Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

What needs to change

Featured Replies

Keep in mind that a ~.710 OPS is the NL average. Coghlan might be below our expectations and yet still end up an above-average bat.

 

 

That's respectable if he could play some defense.

I don't know if he'll be anything other than terrible defensively out in CF, long-term.

 

I'm not worried about his offense. He's likely a ~mid-700's .OPS guy at the end of the day, which is fine. Even in his terrible year so far this year, he was still hitting RHP well, at the very least.

Keep in mind that a ~.710 OPS is the NL average. Coghlan might be below our expectations and yet still end up an above-average bat.

 

His OPS over the last two seasons is .695. He can probably break the .710 mark, but his defense is poor enough in CF that I would not be satisfied with his level of production.

1) The owner needs to spend money - and I don't mean spending it on rejects and pieces of sh*t... 2) Get a damn good CFer, 3Bman and 2 very good starting pitchers (Keep Ani as the #4 pitcher, get rid of Jeckyll & Hyde Nolasco, and figure out #5 later) ... For those that don't think a strong, deep rotation is necesary, look at the Phillies who are on pace for their best season ever... If you want to beat the best, put out a team that can beat them

 

I don't see Coghlan and Infante as long range parts of this team, so trade them, put Boner at 2B

 

p.s. Get Wes Helms the f*** out of here already

1) The owner needs to spend money - and I don't mean spending it on rejects and pieces of sh*t... 2) Get a damn good CFer, 3Bman and 2 very good starting pitchers (Keep Ani as the #4 pitcher, get rid of Jeckyll & Hyde Nolasco, and figure out #5 later) ... For those that don't think a strong, deep rotation is necesary, look at the Phillies who are on pace for their best season ever... If you want to beat the best, put out a team that can beat them

 

I don't see Coghlan and Infante as long range parts of this team, so trade them, put Boner at 2B

 

p.s. Get Wes Helms the f*** out of here already

 

 

What's your favorite video game?

Perception is a funny thing. Nolasco and Anibal are essentially the same as far as consistency goes, only Nolasco doesn't have the very troubling injury history, and yet Nolasco gets killed and Anibal doesn't.

His declining strikeout rate is far more concerning than his "consistency issues." Either way, you're not going to find many starters better than Nolasco available in free agency. He's worth keeping and so is Anibal.

Nolasco definitely has a place in the rotation, but in 2012 the Marlins could use a #2 pitching at the same level that Vazquez has been for the last several weeks if they think that they want to compete against the Braves and Phillies.

Quality starts have their issues as a stat, but it does a well enough job of showing consistency. In 24 starts this year, Nolasco has 16 quality starts, Anibal has 14.

 

Last year, in 26 starts, Nolasco had a 61% QS%, compared to 62% for Anibal.

 

Anibal is no more consistent than Nolasco. It's silly to say otherwise.

Guys like Edwin Jackson, whom the Marlins will probably consider, will be just as frustrating at times and just as costly.

 

Pitching in the NL has become more common lately, but it's still a challenge to find consistent, durable, quality arms at an affordable price.

 

I generally subscribe to the "grow the arms" philosophy. Looking at the 2012 FA class and you can see why; there just aren't many viable options there.

CJ Wilson needs to be the #1 target, and they need to go all out. Beyond that, try to convince Vazquez to come back for $4-5 mil, and failing that, Livan for $2-3.

JJ

CJ

Anibal

Nolasco

Livan

 

That's a good rotation. You've at least got something there that's going to compete - but, sadly, I think this is going to deplete all of the FA money we'd have, and there are still holes in 2B, 3B and CF (less if you count on Bonifacio being good for a whole season, and if you believe Dominguez's defense will offset his offense.)

 

At the very least, we can all agree that we need a CF'er and a good #2 starter.

