Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

What needs to change

Featured Replies

Gaby Sanchez is at maximum value and completely replaceable.

 

 

Trading him for a more expensive player who is close to free agency in BJ Upton is not the rift way of getting Max value for him. That's just limiting our ability to add pitching.

 

I don't think you trade Gaby, but if you do, it's for cost controlled young pitching. That's all.

Gaby Sanchez is at maximum value and completely replaceable.

 

 

Trading him for a more expensive player who is close to free agency in BJ Upton is not the rift way of getting Max value for him. That's just limiting our ability to add pitching.

 

I don't think you trade Gaby, but if you do, it's for cost controlled young pitching. That's all.

 

 

I agree, with the caveat that I would also accept a promising young OF.

Yeah Coco Crisp is a good player just not a game changer. Trading Gaby for a high ceiling pitcher and a couple of moderate prospects is fine. My off season moves along with moving Gaby would be signing CJ Wilson, Edwin Jackson and like an Edwin Encarnacion at 3B. Then move cogs to 2B and Stick Boni in CF. I'd like a team like that.

Yeah Coco Crisp is a good player just not a game changer. Trading Gaby for a high ceiling pitcher and a couple of moderate prospects is fine. My off season moves along with moving Gaby would be signing CJ Wilson, Edwin Jackson and like an Edwin Encarnacion at 3B. Then move cogs to 2B and Stick Boni in CF. I'd like a team like that.

 

 

We want to win next year.

 

 

Also, Coghlan AND Bonifacio is a bad idea. We don't know what we're going to get out of either of them next season, and you're OK trading Gaby Sanchez for prospects that won't help us next season?

 

Coco Crisp and CJ Wilson make this a better team than that thing you're suggesting.

The two best CF'ers on the team (Bonifacio, Stanton) are guys the Marlins don't seem to care to put in CF, long-term.

Payroll needs to change. It's really that simple.

 

We have a really really solid core group of cost-controlled players. If we can sign a couple of FA's to 3 year deals or so, it would make the world of difference. Then after that time is up, Stanton & Co. will be making the big bucks and hopefully our farm system will be stocked by then.

 

Good news is - all signs point to a higher payroll. At least north of 80MM. Possibly more.

I can see Wilson getting something like 5 years / $80 million and I don't see the Marlins offering that.

 

 

John Lackey was considered one of the best starting pitchers in the AL for 8 years, and was consistently an around ~200 IP per year guy when he got a 5/80+ contract.

 

I don't think a guy with two years experience starting gets that.

So ez to fix this team. Convince CC to opt out and sign him and CJ Wilson. Then sign rollins to play 2b, move hanley to 3rd and sign jose reyes to ss. Put boni in center. Compensate them with hookers, mikes hard lemonade, and croquetas.

 

 

Ahhh the life of a major league player...

  • Author

I'm not seeing a free agent pitcher making more than JJ. How would that look?

Yeah Coco Crisp is a good player just not a game changer. Trading Gaby for a high ceiling pitcher and a couple of moderate prospects is fine. My off season moves along with moving Gaby would be signing CJ Wilson, Edwin Jackson and like an Edwin Encarnacion at 3B. Then move cogs to 2B and Stick Boni in CF. I'd like a team like that.

 

Edwin Encarnacion is terrible. He's never been above a 2.0 WAR - he's a bad fielder and nothing special with the bat.

And there's no way we can afford to sign CJ Wilson and Edwin Jackson, since Ricky is getting a good bit of money, JJ gets a lot of money, and Ani will be making a good amount whether or not we extend him. It's too much money for SP.

Yeah, poopooing Coco Crisp and then saying we should sign Edwin Encarnacion is super super silly. I meant to say that earier, thanks for remind me.

I'm not seeing a free agent pitcher making more than JJ. How would that look?

 

like the team wants to win?

The two best CF'ers on the team (Bonifacio, Stanton) are guys the Marlins don't seem to care to put in CF, long-term.

 

What would you think about Stanton in center and Petersen in right? Petey definitely has a good enough arm.

And if we trade Gaby, we can of course put LoMo at 1st and Cogs back in left.

So ez to fix this team. Convince CC to opt out and sign him and CJ Wilson. Then sign rollins to play 2b, move hanley to 3rd and sign jose reyes to ss. Put boni in center. Compensate them with hookers, mikes hard lemonade, and croquetas.

 

:lolup

How much do you think Jose Reyes will make in FA?

 

I saw a report of 8/$126 million. Was that credible ?

The two best CF'ers on the team (Bonifacio, Stanton) are guys the Marlins don't seem to care to put in CF, long-term.

 

What would you think about Stanton in center and Petersen in right? Petey definitely has a good enough arm.

And if we trade Gaby, we can of course put LoMo at 1st and Cogs back in left.

That sounds interesting. But I worry about trading Gaby. and keepng LoMo and that being the case of keeping the wrong player. LoMo's drop in BA this year is troubling to me. Hasn't Gaby's bat been more consistent over the last two years ?

The two best CF'ers on the team (Bonifacio, Stanton) are guys the Marlins don't seem to care to put in CF, long-term.

 

What would you think about Stanton in center and Petersen in right? Petey definitely has a good enough arm.

And if we trade Gaby, we can of course put LoMo at 1st and Cogs back in left.

That sounds interesting. But I worry about trading Gaby. and keepng LoMo and that being the case of keeping the wrong player. LoMo's drop in BA this year is troubling to me. Hasn't Gaby's bat been more consistent over the last two years ?

Logan's a lot younger.

I think we need to keep Gaby, LoMo and Stanton long term. They will all be very productive players for years to come if just given the time to settle into their careers. I am for keeping Hanley and JJ as well. The rest of the team is expendable.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.