Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Andre Dawson elected to HOF

Featured Replies

I get that you (Iowa) have all these memories of him playing and you love him as a player and all, but that's not one of the criteria for induction.

 

 

fortunately the criteria is simply getting enough votes.

 

 

 

FWIW, he did play in something of the "dead-ball" era too. That needs to count for something.

 

 

Dawson becomes the 10th ranked hitter (according to Rally's WAR) debuted in the 70's to make the Hall. 10 per decade seems about right, though 16 per decade seems a bit excessive for overall Hall size. [Asterisk notes not inducted.]

 

Ricky Henderson

Mike Schmidt

George Brett

Robin Yount

Paul Molitor

Lou Whitaker*

Alan Tramell*

Eddie Murray

Gary Carter

Ozzie Smith

Dwight Evans*

Keith Hernandez*

Buddy Bell*

Willie Randolf*

Dave Winfield

Andre Dawson

i dont think he played with hawk. then again who knows with some of those teams

I get that you (Iowa) have all these memories of him playing and you love him as a player and all, but that's not one of the criteria for induction.

 

FWIW, he did play in something of the "dead-ball" era too. That needs to count for something.

 

And OPS+ is designed to take into account league, era, and park.

 

He had a 119 OPS+.

 

Good for a tie for 358th all time, with immortals Mark Grace, Cliff Floyd, and Sal Bando. Below Paul O'Neill, who received 2.2% of the ballot in his one year of eligibility.

 

Yes, he stole a bunch of bases. That's great. Yeah, he hit a bunch of home runs. That's great. He was a good defensive player who's skills eroded considerably as he aged. If you want to blame that on his knees taking the pounding in Montreal, that's fine, but you shouldn't give him extra credit because he got hurt playing the game. He is the player he was, and that player has those flaws, and that player shouldn't be a hall of famer.

Not making outs is the most important thing a batter can do, and he was worse at that single thing than anyone else in the hall.

 

 

Bottom of the ninth, tied score, runner on third, 1 out. Hawk hits a deep fly ball, caught by the center fielder, runner on third comes in to score, Les Expos win the game. But Hawk should get no credit because he made an out when he should have been trying to get on base.

I think the problem is that that the writers still resort to obsolete and backwards criteria. The total number of hits and home runs are huge, as is the longevity of the career.

 

For example, just looking at Hotcorner's 70s list, Keith Hernandez had a career .384 OBP, won a MVP, won a WS, and was pretty good defensively. However, he didn't hit for power and only played 17 seasons, which prevented him from reaching the 3000 hit plateau. Arguably he had a better career than Dawson did.

 

I'm not saying Keith Hernandez should be in the Hall but Dawson has reached 75% of the votes and Hernandez never got much more than 10% (or so).

Not making outs is the most important thing a batter can do, and he was worse at that single thing than anyone else in the hall.

 

 

Bottom of the ninth, tied score, runner on third, 1 out. Hawk hits a deep fly ball, caught by the center fielder, runner on third comes in to score, Les Expos win the game. But Hawk should get no credit because he made an out when he should have been trying to get on base.

 

Ok, in that one situation, getting that specific type of out (and only that type of out, mind you. Every other out is significantly worse than getting on base) is better than getting on base.

 

You've found the like 1% of baseball situations in which an out is arguably favorable to just getting on base.

 

He averaged 7 sac flies per season for his career. THAT is what you are hanging your hall of fame hat on for the Hawk? Come on, man.

Not making outs is the most important thing a batter can do, and he was worse at that single thing than anyone else in the hall.

 

 

Bottom of the ninth, tied score, runner on third, 1 out. Hawk hits a deep fly ball, caught by the center fielder, runner on third comes in to score, Les Expos win the game. But Hawk should get no credit because he made an out when he should have been trying to get on base.

 

Ok, in that one situation, getting that specific type of out (and only that type of out, mind you. Every other out is significantly worse than getting on base) is better than getting on base.

 

You've found the like 1% of baseball situations in which an out is arguably favorable to just getting on base.

 

He averaged 7 sac flies per season for his career. THAT is what you are hanging your hall of fame hat on for the Hawk? Come on, man.