Assuming we go up to $85 million, which would be in line with the "middle of the road" estimates everyone talks about, we could make this work (Hat tip to lou for arbitration estimates):

 

 

C John Buck $6,500,000

1B Gaby Sanchez $420,000

2B Emilio Bonifacio $1,750,000 (arb estimate)

3B Matt Dominguez $410,000

SS Hanley Ramirez $15,000,000

LF Logan Morrison $420,000

RF Mike Stanton $420,000

CF Coco Crisp $6,000,000

B Brett Hayes $420,000

B Mike Cameron CF $2,000,000 (Fa estimate)

B Bryan Peterson $420,000

B Veteran 3B $2,000,000 (Fa estimate)

B Veteran MI $1,000,000 (Fa estimate)

 

SP Josh Johnson $13,750,000

SP Ricky Nolasco $9,000,000

SP Anibal Sanchez $8,000,000 (arb estimate)

SP Wilson $11,000,000 (Fa estimate)

SP Livan Hernandez $2,500,000 (fa estimate)

RP Edward Mujica $1,500,000 (arb estimate)

RP Randy Choate $1,500,000

RP Ryan Webb $430,000

RP Mike Dunn $420,000

RP Burke Badenhop $1,250,000 (arb estimate)

RP Steve Cishek $420,000

RP Jose Ceda $420,000 (Fa estimate)

 

$85,030,000

 

I like that team.

That payroll ain't happeneing...and I don't want Livan here, he is washed up. But as a #5,...eh...really want Javy back but seems not happening...

The year before the Twins' new park opened, they were at $65 million, they jumped to $95 million in their first year. It would be in line with everything they've said, and recent MLB history.

yeah what needs to change is you need your ace healthy and your superstar to show up.

 

They definitely need to target a frontlne starter like Wilson. That is where any available money needs to go, followed by CF.

 

Logan and Stanton should improve a bit with more experience. Bonifacio at least looks like he can hold down a position, I might be okay with him at 2B if Dominguez can take the 3B job.

Any kind of pitching. I'm more worried about our starting rotation than I am about our starting lineup.

 

I don't trust Nolasco one bit. He's always due for a major implosion very other start that gives us automatic losses. He'll be with the team, but I'd trade him next trade deadline when we're out of it again and his value is highest. Get a really good starting 5, and we'll be one step closer to being a playoff team. Long term (even short term) we can't survive having JJ injured for extended periods of time, nor can we survive with the poor Nolasco starts mixed with the mixture of the Hensley's, Volstad's, Sanabia's, Hand's, etc... masquerading as 5th starters. You don't technically need a decent 5th starter to succeed, but given this team's limitations, I think we need above average players at all 5 starter spots to win.

It really doesn't make sense to say that our biggest need is starting pitching, yet we should a trade a guy who's arguably our second best starter and under contract for the next two years?

 

The only way Nolasco should be traded is if the return is nice.

 

His terribly bad starts are frustrating to watch, but he's difficult to replace, at the end of the day.

  • Author

Once again I think its been shown that losing ricky and anibal is stupid. It just doesn't make any sense. We aren't going to get much in return for them. I would love to get a guy like Wilson but I think that's pretty far fetched. But who knows. At least ricky eats up innings too. Haven't been able to say that for JJ yet....

Perception is a funny thing. Nolasco and Anibal are essentially the same as far as consistency goes, only Nolasco doesn't have the very troubling injury history, and yet Nolasco gets killed and Anibal doesn't.

 

 

 

Quality starts have their issues as a stat, but it does a well enough job of showing consistency. In 24 starts this year, Nolasco has 16 quality starts, Anibal has 14.

 

Last year, in 26 starts, Nolasco had a 61% QS%, compared to 62% for Anibal.

 

Anibal is no more consistent than Nolasco. It's silly to say otherwise.

 

 

That was in the context of comments related to "consistency."

 

Also, cool that if you go back exactly one year further, it becomes 100 for Ricky vs. 107 for Anibal, with a 232 IP advantage.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.