December 3, 200817 yr http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/news?slug=ti-h...o&type=lgns have discussed a trade that would send left-handed starter Jonathan Sanchez to the Florida Marlins in exchange for third baseman Jorge Cantu. Sanchez, 26, was promising but ever inconsistent in 29 starts in 2008 for the Giants, whose offseason strategy is to part with some young pitching to upgrade one of the worst offenses in baseball. Released by the Reds last December, Cantu, also 26, turned his career around with 29 home runs, 41 doubles and 95 RBI for the surprising Marlins last season.
December 3, 200817 yr I would definitely love this deal. This is just like a Matt Cain for Dan Uggla thought; I want Cantu around, sure, but for Sanchez I'll give the corner jobs to Dallas/Wes and Gaby. Just for some of you who are not familiar with Sanchez... He's exactly like Andrew Miller. Tall, skinny lefty with very similar, disgusting stuff. Also has very similar mechanics, which have led to very iffy control and consistency. BUT, if one of the two were to put it all together this year, wow. If BOTH were, we may have one of the best rotations age 26-under ever.
December 3, 200817 yr I dont know i think we got enough youn pitching right now but you can never have enough pitching. I like cantu.
December 3, 200817 yr Giving up Cantu would mean our line-up would be missing approximately 80 home runs from last year (Cantu, Jake and Hammer (I know he didnt get 20 last year but he probs would if healthy)) I understand the organisation is focusing on a pitching/speed/defence mentality and J.Sanchez is a good young pitcher but on this occasion I think the benefits Cantu brings to the team outweigh those that Sanchez would.
December 3, 200817 yr Gee, I hope not. Maybe we could interest them in Dallas McPherson. That would appear to be a more equitable trade. The strikeouts look nice until you realize he walks someone every other inning. I'll leave it to others to discuss the rest of his splits. Not to mention you've already given up Jacobs' 30 HRs and 90+ RBIs, do you want to give up Cantu's numbers for a guy with no control who may be pitching in the minors when the season starts? I kind of doubt it after Beinfest's comments just yesterday. http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=28472
December 3, 200817 yr Giving up Cantu would mean our line-up would be missing approximately 80 home runs from last year (Cantu, Jake and Hammer (I know he didnt get 20 last year but he probs would if healthy)) I understand the organisation is focusing on a pitching/speed/defence mentality and J.Sanchez is a good young pitcher but on this occasion I think the benefits Cantu brings to the team outweigh those that Sanchez would. No. Cantu is replacable. Moving him and bringing in Sanchez only makes our rotation incredibly strong, and finally makes our infield set. The front office seems to think Gaby Sanchez is really ready for the big show, and a McPherson/Helms platoon should outproduce Cantu's production from 2008. Plus, if we sign Pudge... I'll take this anyday: vs. RHP Maybin CF Baker C Ramirez SS McPherson 3B Uggla 2B Ross LF Hermida RF G. Sanchez 1B vs. LHP Maybin CF Rodriguez C Ramirez SS Uggla 2B Ross LF G. Sanchez 1B Helms 3B Hermida RF Rotation Nolasco Johnson Miller Volstad J. Sanchez
December 3, 200817 yr Could this mean the FO is thinking of sending Anibal Sanchez to Texas for one of the catchers and inserting Jonathan in the starting rotation? What are your thoughts if this does happen?
December 3, 200817 yr Could this mean the FO is thinking of sending Anibal Sanchez to Texas for one of the catchers and inserting Jonathan in the starting rotation? What are your thoughts if this does happen? I'll take Anibal Sanchez for Max Ramirez. All that does is eliminate the idea of signing Pudge. But, I have a feeling they'd hold onto Anibal and let he, Jon Sanchez, and Andrew Miller battle for the bottom two rotation spots, and send the least consistent one to triple-A.