If you include his sac bunts, I think there's a strong case.

i think keith gets votes taken away for turning doc and darryl in to coke heads ;) = do former players account for anything? maddux and ryno to name a few say hes the best theyve ever seen. but what do they know

I can see the Expos but will the Hall want to give recognition to a team that basically no longer exists?

 

 

Why not?

 

BTW No one, including announcers, ever get this right. It's called the National Baseball Hall Of Fame And Museum. Everyone drops the "Museum" part. Visit the place and you would know why it has that name. Heck, a good part of Main Street could be part of the museum.

 

 

The whole reason is because the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum is split into two parts; The Hall of Fame and the Museum. I thought this was rather self explanatory. The Hall of Fame is the actual hallway where all the plaques are located, and the museum is the place where all the exhibits are. That's why you hear the announcers say Andre Dawson has been elected to the Hall of Fame, because he will get his plaque put up in the hall. So the announcers are not the ones who aren't getting it right; it's you.

Not making outs is the most important thing a batter can do, and he was worse at that single thing than anyone else in the hall.

 

 

Bottom of the ninth, tied score, runner on third, 1 out. Hawk hits a deep fly ball, caught by the center fielder, runner on third comes in to score, Les Expos win the game. But Hawk should get no credit because he made an out when he should have been trying to get on base.

 

Ok, in that one situation, getting that specific type of out (and only that type of out, mind you. Every other out is significantly worse than getting on base) is better than getting on base.

 

You've found the like 1% of baseball situations in which an out is arguably favorable to just getting on base.

 

He averaged 7 sac flies per season for his career. THAT is what you are hanging your hall of fame hat on for the Hawk? Come on, man.

If you include his sac bunts, I think there's a strong case.

 

Forgive me if I'm mistaken, but it looks like he averaged 8 sacrifices per year of any sort for his career. That's a weak ass case.

 

Also, nobody ever talks about his absolutely abysmal postseason record (albeit in just 60+ PAs, still).

I think penguino was being sarcastic, but nonetheless, I'm not basing my opinion that Dawson should be in the HOF on sacrifice flies, I'm just saying there are certain scenarios such as this when an out is not always a bad thing.

 

I will agree that it's questionable as to whether or not Dawson's statistics are HOF worthy. However, not many people realize the Hall of Fame is not all about numbers and on-field performance. It says right on the Hall of Fame website that "Voting shall be based upon the player's record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character, and contributions to the team(s) on which the player played." Hawk was a guy who was respected by his peers and his fans, and was always known as a class act and a person of great integrity, sportsmanship, and character. I think that gives him a slight edge and propels him into HOF worthiness.

I have a problem with the whole integrity/character thing when Jim Rice got in last year, and his numbers were just as questionable as Dawson's, and he was pretty much universally considered a jerk.

 

Let's have some consistency. It either counts or it doesn't.

I'm sick of all of the Saber Guys crying about Andre Dawson's OPS. He was not a steroided up freak like a lot of players are today so sure his numbers like OPS might not even be better than say Dan Uggla's. But it was a different time and Dawson was one of the best players of HIS time therefore he got into the Hall of Fame. Do I think he is in the class of Hank Aaron or Babe Ruth? No, but not many are.

I'm sick of all of the Saber Guys crying about Andre Dawson's OPS. He was not a steroided up freak like a lot of players are today so sure his numbers like OPS might not even be better than say Dan Uggla's. But it was a different time and Dawson was one of the best players of HIS time therefore he got into the Hall of Fame. Do I think he is in the class of Hank Aaron or Babe Ruth? No, but not many are.

 

 

One of his defenders on this very page showed he was the 16th best player of his time.

 

WOO.

 

I'm tired of people like you not reading what I'm posting.

 

Even relative to his peers and the time he played in, his numbers aren't that impressive, except his counting stats because he played for ever.

He's definitely not the 16th rated player out of that post. I've seen all of those guys play with my own two eyes and I would say that only six of them were better baseball players than Andre Dawson. Rickey Henderson, George Brett, Paul Molitor, Dave Winfield, Eddie Murray and Mike Schmidt were better than Dawson. Dwight Evans, Alan Trammell, Lou Whitaker, Gary Carter, Ozzie Smith, Keith Hernandez, Buddy Bell and certainly Willie Randolph were not in Dawson's league as a player.

By WAR, he is the 16th rated player in that post.

 

Ozzie Smith was absolutely more deserving of the Hall than Dawson.

