Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Yahoo's Tim Brown: Cantu for Jonathan Sanchez?

Featured Replies

Meh, I couldn't figure out the formatting. That's from:

http://www.rotoworld.com/content/home_MLB.aspx

 

So it seems as if the two teams may have dicussed it; of course, if they are just piggybacking Brown's article from Yahoo, it could be poor reporting of identical information.

 

I like the idea of this deal; then, use the extra money to sign a better back-up/platoon catcher, as well as a 4th OF.

 

To be honest, I wouldn't mind swapping Anibal for Max Ramirez, assuming that's on the table.

 

2011?:

1. Cameron Maybin CF

2. Chris Coghlan/Emilio Bonifacio 2B

3. Hanley Ramirez SS

4. Mike Stanton LF/RF

5. Logan Morrison 1B

6. Max Ramirez C

7. Matt Dominguez 3B

8. Jeremy Hermida/John Raynor/Scott Cousins RF

 

Rotation:

1. Josh Johnson

2. Ricky Nolasco

3. Andrew Miller

4. Chris Volstad

5. Jonathan Sanchez

Waiting: Sean West

 

Bullpen:

1. Jose Ceda

2. Ryan Tucker

3. Leo Nunez

4. Renyel Pinto

Fill in the blanks with any 3 of the multitude of talented young arms we have (I'm not sure we'll still have Lindstrom then).

And you still have Dan Uggla, Cody Ross, and whoever loses out in RF (Hermida?) to trade. Not to mention Gaby Sanchez + Dallas McPherson, who might have some value if they can play well this year, but the team wouldn't want to keep them as backups.

 

Starting my 3rd year of law school as that team wins the championship will be happy days. :thumbup

I think you need Cantu on this team. He played a major role on this team and not just on the field. You can never have enough pitching, but I think you need a complete team before you can stockpile on pitching and losing Cantu puts them backwards.

Some background on Sanchez:

 

Jonathan Sanchez misses a LOT of bats.

 

Unfortunately, sometimes that?s because he throws too many balls. But he also induces a lot of strikeouts. And he?s primed to break out in 2009.

 

Sanchez had an okay year in 2008, posting a 5.01 ERA. He managed 157 strikeouts in only 158 innings, although this came with 75 walks and 14 homers as well.

 

However, Sanchez?s ERA is misleading: his 08 campaign was actually pretty good, and, more importantly, there are several signs that his 09 could be a lot better.

 

First of all, Sanchez was somewhat unlucky to post an ERA over 5 in 2008. His FIP was an impressive 3.85, and his tRA was 4.23 (league average is 4.77). Part of the problem was his BABIP: Sanchez allowed an inordinately high .327 BABIP this season. Additionally, Sanchez gave up an extremely high amount of hits in situations in which they scored the most runs: with runners at first and third, batters were 6-for-15; with runners at second and third, batters were 6-for-13; and with the bases loaded batters were 3-for-10 (with three walks). In those three situations, batters hit a combined .395, leading to an inordinately high number of runners scoring.

 

Furthermore, of the 14 homers that Sanchez allowed, only six were solo shots ? despite the fact that 55% of at bats against Sanchez came with no one on base.

 

In other words, Sanchez gave up far more hits and homers with runners on base than he ?should? have, leading to a disproportionately high number of runners who reached base coming around to score. Sure enough, his 67.5% LOB% provides further evidence of this.

 

On the bright side, Sanchez struck out almost a batter per inning over 158 innings ? not an easy feat. Despite not throwing terribly hard (his fastball averaged 91 MPH), he showed a remarkable ability to induce swings-and-misses ? in fact, batters swung and missed at 10.9% of his Sanchez?s pitches, the 9th highest total in baseball. Pitchers who induced higher rates of swings-and-misses were a who?s who of major league baseball?s best pitchers: CC Sabathia, Scott Kazmir, Ryan Dempster, Johan Santana, Cole Hamels, Edinson Volquez, and John Danks. That?s some elite company.

