Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

What needs to change

Featured Replies

He had a 1.51 WHIP and a 3.87 ERA in 09 in less than half of a season, so I wouldn't say he was better then.

Anibal was definitely better last year.

And Ricky's been better this year.

 

But even when Anibal was better last year, he was just as likely to have a bad start as Ricky, which was what I was referring to.

Not sure I can agree that Nolasco and his ERA over 5.00 in 2009 is more preferable than Sanchez's high WHIP and lower ERA. I mean, yeah, Sanchez had less starts, but isn't that the year that Nolasco even got sent down for a little while because he was being smacked around?

Not sure I can agree that Nolasco and his ERA over 5.00 in 2009 is more preferable than Sanchez's high WHIP and lower ERA. I mean, yeah, Sanchez had less starts, but isn't that the year that Nolasco even got sent down for a little while because he was being smacked around?

 

 

 

 

At best, I'll say it's a push. One guy was better, but threw 100 fewer innings, and his success was highly flukey. I'm not going to say Sanchez pitched better than him.

When I make the type of evaluation I think you are trying to make, I don't think the IP weighs very heavily. A pitcher is always more valuable when he can throw more innings, but performance-wise (rate statistics) Nolasco didn't have much to offer that season (although--if memory serves me right--Nolasco did improve a bit after being sent down.)

 

Generally speaking, Sanchez when healthy seems to be a better pitcher than Nolasco when healthy. To Sanchez's credit, the shoulder problems seem to be behind him. However, Nolasco's peripherals have improved a bit since last year. Strikeouts are down, but his FB% and HR/9 rates are down too, which have probably helped him keep a lower ERA. If he keeps this up he might put the 2009-2010 problems behind him.

After he was sent down, he went 22 GS with 144 IP And a 3.82 ERA.

 

He had 8 terrible starts to begin the year, which certainly should count against him, but Id probably take that season over 80 innings at 3.8 ERA.

1) The owner needs to spend money - and I don't mean spending it on rejects and pieces of sh*t... 2) Get a damn good CFer, 3Bman and 2 very good starting pitchers (Keep Ani as the #4 pitcher, get rid of Jeckyll & Hyde Nolasco, and figure out #5 later) ... For those that don't think a strong, deep rotation is necesary, look at the Phillies who are on pace for their best season ever... If you want to beat the best, put out a team that can beat them

 

I don't see Coghlan and Infante as long range parts of this team, so trade them, put Boner at 2B

 

p.s. Get Wes Helms the f*** out of here already

 

 

What's your favorite video game?

 

 

Knock off the bulls***, you are not a f***ing know-it-all, your opinions are not "Gospel" in here...this team has holes to fill, and this team needs to spend money... you really think patching a few holes with so-so players is gonna put this team at the top? The Phillies have a monster rotation, the Braves got better and the Nationals will be very scary in a year or two... We need another pitcher who is at JJ's level of talent, Anibal is good but inconsistent and Nolasco's schizo mound performance is getting old

I honestly think if we signed Crisp, Fielder, and CJ Wilson we still wouldn't have a shot in hell at the Phillies... that f***ing team :cussing

1) The owner needs to spend money - and I don't mean spending it on rejects and pieces of sh*t... 2) Get a damn good CFer, 3Bman and 2 very good starting pitchers (Keep Ani as the #4 pitcher, get rid of Jeckyll & Hyde Nolasco, and figure out #5 later) ... For those that don't think a strong, deep rotation is necesary, look at the Phillies who are on pace for their best season ever... If you want to beat the best, put out a team that can beat them

 

I don't see Coghlan and Infante as long range parts of this team, so trade them, put Boner at 2B

 

p.s. Get Wes Helms the f*** out of here already

 

 

What's your favorite video game?

