October 19, 201115 yr Why does Mike Greenberg keep saying he can't say "Suck for Luck" on the air on Mike and Mike? :huh
October 19, 201115 yr I also agree that we can't just throw out his worst game. As an aside, I do think there are a lot of factors that point to the Ravens game being quite an anomaly - Mangold was out and the Ravens were just destroying Colin Baxter and the rest of the O-line, and the Jets got behind early so he had to throw right into the league's top scoring defense when they knew he was going to be throwing. While that is true, I was just making the point that his rating has been dragged down by an outlier. If he doesnt have anymore of those games, then by seasons end his rating will be much higher. The Jets have had their fair share of problems this year... However, Mark Sanchez is not one of them.
October 19, 201115 yr Sure, the Ravens game was an outlier against a tough defense. He also combined for 367 yards against the two worst passing defenses in the NFL, so I think it's stupid to bring up that Ravens game.
October 19, 201115 yr Sure, the Ravens game was an outlier against a tough defense. He also combined for 367 yards against the two worst passing defenses in the NFL, so I think it's stupid to bring up that Ravens game. I am not arguing the strength of the defenses they've played. The point being made was about QB rating. It wouldn't have mattered if the Ravens were ranked 1st or last. With that said, QB rating isn't the best indicator of how well a QB is playing. I've said that before many times on here. In the New England game, a game you inferring he had a poor game based on his passing yards, he finished with a qb rating higher than Tom Brady. He isn't a top tier QB, but he also isn't as bad as biased fans are making him out to be.
October 20, 201115 yr But Tom Brady played against a much worse defense than he did. Do you not get that?
October 20, 201115 yr With that said, QB rating isn't the best indicator of how well a QB is playing. Do you have a better indicator?
October 20, 201115 yr With that said, QB rating isn't the best indicator of how well a QB is playing. Do you have a better indicator? I dont think there is a single clear cut indicator. Its a combination of them, plus actually watching games. Kyle Orton is a good example of that. On paper, it seemed like he was putting up decent stats. That doesn't take into account that he was 12-22 as a starter for Denver and the fact that a lot of his yardage came when the team was behind by several scores. Are comebacks or making big plays in the 4th quarter worth more than making plays in the 1st? I think so, but the QB rating doesn't account for that.
October 20, 201115 yr With that said, QB rating isn't the best indicator of how well a QB is playing. Do you have a better indicator? I dont think there is a single clear cut indicator. Its a combination of them, plus actually watching games. Kyle Orton is a good example of that. On paper, it seemed like he was putting up decent stats. That doesn't take into account that he was 12-22 as a starter for Denver and the fact that a lot of his yardage came when the team was behind by several scores. Are comebacks or making big plays in the 4th quarter worth more than making plays in the 1st? I think so, but the QB rating doesn't account for that. Doesn't ESPN's new total QBR take that into account?
October 20, 201115 yr There may not be a single indicator that tells you whether a QB is good or not, but QB rating does a better job than most. I also feel fairly confident that this... That doesn't take into account that he was 12-22 as a starter for Denver ...is an absolutely dreadful way to judge a quarterback's competence. The Denver Broncos were dead last in the NFL in yards per game and points per game defensively last year. They are 28th and 31st in the NFL this year, respectively. The year he had a pretty decent defense, they finished 8-8.
October 20, 201115 yr There may not be a single indicator that tells you whether a QB is good or not, but QB rating does a better job than most. I also feel fairly confident that this... That doesn't take into account that he was 12-22 as a starter for Denver ...is an absolutely dreadful way to judge a quarterback's competence. The Denver Broncos were dead last in the NFL in yards per game and points per game defensively last year. They are 28th and 31st in the NFL this year, respectively. The year he had a pretty decent defense, they finished 8-8. I disagree with you. Finding ways to win is quite possibly the most important thing, IMO. Granted football is a team game, but the QB has by far the biggest impact on the field. Tom Brady had a great year last year despite having one of the worst defenses in the NFL. If your team is losing every game and a QB is picking up yards and tds when the game is out of reach, that does not make him a good QB. While the QB rating may be the best indicator out there, it does not take account for this.
October 20, 201115 yr With that said, QB rating isn't the best indicator of how well a QB is playing. Do you have a better indicator? I dont think there is a single clear cut indicator. Its a combination of them, plus actually watching games. Kyle Orton is a good example of that. On paper, it seemed like he was putting up decent stats. That doesn't take into account that he was 12-22 as a starter for Denver and the fact that a lot of his yardage came when the team was behind by several scores. Are comebacks or making big plays in the 4th quarter worth more than making plays in the 1st? I think so, but the QB rating doesn't account for that. Doesn't ESPN's new total QBR take that into account? It does, but it over values some of the 4th quarter stuff. Tim Tebows 79 yard performance last week rated higher than Aaron Rodges 300+ yards 3td performance. In week one, they had McNabb's 39 yard, 2int game rated higher than some QBs who played pretty good.