 

Certainly, Sanchez threw too many balls this year (38.6%, to be exact ? league average is 36.5%), and walked too many ? 4.27 per nine innings. However, starting pitchers who can get as many swings-and-misses ? and, therefore, strikeouts ? as Sanchez are few and far between. Sanchez?s ERA was artificially inflated by his inability to ?stop the bleeding? this year ? a fact that is probably borne from a combination of inexperience and bad luck. Therefore, it?s likely that Sanchez will fare better in ?clutch? situations next season, thus lowering his ERA, perhaps considerably. He will almost certainly rack up a lot of strikeouts. And, if he can cut down on his walks ? certainly possible ? he could lower his ERA even further. However, even if Sanchez walks too many, he?ll more than make up for it with a ton of strikeouts and a respectable ERA.

 

http://www.fangraphs.com/fantasy/index.php...onathan-sanchez

Like I said, pretty much Andrew Miller, just a tad bit better results last year.

Mystikol87 - all very well speculating on a possible 2011 line up but we need to focus on the immediate future ie 2009

 

With a few transactions here and there we could potentially give it a good run in the playoffs next year

I think you need Cantu on this team. He played a major role on this team and not just on the field. You can never have enough pitching, but I think you need a complete team before you can stockpile on pitching and losing Cantu puts them backwards.

 

I like Jorge Cantu, and he think he was a fantastic, incredible find. His OPS was still just .808 though. This is good, but this is far from excellent at a corner infield spot. To trade him for Sanchez would give this team a lot of flexibility with both SP and RP depth, while not feeling a huge drop-off in offensive production from a Helms/McPherson platoon. And Gaby would still be protected if we can lock up a lefty 1B/OF. Oh, and our 3B defense would likely improve with Helms logging more innings.

This trade would potentially provide a 2nd MLB SP talent down on the farm to join Sean West; or, allow us to trade a guy like Anibal who is a significant trade chip.

I mean, I think this deal is a no-brainer.

Some background on Sanchez:

 

Jonathan Sanchez misses a LOT of bats.

 

Unfortunately, sometimes that's because he throws too many balls. But he also induces a lot of strikeouts. And he's primed to break out in 2009.

 

Sanchez had an okay year in 2008, posting a 5.01 ERA. He managed 157 strikeouts in only 158 innings, although this came with 75 walks and 14 homers as well.

 

However, Sanchez's ERA is misleading: his 08 campaign was actually pretty good, and, more importantly, there are several signs that his 09 could be a lot better.

 

First of all, Sanchez was somewhat unlucky to post an ERA over 5 in 2008. His FIP was an impressive 3.85, and his tRA was 4.23 (league average is 4.77). Part of the problem was his BABIP: Sanchez allowed an inordinately high .327 BABIP this season. Additionally, Sanchez gave up an extremely high amount of hits in situations in which they scored the most runs: with runners at first and third, batters were 6-for-15; with runners at second and third, batters were 6-for-13; and with the bases loaded batters were 3-for-10 (with three walks). In those three situations, batters hit a combined .395, leading to an inordinately high number of runners scoring.

 

Furthermore, of the 14 homers that Sanchez allowed, only six were solo shots ? despite the fact that 55% of at bats against Sanchez came with no one on base.

 

In other words, Sanchez gave up far more hits and homers with runners on base than he "should" have, leading to a disproportionately high number of runners who reached base coming around to score. Sure enough, his 67.5% LOB% provides further evidence of this.

 

On the bright side, Sanchez struck out almost a batter per inning over 158 innings ? not an easy feat. Despite not throwing terribly hard (his fastball averaged 91 MPH), he showed a remarkable ability to induce swings-and-misses ? in fact, batters swung and missed at 10.9% of his Sanchez's pitches, the 9th highest total in baseball. Pitchers who induced higher rates of swings-and-misses were a who's who of major league baseball's best pitchers: CC Sabathia, Scott Kazmir, Ryan Dempster, Johan Santana, Cole Hamels, Edinson Volquez, and John Danks. That's some elite company.

