January 6, 201016 yr Except comparing a SS' ops to an OF isn't really the same standard. Also: .323 OBP for his career. If you're judging strictly by position, then yeah, I guess he set a new standard for outfielders. But I don't think position is of top priority when it comes to the voters unless you're Ozzie Smith good with the glove.
January 6, 201016 yr Congrats to Hawk the Marlins first player elected!!! Shame Blyleven didn't get in he only threw more shutouts in his career than have been thrown by the entire American League in the last 18 seasons(Source Gammons)I wonder if the spitting incident didn't effect Alomar some? So who's the next Marlins player elected? Tim Raines? Gary Sheffield? Trevor Hoffman? My guess Mike Piazza!!!
January 6, 201016 yr Some massive stupidity occurred today. I like Hawk and all and think that he might deserve to be in the HOF, but two much better candidates missed it.
January 6, 201016 yr Hey, Davey Johnson, how do you feel about Alomar not making the HOF? Rabb is right, Blyleven once again gets robbed of his rightful HOF spot, and Alomar should've easily been a first ballot HOFer.
January 6, 201016 yr Alomar got HOSED however happy for Dawson Larkin will make it eventually as well
January 6, 201016 yr Congrats to Hawk the Marlins first player elected!!! Shame Blyleven didn't get in he only threw more shutouts in his career than have been thrown by the entire American League in the last 18 seasons(Source Gammons)I wonder if the spitting incident didn't effect Alomar some? So who's the next Marlins player elected? Tim Raines? Gary Sheffield? Trevor Hoffman? My guess Mike Piazza!!! Piazza then maybe Raines
January 7, 201016 yr Dawson's been a longtime baseball hero of mine, so I'm happy to see he made it in to the Hall. And I'm a bit perplexed about Blyleven and Alomar not making it in. Thought they deserved it too.
January 7, 201016 yr Dawson's stats may not impress most, but his achievements impress me. He's one of only 3 members of the 400 HR-300 SB club (Bonds and Mays of course), 8x Gold Glove winner, 8x All-Star, 4x Silver Slugger, NL MVP and ROY.
January 7, 201016 yr If Roberto Alomar got inducted he would probably be wearing a University of Pennsylvania hat on his plaque.
January 7, 201016 yr I'm really happy for The Hawk. I think he deserved it. I think Alomar and Blyleven will be in and deserve to be but I never liked Alomar even before he spit on Hirshbeck.
January 7, 201016 yr I think Alomar didn't get in because of a handful of baseball writers who are tools and don't like to induct "just anybody" on the first ballot. Blyleven was damn close and he'll probably make it next year. Major congrats to Hawk though. The 400 HR/300 SB club, that only Hawk, Mays and Bonds are members of, seals the deal for me. That's a damn good ballplayer no matter how you slice it. If not for the invention of AstroTurf, and the damage it did to his knees, Andre probably would have had even more stolen bases. ...and if not for that bogus policy of not letting the player decide which cap goes on his plaque, who knows, he just may have gone in with a "F" on his cap. I hope they make him an Expo.... Maybe Hanley gets in years from now and has a good 'ol "F" on his cap.
January 7, 201016 yr I think Alomar didn't get in because of a handful of baseball writers who are tools and don't like to induct "just anybody" on the first ballot. Blyleven was damn close and he'll probably make it next year. Major congrats to Hawk though. The 400 HR/300 SB club, that only Hawk, Mays and Bonds are members of, seals the deal for me. That's a damn good ballplayer no matter how you slice it. If not for the invention of AstroTurf, and the damage it did to his knees, Andre probably would have had even more stolen bases. ...and if not for that bogus policy of not letting the player decide which cap goes on his plaque, who knows, he just may have gone in with a "F" on his cap. I hope they make him an Expo.... Maybe Hanley gets in years from now and has a good 'ol "F" on his cap. That "bogus policy" is the reason Wade Boggs doesn't have a Devil Rays cap in the HOF. It would be stupid for Hawk to go in wearing our cap.
January 7, 201016 yr My unpopular opinion of the day: Cal Ripken Jr. is not a HOFer. Yeah, I can't get on board with this. Redefined the SS position and was basically an .800 OPS bat for his career, while retiring with the most home runs for his position in history (I believe). Yeah, the streak overrates him, but he was absolute a hall of famer. No he didn't. He basically redefined the work ethic of MLBers. Because of his streak, what it meant to bseball at that time, his lack of using chemicals to achieve what he did, and his popularity, had he NOT been inducted riots would have broken out. Literally. Cal is a HOFer for reasons that don't come out in the numbers. Pretty much like Hawk. Things stats people don't like to admit are there but those in and very close to the game say are just as important. Guess who I side with. I'll give my congrats to Hawk next time I see him. And we have always said when he is inducted we will be attending. Late July in upstate NY is a beautiful time of year (not to mention a pretty good time not to be here). And Cooperstown is a georgous little community.
January 7, 201016 yr I think Alomar didn't get in because of a handful of baseball writers who are tools and don't like to induct "just anybody" on the first ballot. Blyleven was damn close and he'll probably make it next year. Major congrats to Hawk though. The 400 HR/300 SB club, that only Hawk, Mays and Bonds are members of, seals the deal for me. That's a damn good ballplayer no matter how you slice it. If not for the invention of AstroTurf, and the damage it did to his knees, Andre probably would have had even more stolen bases. ...and if not for that bogus policy of not letting the player decide which cap goes on his plaque, who knows, he just may have gone in with a "F" on his cap. I hope they make him an Expo.... Maybe Hanley gets in years from now and has a good 'ol "F" on his cap. That "bogus policy" is the reason Wade Boggs doesn't have a Devil Rays cap in the HOF. It would be stupid for Hawk to go in wearing our cap. Agreeing with Rab here. If ours was even a choice then so should Bostons. He's being inducted for his playing days, not his FO days. I thought it was totally up to the Hall which cap he wears. From what I understand after reading some articles, he does have some say in it. It will be an interesting decision. I can see the Expos but will the Hall want to give recognition to a team that basically no longer exists? I can see the Cubs because of winning the MVP on a last place team and also because of the popularity of that team. BTW No one, including announcers, ever get this right. It's called the National Baseball Hall Of Fame And Museum. Everyone drops the "Museum" part. Visit the place and you would know why it has that name. Heck, a good part of Main Street could be part of the museum.
