October 24, 201115 yr If we don't end up with the 1st pick and can't work a trade for it, we trade down, acquire more picks and draft either Barkley or Jones. No matter what we're getting a potential franchise QB after this season. The new coach is going to want a QB to build the team around who is "his guy". I doubt they trade down. They probably wouldn't want to risk not getting their guy. If they have the #2 pick, for example, they'll just pick whoever they like better out of Barkley and Jones. Otherwise, it's far too risky that some other team will either draft the QBs or trade up to do so. If we learned anything last year it's that teams are going to get the QB they want, and they're going to get him early. They would rather gamble that they can get a guy who can man the ship for years rather than maybe make a better "value" pick at the spot. I don't think the Dolphins can take the risk of trading down if they think highly of either Barkley or JOnes and either is available.
October 24, 201115 yr I think it might be around 3 first round picks, possible 4. And no, it wouldn't. The Raiders may have helped shaped the market. They sent a first and conditional second for an average QB. If the Rams get the first pick, I think 3-4 first rounders is very possible. BTW if the Rams get the 1st pick, what's to say they dont trade Bradford and his contract? That contract's physically untradeable. No team would take it on given the current rookie wage scale and the depth of QB's in this years draft class. And you saying we'd all look like assholes for wanting to get a good QB, you know Matt Barkley, Landry Jones, Brandon Weeden, Robert Griffin III, Kirk Cousins, and Nick Foles aren't "OMG THIS IS AWFUUUUUUUL"reaction worthy, right? We've been saying this for a while. Most of us obviously want Luck, but nobody's going to cry if we get the 2nd or 3rd pick, can't get Luck, and grab Matt Barkley (if he comes out of college) or Landry Jones, both of whom are top 5 picks (and Barkley will probably be the 1st overall pick next year if he stays at USC one more year). But I understand given the Jets/Dolphins rivalry, Jets fans will try to turn our wanting to get a good QB for the first time in over a decade being "bad fans". Really, nobody is superior enough to any other fan to call somebody a bad fan. I think it's pure stupidity to root for absolutely meaningless wins in an absolutely meaningless season.
October 24, 201115 yr I think it might be around 3 first round picks, possible 4. And no, it wouldn't. The Raiders may have helped shaped the market. They sent a first and conditional second for an average QB. If the Rams get the first pick, I think 3-4 first rounders is very possible. BTW if the Rams get the 1st pick, what's to say they dont trade Bradford and his contract? That contract's physically untradeable. No team would take it on given the current rookie wage scale and the depth of QB's in this years draft class. And you saying we'd all look like assholes for wanting to get a good QB, you know Matt Barkley, Landry Jones, Brandon Weeden, Robert Griffin III, Kirk Cousins, and Nick Foles aren't "OMG THIS IS AWFUUUUUUUL"reaction worthy, right? We've been saying this for a while. Most of us obviously want Luck, but nobody's going to cry if we get the 2nd or 3rd pick, can't get Luck, and grab Matt Barkley (if he comes out of college) or Landry Jones, both of whom are top 5 picks (and Barkley will probably be the 1st overall pick next year if he stays at USC one more year). But I understand given the Jets/Dolphins rivalry, Jets fans will try to turn our wanting to get a good QB for the first time in over a decade being "bad fans". Really, nobody is superior enough to any other fan to call somebody a bad fan. I think it's pure stupidity to root for absolutely meaningless wins in an absolutely meaningless season. Well I keep hearing that its the Suck for Luck campaign, not Suck for Weeden. Many fans (not saying you) started wanting to suck for luck after week 2. I understand that once the team is out of it, its not the end of the world if they lose games. I'd rather have the 2nd pick and the 10th. It just seems that too many people gave up so soon, banking that the team would get Andrew Luck. That is all.
October 24, 201115 yr Man, Colts suck. Manning has to return. The Colts are showing up the Dolphins right now. 62-7 is just putrid. Any chance Caldwell goes on the hot seat?
October 24, 201115 yr Its as simple as this, do you want Peyton Manning for the next 15 seasons or a few extra wins and no Peyton Manning?
October 24, 201115 yr Its as simple as this, do you want Peyton Manning for the next 15 seasons or a few extra wins and no Peyton Manning? However, there is no guarantee he turns into Peyton Manning.
October 25, 201115 yr Its as simple as this, do you want Peyton Manning for the next 15 seasons or a few extra wins and no Peyton Manning? However, there is no guarantee he turns into Peyton Manning. I'm tired of hearing that argument. If Luck doesn't pan out, the Dolphins are no worse than they are now. The Dolphins are playing with house money.
October 25, 201115 yr Its as simple as this, do you want Peyton Manning for the next 15 seasons or a few extra wins and no Peyton Manning? However, there is no guarantee he turns into Peyton Manning. The chances of him becoming Manning are high. I'm willing to take that chance. If he doesn't turn into Manning, he'll still be a Chad Pennington type QB. That's his floor. He's that good.
October 25, 201115 yr Its as simple as this, do you want Peyton Manning for the next 15 seasons or a few extra wins and no Peyton Manning? However, there is no guarantee he turns into Peyton Manning. The chances of him becoming Manning are high. I'm willing to take that chance. If he doesn't turn into Manning, he'll still be a Chad Pennington type QB. That's his floor. He's that good. Manning might be the best ever, you're being a little silly.
October 25, 201115 yr Yeah Ashraf. Take it down a notch. I love Luck, but let's not compare him to top 5 QB's before he's played a down in the NFL. Luck could still bust as bad as Jamarcus Russell for all we know. However, it's true that there isn't much negative about him. Other than the fact that he's got an average arm for the deep pass, I can't think of anything that really stands out to make me not like Luck. Been a big reason why I've been a big fan of his since he was a redshirt freshman.
October 25, 201115 yr Saying somebody's ceiling is a great player and honestly expecting them to become that great player are two totally different things.
October 25, 201115 yr Not when it comes to Andrew Luck. When you have his talent combined with his character and work ethic, you have greatness.
October 25, 201115 yr I like a good defensive battle as much as anyone.. but this is just putrid offense. Baltimore got their first 1st down halfway through the 3rd!
October 25, 201115 yr Imagine being a fan of a team involved in a game like this... I've definitely seen my share of games like this.. its awful. lol Joe Flacco... ouch.
October 25, 201115 yr This takes the Jags out of the SFL sweepstakes! Huge loss for Baltimore though. Pittsburgh is getting hot now, they can't afford to lose games like these.
October 25, 201115 yr @sportsguy33 Bill Simmons The Raiders just offered 2 first round picks for Joe Flacco. :lol
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.