January 6, 200917 yr Billy Beane - The guy who always finds studs and now used only a couple of them to get himself Matt Holliday. Just stole Giambi. Andrew Friedman - He was able to push so many right buttons that he got the freakin Rays to the World Series and now he has added a very nice lineup to his great pitching. Theo Epstein - They refuse to give players NTC's, they make smart moves and don't usually throw money at players. Admin Beinfest - It isn't his fault that the Marlins trade all their stars, does a great job of finding talent. Guy got Hanley, he just got Ceda for someone that I think sucks, Gregg. He has done so much more and hes your boy!
January 6, 200917 yr Beane should probably literally win this in a landslide... but being a Marlins board... Beinfest will get the homer votes
January 6, 200917 yr Author Beane should probably literally win this in a landslide... but being a Marlins board... Beinfest will get the homer votes this
January 6, 200917 yr no question CURRENTLY its Andrew Friedman. Over the last couple of years its Beane, but the way Friedman has built his team from the bottom up, gotta give the man props.
January 6, 200917 yr If the rays play like they did last yearor something close this year then I give it to friedman but right now its Beane for me.
January 6, 200917 yr no question CURRENTLY its Andrew Friedman. Over the last couple of years its Beane, but the way Friedman has built his team from the bottom up, gotta give the man props. The primary advantage the Rays had over the A's in that time is that Tampa consistently had really high draft picks... realistically, if you get as many as TB did, you'll dumb luck your way into quality players... let alone if you put someone (Friedman) who knows what he's doing... Beane's had lower draft picks over the past almost-decade and has put up very high quality teams because of coy trades and consistently bring in a good quantity of draft picks... plus his old "Make a closer, sell high and repeat" strategy
January 7, 200917 yr Beane should probably literally win this in a landslide... but being a Marlins board... Beinfest will get the homer votes :homer
January 7, 200917 yr I realize beane keeps his team in contention just about every year, But they haven't won a series since 1989!?!?! In the short time Theo has been in Boston he's made several key moves and has 2 rings to his credit. Since Beinfest is no longer the GM of the Marlins I couldn't vote for him.
January 7, 200917 yr I realize beane keeps his team in contention just about every year, But they haven't won a series since 1989!?!?! In the short time Theo has been in Boston he's made several key moves and has 2 rings to his credit. Since Beinfest is no longer the GM of the Marlins I couldn't vote for him. Theo has infinitely more resources than Beane does... Beane can't go out and sign a Daisuke or afford a Manny Ramirez or something...
January 7, 200917 yr Beane should probably literally win this in a landslide... but being a Marlins board... Beinfest will get the homer votes Beinfest's WS teams: 1 Beane's WS teams: 0 :thumbup
January 7, 200917 yr Beane should probably literally win this in a landslide... but being a Marlins board... Beinfest will get the homer votes Beinfest's WS teams: 1 Beane's WS teams: 0 :thumbup Half of that team wasn't constructed by Beinfest...
January 7, 200917 yr Beane should probably literally win this in a landslide... but being a Marlins board... Beinfest will get the homer votes Beinfest's WS teams: 1 Beane's WS teams: 0 :thumbup Half of that team wasn't constructed by Beinfest... How much of the Rays was constructed by Fiedman? This isn't said tounge-in-cheek, I'm curious. And I don't really understand the logic of faulting somebody for doing well, as is the case for Theo. Who's to say he wouldn't do better than Fiedman/Beinfest/Beane with their resources? Who's to say they would do aswell as Theo with his resources? Fact remains he's getting better results
January 7, 200917 yr I think Dave Dombrowski should at least get some consideration, seeing as he built the 1997 champion team, plus had a lot to do with the 2003 championship team, AND rebuilt the Tigers from worst team in baseball to AL Champs in about 4 years. Not too shabby
January 7, 200917 yr I think Dave Dombrowski should at least get some consideration, seeing as he built the 1997 champion team, plus had a lot to do with the 2003 championship team, AND rebuilt the Tigers from worst team in baseball to AL Champs in about 4 years. Not too shabby Obviously no GM is perfect, but I think getting Dontrelle and giving him that fat contract is a massive mistake plastered in the minds of Marlins fans. Doesn't mean he's not a great GM, but I couldn't see him getting many votes here as #1, if for no other reason than that.
January 7, 200917 yr Billy Beane - The guy who always finds studs and now used only a couple of them to get himself Matt Holliday. Just stole Giambi. Andrew Friedman - He was able to push so many right buttons that he got the freakin Rays to the World Series and now he has added a very nice lineup to his great pitching. Theo Epstein - They refuse to give players NTC's, they make smart moves and don't usually throw money at players. Admin Beinfest - It isn't his fault that the Marlins trade all their stars, does a great job of finding talent. Guy got Hanley, he just got Ceda for someone that I think sucks, Gregg. He has done so much more and hes your boy! FTR, Joe, I like that lineup better. Just because Aki is small and quick, doesn't mean a guy with a .320 OBP should lead off with so many other talented players in the lineup.