 

Certainly, Sanchez threw too many balls this year (38.6%, to be exact ? league average is 36.5%), and walked too many ? 4.27 per nine innings. However, starting pitchers who can get as many swings-and-misses ? and, therefore, strikeouts ? as Sanchez are few and far between. Sanchez's ERA was artificially inflated by his inability to "stop the bleeding" this year ? a fact that is probably borne from a combination of inexperience and bad luck. Therefore, it's likely that Sanchez will fare better in "clutch" situations next season, thus lowering his ERA, perhaps considerably. He will almost certainly rack up a lot of strikeouts. And, if he can cut down on his walks ? certainly possible ? he could lower his ERA even further. However, even if Sanchez walks too many, he'll more than make up for it with a ton of strikeouts and a respectable ERA.

 

http://www.fangraphs.com/fantasy/index.php...onathan-sanchez

Like I said, pretty much Andrew Miller, just a tad bit better results last year.

 

 

Andrew Miller was also incredibly unlucky, so that's kinda funny. Seriously, sell high on Cantu and buy "low" on Sanchez. DO IT! Of course, I was this excited about the Olsen + ? for Salty/Max deals and those never happened, so I should probably keep my cool.

It would be smart to trade Cantu.

 

 

How quickly you as fans are willing to a trade sure producer on this team. If you want Cantu out, you are "what have you done for me lately" type of fans. You don't seem to remember that Cantu was our most productive player throughout the season, he just fell off a little late in the season. Cantu is the player we NEED to keep, little doubt. Would rather worsen our defense by keeping Cantu at 3rd and starting the rookie at first than lessening our hitting production with a McPherson/Helms platoon

With a few transactions here and there we could potentially give it a good run in the playoffs next year

 

Cantu for Sanchez would be one of those good transactions. If this is being discussed, it's probably to figure out who the Giants would also be giving us besides Sanchez IMO. Cantu would immediately become San Fran's top bat if dealt. Sanchez would most likely be our fourth starter in '09, and could dominate in Dolphin Stadium if the defense is behind him (which, by design, it should be).

 

The Marlins don't NEED Cantu. He will be replaced by McPherson/Helms. The Giants don't NEED Sanchez. They have plenty of young talent to step up into the rotation. The Marlins DO need more starting pitching depth. The Giants DO need a middle of the order bat, capable of 30+/100+, and specifically they DO need a third baseman.

 

Not to mention, Cantu is VERY affordable for them. And, not to mention, if we shed his salary we have plenty of room to sign Pudge AND get a left-handed 1B/LF while staying within our means.

 

This deal makes too much sense.

For the record, Sanchez will make the minimum next year and be arbitration eligible in 2010.

 

 

I believe the majority of us understand that, but currently we aren't in need of another starting pitcher, we are set. And this offseason we have done everything to shape up our bullpen, trading Cantu would just add more questions to what our rotation will be and will weaken our starting lineup next year

It would be smart to trade Cantu.

 

 

How quickly you as fans are willing to a trade sure producer on this team. If you want Cantu out, you are "what have you done for me lately" type of fans. You don't seem to remember that Cantu was our most productive player throughout the season, he just fell off a little late in the season. Cantu is the player we NEED to keep, little doubt. Would rather worsen our defense by keeping Cantu at 3rd and starting the rookie at first than lessening our hitting production with a McPherson/Helms platoon

 

Now, that's just insane. We do have a guy named Hanley, remember?

With a few transactions here and there we could potentially give it a good run in the playoffs next year

 

 

The Marlins don't NEED Cantu. He will be replaced by McPherson/Helms. The Giants don't NEED Sanchez. They have plenty of young talent to step up into the rotation. The Marlins DO need more starting pitching depth. The Giants DO need a middle of the order bat, capable of 30+/100+, and specifically they DO need a third baseman.

 

This deal makes too much sense.

 

 

This trade makes a lot more sense for them than us. You say we need more depth, but I beg to disagree. I am happy with Sanchez and Miller at the back end of our rotation, and a #3-5 hitter in the lineup is not worth giving up for a #4 starter in the rotation

It would be smart to trade Cantu.

 

 

How quickly you as fans are willing to a trade sure producer on this team. If you want Cantu out, you are "what have you done for me lately" type of fans. You don't seem to remember that Cantu was our most productive player throughout the season, he just fell off a little late in the season. Cantu is the player we NEED to keep, little doubt. Would rather worsen our defense by keeping Cantu at 3rd and starting the rookie at first than lessening our hitting production with a McPherson/Helms platoon

 

Now, that's just insane. We do have a guy named Hanley, remember?

