs, you go with Luis.

 

If you just want a guy that can drive in runs, Soriano is your man.

 

But think about this: Soriano hit .259 with RISP (12 points lower than the hated Lee), and a .338 OBP (43 points lower than Luis).

i wouldnt want Soriano for Lowell. Lowell doesnt strikeout as much and its the same thing. Lowell gets the job done and there is no need for Soriano to come. I just wanna see Hooper play but the Marlins will probally go after a 2nd baseman if Castillo goes.

A Penny/Lowell deal for Nick Johnson/A. Soriano is a very good baseball deal BUT its not a good PR move or is it :whistle

Who'd replace Lowell? Cabrera

Who'd replace Penny? AJ Burnett

So my question to you is...Would you move Lowell for Soranio if Casstillo signs elsewhere?

AL "FAN" SO Soriano is not my ideal off-season pick. Better Guerro who has the power and big play ability that we are looking for. And trust me we'll have space in that Outfield for him.

  • Author

So my question to you is...Would you move Lowell for Soranio if Casstillo signs elsewhere?

AL "FAN" SO Soriano is not my ideal off-season pick. Better Guerro who has the power and big play ability that we are looking for. And trust me we'll have space in that Outfield for him. Well, my point int his post was to be somewhat realistic...Berendino is tallking about the Marlins probably going to non-tender Burnett because they have to get the payroll down to 60 mil...and you guys really think we have a shot at getting Guerrero?

 

The only way thats possible is 3 of 4 of Enc, Lowell Lee and Pudge are gone and their replacements make the league minimum..and even then, thats still probably not enough to put Guerrero's 15 mil on our payroll.

Nick Johnson is a future gold glover. stokes isnt...

Stokes also is struggling mightily...a terrible year for the expectations we had for him and he is looking silly in the AZ league thus far.

So my question to you is...Would you move Lowell for Soranio if Casstillo signs elsewhere?

AL "FAN" SO Soriano is not my ideal off-season pick. Better Guerro who has the power and big play ability that we are looking for. And trust me we'll have space in that Outfield for him. Well, my point int his post was to be somewhat realistic...Berendino is tallking about the Marlins probably going to non-tender Burnett because they have to get the payroll down to 60 mil...and you guys really think we have a shot at getting Guerrero?

 

The only way thats possible is 3 of 4 of Enc, Lowell Lee and Pudge are gone and their replacements make the league minimum..and even then, thats still probably not enough to put Guerrero's 15 mil on our payroll. I hope Berardino has no clue. Letting Burnett walk could be a HUGE mistake!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.