 

 

Knock off the bulls***, you are not a f***ing know-it-all, your opinions are not "Gospel" in here...this team has holes to fill, and this team needs to spend money... you really think patching a few holes with so-so players is gonna put this team at the top? The Phillies have a monster rotation, the Braves got better and the Nationals will be very scary in a year or two... We need another pitcher who is at JJ's level of talent, Anibal is good but inconsistent and Nolasco's schizo mound performance is getting old

I dunno where the venom is coming from here, being a gamer i was actually curious to hear your response.

 

This team needs some f***ing consistency, across the board, in order to be better. Consistency with health, offense, defense, records at home, f*** even which concession stands are open.

If JJ craps out again next season then I think we should move him.

Boni at 2nd, he can definitely play ball.

Cogs..eh...at least not in CF. His arm isn't strong enough, coupled with bucks Conga line to 2nd (and i like Buck) it just compounds the problem.

Could we get some guys from Japan or something? I don't know the rules but maybe if pitching is at a premium here we should shop elsewhere.

more Coco Crisp and Lance Berkman (if not Fielder or Pujols), less Wes Helms

 

...the advantage of signing Pujols would be more than the 7 WAR. take the 4-6 games against the Cards where he single-handedly kills us and we have a 10+ win player

 

 

Are you going to help Loria rob the bank it will take to do that ?

Coghlan's problem is not that he is an unproven hitter, it is that he is made of glass. He's been quite effective when not hurt, which in the past 3 seasons has amounted to about 4 months. He will not stay healthy in CF, and there is not other spot for him with Sanchez on the team.

 

C: Buck

1B: Sanchez

2B: Bonifacio

3B: Dominguez (face it, they are giving him a shot)

SS: Ramirez

LF: Morrison

CF: Coghlan

RF: Stanton

 

That is what I expect, and I expect to be unhappy about it.

 

That lineup is not winning a playoff spot next year, even if healthy all year. Loria does that and a lot of people will stop going to that stadium starting the 2nd year. What a wasted opportunity for him.

It really doesn't matter whether or not he's fully healthy; even if he is, he's likely not the answer in CF. I don't see any reason to believe that he can handle the position, long-term. We need a CF'er.

 

There's nothing special about Coghlan's offense, but at least that portion of his game is passable if you put him at another position where he's more likely to stay healthy/play better defense.

 

2nd base or has his chance there passed by because of so much time ? Can he regain his 2nd base skills ?

What needs to happen next year for the Marlins to compete:

 

The Phillies and Braves are abducted by aliens.

 

But seriously, the Marlins organizational philosophy is to simply hope that their guys get better and everyone else gets worse while adding some cast off role players during the offseason. If this team wants to compete, they need to improve drastically through free agency. You have the best two teams in the league in your division. Either be aggressive and honest about improvement, or expect more of the same crap next year - division doormats.

 

Ouch, and I agree completely.

Guys like Edwin Jackson, whom the Marlins will probably consider, will be just as frustrating at times and just as costly.

 

Pitching in the NL has become more common lately, but it's still a challenge to find consistent, durable, quality arms at an affordable price.

 

I generally subscribe to the "grow the arms" philosophy. Looking at the 2012 FA class and you can see why; there just aren't many viable options there.

 

Then we need to get better at developing our own pitching. When was the last time a legitimate top 2 of the rotation pitching prospect was drafted and developed by our system ? JJ ? That's been 5 years ago now.

 

Is that all scouting & developement coaching ? Are we spending enough there and how about getting some of the Atlanta staff here, they seem to be able to do that better than most teams in MLB (or at least it seems that way). Also Latin America, was Cabrera the last one we developed from there ? That is pretty piss-poor if it is.

Ok here is the plan. Trade Gaby Leo and a prospect to Tampa for Bj Upton then sign Michael Cuddyer, Cj Wilson and Edwin Jackson.

Team looks something like this.

 

CF Upton

3B Cogs

SS Hanley

RF Mike

1B Lomo

LF Cuddyer

C Buck

2B Boni

P JJ

 

1 JJ

2 CJ

3 Edwin

4 Anibal

5 Ricky

 

LR Badenhop

MR Choate

MR Mujica

SU Webb

CL Dunn

 

Looks good to me eh?

