May 30, 200917 yr It's crazy seeing people wanting to call up 19 year old Stanton. Best case scenario is him being up mid season 2010, Stanton isn't ready, and this is from a guy who was rooting for the callup of Sean West before everybody else jumped on the bandwagon. People on this board are f*cking crazy at times, srsly. Some people need to understand you don't always have the best of teams, and sometimes there aren't always a quick, simple fix. We need to let time take its course, small adjustments will be made over time to make the team better, calling up an unproven player at the age of 19 is not what I would consider the "season changing move".
May 30, 200917 yr Everyone on here bashed me for saying that we should call up 19 year old Michael Stanton. Sure, it's early but he's special. He doesn't need to be babysat throughout his career. Look at the Mets playing their 20 year prospect Fernando Martinez (who isn't as good as Stanton). Hermida for the year is hitting .260 with 4 homers and 18 RBI. Give me a break. Stanton can do better than that now! Dude, you are wasting your time. This board is full of Hermida lovers who are still expecting a lefty Albert Pujols any day now. No one ever said this. And the fact people actually want Stanton now is incredibly stupid. You guys make the decisions being made now look smart, with these stupid ideas.
May 30, 200917 yr Everyone on here bashed me for saying that we should call up 19 year old Michael Stanton. Sure, it's early but he's special. He doesn't need to be babysat throughout his career. Look at the Mets playing their 20 year prospect Fernando Martinez (who isn't as good as Stanton). Hermida for the year is hitting .260 with 4 homers and 18 RBI. Give me a break. Stanton can do better than that now! Martinez has been in the minors since he was 16 i think, so hes has some minor league experience.
May 30, 200917 yr Everyone on here bashed me for saying that we should call up 19 year old Michael Stanton. Sure, it's early but he's special. He doesn't need to be babysat throughout his career. Look at the Mets playing their 20 year prospect Fernando Martinez (who isn't as good as Stanton). Hermida for the year is hitting .260 with 4 homers and 18 RBI. Give me a break. Stanton can do better than that now! Martinez has been in the minors since he was 16 i think, so hes has some minor league experience. Why does he keep bringing up people who've played in above Single-A as proof that Stanton should skip AA?
May 30, 200917 yr Author If over-rated Stephen Strausberg is going to skip ALL of the minors then Stanton COULD skip AA if he wanted to and be successful. However, I would never encourage the Marlins to do so. Instead, the Marlins SHOULD promote Stanton to AA now and then at the trade deadline when Hermida is shipped, bring him up if he's successful in AA. I'm saying trade Uggla (if anyone wants him) and Hermida at the trade deadline.
May 30, 200917 yr If over-rated Stephen Strausberg is going to skip ALL of the minors then Stanton COULD skip AA if he wanted to and be successful. However, I would never encourage the Marlins to do so. Instead, the Marlins SHOULD promote Stanton to AA now and then at the trade deadline when Hermida is shipped, bring him up if he's successful in AA. I'm saying trade Uggla (if anyone wants him) and Hermida at the trade deadline. Why would Strasburg skip all the minors?
May 30, 200917 yr Author If over-rated Stephen Strausberg is going to skip ALL of the minors then Stanton COULD skip AA if he wanted to and be successful. However, I would never encourage the Marlins to do so. Instead, the Marlins SHOULD promote Stanton to AA now and then at the trade deadline when Hermida is shipped, bring him up if he's successful in AA. I'm saying trade Uggla (if anyone wants him) and Hermida at the trade deadline. Why would Strasburg skip all the minors? Because he's that good. You see sometimes, just sometimes SPECIAL talent is special. There are exceptions. Strasberg will be drafted by the Nationals and be placed on their team right away according to anaylsts. I think it's stupid especially for a pitcher because the learning curve is much more difficult than a hitter. Going from San Diego State to the pros is like night and day. Just because you throw hard doesn't mean you are a pitcher or will have success- ask Matt "Flat Ball" Lindstrom". In Stanton's case though, he has the talent of a Griffey, Andruw Jones, etc. We could see him mid-way through the year if he gets the Double A call up.
