Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins Issue Statement On Leaked Financial Information

Featured Replies

MiamiLifer247, your numbers are wrong. I'm just taking a quick break from a movie night so I'm not going to check them right now but the Marlins net income was $29M that year.

 

That said, their net income was $3.9M last year and the team overall is $61M in debt, negative equity.

 

Also, the fact that Double Play, which is the business which is in the contract with the County and City (as opposed to Florida Marlins LP) doesn't mean he's pocketing money at all. I believe it's Double Play that is paying for the stadium, so it'd make sense for money to go from Florida Marlins LP to Double Play.

 

 

 

Double Play would have no product/service to sell. So their only means of income would be monies "funneled" into it from the parent company. What I would wonder is what exactly is Double Play paying for? I would think everything related to getting the new pond completed. All research, the campaigning for it, the lawyers, the drawings, anything related to bringing the right people in to advise. That would most likely include hotels and food. The list just goes on and on. Things most people don't even realize that goes into a lengthy campaign that the Marlins went on to get this approved. IOW, it's a huge money pit.

I would have to assume that when Loria and Co took over in 2002 they inherited whatever existing debt there was. (...) Same reasoning I would use to think MLB accepted responsibility for the Expos debts when they took over that team from Loria.

 

This is most likely the case.

 

First, let me try to clear up a point about debt on the books versus the accumulated partner's loss of $61 million as there isn't necessarily any close relationship between them.

 

For instance, assume that Loria originally formed Expos, LP with 20 million of contributed partner capital and the partnership then borrowed 30 million and bought the Expos for 50 million (which he actually did, the financing split is assumed by me.) If the Expos then lost 30 million (assumed by me) over 3 years and the losses were financed by borrowing another 30 million, their capital account would stand at -10 million, but total debt would be 60 million. This would not be unlike the Marlins current partners' capital deficit of 61 million versus current debt of 113 million. Point being that cumulative losses don't necessarily bear any relationship to total debt.

 

Loria then acquired the Marlins (including all assets and liabilities) for 158.5 million (which he actually did) made up of 120 million for assets and liabilities of the Expos plus a loan of 38.5 million from MLB.

 

It probably qualified as a tax-free swap of similar assets under Section 1031, negating most (but not all) of the tax due on the gain of 70 million (just an aside for you tax geeks out there.)

 

I'm not quite sure why MLB would pay 120 million for the Expos other than that any goofy actual MLB franchise was worth at least that much because it could be moved elsewhere. Or maybe Loria has pictures of Bud.

 

In any case, at this point we really have no idea of how much Expo debt was assumed by MLB. Nor do we have any idea of how much Marlin debt was assumed by Loria. We do know that the Marlins still owe 21 million on a note due to "Baseball Expos, LP" (MLB and its 29 MLB partners,) so some of the Expo debt is still around and obviously all of the Expo debt wasn't assumed.

 

And we know one other thing. Loria needed a loan from MLB of 38.5 million to make the deal happen. Which would lead one to conclude that Loria probably assumed more debt than he got rid of, and needed a cushion to get through the years needed to pay it off. Gosh, imagine that. An MLB franchise is supposed to make a profit so it can pay its debts and provide a return to the people who provided the capital that enables it to exist.

 

It seems that there's a pretty fair chance that most of the 61 million of accumulated partner losses was either accumulated since 2002 or accumulated before 2002 by previous Marlins' owners and then assumed by Loria.

 

Any way you slice that pie, the return on the money invested in the Marlins has sucked canal water for decades.

This whole thing is just f***ing ridiculous. Ignorant people in the media are just making it worse. Accomplished players like Dontrelle Willis? Yeah how's he doing now? Jorge Cantu? Where would he fit into our future?

I think what's funny is seeing all these "reporters" talk about this issue as if they actually followed the team. If the herald or sentinel picked up somebody who actvely followed the Marlins I doubt the statement about Willis and Cantu ever get published.

I think what's funny is seeing all these "reporters" talk about this issue as if they actually followed the team. If the herald or sentinel picked up somebody who actvely followed the Marlins I doubt the statement about Willis and Cantu ever get published.

 

 

Yea this is my biggest problem... when the media makes false statements about the team and then I, as the resident Marlins expert in my family, my workplace, etc... I get asked the most asinine questions by people who never cared anything about the Marlins beforehand.

 

Im sick of people coming up to me and asking why the Marlins lost the great Cody Ross who in their minds was apparently the untouchable MVP of the planet, even though they never went to a game this year. Im sick of people coming to me to tell me the Marlins losing Cantu was a huge mistake, while at the same time they've never heard of Stanton or Morrison. I'm sick of people telling me that the Marlins had a "firesale" after the 2003 championship, apparently they missed the 2004 and 2005 seasons. And now I'm sick of people who never once cared about the team having a stadium, suddenly coming to me and basically accusing ME, as a Marlins fan, of being part of a franchise that lies about their finances. My response is often something like: unless you really cared about the Marlins before you heard that false media report that brought you to me, mind your business because I dont wanna waste my time explaining it to you.

