Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Yahoo's Tim Brown: Cantu for Jonathan Sanchez?

Featured Replies

For the record, Sanchez will make the minimum next year and be arbitration eligible in 2010.

 

 

I believe the majority of us understand that, but currently we aren't in need of another starting pitcher, we are set. And this offseason we have done everything to shape up our bullpen, trading Cantu would just add more questions to what our rotation will be and will weaken our starting lineup next year

 

Let me get this straight: A Major League starting rotation has 5 pitchers. We already have 5 talented potential starters. Getting another one would give us 6. 6 is more than 5, so we will have more starters than we need. This will lead to questions as to what our rotation will be.

Is this seriously a concern? :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead

The front-office will decide which 5 deserve rotation slots to start the year. If questions as to the set order of our roster and starters because of TOO MUCH TALENT is bad, then I just don't get it.

If a team's rotation was - Lincecum, Sabathia, Santana, Halladay, and Cliff Lee - then would it be bad for them to add Cole Hamels to their roster while losing little to no production and subtracting over 10% of their projected overall salary? Sure, having those 6 would pose questions over who the exact starting 5 would be, but how is that bad?!?!??!??!!?!!?!?

Here is another slightly worrying (imo) aspect of this potential trade

 

Quoted from Joe Frisaro: If Cantu is traded, it clears first base for Gaby Sanchez, and Emilio Bonifacio would have a better chance of winning the third base job.

I see where your going Erick. You want Cantu here, but the cheap Marlins once again fail at keeping a winning product together. We made a dumb moving in signing Helms two years, but I can still see us signing Helms that much to occasionally pinch hit. Helms won us a few games from the bench, I guess Beinfest just valued that a lot. I hope Cantu stays, and i feel you want him to stay too, you just want the Marlins to save money. Sad when you can't even think as a fan and you aren't even looking at it as trying to win, you are looking to save money everytime. Cantu was vital to us last year, and we will need him to contend next year. Sanchez would be a #4 pitcher for us next year, if anything the only pitcher i would settle for would be Cain from the Giants (in an Uggla trade), that is the only way i would trade a big marlins producer for a pitcher this year, period

 

Uggla is far superior to Cantu. More proven, and much better offensive numbers at a position where offense is at more of a premium. I don't think it's fair to put those two on a parallel.

Here is another slightly worrying (imo) aspect of this potential trade

 

Quoted from Joe Frisaro: If Cantu is traded, it clears first base for Gaby Sanchez, and Emilio Bonifacio would have a better chance of winning the third base job.

 

Yea, this deal is perfect in my eyes, IF it's to open up first for Gaby and third for McPherson/Helms.

 

If this deal goes down, and Bonifacio is starting third base, I'll shoot my foot.

I'm still waiting for the first legitimate piece that suggests Helms is anything other than a part-time player and neither a platoon or starting at any position. The Marlins brought him back for three reasons 1) his versatility 2) his willingness to accept his role with the team, play hard whenever and wherever asked and 3) dare I say it, for the veteran presence he provides on the field and in the clubhouse.

 

He's not an everyday player, he wasn't signed to be an everyday player and the Marlins locked him for two years because they knew what they could expect in return. In some ways Helms' role as enforcer and mentor allows the younger players to be themselves without the responsibilities that go with the job.

 

As exhibit A (from a few days ago):

 

"Since he came up, Sanchez said it's been 10-year veteran Wes Helms who has helped him out the most. And with Helms signing a two-year extension on Oct. 3 -- likely to maintain his role as a pinch-hitter and corner-infield defensive replacement -- Sanchez can continue to get that much-needed veteran leadership.

 

"The first day I got there, he said, 'Let's go in the weight room,' and I had to work out every single day since," Sanchez said. "If I didn't work out with him, he was yelling at me.

 

"He saw things when I was catching ground balls, and he was like, 'Hey, you have to do this, and you have to do this.' I worked real hard with him while I was there just doing techniques at first base."