Trading Gaby (who has the second highest WAR on the team behind Stanton) makes no sense when we could just sign Coco Crisp...

+ Leo's solid enough to not trade because he probably wouldn't bring back anything that'd help the team immediately

 

no good

Coco Crisp. Talk about wasting money on cast offs. There is a reason he's played for every team in the league. Besides Gaby is probably our most replaceable player next to infante or whoever is playing CF or 3B on a given night. I'd much rather have the upside of Upton than waste money on a Coco Crisp.

1) The owner needs to spend money - and I don't mean spending it on rejects and pieces of sh*t... 2) Get a damn good CFer, 3Bman and 2 very good starting pitchers (Keep Ani as the #4 pitcher, get rid of Jeckyll & Hyde Nolasco, and figure out #5 later) ... For those that don't think a strong, deep rotation is necesary, look at the Phillies who are on pace for their best season ever... If you want to beat the best, put out a team that can beat them

 

I don't see Coghlan and Infante as long range parts of this team, so trade them, put Boner at 2B

 

p.s. Get Wes Helms the f*** out of here already

 

 

What's your favorite video game?

 

 

Knock off the bulls***, you are not a f***ing know-it-all, your opinions are not "Gospel" in here...this team has holes to fill, and this team needs to spend money... you really think patching a few holes with so-so players is gonna put this team at the top? The Phillies have a monster rotation, the Braves got better and the Nationals will be very scary in a year or two... We need another pitcher who is at JJ's level of talent, Anibal is good but inconsistent and Nolasco's schizo mound performance is getting old

I agree with all, especially the Nationals. If we don't get on the ball, we could be cellar dwellers for a while. The Mets have better management, the Nationals do too, and they seem to be stockpiling good players, and the Phillies and the Braves are the Phillies and the Braves. Its could get very depressing even with a new stadium.

Logan Morrison you damn rock. Funny how everyone wants the team to improve but doesn't want to move our very average first baseman when we have another one playing out of position in left field making this team even weaker. So in terms of a trade yeah Gaby is pretty replaceable. I mean Lomo is the future right.

Logan Morrison you damn rock. Funny how everyone wants the team to improve but doesn't want to move our very average first baseman when we have another one playing out of position in left field making this team even weaker. So in terms of a trade yeah Gaby is pretty replaceable. I mean Lomo is the future right.

the same Logan Morrison who's a worse hitter than Gaby Sanchez and can hardly hold his ground in left field should be the first baseman of this team, getting the ball thrown to him every single play? sounds solid.

Yeah Logan Morrison who is 4 years younger has way more talent and is a natural 1B and he would be our everyday 1B if we has any outfield depth at all. If Gaby finishes out with a .280 ave and atleast 20 Hr he must get shipped in the off season unless we want a repeat of this season which it sounds like you do.

Coco Crisp. Talk about wasting money on cast offs. There is a reason he's played for every team in the league. Besides Gaby is probably our most replaceable player next to infante or whoever is playing CF or 3B on a given night. I'd much rather have the upside of Upton than waste money on a Coco Crisp.

 

Gaby is the most replaceable player out of the 8 position players..............except for the other 3 more replaceable players.

Gaby is replaceable because we have Lomo to step in for him. The other three positions not so much.

But we do not have anyone to step in in LF. Cuddyer is going to be cost prohibitive and likely just as bad as Lomo defensively, while only being moderately better than Gaby offensively. It's a sideways move without the upside of keeping both Gaby and Lomo.

 

Why spend money on Cuddyer? Why not spend money on a CF?

 

Oh, right, because Coco Crisp has played for 4 teams in 10 years, so he must suck.

Coco Crisp does not make this team better. A veteran outfielder a talented centerfielder and two more quality SPs do so whatever it takes to do that. I'm in

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.