I would like to see a statement from the Marlins on why team president Samson has told outright, demonstrable lies as recently as last week.

I remember when the story broke about Scott rothstein his friends and people in his circle were saying, he is to good a man and care to much about s fla, it is all lies, his lawyers were saying the lying media don't know what their are writing about and in the end the truth will come out and he will be free, then the same lawyers and Scott plea bargain and is spending fifty years in the country club, i'm so glad i cancel my season tickets, " Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me"

I remember when the story broke about Scott rothstein his friends and people in his circle were saying, he is to good a man and care to much about s fla, it is all lies, his lawyers were saying the lying media don't know what their are writing about and in the end the truth will come out and he will be free, then the same lawyers and Scott plea bargain and is spending fifty years in the country club, i'm so glad i cancel my season tickets, " Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me"

 

No idea how that has anything to do with this. We're the ones who actually have the proof in front of us.

 

You kind of remind me like one of those people who's "just been hurt too many times and has forgotten how to love!".

Meh, don't read much into this statement. The team has always twisted things around to make themselves sound better rather than admit some misdeeds, as they should. Loria likes to make a profit, and sometimes I believe, like many other have speculated for years, that Loria pockets some of the money made.

 

The financial records in no way shows that Loria actually pocketed the money, but it can somewhat be assumed based on Loria's character and history.

 

I don't claim to be an expert on this matter, this is simply an opinion of mine.

 

 

You understand the financial reports would have been checked by a CPA, right? That the CPA would have to assure that expenses Double Play met the criteria for management fees? For Loria to somehow pocket the money without a paper trail would mean he'd have to defraud the CPA too. Kind of makes your claim seem ridiculous.

The idea that Revenue sharing cannot be used to pay down debt is asinine. Money is fungible, if the team pays down debt at all, the argument could be made that revenue sharing money is used for it.

 

 

This is a problem in non-profit and government contracting. It's solved by applying necessary matching funds. States and municipalities call them by another term: un(der)funded mandates.

Isnt there still some contention that a large portion, if not most(and if not all) of the debt is from the previous ownership of Montreal?

 

 

That would seem unlikely. Only way to know is to see past year's statements. We can attempt to estimate the P/L figures. Forbes has already made their own estimates and show significant losses from the 2002-07 Marlins.

 

An easy to back into the profit/loss figures is to pick a few variables to change and assume everything else has remained equal. In 2009 and 2008 the net income was $3.9 and $29.4 million. Average that out to $16.7 million.

 

Let's change one variable. One we know that revenue sharing was not always on average $46 million per year. The Marlins received an average of $21 million in 2002 and 2003. (See http://sports.espn.g...tory?id=1803536) Let's assume that revenue sharing was closer to $21M than $46M during the pre-2008 period. (A fair assumption considering that 2008 marks the year the Expos/Nats went from payee to payor and the first year the Yankees and Mets went back to full payors after being allowed to use their contributions towards their new stadiums.) Therefore, in the prior periods we now assume not a $16.7 million profit that 2008-9 might suggest for the prior periods, but a $8.3 million loss. (16.7 - (46-21))

 

Now let's change another variable on top of that. In 2008 and 2009 the media reported an "Opening Day payroll" of $22 and $35 million for an average of $29 million. Between 2002 and 2007 the average was $39 million (2007: 30.5, 2006: 15, 2005: 60.5, 2004: 42, 2003: 45, 2002: 42 according to Cots' Contracts. USA Today has similar, if not higher, numbers. (See http://content.usato...ts.aspx?team=20)). So we adjust our profits down $10 million from a $8.3 million loss to a $18.3 million loss. (16.7 - (46-21) - (39-29))

 

Again this is a simplified analysis. However, one that's necessary if one hopes to extrapolate anything from the data about the prior years. These two variables are the only things we adjust for. Not attendance, not stadium design costs, not amateur player bonuses, not ticket prices, not anything else.

 

So after changing just 2 of the variables we can estimate that for the 6 years there were losses of $18.3 million each year. 6 years of $18.3 million losses equals $109.8 million of debt entering into the 2008 season. That's $109.8 million of Marlins-era debt. $76.4 million when you add back in the 2008 and 2009 profits.

 

Is it then unreasonable to think that all or most of the $61 million debt came from Loria's investments in the Marlins? Forbes' estimates didn't think so either (and their system is a bit more complicated).

Meh, don't read much into this statement. The team has always twisted things around to make themselves sound better rather than admit some misdeeds, as they should. Loria likes to make a profit, and sometimes I believe, like many other have speculated for years, that Loria pockets some of the money made.

 

The financial records in no way shows that Loria actually pocketed the money, but it can somewhat be assumed based on Loria's character and history.

 

I don't claim to be an expert on this matter, this is simply an opinion of mine.