 

 

Really, Hanley was a streaky hitter, he was good before the all star break, and fell off, then came back late. Hanley wasn't nearly as productive as we all hoped he would be, although many teams would take a Hanley down year. Cantu was that hitter that most of us relied on with RISP, Hanley was not. Cantu was productive in that he got runners in via RBI with RISP, Hanley didn't when the pressure was on.

I think you need Cantu on this team. He played a major role on this team and not just on the field. You can never have enough pitching, but I think you need a complete team before you can stockpile on pitching and losing Cantu puts them backwards.

 

I like Jorge Cantu, and he think he was a fantastic, incredible find. His OPS was still just .808 though. This is good, but this is far from excellent at a corner infield spot. To trade him for Sanchez would give this team a lot of flexibility with both SP and RP depth, while not feeling a huge drop-off in offensive production from a Helms/McPherson platoon. And Gaby would still be protected if we can lock up a lefty 1B/OF. Oh, and our 3B defense would likely improve with Helms logging more innings.

This trade would potentially provide a 2nd MLB SP talent down on the farm to join Sean West; or, allow us to trade a guy like Anibal who is a significant trade chip.

I mean, I think this deal is a no-brainer.

 

Why do u think this? A guy coming off a serious, potentially career ending in my opinion does not have much trade value regardless of how they performed before the injury.

For the record, Sanchez will make the minimum next year and be arbitration eligible in 2010.

 

 

I believe the majority of us understand that, but currently we aren't in need of another starting pitcher, we are set. And this offseason we have done everything to shape up our bullpen, trading Cantu would just add more questions to what our rotation will be and will weaken our starting lineup next year

 

Dealing Cantu would give our rotation questions, sure. But it will give us the BEST possible problem to have. And, while opening up a competition in the rotation (which IMO is neccessary, because Miller and Anibal are both big question marks), you're also SOLVING the overload problem you have in the infield.

 

This trade makes a lot more sense for them than us. You say we need more depth, but I beg to disagree. I am happy with Sanchez and Miller at the back end of our rotation, and a #3-5 hitter in the lineup is not worth giving up for a #4 starter in the rotation

 

Like I just said, Anibal and Miller are still big questions marks, both in health and performance. We will still be considered a top 10 offensive team in baseball if we move Cantu IMO. But, our rotation would go from being potentially a top 5 staff in the NL to possibly top 5 in all of baseball. And, IMO, that is much more important.

For the record, Sanchez will make the minimum next year and be arbitration eligible in 2010.

 

 

I believe the majority of us understand that, but currently we aren't in need of another starting pitcher, we are set. And this offseason we have done everything to shape up our bullpen, trading Cantu would just add more questions to what our rotation will be and will weaken our starting lineup next year

 

Dealing Cantu would give our rotation questions, sure. But it will give us the BEST possible problem to have. And, while opening up a competition in the rotation (which IMO is neccessary, because Miller and Anibal are both big question marks), you're also SOLVING the overload problem you have in the infield.

 

This trade makes a lot more sense for them than us. You say we need more depth, but I beg to disagree. I am happy with Sanchez and Miller at the back end of our rotation, and a #3-5 hitter in the lineup is not worth giving up for a #4 starter in the rotation

 

Like I just said, Anibal and Miller are still big questions marks, both in health and performance. We will still be considered a top 10 offensive team in baseball if we move Cantu IMO. But, our rotation would go from being potentially a top 5 staff in the NL to possibly top 5 in all of baseball. And, IMO, that is much more important.

 

 

With Anibal and Miller, I feel we are already a top 5 staff in the NL. You are taking away a chance from two players who are just itching to prove themselves and are poised to have good years, and are getting rid of our #3 hitter to get him. If this trade goes down, this is just a sign of the FO going crazy on trying to improve our defense and getting rid of so much power on this team. Cantu was one of the prime players to our run last season, and we NEED him next year if we want to succeed imo

It would be smart to trade Cantu.

