September 18, 201016 yr Phil Jackson is overrated. The reason he has so many rings is because basketball is a game highly impacted by stars, and he's gotten the opportunity to "coach" the best player in the league...twice. Not to mention the great talents around Jordan/Kobe, as well. :lol Red Auerbach is overrated because he had Bill Russell. Riley is overrated because he had Magic and Kareem. Give me a break.. this statement, is and always will be,one of the most asinine, ridiculous statements ever. I thought you were smarter than that. Agreed...there are some real dummies out there for coaches that couldn't handle those title teams.
September 18, 201016 yr Ozzie would be the best. I'd love this team so much with his loud-ass mouth on it.
September 18, 201016 yr Yea.. opinions on message boards are stupid. For the most part, yes they are. But I find it funny when people are adamant about managers in real life, on the radio, or on message boards. Nothing to do with just message boards. Also, can you post about how much you want Ozzie to be the manager again?
September 18, 201016 yr only problem i have is owner could treat Ozzie as their did with Fred both were with marlins before
September 18, 201016 yr I still wonder if the Marlins will wait until 2012 before thinking of a new manager. But I don't know, that's a large list to choose from and I think regardless of what manager we get, if we don't have the pitching and bullpen (and other holes filled in), we're not going to be a good team next year. I didn't even realize Joe Torre was in connection with the Marlins
September 18, 201016 yr Author Yea.. opinions on message boards are stupid. They're only stupid when your opinion is that coaching is overrated, right?
September 18, 201016 yr Torre never did anything before he went to the Yankees and he just left the Dodgers and they have a losing record.
September 18, 201016 yr Yea.. opinions on message boards are stupid. They're only stupid when your opinion is that coaching is overrated, right? huh?
September 18, 201016 yr Author Torre never did anything before he went to the Yankees and he just left the Dodgers and they have a losing record. I agree with this. Hell, the media thought hiring Torre was a huge mistake, he was known as Clueless Joe. But in his first year he took the Yankees all the way! Not some rookie shortstop who was on base all the time, but Joe Torre!
September 18, 201016 yr Author Yea.. opinions on message boards are stupid. They're only stupid when your opinion is that coaching is overrated, right? huh? I'm not sure how to clarify.
September 18, 201016 yr I think that its kinda lame to come in to a thread about who you want as manager and pretty much dismiss everybody's opinion because you don't think it matters.. but whatever.
September 18, 201016 yr Author I think that its kinda lame to come in to a thread about who you want as manager and pretty much dismiss everybody's opinion because you don't think it matters.. but whatever. And what if you do think it matters, like Erick, but that it doesn't matter as much as is said. I frankly believe that Jackson is indeed overrated, as are most coaches\managers. I'm not saying he wasn't good, but way too much is made on him being their leader as opposed to the players being really good. He has Jordan, he wins 3. Jordan leaves, he wins zero, Jordan comes back and he wins 3, Jordan leaves, he goes to where Kobe and Shaq are, he wins 3. Kobe and Shaq start to fight, he wins zero (leadership!). Years pass, they put more players around Kobe, he wins 2. I believe Red Auerbach is indeed overrated because it wasn't all about his leadership, it was about having 5 of the top 50 greatest players of all time. I mean, how many did Auerbach win without Russell? I'll give you a hint, it's none. And what happened after Auerbach left? They won another 2 with Russell as a player-coach. Russell himself never made a very good head coach, so they basically won 2 championships without a head coach. Because I believe that am I not smart? Also it's worth noting that I, who started this tread, don't think the difference between managers are that big so I basically agree with Bobbob. I was just interested in seeing what everyone else thinks. I personally like Ozzie just because I think he'll keep things interesting off the field.
September 18, 201016 yr Well, i couldnt disagree more. I think coaches and managers are integral parts to a team. Great players and great coaches go hand-in-hand, IMO. More so in basketball and football than baseball.. which is why I list what Ozzie can bring to the team outside of baseball, which is what you pointed out.
September 18, 201016 yr Has Torre been mentioned anywhere as a possible candidate for the Marlins? I do think managers matter to a certain extent. I prefer managers who seem like they actually have a brain inside their heads. Fredi Gonzalez was lacking in this capacity. I dislike people like Ozzie Guillen and Bobby Valentine for this reason as well. They seem like idiots to me. People seem to like Guillen because he's "funny" and says what he wants; people like Valentine because he wore a disguise once. These aren't things I look for in a manager. Ozzie Guillen is pretty much the Latino version of Kenny Powers. I'd love to get Torre, but I think money will be an issue. I wanted Showalter this season too. I like these types of managers.