By WAR, he is the 16th rated player in that post.

 

Ozzie Smith was absolutely more deserving of the Hall than Dawson.

 

 

If Andre Dawson's GM ever called the Cardinals about trading him straight up for Ozzie Smith the Cardinals would have without a doubt taken that deal.

You have a right to your opinion even if you're wrong......which you are.

 

He's probably not. It was a time when the world was completely in love with defense and he proved himself to be the greatest defensive SS in the history of the game. I highly doubt they would have done that. There's a reason that he stayed with the Cards for his entire career once he got there and brought out the defense that made him a HOFer, even after his body wore down and he slowed down. Hawk on the other hand spent time with 4 teams. There's a reason Ozzie was elected in on his first ballot and Hawk was put in on his ninth.

 

And the reason I say probably is because I don't actually know, just like you don't actually know. You're coming up with a hypothetical with absolutely nothing to back it up.

I can see the Expos but will the Hall want to give recognition to a team that basically no longer exists?

 

 

Why not?

 

BTW No one, including announcers, ever get this right. It's called the National Baseball Hall Of Fame And Museum. Everyone drops the "Museum" part. Visit the place and you would know why it has that name. Heck, a good part of Main Street could be part of the museum.

 

 

The whole reason is because the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum is split into two parts; The Hall of Fame and the Museum. I thought this was rather self explanatory. The Hall of Fame is the actual hallway where all the plaques are located, and the museum is the place where all the exhibits are. That's why you hear the announcers say Andre Dawson has been elected to the Hall of Fame, because he will get his plaque put up in the hall. So the announcers are not the ones who aren't getting it right; it's you.

 

The first part I've been rethinking. Now I think they may want to. And actually, there is a presedence(sp) set. Gary Carter.

 

The second part, I see your reasoning, even with the poor jab at me. But I'm talking about when they are speaking of the building. It's always the National Baseball Hall Of Fame. FWIW, I say HOF when talking of a player being elected, or players that are in. So I guess I am getting it right. They aren't.

Every year, same-o same-o. A group of fans don't agree with who was left out so they bash the ones that did. The writers deemed him worthy, the guys he played with/against have always said he should be in there, the current HOFers have said (one even in his introduction ceremony) he should be in there. Some fans say he shouldn't. You pick who is right.

 

I was surprised Hawk was the only one to make it. I thought at least Blyleven and Alomar would get in with him. I do think Alomar was penalized for the spitting incident. Heck, I was talking to friends about the election and one that dosen't even follow baseball heard his name and asked if that was the guy that spit at someone. So, it is remembered. But both get in next year. And next year there will be more complaints.

  • Author

Every year, same-o same-o. A group of fans don't agree with who was left out so they bash the ones that did. The writers deemed him worthy, the guys he played with/against have always said he should be in there, the current HOFers have said (one even in his introduction ceremony) he should be in there. Some fans say he shouldn't. You pick who is right.

 

I was surprised Hawk was the only one to make it. I thought at least Blyleven and Alomar would get in with him. I do think Alomar was penalized for the spitting incident. Heck, I was talking to friends about the election and one that dosen't even follow baseball heard his name and asked if that was the guy that spit at someone. So, it is remembered. But both get in next year. And next year there will be more complaints.

 

 

They both almost got in.

 

72 for Alomar (spitting incident and those dumb as writers who never vote for the 1st time probably caused this)

74 for Blylevin (probably got a bit less because those votes went to Dawson or Alomar.

You have a right to your opinion even if you're wrong......which you are.

 

He's probably not. It was a time when the world was completely in love with defense and he proved himself to be the greatest defensive SS in the history of the game. I highly doubt they would have done that. There's a reason that he stayed with the Cards for his entire career once he got there and brought out the defense that made him a HOFer, even after his body wore down and he slowed down. Hawk on the other hand spent time with 4 teams. There's a reason Ozzie was elected in on his first ballot and Hawk was put in on his ninth.

 

And the reason I say probably is because I don't actually know, just like you don't actually know. You're coming up with a hypothetical with absolutely nothing to back it up.

 

The best defensive shortstop ever is still playing....with the Chicago White Sox. It's Omar Vizquel. He is a better player than Ozzie Smith was so get his bust in Cooperstown ready.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.