December 3, 200817 yr ...a McPherson/Helms platoon should outproduce Cantu's production from 2008. That's an awful lot of optimism you're displaying. Assuming Miller is in the mix, and let's say for argument sake we *pick* up JS, is Anibal gone? You aren't going to turn him into long relief, and with his shoulder throwing night after night in the seventh or eigth inning is a prescription for trouble. I thought this quote from SF Giants own website was interesting: "The Lincecum non-trade is instructive, however. If Rios represented the best offer Sabean could get for Lincecum, the Giants probably couldn't get a big bat for Sanchez alone. They'd either have to give in and dangle Cain, or couple Sanchez with a prospect. Left-hander Madison Bumgarner and right-hander Tim Alderson have received plenty of attention, but the Giants are as reluctant to part with either of them as they are with Cain." One could legitimately argue that with fifteen more homeruns and 20 more RBIs, a higher OPS the same OBP, Cantu had the better season between Rios and himself. Not to mention Rios is the more expensive player. Addendum: I couldn't help but notice, and maybe I'm being too knit-picky but it comes from reading too many contracts, that the piece doesn't say the Giants AND Marlins have discussed this theoretical move, it says the Giants have discussed, which could mean they've had internal discussions about such a move in the same many teams have them about a wide range of players especially going into the Winter Meetings. And I'm willing to be 100% wrong on my read if another piece comes out that is authorative and credible (and doesn't use this one as it's source).
December 3, 200817 yr ...a McPherson/Helms platoon should outproduce Cantu's production from 2008. That's an awful lot of optimism you're displaying. Assuming Miller is in the mix, and let's say for argument sake we *pick* up JS, is Anibal gone? You aren't going to turn him into long relief, and with his shoulder throwing night after night in the seventh or eigth inning is a prescription for trouble. I thought this quote from SF Giants own website was interesting: "The Lincecum non-trade is instructive, however. If Rios represented the best offer Sabean could get for Lincecum, the Giants probably couldn't get a big bat for Sanchez alone. They'd either have to give in and dangle Cain, or couple Sanchez with a prospect. Left-hander Madison Bumgarner and right-hander Tim Alderson have received plenty of attention, but the Giants are as reluctant to part with either of them as they are with Cain." One could legitimately argue that with fifteen more homeruns and 20 more RBIs, a higher OPS the same OBP, Cantu had the better season between Rios and himself. Not to mention Rios is the more expensive player. Like I said above, Anibal, Jonathan, and Andrew would probably be competing for the final two rotation spots, with the least consistent arm sent to triple-A. And I hope you aren't suggesting Lincecum could be had for Cantu. Cain? Maybe, and I'd make that deal in a second. It all depends on just how desperate the Giants are for offense. They could surely use Cantu at third... quite an upgrade over the guy we handed to them, Jose Castillo.
December 3, 200817 yr I would much rather have Cantu at 3rd and Anibal in the rotation than McPherson/Helms platooning at 3rd and J.Sanchez I think the organisation would make a big mistake by trading Anibal this offseason. I know he struggled somewhat in his return from his awful injury but with a proper Spring Training under his belt I think he could come close to re-discovering his 2006 form in 2009
December 3, 200817 yr I honestly don't know how I feel about that idea. I loved Cantu last season, but we could use another young lefty....
December 3, 200817 yr I would much rather have Cantu at 3rd and Anibal in the rotation than McPherson/Helms platooning at 3rd and J.Sanchez I think the organisation would make a big mistake by trading Anibal this offseason. I know he struggled somewhat in his return from his awful injury but with a proper Spring Training under his belt I think he could come close to re-discovering his 2006 form in 2009 Anibal could surely do that. But what if he's terrible? And what if Andrew Miller is, too? We need that sixth cheap, talented arm to create a little more competition, and spark some progress and results. If we can do that, and lose little to no offense at third base, then awesome. You do it. I completely trust McPherson having a great year if starting next season. I honestly don't know how I feel about that idea. I loved Cantu last season, but we could use another young lefty.... And we're not talking about any Scott Olsen-type lefty... We're talking Andrew Miller-like stuff. Definitely worth it. Free's up salary, and solves our 1B/3B surplus going on.
December 3, 200817 yr I like this one. This could allow us to trade off another starter for a position player. I would also be very suprised if Cantu puts up the same numbers as last year
December 3, 200817 yr I like this one. This could allow us to trade off another starter for a position player. I would also be very suprised if Cantu puts up the same numbers as last year I don't doubt Cantu, he's very strong and very motivated, and certainly still young. BUT, I think it's just as likely Sanchez has a great year next season in Florida as it is Cantu repeats his success. It all works out.