May 30, 200917 yr If over-rated Stephen Strausberg is going to skip ALL of the minors then Stanton COULD skip AA if he wanted to and be successful. However, I would never encourage the Marlins to do so. Instead, the Marlins SHOULD promote Stanton to AA now and then at the trade deadline when Hermida is shipped, bring him up if he's successful in AA. I'm saying trade Uggla (if anyone wants him) and Hermida at the trade deadline. I beleive the nats have already said he will pitch some in the minors.
May 30, 200917 yr Author If over-rated Stephen Strausberg is going to skip ALL of the minors then Stanton COULD skip AA if he wanted to and be successful. However, I would never encourage the Marlins to do so. Instead, the Marlins SHOULD promote Stanton to AA now and then at the trade deadline when Hermida is shipped, bring him up if he's successful in AA. I'm saying trade Uggla (if anyone wants him) and Hermida at the trade deadline. I believe the nats have already said he will pitch some in the minors. He should. Then again people are saying that the Nationals can not afford him. We shall see.
May 30, 200917 yr I love only hand picking examples like Griffey and overlooking the majority of players like Wily Mo Pena that were rushed.
May 30, 200917 yr If over-rated Stephen Strausberg is going to skip ALL of the minors then Stanton COULD skip AA if he wanted to and be successful. However, I would never encourage the Marlins to do so. Instead, the Marlins SHOULD promote Stanton to AA now and then at the trade deadline when Hermida is shipped, bring him up if he's successful in AA. I'm saying trade Uggla (if anyone wants him) and Hermida at the trade deadline. Why would Strasburg skip all the minors? Because he's that good. You see sometimes, just sometimes SPECIAL talent is special. There are exceptions. Strasberg will be drafted by the Nationals and be placed on their team right away according to anaylsts. I think it's stupid especially for a pitcher because the learning curve is much more difficult than a hitter. Going from San Diego State to the pros is like night and day. Just because you throw hard doesn't mean you are a pitcher or will have success- ask Matt "Flat Ball" Lindstrom". In Stanton's case though, he has the talent of a Griffey, Andruw Jones, etc. We could see him mid-way through the year if he gets the Double A call up. He's not going to skip the minors. He might Andrew Miller his way through it, but he won't skip them.
June 1, 200917 yr If over-rated Stephen Strausberg is going to skip ALL of the minors then Stanton COULD skip AA if he wanted to and be successful. However, I would never encourage the Marlins to do so. Instead, the Marlins SHOULD promote Stanton to AA now and then at the trade deadline when Hermida is shipped, bring him up if he's successful in AA. I'm saying trade Uggla (if anyone wants him) and Hermida at the trade deadline. Why would Strasburg skip all the minors? Because he's that good. You see sometimes, just sometimes SPECIAL talent is special. There are exceptions. Strasberg will be drafted by the Nationals and be placed on their team right away according to anaylsts. I think it's stupid especially for a pitcher because the learning curve is much more difficult than a hitter. Going from San Diego State to the pros is like night and day. Just because you throw hard doesn't mean you are a pitcher or will have success- ask Matt "Flat Ball" Lindstrom". In Stanton's case though, he has the talent of a Griffey, Andruw Jones, etc. We could see him mid-way through the year if he gets the Double A call up. Andruw Jones....I'm glad you brought him up. Remember the absolutely horrendous slide he went on for the past 2 years? Guess what....he's himself again. How is it right to say that Uggla is on the decline and will never recover? I know he struggled the second half last year and he is currently struggling. However he does occasionally show glimpses of promise through his AB's. He could very easily turn the switch back on in the second half, just as quickly as it was turned off last year. He needs to learn to see the change up. That's his major flaw....that cures about 80% of pop ups, and cuts K's in half. If he learns to see the change up out of the pitchers hand, then he becomes a great hitter with a higher avg, less K's, less pop ups, and more HR's. Notice that I put avg at the front of the list and HR's at the end? Those are listed in order of importance for him and this team to be succesful.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.