 

 

You understand the financial reports would have been checked by a CPA, right? That the CPA would have to assure that expenses Double Play met the criteria for management fees? For Loria to somehow pocket the money without a paper trail would mean he'd have to defraud the CPA too. Kind of makes your claim seem ridiculous.

 

Ridiculous like a fox.

Debt is NOT the sum of accumulated losses.

 

What are you trying to say here?

 

Just what I wrote.

 

An entity can take on debt for many reasons.

 

For investment in, say, a new ballpark.

 

Or to cover operating loses.

 

Or to make a distribution to a partner to pay off a divorce settlement.

Debt is NOT the sum of accumulated losses.

 

What are you trying to say here?

 

Just what I wrote.

 

An entity can take on debt for many reasons.

 

For investment in, say, a new ballpark.

 

Or to cover operating loses.

 

Or to make a distribution to a partner to pay off a divorce settlement.

That's not what you wrote. What you wrote could have alluded to that but I can't know that.

 

I don't pretend to understand all this stuff all that well but the financials do show that the debt was there before the ballpark agreement and I don't know where the divorce settlement thing comes from.

Debt is NOT the sum of accumulated losses.

 

What are you trying to say here?

 

Just what I wrote.

 

An entity can take on debt for many reasons.

 

For investment in, say, a new ballpark.

 

Or to cover operating loses.

 

Or to make a distribution to a partner to pay off a divorce settlement.

That's not what you wrote. What you wrote could have alluded to that but I can't know that.

 

I don't pretend to understand all this stuff all that well but the financials do show that the debt was there before the ballpark agreement and I don't know where the divorce settlement thing comes from.

 

It seems like you are on Loria payroll, i hope it don't blowup in your face.

Debt is NOT the sum of accumulated losses.

 

What are you trying to say here?

 

Just what I wrote.

 

An entity can take on debt for many reasons.

 

For investment in, say, a new ballpark.

 

Or to cover operating loses.

 

Or to make a distribution to a partner to pay off a divorce settlement.

That's not what you wrote. What you wrote could have alluded to that but I can't know that.

 

I don't pretend to understand all this stuff all that well but the financials do show that the debt was there before the ballpark agreement and I don't know where the divorce settlement thing comes from.

 

It seems like you are on Loria payroll, i hope it don't blowup in your face.

How so? I wish I was though, working in baseball would be awesome.

Well, there's at least one idiot and one pure troll on this thread.

 

I've about reached my limit for courteous explanations, so I'll leave it to degenerate into whatever.

God c'mon guys give this crappola a rest. We have no idea what those 2002-07 financials are.

 

At this point, "Who cares ?" Lets just drop it, because the more everyone talks about it, it looks like you are just talking about it until you believe it. It is, what it is, and we know the Marlins are $ 61 million in the deficit department, and Loria will use that excuse to not extend the payroll in the new stadium. We all know that will happen. So lets just go on and make the best of it and forget about the $ and ¢ of it.

 

Lets get back to talking baseball ! :thumbup

Loria will use that excuse to not extend the payroll in the new stadium.

 

I was wrong. There are two trolls.

Why as soon as one don't buy what Loria is selling they are trolls, if you are saying i'm a troll, from 2005 i had a four season tickets package, so i think i'm entitle to say what i want.

Why as soon as one don't buy what Loria is selling they are trolls, if you are saying i'm a troll, from 2005 i had a four season tickets package, so i think i'm entitle to say what i want.

 

That's kind of hypocritical of you. Why is it that as soon as one believes what the financial reports say instead of what the mob mentality they are on Loria's payroll?

 

Also, everyone's entitled to their opinion, it's the beauty of freedom. I personally don't think you're a troll, I just think you're wrong.

Why as soon as one don't buy what Loria is selling they are trolls, if you are saying i'm a troll, from 2005 i had a four season tickets package, so i think i'm entitle to say what i want.

 

That's kind of hypocritical of you. Why is it that as soon as one believes what the financial reports say instead of what the mob mentality they are on Loria's payroll?

 

Also, everyone's entitled to their opinion, it's the beauty of freedom. I personally don't think you're a troll, I just think you're wrong.

 

Nothing wrong with that, we all are entitled to our opinion and with that i will let the chips fall how their may, i'm finish with this thread,

Why as soon as one don't buy what Loria is selling they are trolls, if you are saying i'm a troll, from 2005 i had a four season tickets package, so i think i'm entitle to say what i want.

 

 

Did you mean:

 

"Why is it that as soon as one does not buy what Loria is selling they are considered to be trolls? If you are saying I'm a troll, know that since 2005 I have had 4 season ticket packages. Being as such, I am entitled to say what I want"

 

My response:

 

You certainly are entitled to say whatever you want, it just is not good debate to accuse those who disagree with you to be "on Loria payroll". To me, it appears most of your argument has consisted of blind denial of the facts presented to us through the financial reports.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.