December 3, 200817 yr ...a McPherson/Helms platoon should outproduce Cantu's production from 2008. That's an awful lot of optimism you're displaying. Assuming Miller is in the mix, and let's say for argument sake we *pick* up JS, is Anibal gone? You aren't going to turn him into long relief, and with his shoulder throwing night after night in the seventh or eigth inning is a prescription for trouble. I thought this quote from SF Giants own website was interesting: "The Lincecum non-trade is instructive, however. If Rios represented the best offer Sabean could get for Lincecum, the Giants probably couldn't get a big bat for Sanchez alone. They'd either have to give in and dangle Cain, or couple Sanchez with a prospect. Left-hander Madison Bumgarner and right-hander Tim Alderson have received plenty of attention, but the Giants are as reluctant to part with either of them as they are with Cain." One could legitimately argue that with fifteen more homeruns and 20 more RBIs, a higher OPS the same OBP, Cantu had the better season between Rios and himself. Not to mention Rios is the more expensive player. Like I said above, Anibal, Jonathan, and Andrew would probably be competing for the final two rotation spots, with the least consistent arm sent to triple-A. And I hope you aren't suggesting Lincecum could be had for Cantu. Cain? Maybe, and I'd make that deal in a second. It all depends on just how desperate the Giants are for offense. They could surely use Cantu at third... quite an upgrade over the guy we handed to them, Jose Castillo. Gee, did I say that?
December 3, 200817 yr ...a McPherson/Helms platoon should outproduce Cantu's production from 2008. That's an awful lot of optimism you're displaying. Assuming Miller is in the mix, and let's say for argument sake we *pick* up JS, is Anibal gone? You aren't going to turn him into long relief, and with his shoulder throwing night after night in the seventh or eigth inning is a prescription for trouble. I thought this quote from SF Giants own website was interesting: "The Lincecum non-trade is instructive, however. If Rios represented the best offer Sabean could get for Lincecum, the Giants probably couldn't get a big bat for Sanchez alone. They'd either have to give in and dangle Cain, or couple Sanchez with a prospect. Left-hander Madison Bumgarner and right-hander Tim Alderson have received plenty of attention, but the Giants are as reluctant to part with either of them as they are with Cain." One could legitimately argue that with fifteen more homeruns and 20 more RBIs, a higher OPS the same OBP, Cantu had the better season between Rios and himself. Not to mention Rios is the more expensive player. Like I said above, Anibal, Jonathan, and Andrew would probably be competing for the final two rotation spots, with the least consistent arm sent to triple-A. And I hope you aren't suggesting Lincecum could be had for Cantu. Cain? Maybe, and I'd make that deal in a second. It all depends on just how desperate the Giants are for offense. They could surely use Cantu at third... quite an upgrade over the guy we handed to them, Jose Castillo. Gee, did I say that? Well, the article mentioned Rios is the best bat they could get for Lincecum, and you compared Rios and Cantu's seasons... Kinda sounded like it.
December 3, 200817 yr ...a McPherson/Helms platoon should outproduce Cantu's production from 2008. That's an awful lot of optimism you're displaying. Assuming Miller is in the mix, and let's say for argument sake we *pick* up JS, is Anibal gone? You aren't going to turn him into long relief, and with his shoulder throwing night after night in the seventh or eigth inning is a prescription for trouble. I thought this quote from SF Giants own website was interesting: "The Lincecum non-trade is instructive, however. If Rios represented the best offer Sabean could get for Lincecum, the Giants probably couldn't get a big bat for Sanchez alone. They'd either have to give in and dangle Cain, or couple Sanchez with a prospect. Left-hander Madison Bumgarner and right-hander Tim Alderson have received plenty of attention, but the Giants are as reluctant to part with either of them as they are with Cain." One could legitimately argue that with fifteen more homeruns and 20 more RBIs, a higher OPS the same OBP, Cantu had the better season between Rios and himself. Not to mention Rios is the more expensive player. Like I said above, Anibal, Jonathan, and Andrew would probably be competing for the final two rotation spots, with the least consistent arm sent to triple-A. And I hope you aren't suggesting Lincecum could be had for Cantu. Cain? Maybe, and I'd make that deal in a second. It all depends on just how desperate the Giants are for offense. They could surely use Cantu at third... quite an upgrade over the guy we handed to them, Jose Castillo. Gee, did I say that? Well, the article mentioned Rios is the best bat they could get for Lincecum, and you compared Rios and Cantu's seasons... Kinda sounded like it. Try reading it again. The point was, the Giants beat guy didn't think that Sanchez was enough for Rios or "a big bat", and I pointed out Cantu had a better season than Rios, which says to me an admission that Sanchez is not enough to land the better-producing, lower cost Cantu.