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20...8&fext=.jsp

I'm still waiting for the first legitimate piece that suggests Helms is anything other than a part-time player and neither a platoon or starting at any position. The Marlins brought him back for three reasons 1) his versatility 2) his willingness to accept his role with the team, play hard whenever and wherever asked and 3) dare I say it, for the veteran presence he provides on the field and in the clubhouse.He's not an everyday player, he wasn't signed to be an everyday player and the Marlins locked him for two years because they knew what they could expect in return. In some ways Helms' role as enforcer and mentor allows the younger players to be themselves without the responsibilities that go with the job. As exhibit A (from a few days ago):"Since he came up, Sanchez said it's been 10-year veteran Wes Helms who has helped him out the most. And with Helms signing a two-year extension on Oct. 3 -- likely to maintain his role as a pinch-hitter and corner-infield defensive replacement -- Sanchez can continue to get that much-needed veteran leadership."The first day I got there, he said, 'Let's go in the weight room,' and I had to work out every single day since," Sanchez said. "If I didn't work out with him, he was yelling at me."He saw things when I was catching ground balls, and he was like, 'Hey, you have to do this, and you have to do this.' I worked real hard with him while I was there just doing techniques at first base."http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20...8&fext=.jsp

 

I think this is very likely. Don't forget, he is signed for 2 years and a total of $1.9 million. That's $950,000 a year. What's the veteran's minimum for a player like Helms? 500k? He's not signed for much over the minimum, but I think he can add a lot of value without being a full-time starter or even a 60-80 games a year starter. Not to mention he's a very good option in the late innings in many situations. One that sticks out is if a team were to bring in a lefty to face Dallas [assuming he's a starter]; you bring in Helms, who has been solid against LHP, and you improve your defense for the rest of the game.

This is just getting ridiculous. Under normal circumstances I would be happy to see us exploring trading a high value guy for a top prospect, but we've already traded half our offense and I just don't understand where we are expecting to get that next year. Hermida? Doubtful. I know that we've wanted to get away from the free swinging strikeout guys, but Cantu is just a little more consistent than those guys and I just don't think that addition by subtraction is really goint to benefit us.

 

Forgive me if I don't think that a combo of Gaby Sanchez, McPherson and Helms is really going to provide the offense we need. I like Sanchez and McPherson but they are wild cards, and to give them both an open spot out of the gate is just very short-sighted for a team that was tantalizingly close to the playoffs last year.

I'm still waiting for the first legitimate piece that suggests Helms is anything other than a part-time player and neither a platoon or starting at any position. The Marlins brought him back for three reasons 1) his versatility 2) his willingness to accept his role with the team, play hard whenever and wherever asked and 3) dare I say it, for the veteran presence he provides on the field and in the clubhouse.

 

He's not an everyday player, he wasn't signed to be an everyday player and the Marlins locked him for two years because they knew what they could expect in return. In some ways Helms' role as enforcer and mentor allows the younger players to be themselves without the responsibilities that go with the job.

 

As exhibit A (from a few days ago):

 

"Since he came up, Sanchez said it's been 10-year veteran Wes Helms who has helped him out the most. And with Helms signing a two-year extension on Oct. 3 -- likely to maintain his role as a pinch-hitter and corner-infield defensive replacement -- Sanchez can continue to get that much-needed veteran leadership.

 

"The first day I got there, he said, 'Let's go in the weight room,' and I had to work out every single day since," Sanchez said. "If I didn't work out with him, he was yelling at me.

 

"He saw things when I was catching ground balls, and he was like, 'Hey, you have to do this, and you have to do this.' I worked real hard with him while I was there just doing techniques at first base."

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20...8&fext=.jsp

 

I've seen quotes from players and coaches about Helms and his veteran leadership role. His "tuff love" technique was balanced out with Gonzos more laid back approach at teaching the younger players. You are c0pletely correct on all 3 reasons you gave of why he was signed.