 

 

How quickly you as fans are willing to a trade sure producer on this team. If you want Cantu out, you are "what have you done for me lately" type of fans. You don't seem to remember that Cantu was our most productive player throughout the season, he just fell off a little late in the season. Cantu is the player we NEED to keep, little doubt. Would rather worsen our defense by keeping Cantu at 3rd and starting the rookie at first than lessening our hitting production with a McPherson/Helms platoon

 

This has nothing to do with Cantu, the player.

It has to do with Cantu, the salary.

 

You people are overreacting to the whole "we're losing 80 HR's" theory. Fact is, signing Wes Helms for 2 years was a horrid move for a team like the Marlins, but now that he's signed...he's going to play. The Marlins aren't going to sign a player to a multi-year contract to occasionally pinch-hit.

 

Cantu is due a big raise...and fact is, he doesn't fit into what Beinfest is trying to do. The team seems content with Gaby at 1B...hoping that his value starts to rise this year; that leaves 3B, and Cantu is one of the worst defensive 3B, in baseball. McPherson not only was impressive last year...but against RHP, he was incredible. He's Mike Jacobs with more patience, and is projected as an average defensive 3B (better than Cantu defensively). Then, it's Helms against lefties, which he's been solid against throughout his career. He, too, is better than Cantu, defensively.

 

For all the power, we're losing...Mike Jacobs ONLY provided power...he sucked at all else. The "amazing" Cantu had an .808 .OPS last year. Not amazing by any means...especially for a corner infielder. He just so happens to be a fan favorite. There's no reason why a McPherson/Helms platoon can't produce an .808 .OPS, while improving team defense.

 

This all dates back to the Helms signing...which I never approved of; but it's a done deal now, so you go with what you got.

 

Getting a potential power pitcher like Sanchez for a guy like Cantu is not a bad value deal.

 

And with Cantu's salary gone, and an extra young pitcher in who can start in '09...it gives the Marlins a ton of options to build the rest of the '09 team, this offseason.

For the record, Sanchez will make the minimum next year and be arbitration eligible in 2010.

 

 

I believe the majority of us understand that, but currently we aren't in need of another starting pitcher, we are set. And this offseason we have done everything to shape up our bullpen, trading Cantu would just add more questions to what our rotation will be and will weaken our starting lineup next year

 

You never have enough starting pitching. And with Anibal coming off a torn labrum + Andrew Miller never really proving himself...there are some question marks.

 

Worst case scenario is Sanchez would go to the pen...which right now looks average, at best (not as good as you say).

I think you need Cantu on this team. He played a major role on this team and not just on the field. You can never have enough pitching, but I think you need a complete team before you can stockpile on pitching and losing Cantu puts them backwards.

 

I like Jorge Cantu, and he think he was a fantastic, incredible find. His OPS was still just .808 though. This is good, but this is far from excellent at a corner infield spot. To trade him for Sanchez would give this team a lot of flexibility with both SP and RP depth, while not feeling a huge drop-off in offensive production from a Helms/McPherson platoon. And Gaby would still be protected if we can lock up a lefty 1B/OF. Oh, and our 3B defense would likely improve with Helms logging more innings.

This trade would potentially provide a 2nd MLB SP talent down on the farm to join Sean West; or, allow us to trade a guy like Anibal who is a significant trade chip.

I mean, I think this deal is a no-brainer.

 

Why do u think this? A guy coming off a serious, potentially career ending in my opinion does not have much trade value regardless of how they performed before the injury.

 

I don't claim to know exactly what he's worth, but reports have been he's still enough of a chip to get Max Ramirez, and I consider that to be significant. Sure, he doesn't have as a high a value as he did after his rookie campaign, but I'd love to have Max.

I see where your going Erick. You want Cantu here, but the cheap Marlins once again fail at keeping a winning product together. We made a dumb moving in signing Helms two years, but I can still see us signing Helms that much to occasionally pinch hit. Helms won us a few games from the bench, I guess Beinfest just valued that a lot. I hope Cantu stays, and i feel you want him to stay too, you just want the Marlins to save money. Sad when you can't even think as a fan and you aren't even looking at it as trying to win, you are looking to save money everytime. Cantu was vital to us last year, and we will need him to contend next year. Sanchez would be a #4 pitcher for us next year, if anything the only pitcher i would settle for would be Cain from the Giants (in an Uggla trade), that is the only way i would trade a big marlins producer for a pitcher this year, period

For the record, Sanchez will make the minimum next year and be arbitration eligible in 2010.