October 20, 201115 yr There may not be a single indicator that tells you whether a QB is good or not, but QB rating does a better job than most. I also feel fairly confident that this... That doesn't take into account that he was 12-22 as a starter for Denver ...is an absolutely dreadful way to judge a quarterback's competence. The Denver Broncos were dead last in the NFL in yards per game and points per game defensively last year. They are 28th and 31st in the NFL this year, respectively. The year he had a pretty decent defense, they finished 8-8. I disagree with you. Finding ways to win is quite possibly the most important thing, IMO. Granted football is a team game, but the QB has by far the biggest impact on the field. Tom Brady had a great year last year despite having one of the worst defenses in the NFL. If your team is losing every game and a QB is picking up yards and tds when the game is out of reach, that does not make him a good QB. While the QB rating may be the best indicator out there, it does not take account for this. QB rating doesn't account for those things, you're right. QB record doesn't account for anything at all that actually has to do with how a QB plays. So yeah, it's a stupid way to judge a QB's performance.
October 20, 201115 yr There may not be a single indicator that tells you whether a QB is good or not, but QB rating does a better job than most. I also feel fairly confident that this... That doesn't take into account that he was 12-22 as a starter for Denver ...is an absolutely dreadful way to judge a quarterback's competence. The Denver Broncos were dead last in the NFL in yards per game and points per game defensively last year. They are 28th and 31st in the NFL this year, respectively. The year he had a pretty decent defense, they finished 8-8. I disagree with you. Finding ways to win is quite possibly the most important thing, IMO. Granted football is a team game, but the QB has by far the biggest impact on the field. Tom Brady had a great year last year despite having one of the worst defenses in the NFL. If your team is losing every game and a QB is picking up yards and tds when the game is out of reach, that does not make him a good QB. While the QB rating may be the best indicator out there, it does not take account for this. QB rating doesn't account for those things, you're right. QB record doesn't account for anything at all that actually has to do with how a QB plays. So yeah, it's a stupid way to judge a QB's performance. You are right, making plays that win games are a stupid way to judge QBs. Chad Henne was the star of that Browns game with a rating of 90. I guess it doesnt matter how he finished that game.
October 20, 201115 yr Is it possible to play poorly and win a game? Is it possible to play well and lose? A quarterback is on the field less than half of the time, generally. Yes, it's absolutely stupid to judge a quarterback based on w/l record. Yes, sometimes a QB will play well and lead his team to a win. But it's certainly not always the determining factor. QB rating absolutely tells you more about whether a QB played well than whether his team won or not. It's absolute insanity to suggest other wise.
October 21, 201115 yr Olin Kreutz is walking away from the Saints saying he has lost passion for the game. I wish the Bears would have handled him better in the offseason but it looks like it was a good move in hindsight. A great Bear and one of my all-time faves.. a future HOFer.
October 22, 201115 yr Lmao, did anyone hear the radio interview between Mike Francesa and Darelle Revis?
October 22, 201115 yr So are you guys worried you might actually beat Denver this week? Yes :nailbite But I figure the Colts will beat Jacksonville once and win one other game. And St. Louis only has 2 or 3 games left that they have no chance of winning. So the Dolphins should be ok with one loss. I suppose I should worry about the one win teams too. But until the Dolphins lose, they don't matter. Are you going to the game in London Schnellders?
October 22, 201115 yr So are you guys worried you might actually beat Denver this week? Yes :nailbite But I figure the Colts will beat Jacksonville once and win one other game. And St. Louis only has 2 or 3 games left that they have no chance of winning. So the Dolphins should be ok with one loss. I suppose I should worry about the one win teams too. But until the Dolphins lose, they don't matter. Are you going to the game in London Schnellders? Unfortunately I cant as I have to attend a course on Monday morning that if I went to London for the game, I couldnt get back up in time for.
October 22, 201115 yr There's been a lot of talk about the Bears leaving too late in the weekend compared to the Bucs. Hoping for a good game.. super happy that Earl Bennett is finally back. So what's the wager Schnellders?
October 23, 201115 yr There's been a lot of talk about the Bears leaving too late in the weekend compared to the Bucs. Hoping for a good game.. super happy that Earl Bennett is finally back. So what's the wager Schnellders? What terms do you have in mind?
October 23, 201115 yr Will Tebow or the Dolphins get a louder cheer when they announce the starting lineups?
October 23, 201115 yr This weeks Dolphins game is a win-win for me. If we win, we squash the Tebust love. If we lose, still all aboard the suck for Luck train.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.