 

I'm not buying into the Cantu rumor. Signing him and Amazega were priorities going into the off season according to quotes from the FO and coaches. His name always is mentioned when they talk about what may happen come ST. The name that is rarely mentioned is Dallas. But I think we may hear that one before the Winter Meetings wrap up.

I wouldn't make this trade if I were the Marlins. I have watched Jonathan Sanchez pitch a bunch of times and unless they are going to use him as a reliever I don't really like him. After all, he has a 5.18 career ERA and a 1.50 WHIP. Sanchez has great stuff but he doesn't know how to pitch yet. He has walked 126 batters in 250 career innings in the majors and he seems to lose focus when the going gets tough. I don't think that Wes Helms and Dallas McPherson would produce anything near what Cantu would in 2009 for the Marlins. That's my opinion and I'm sticking to it.

This is just getting ridiculous. Under normal circumstances I would be happy to see us exploring trading a high value guy for a top prospect, but we've already traded half our offense and I just don't understand where we are expecting to get that next year. Hermida? Doubtful. I know that we've wanted to get away from the free swinging strikeout guys, but Cantu is just a little more consistent than those guys and I just don't think that addition by subtraction is really goint to benefit us.

 

Forgive me if I don't think that a combo of Gaby Sanchez, McPherson and Helms is really going to provide the offense we need. I like Sanchez and McPherson but they are wild cards, and to give them both an open spot out of the gate is just very short-sighted for a team that was tantalizingly close to the playoffs last year.

That is the most important part to look at, I think adding more pitching is always good, but as I said earlier, only when the rest of the team is complete. When you are missing out on people in the field it makes no sense to have all these extra pitchers. Especially when the team made a good run last year and this year should/could be a better team.

Cantu was the MVP last year for us! No!!!! try trading Mcpherson for sanchez, i accept, but not cantu!!!! geez are the marlins crazy

Cantu was the MVP last year for us! No!!!! try trading Mcpherson for Sanchez, i accept, but not cantu!!!! geez are the marlins crazy

 

McP is not getting us Jonathan Sanchez, probably because the Marlins kept him down in triple A too long. I am sure Cantu is a required component for a deal. I rather see Cantu traded for a catcher but hey Sanchez would be awesome

I wouldn't make this trade if I were the Marlins. I have watched Jonathan Sanchez pitch a bunch of times and unless they are going to use him as a reliever I don't really like him. After all, he has a 5.18 career ERA and a 1.50 WHIP. Sanchez has great stuff but he doesn't know how to pitch yet. He has walked 126 batters in 250 career innings in the majors and he seems to lose focus when the going gets tough. I don't think that Wes Helms and Dallas McPherson would produce anything near what Cantu would in 2009 for the Marlins. That's my opinion and I'm sticking to it.

 

Feel free to stick to it. Also, feel free to be wrong.

Some background on Sanchez:

 

Jonathan Sanchez misses a LOT of bats.

 

Unfortunately, sometimes that's because he throws too many balls. But he also induces a lot of strikeouts. And he's primed to break out in 2009.

 

Sanchez had an okay year in 2008, posting a 5.01 ERA. He managed 157 strikeouts in only 158 innings, although this came with 75 walks and 14 homers as well.

 

However, Sanchez's ERA is misleading: his 08 campaign was actually pretty good, and, more importantly, there are several signs that his 09 could be a lot better.

 

First of all, Sanchez was somewhat unlucky to post an ERA over 5 in 2008. His FIP was an impressive 3.85, and his tRA was 4.23 (league average is 4.77). Part of the problem was his BABIP: Sanchez allowed an inordinately high .327 BABIP this season. Additionally, Sanchez gave up an extremely high amount of hits in situations in which they scored the most runs: with runners at first and third, batters were 6-for-15; with runners at second and third, batters were 6-for-13; and with the bases loaded batters were 3-for-10 (with three walks). In those three situations, batters hit a combined .395, leading to an inordinately high number of runners scoring.