 

 

I believe the majority of us understand that, but currently we aren't in need of another starting pitcher, we are set. And this offseason we have done everything to shape up our bullpen, trading Cantu would just add more questions to what our rotation will be and will weaken our starting lineup next year

 

You never have enough starting pitching. And with Anibal coming off a torn labrum + Andrew Miller never really proving himself...there are some question marks.

 

Worst case scenario is Sanchez would go to the pen...which right now looks average, at best (not as good as you say).

 

2006 begs to differ.

For the record, Sanchez will make the minimum next year and be arbitration eligible in 2010.

 

 

I believe the majority of us understand that, but currently we aren't in need of another starting pitcher, we are set. And this offseason we have done everything to shape up our bullpen, trading Cantu would just add more questions to what our rotation will be and will weaken our starting lineup next year

 

You never have enough starting pitching. And with Anibal coming off a torn labrum + Andrew Miller never really proving himself...there are some question marks.

 

Worst case scenario is Sanchez would go to the pen...which right now looks average, at best (not as good as you say).

 

2006 begs to differ.

 

 

Not sure what that means...

You talking about Anibal here?

It would be smart to trade Cantu.

 

 

How quickly you as fans are willing to a trade sure producer on this team. If you want Cantu out, you are "what have you done for me lately" type of fans. You don't seem to remember that Cantu was our most productive player throughout the season, he just fell off a little late in the season. Cantu is the player we NEED to keep, little doubt. Would rather worsen our defense by keeping Cantu at 3rd and starting the rookie at first than lessening our hitting production with a McPherson/Helms platoon

 

Now, that's just insane. We do have a guy named Hanley, remember?

 

 

Really, Hanley was a streaky hitter, he was good before the all star break, and fell off, then came back late. Hanley wasn't nearly as productive as we all hoped he would be, although many teams would take a Hanley down year. Cantu was that hitter that most of us relied on with RISP, Hanley was not. Cantu was productive in that he got runners in via RBI with RISP, Hanley didn't when the pressure was on.

 

2008 Situational Stats G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS Total 155 628 92 174 41 0 29 95 40 111 6 2 .277 .327 .481 .808 G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS Bases Empty 153 339 16 91 21 0 16 16 15 68 0 0 .268 .307 .472 .779 Runners On 146 289 76 83 20 0 13 79 25 43 6 2 .287 .349 .491 .840 RISP 130 169 62 46 9 0 6 64 19 23 1 0 .272 .347 .432 .779

 

He was WORSE with RISP than he was overall!!!!!!!! But, no, clearly your eyes are better than my numbers.

Sure, Cantu was very good with RISP and 2 outs, but 71 ABs there is a pretty small sample size.

http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/players/7380/situational

And everyone seems to forget how Helms' career numbers vs LHP are decent, while Dallas has mashed right-handed pitching.

That "clutch" stuff is total, utter [fill in the blank].

I see where your going Erick. You want Cantu here, but the cheap Marlins once again fail at keeping a winning product together. We made a dumb moving in signing Helms two years, but I can still see us signing Helms that much to occasionally pinch hit. Helms won us a few games from the bench, I guess Beinfest just valued that a lot. I hope Cantu stays, and i feel you want him to stay too, you just want the Marlins to save money. Sad when you can't even think as a fan and you aren't even looking at it as trying to win, you are looking to save money everytime. Cantu was vital to us last year, and we will need him to contend next year. Sanchez would be a #4 pitcher for us next year, if anything the only pitcher i would settle for would be Cain from the Giants (in an Uggla trade), that is the only way i would trade a big marlins producer for a pitcher this year, period

 

No...the Marlins just aren't in position to invest millions on a bunch of players due to the whole stadium dilemma.

 

I never wanted Helms back.

 

I wanted Lou's original platoon of Cantu/Gaby at 1B (with Cantu getting the righties / Gaby getting the lefties) + McPherson/Cantu at 3B (with DMc getting the righties / Cantu getting the lefties).

 

But reality is...Helms is here.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.