December 3, 200817 yr I would much rather have Cantu at 3rd and Anibal in the rotation than McPherson/Helms platooning at 3rd and J.Sanchez I think the organisation would make a big mistake by trading Anibal this offseason. I know he struggled somewhat in his return from his awful injury but with a proper Spring Training under his belt I think he could come close to re-discovering his 2006 form in 2009 Anibal could surely do that. But what if he's terrible? And what if Andrew Miller is, too? We need that sixth cheap, talented arm to create a little more competition, and spark some progress and results. If we can do that, and lose little to no offense at third base, then awesome. You do it. I completely trust McPherson having a great year if starting next season. I honestly don't know how I feel about that idea. I loved Cantu last season, but we could use another young lefty.... And we're not talking about any Scott Olsen-type lefty... We're talking Andrew Miller-like stuff. Definitely worth it. Free's up salary, and solves our 1B/3B surplus going on. If this deal were to happen it would make the Spring Training battle for 1B/3B a bit more interesting, I'll give you that. I'm just not totally sold on Dallas yet.
December 3, 200817 yr I would much rather have Cantu at 3rd and Anibal in the rotation than McPherson/Helms platooning at 3rd and J.Sanchez I think the organisation would make a big mistake by trading Anibal this offseason. I know he struggled somewhat in his return from his awful injury but with a proper Spring Training under his belt I think he could come close to re-discovering his 2006 form in 2009 Anibal could surely do that. But what if he's terrible? And what if Andrew Miller is, too? We need that sixth cheap, talented arm to create a little more competition, and spark some progress and results. If we can do that, and lose little to no offense at third base, then awesome. You do it. I completely trust McPherson having a great year if starting next season. I honestly don't know how I feel about that idea. I loved Cantu last season, but we could use another young lefty.... And we're not talking about any Scott Olsen-type lefty... We're talking Andrew Miller-like stuff. Definitely worth it. Free's up salary, and solves our 1B/3B surplus going on. If this deal were to happen it would make the Spring Training battle for 1B/3B a bit more interesting, I'll give you that. I'm just not totally sold on Dallas yet. It would make the battle for 1B/3B more interesting, as well as the battle for the 4th and 5th starter spots. And you have the right to be skeptical about Dallas, but the guy just had the year everyone was waiting for to prove himself. He's healthy, he's strong, and he's performed. IMO, his chance is here. Same goes for Gaby. I'd be excited.
December 3, 200817 yr Cantu>McPherson,Helms platoon... McPherson is unproven,yea he mashed the ball in AAA in a hitters park but he hasnt dont squat in ML level... Helms is only good off the bench,we all saw what he does as a starter... There's way to many people on this board that dont appreciate what Cantu did for this club last year.
December 3, 200817 yr Jonathan Sanchez-S-GiantsDec. 3 - 2:38 pm et The Giants and Marlins have reportedly discussed swapping Jonathan Sanchez and Jorge Cantu. That's be a terrific deal for the Marlins. Florida isn't necessarily looking to add an additional starter, but Cantu would be a small price to pay for someone with Sanchez's considerable upside. If the Marlins made the deal, they could use Gaby Sanchez at first and Dallas McPherson and Wes Helms at third. A deal would also free up some money to use to sign Ivan Rodriguez or another player.Source: The Associated Press Related: Dallas McPherson, Jorge Cantu
December 3, 200817 yr Cantu>McPherson,Helms platoon... McPherson is unproven,yea he mashed the ball in AAA in a hitters park but he hasnt dont squat in ML level... Helms is only good off the bench,we all saw what he does as a starter... There's way to many people on this board that dont appreciate what Cantu did for this club last year. I appreciate everything Cantu did last year. If he stayed, no biggie. But we traded possibly one of the greatest hitters ever away a year ago tomorrow, and one of the major pieces of that deal was Andrew Miller. Now we have the opportunity to grab a guy that is extremely comparable to Miller, for a guy that we can replace with a potential monster in McPherson. If we made the deal, and Sanchez and McPherson both bombed, too bad. If we made the deal and Sanchez finished with a .500 record, 4.50 ERA, and 180+ innings, and McPherson hit .260/.350/500, I'd have to say we improved this ballclub. Which scenario is more realistic? I'd have to go with the latter.