 

Furthermore, of the 14 homers that Sanchez allowed, only six were solo shots ? despite the fact that 55% of at bats against Sanchez came with no one on base.

 

In other words, Sanchez gave up far more hits and homers with runners on base than he "should" have, leading to a disproportionately high number of runners who reached base coming around to score. Sure enough, his 67.5% LOB% provides further evidence of this.

 

On the bright side, Sanchez struck out almost a batter per inning over 158 innings ? not an easy feat. Despite not throwing terribly hard (his fastball averaged 91 MPH), he showed a remarkable ability to induce swings-and-misses ? in fact, batters swung and missed at 10.9% of his Sanchez's pitches, the 9th highest total in baseball. Pitchers who induced higher rates of swings-and-misses were a who's who of major league baseball's best pitchers: CC Sabathia, Scott Kazmir, Ryan Dempster, Johan Santana, Cole Hamels, Edinson Volquez, and John Danks. That's some elite company.

 

Certainly, Sanchez threw too many balls this year (38.6%, to be exact ? league average is 36.5%), and walked too many ? 4.27 per nine innings. However, starting pitchers who can get as many swings-and-misses ? and, therefore, strikeouts ? as Sanchez are few and far between. Sanchez's ERA was artificially inflated by his inability to "stop the bleeding" this year ? a fact that is probably borne from a combination of inexperience and bad luck. Therefore, it's likely that Sanchez will fare better in "clutch" situations next season, thus lowering his ERA, perhaps considerably. He will almost certainly rack up a lot of strikeouts. And, if he can cut down on his walks ? certainly possible ? he could lower his ERA even further. However, even if Sanchez walks too many, he'll more than make up for it with a ton of strikeouts and a respectable ERA.

 

http://www.fangraphs.com/fantasy/index.php...onathan-sanchez

Thank you! great find!

I wouldn't make this trade if I were the Marlins. I have watched Jonathan Sanchez pitch a bunch of times and unless they are going to use him as a reliever I don't really like him. After all, he has a 5.18 career ERA and a 1.50 WHIP. Sanchez has great stuff but he doesn't know how to pitch yet. He has walked 126 batters in 250 career innings in the majors and he seems to lose focus when the going gets tough. I don't think that Wes Helms and Dallas McPherson would produce anything near what Cantu would in 2009 for the Marlins. That's my opinion and I'm sticking to it.

 

Feel free to stick to it. Also, feel free to be wrong.

 

 

I've seen a lot of Giants games that Sanchez has pitched and he's not that impressive to me. He strikes me a lot like Daniel Cabrera does.......great arm but no feel for pitching.

I wouldn't make this trade if I were the Marlins. I have watched Jonathan Sanchez pitch a bunch of times and unless they are going to use him as a reliever I don't really like him. After all, he has a 5.18 career ERA and a 1.50 WHIP. Sanchez has great stuff but he doesn't know how to pitch yet. He has walked 126 batters in 250 career innings in the majors and he seems to lose focus when the going gets tough. I don't think that Wes Helms and Dallas McPherson would produce anything near what Cantu would in 2009 for the Marlins. That's my opinion and I'm sticking to it.

 

Feel free to stick to it. Also, feel free to be wrong.

 

 

I've seen a lot of Giants games that Sanchez has pitched and he's not that impressive to me. He strikes me a lot like Daniel Cabrera does.......great arm but no feel for pitching.

 

No one can predict the future, but obviously that article feels Sanchez has terrific upside and he will soon achieve success. He's still pretty young, especially as pitchers go. Also, McPherson destroys righties and Helms has been fine against LHP. Their combined defense will absolutely be better than Cantu's at 3B, and it will save us $4.5 million while giving us very good/great young SP depth (as well as a better balance of RHP to LHP in our potential starting rotation). Don't forget Cantu's OPS was barely over .800 - certainly I like him very much, and he is far from irreplaceable with that type of offense at a corner infield spot. He'd be worth more if he was going to play second base, but he's not.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.