September 18, 201016 yr I can't wait for Ozzie to bat Bonifacio lead off and bunt with Logan Morrison in the first inning.
September 18, 201016 yr Torre never did anything before he went to the Yankees and he just left the Dodgers and they have a losing record. But you know what? He STILL got the Dodgers to the playoffs for 2 years straight after he left the Yankees. So what if he didn't do anything before the Yanks? They hadn't gotten into the ALCS for a long time until Torre got there in 96. [i would say Playoffs but 95 they got Wild Card]. They hadn't won a world series since the 70s before Torre got there. So to say that TORRE is overrated would definitely be stretching things. Just my opinion.
September 18, 201016 yr People always seem to misinterpret the meaning of overrated, but whatever. Anyway, I believe coaching in the NBA is overrated. I believe coaching in general is overrated, but it means the least in the NBA. I could tell you who's going to be in the NBA Finals right now, and the season hasn't even started. If Pat Riley doesn't fire him over a loss, Erik Spoelstra will be looking like a genius for the next handful of years. I'd look like a genius too with certain NBA teams. If you ask me, the best coach in the NBA isn't Phil Jackson; it's Greg Popovich, and I think you can make a case for Jerry Sloan, as well. They've won consistently (at least made the playoffs) with lesser talented teams. Coaching in the NFL is most important; in the NHL they're important too because there are systems to follow, in order to win games, consistently. MLB I believe I can be a big league manager; I will say it's more important than being an NBA coach, though. At least ML managers have signs, and have to make certain moves that can impact a game. The NBA is a game that is impacted greatly by superstars. It's not difficult to call isolation plays for a superstar, which is what most coaches do late in games, when they have a star. I'd look like a genius, too.
September 18, 201016 yr I can't wait for Ozzie to bat Bonifacio lead off and bunt with Logan Morrison in the first inning. By the way, this would happen with Ozzie Guillen. It's the type of player he was, and it's the type of manager he is. It's the reason why Omar Vizquel plays 3rd base and hits 2nd for the White Sox. Players like Bonifacio (especially if Bonifacio ever learns to do the "little things" like bunt, consistently) would get a lot of playing time under Ozzie Guillen. My brother is good friends with Guillen (his son went to Pace), and you'd be surprised who his favorite players to manage have been.
September 18, 201016 yr I'd be interested to know who you think the white sox should bat 2nd and play 3rd Beckham was penciled in to bat 2nd but was brutal this year... they have nobody else to put there. Vizquel isn't having a bad year and is a great defender. Ozzie likes to run.. with coghlan, hanley, stanton, boner and maybin all potentially starting and with plus speed, we will be very dangerous on the base paths. I don't see it as a negative.
September 19, 201016 yr I'd be interested to know who you think the white sox should bat 2nd and play 3rd Beckham was penciled in to bat 2nd but was brutal this year... they have nobody else to put there. Vizquel isn't having a bad year and is a great defender. Ozzie likes to run.. with coghlan, hanley, stanton, boner and maybin all potentially starting and with plus speed, we will be very dangerous on the base paths. I don't see it as a negative. If you aren't running efficiently, then it's a negative.
September 19, 201016 yr No clue if the organization has any interest but I'll throw up another vote for Erik Wedge. He had some solid success with young a team built similar to the current Marlin's. Dealt with a penny-pinching front office. He'd be cheap which is always a factor with this front office and I don't remember him having any problems with the team or players, always seemed like a good guy who knew what he was doing. If he's completely out of the question I wouldn't mind Ozzie simply because he'd get some of the spotlight on the Marlin's. Obviously he's not going to sell tickets himself but at least he'll get people looking and if we have a good early run might speed up the process it takes to get some of the more casual fans in the stadium. Would be a timebomb waiting to go off though between him and the front office. Tony Pena and Admin Bowa would also be an excellent choices.
September 19, 201016 yr Because I believe that am I not smart? Also it's worth noting that I, who started this tread, don't think the difference between managers are that big so I basically agree with Bobbob. I was just interested in seeing what everyone else thinks. I personally like Ozzie just because I think he'll keep things interesting off the field. I get what Iowa is saying here. He's not saying it's stupid to have the opinion that coaching does not matter, or that it is overrated. He was commenting on the way bobbob1313 dickishly came into the thread dismissing the idea by saying it's funny. But, of course, I've come to expect nothing less of bobbob1313.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.