December 3, 200817 yr Jonathan Sanchez-S-GiantsDec. 3 - 2:38 pm et The Giants and Marlins have reportedly discussed swapping Jonathan Sanchez and Jorge Cantu. That's be a terrific deal for the Marlins. Florida isn't necessarily looking to add an additional starter, but Cantu would be a small price to pay for someone with Sanchez's considerable upside. If the Marlins made the deal, they could use Gaby Sanchez at first and Dallas McPherson and Wes Helms at third. A deal would also free up some money to use to sign Ivan Rodriguez or another player.Source: The Associated Press Related: Dallas McPherson, Jorge Cantu And rotoworld literally repeats my EXACT theory. Awesome :thumbup
December 3, 200817 yr Some background on Sanchez: Jonathan Sanchez misses a LOT of bats. Unfortunately, sometimes that?s because he throws too many balls. But he also induces a lot of strikeouts. And he?s primed to break out in 2009. Sanchez had an okay year in 2008, posting a 5.01 ERA. He managed 157 strikeouts in only 158 innings, although this came with 75 walks and 14 homers as well. However, Sanchez?s ERA is misleading: his 08 campaign was actually pretty good, and, more importantly, there are several signs that his 09 could be a lot better. First of all, Sanchez was somewhat unlucky to post an ERA over 5 in 2008. His FIP was an impressive 3.85, and his tRA was 4.23 (league average is 4.77). Part of the problem was his BABIP: Sanchez allowed an inordinately high .327 BABIP this season. Additionally, Sanchez gave up an extremely high amount of hits in situations in which they scored the most runs: with runners at first and third, batters were 6-for-15; with runners at second and third, batters were 6-for-13; and with the bases loaded batters were 3-for-10 (with three walks). In those three situations, batters hit a combined .395, leading to an inordinately high number of runners scoring. Furthermore, of the 14 homers that Sanchez allowed, only six were solo shots ? despite the fact that 55% of at bats against Sanchez came with no one on base. In other words, Sanchez gave up far more hits and homers with runners on base than he ?should? have, leading to a disproportionately high number of runners who reached base coming around to score. Sure enough, his 67.5% LOB% provides further evidence of this. On the bright side, Sanchez struck out almost a batter per inning over 158 innings ? not an easy feat. Despite not throwing terribly hard (his fastball averaged 91 MPH), he showed a remarkable ability to induce swings-and-misses ? in fact, batters swung and missed at 10.9% of his Sanchez?s pitches, the 9th highest total in baseball. Pitchers who induced higher rates of swings-and-misses were a who?s who of major league baseball?s best pitchers: CC Sabathia, Scott Kazmir, Ryan Dempster, Johan Santana, Cole Hamels, Edinson Volquez, and John Danks. That?s some elite company. Certainly, Sanchez threw too many balls this year (38.6%, to be exact ? league average is 36.5%), and walked too many ? 4.27 per nine innings. However, starting pitchers who can get as many swings-and-misses ? and, therefore, strikeouts ? as Sanchez are few and far between. Sanchez?s ERA was artificially inflated by his inability to ?stop the bleeding? this year ? a fact that is probably borne from a combination of inexperience and bad luck. Therefore, it?s likely that Sanchez will fare better in ?clutch? situations next season, thus lowering his ERA, perhaps considerably. He will almost certainly rack up a lot of strikeouts. And, if he can cut down on his walks ? certainly possible ? he could lower his ERA even further. However, even if Sanchez walks too many, he?ll more than make up for it with a ton of strikeouts and a respectable ERA. http://www.fangraphs.com/fantasy/index.php...onathan-sanchez
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.