January 7, 201016 yr Dawson's stats may not impress most, but his achievements impress me. He's one of only 3 members of the 400 HR-300 SB club (Bonds and Mays of course), 8x Gold Glove winner, 8x All-Star, 4x Silver Slugger, NL MVP and ROY. And he garnered those awards on some awful teams too.
January 7, 201016 yr Ripken wasn't that good defensively. He "revolutionized" the position because he probably should have been playing elsewhere. Ripkin played an excellent SS, I mean he wasn't as rangy or as atheletic as Ozzie or Trammell but he played so smart he was always in position. Probably one of the smartest infielder to ever play the game
January 7, 201016 yr i shed a tear when i heard the news. hes the reason i am a fish fan today. long overdue. i suggest the detracters read starks article before looking stupid because you are indeed an idiot if you think he is lowering the bar. congrats to one of the most feared players of his time... one of the original 5 tool players and one of the classiest players this game will ever see. ill be making the trip to see him inducted . long overdue. first the hawks win and then the hawk gets in. a good week
January 8, 201016 yr I think Alomar didn't get in because of a handful of baseball writers who are tools and don't like to induct "just anybody" on the first ballot. Blyleven was damn close and he'll probably make it next year. Major congrats to Hawk though. The 400 HR/300 SB club, that only Hawk, Mays and Bonds are members of, seals the deal for me. That's a damn good ballplayer no matter how you slice it. If not for the invention of AstroTurf, and the damage it did to his knees, Andre probably would have had even more stolen bases. ...and if not for that bogus policy of not letting the player decide which cap goes on his plaque, who knows, he just may have gone in with a "F" on his cap. I hope they make him an Expo.... Maybe Hanley gets in years from now and has a good 'ol "F" on his cap. That "bogus policy" is the reason Wade Boggs doesn't have a Devil Rays cap in the HOF. It would be stupid for Hawk to go in wearing our cap. I agree it wouldn't be quite right for Hawk to go in as a Marlin, but if anyone wanted to use a team they only played for for a few seasons, he might have the best case, being born and raised in Miami and all. Shame about Boggs, would have been awesome to see that horrible gradient-oval cap logo the Rays had back then in the Hall lol.
January 8, 201016 yr Would you like to post the article you alluded to? Though I doubt it will change mine or any detractors minds. He may have been feared, but he also had a tremendous amount of flaws in his game. The Hall of Fame shouldn't be a place for deeply flawed players, no matter what else they may have done well. He was below league average in on base percentage in 14 of the 21 seasons he played. He (along with Jim Rice, who shouldn't have gone in) was the definition of a "Very good, not great" player. I almost think Blyleven is in this category, except he had 9 seasons of an ERA under 3, 60 shut outs, and is like 5th all time in Ks. He was very very good, and the fact that he was able to pitch so long so effectively gets him over. Look, it sucks that Andre Dawson's knees stopped working in, like, 84' and he had to play on sh*tty knees for the rest of his career. He put up pretty good numbers despite that, but he also might have the lowest OBP of anybody in the hall. If he hadn't gotten hurt, I have no doubt he would be in the hall of fame. But the HOF isn't the place for "what ifs". And yes, I know Kirby Puckett is in, but that wasn't related to baseball, so I think it's a completely different case. If Mike Schmidt had taken to Andre Dawson's knees with a bat like Tonya Harding and Nancy Kerigan, then yeah, you give him the benefit of the doubt. But sometimes baseball players get hurt, and they can't reach their full potential, and that is sad, but you don't get extra points because of it. Not making outs is a really, really important part of baseball, and frankly Andre Dawson was terrible at this. That should have been enough to keep him out. I get that you (Iowa) have all these memories of him playing and you love him as a player and all, but that's not one of the criteria for induction.
January 8, 201016 yr Good for the Hawk, glad to see he made it in. Would like to have seen Larkin get in but there's that 1st-timer thing...
January 8, 201016 yr kurkijan not starks. wrong espn dork. perception. 75 percent of people think he should be in. 100 percent of former players think he should be in. but he didnt walk! maybe the hawk should be more patient so darryl smith could drive in runs. maybe jerome walton. sounds right
January 8, 201016 yr kurkijan not starks. wrong espn dork. perception. 75 percent of people think he should be in. 100 percent of former players think he should be in. but he didnt walk! maybe the hawk should be more patient so darryl smith could drive in runs. maybe jerome walton. sounds right What's that you say? He was absolutely terrible at the single most important thing a batter can do in an at bat? But he played with guys named Darryl Smith and Jerome Walton! Hall of fame! You can dress it up however you want. Say it wasn't "his job" to get on base". Say that he had bad players around him so there was no point in getting on base. However you want to go, is fine. But it's dumb to think that. Not making outs is the most important thing a batter can do, and he was worse at that single thing than anyone else in the hall.
January 8, 201016 yr find me one former player who doesnt think hes a hall of famer. baseball nerds are the worst. form an opinion yourself by watching instead of looking at paper. the guy was amazing
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.