January 7, 200917 yr Player - Year Acquired- GM Position Players D. Navarro - 2006 - Friedman C. Pena - 2007 - Friedman A. Iwamura- 2007 - Friedman J. Bartlett- 2008 - Friedman E. Longoria- 2006- Friedman C. Crawford- 1999-LaMar B. Upton- 2002 -LaMar E. Hinske -2008- Friedman G. Gross- 2008- Friedman Rotation S. Kazmir- 2004-LaMar J. Shields- 2000-LaMar M. Garza- 2008-Friedman A. Sonnanstine- 2004-LaMar E. Jackson -2006- Friedman I would do the bullpen and bench, but It's getting late and I'm lazy... So the majority of the team was pretty much constructed by Friedman. The only players he is not resonsibe for are Crawford, Upton, Kazmir, Shields, and Sonnanstine. Those players do happen to be a big reason why the Rays were so good in '08, though...So it's a tough call on how much credit Friedman truly deserves for the team's success.
January 7, 200917 yr I think Dave Dombrowski should at least get some consideration, seeing as he built the 1997 champion team, plus had a lot to do with the 2003 championship team, AND rebuilt the Tigers from worst team in baseball to AL Champs in about 4 years. Not too shabby Obviously no GM is perfect, but I think getting Dontrelle and giving him that fat contract is a massive mistake plastered in the minds of Marlins fans. Doesn't mean he's not a great GM, but I couldn't see him getting many votes here as #1, if for no other reason than that. Yeah, that was a pretty bad move, but I don't think that should at all tarnish what he has done. Plus, it could end up working out for all we know.
January 7, 200917 yr I think Dave Dombrowski should at least get some consideration, seeing as he built the 1997 champion team, plus had a lot to do with the 2003 championship team, AND rebuilt the Tigers from worst team in baseball to AL Champs in about 4 years. Not too shabby Obviously no GM is perfect, but I think getting Dontrelle and giving him that fat contract is a massive mistake plastered in the minds of Marlins fans. Doesn't mean he's not a great GM, but I couldn't see him getting many votes here as #1, if for no other reason than that. I think the complete incompetence in building a pitching staff for Detroit has weighed him down the past couple of years, although he's certainly a great GM. It's not just Dontrelle. It's also Robertson's contract. It's also Bomberman's contract. It's overworking Verlander (his breakdown was predictable and one of the reasons to worry as a Marlins fan for 2009). It's contructed a bat sh*t bad bullpen years running. He did a great job rebuilding detroit but after two steps forward it's like he's taken one step backwards with that franchise.
January 7, 200917 yr I think Dave Dombrowski should at least get some consideration, seeing as he built the 1997 champion team, plus had a lot to do with the 2003 championship team, AND rebuilt the Tigers from worst team in baseball to AL Champs in about 4 years. Not too shabby Obviously no GM is perfect, but I think getting Dontrelle and giving him that fat contract is a massive mistake plastered in the minds of Marlins fans. Doesn't mean he's not a great GM, but I couldn't see him getting many votes here as #1, if for no other reason than that. I think the complete incompetence in building a pitching staff for Detroit has weighed him down the past couple of years, although he's certainly a great GM. It's not just Dontrelle. It's also Robertson's contract. It's also Bomberman's contract. It's overworking Verlander (his breakdown was predictable and one of the reasons to worry as a Marlins fan for 2009). It's contructed a bat sh*t bad bullpen years running. He did a great job rebuilding detroit but after two steps forward it's like he's taken one step backwards with that franchise. Although I don't follow the Tigers closely, I agree with what you say, based on what I do know. I just meant as per this poll on this site, it would hurt his chances IMO.
January 7, 200917 yr I think the complete incompetence in building a pitching staff for Detroit has weighed him down the past couple of years, although he's certainly a great GM. It's not just Dontrelle. It's also Robertson's contract. It's also Bomberman's contract. It's overworking Verlander (his breakdown was predictable and one of the reasons to worry as a Marlins fan for 2009). It's contructed a bat sh*t bad bullpen years running. He did a great job rebuilding detroit but after two steps forward it's like he's taken one step backwards with that franchise. I agree with everything said here except for the part about overworking Verlander. GM's don't make on field decisions like that. Leyland is to blame for that one. But yeah, he has taken a bit of a step back in the past year or two. He might not be the best, but he is certainly one of the best, and I felt like bringing his name up.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.